[Jagannath] Attn: Live Prasna

[Guest guest]

Om Sree Gurubhyo Namaha

Dear Gauranga,

 

> Interestingly enough when Sarajit posted his " Live Prashna " , I

> have made a

> prashna chart for the time when I opened the letter. It was

> different from

> what Sarajit gave or when Gurudeva did it. I don't remember it

> exactly, but

> there were indications into both directions, so it wasn't

> unilateral, so I

> left it to others to try. When Gurudeva made His prashna, I

> just added upon

> the number of opponents and said that they are more dangerous

> than they look

> like. This only shows that prashna is a very peculiar thing

> and depends only

> on Sri Jagannath's will. and who knows, maybe later you will

> be able to

> comprehend why Gurudeva said that you won by apparenlty losing

> this

> opportunity.

 

This is precisely what I was saying earlier. Going by Sanjay's

approach of casting the chart when the astrologer answers prasna,

you get one chart, Sanjay gets one chart, I get one chart and so

on. Which chart is correct? It is arbitrary. The only way we can

solve this riddle is by saying that Sarajit's prasna is invalid

because it is posed to many people.

 

Using my father's approach of casting the chart when the queror

asks his prasna, there is a clearly and uniquely defined chart

for the prasna. That is also Jagannatha's will. Sarajit may have

wondered about it several times, but decided to ask us at one

particular moment due to Jagannatha's will.

 

I don't see why the second approach has to be rejected outright.

In fact, it is the first approach that fails the scientific

sanity check (unless we say that a prasna posed to many people is

invalid. Then, why did Sanjay try Sarajit's prasna which was

posed to the whole Varahamihira list?).

 

May Jupiter's light shine on us,

Narasimha