TP controversy example (Partha's Accident)

[Guest guest]

Namaste,

 

Let us look at the Tithi Pravesha chart of 2008-09 for the birthdata given by

Partha below. Using standard SJC teachings, annual TP chart is cast for 2008

November 20, 8:24:12 pm (IST), New Delhi. Jupiter's Tithi Ashtottari dasa gave

the accident. Jupiter is the 7th and 10th lord in 7th in moolatrikona, joined by

the 5th lord and giving a raja yoga. Why did he have a major accident in Jupiter

dasa, be bed-ridden for 3 months and why did his career suffer?

 

Though one can justify any event with any chart or any dasa or any technique by

seeing shapes in clouds and beating around the bush, I honestly could not have

seen that event in Jupiter dasa in that chart.

 

* * *

 

Now, note that Partha was born on *Margasira* Krishna Navami with Sun in Sc. In

the TP chart above, Sun is in Sc again, but the tithi is *Karthika* Krishna

Navami. Though solar month has been preserved, soli-lunar month (which is the

basis for tithis!!!) has not been preserved.

 

If you make a TP chart strictly using soli-lunar calendar (instead of mixing up

soli-lunar days with solar months as taught by Sanjay ji), you will get the

annual TP chart on 2008 December 20, 10:02:13 am (IST), New Delhi. That happens

to be Margasira Krishna Navami, though Sun is in Sg. In fact, his lunar birthday

is celebrated on that day in tradition!

 

In this chart, Cp rises. Three planets are in the 12th house, whether you use

SJC reckoning or the house reckoning I recommend. The 12th lord Jupiter is

debilitated and with Rahu. This explains being bed-ridden much better. Saturn is

in the 8th house in D-1 and D-30 and the accident occurred in his dasa as per

both annual Tithi Ashtottari dasa and annual Vimsottari dasa.

 

* * *

 

There is no comparison. This chart explains the events on the ground much better

than the version of TP chart given by Sanjay ji's teachings. If you see a TP

chart not explaining events well, please try the TP chart based strictly on

soli-lunar months ( " Preferences " , " Related to calculations " , " Tithi Prevesha

Calculation Options " in JHora). The default in JHora is Sanjay ji's teaching.

 

As I mentioned before, Sanjay ji was not sure in 1998-99 whether solar or

soli-lunar months should be used in TP. He honestly told that to me and asked me

to research. We ended up teaching solar month based TP. The result of my

research is that solar months should not be mixed up and soli-lunar months

should be used.

 

Best regards,

Narasimha

-

Free Jyotish Software, Free Jyotish Lessons, Jyotish Writings,

" Do It Yourself " ritual manuals for short Homam and Pitri Tarpana:

http://www.VedicAstrologer.org

Films that make a difference: http://SaraswatiFilms.org

Spirituality:

Jyotish writings: JyotishWritings

-

 

sohamsa , Partha Sarathy <partvinu wrote:

> Hi All,

>

> I had an accident last year because of which was bedridden for three months.

You

> can use either Narayana dasa or vimshottari to analyse the event for

everybody's

> benefit.

> Transits can also be used.

>

> Event: June 11, 2009, 4:45 AM, chennai

>

> Birth particular

> 15/december/1976

> Time: 8 :30 AM

> PLace: New Delhi,

>

> Regards

> Partha

 

> Dear Goel Sir,

>

> Thank you. Honestly, i was expecting good last year, but everything

> went from bad to worse, no salary for months, bad treatment at office

> compounded matters.

> Anyways, i am waiting for Jupiter dasa, atleast he should provide some

> relief to the nonsense i am facing since 17 years.

>

> Regards

> Partha