Guest guest Posted August 25, 2000 Report Share Posted August 25, 2000 Jaya Jagannath Dear Narasimha, The criteria chosen is usen in KARAKA KENDRADI DASA AND NOT LAGNA KENDRADI DASA. The reason is that in the Karaka Kendradi Dasa we give prominence to the AK whereas in the Dasa's starting from the Lagna (Including the Narayana Dasa) the first rule of the first source and other rules associated with the AK are not used. Else, the sign housing the AK will always be stronger even if more planets are in the 7th from it. We are comparing the strength of signs. When they prove to be equal in many respects then the subsequent rules start comparing the strength of the Lords of the signs. I know of your desire to experiment, but before enunciating anything new I am glad to see that you are careful to first check if something has been said on this by the standard texts. Parasara has also talked about this. Later. KNR made this great blunder of giving out original research without bothering to refer to the classics. We have learnt from his mistake. May Jagannath give him some peace. With Best Wishes, Sanjay Rath - Narasimha Rao <pvr <varahamihira > Thursday, August 24, 2000 9:05 AM [sri Guru] Sri Rama's Moola Dasa > Pranaam Sanjay, > > I read your answer to Brendan. I explained the order of dasas in Sri > Rama's Moola dasa based on a different logic. After some experiments, > I had earlier concluded that we should compare the strengths of rasis > and not planets. > > If Mars is in Cp and Saturn in Li, we should compare the strengths of > Cp and Li and then decide which quadrant comes first. We should > compare the strength of two planets only when they are in the same > sign. First we arrange the quadrants in the order of strength and then > the planets within each quadrant. Your original teaching wasn't very > clear and I experimented different approaches. I found the above to be > better. " Rahu and Ketu alone " case can also be used to support my view > in some cases. Of course, my conclusions could be wrong. > > Based on this approach, Cp is stronger than Li, because Cp's lord is > in a quadrant from AK and Li's lord is in an apoklima. So Cp is > stronger than Li. Ar is weaker than both Cp and Cn (Mercury's aspect) > and so Sun dasa comes later. > > Why does Rahu dasa come before Ketu dasa? Both are alone, but I do not > compare the strengths of Rahu and Ketu. I compare the strengths of the > signs containing them. It is because Sg having Rahu is stronger than > Ge having Ketu. Sg's lord Jupiter is in a quadrant from AK and Ge's > lord Mercury is in a panaphara from AK. > > Your sishya, > Narasimha > > PS: I assumed Sun to be Sri Rama's AK. > > > > > OM TAT SAT > Archive: varahamihira > Info: varahamihira/info.html > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted August 25, 2000 Report Share Posted August 25, 2000 Pranaam Sanjay, You once told me that the rules based on AK should be used in Lagna Kendradi dasas also. The reason you gave was this: Narayana dasa shows the progress of lagna in this life and the situations one comes under. But Lagna Kendradi dasas are strongly linked to the influences from past lives and karma. You also said that AK is important when dealing with karma and so AK plays a role in deciding strengths in dasas which show karmic influences strongly (this includes Lagna Kendradi dasas). So you told me to ignore the rules based on AK in Narayana dasa but to use them in Lagna Kendradi as well as Karaka Kendradi dasas. It made sense to me then. Now you are telling me to ignore the rules based on AK in Lagna Kendradi dasas. This contradicts your earlier teaching and I am confused! Your sishya, Narasimha > The criteria chosen is usen in KARAKA KENDRADI DASA AND NOT LAGNA KENDRADI > DASA. The reason is that in the Karaka Kendradi Dasa we give prominence to > the AK whereas in the Dasa's starting from the Lagna (Including the Narayana > Dasa) the first rule of the first source and other rules associated with the > AK are not used. Else, the sign housing the AK will always be stronger even > if more planets are in the 7th from it. > > We are comparing the strength of signs. When they prove to be equal in many > respects then the subsequent rules start comparing the strength of the Lords > of the signs. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.