Lesson 3 - AK Kaul

[Guest guest]

Dear Mr Kaul, We have seen you doing postings in hundreds of the groups

that in the vedic texts there is no mention of months like Asharh,

Mrigsira, Bhaadrapad etc.., It's absolutely wrong, a funny thing from

that you derived substance to your propoganda agains Vedang Jyotish. I

must tell you to read vedic text seriously, Find reference from

Boudhayana Sutra, 4th Prashna, 5th Adhyaya, 24th Sutra - Paush

Bhaadrapad Jyestha Aadra Aakashaat Paashrayat ! Trin Shuklaan Muchyate

Paapatpat Niyaadriyate !! That means, in the shukla paksha of Paush,

Bhadrapad and Jyestha months if a person wearing wet cloths does TAPA

in the sun rays, he overcomes his sins ( papa ). It's clear that you

never taken pains, never did honest effort to know how far you are

correct and without knowing truth, you started your postings against

Jyotish. We cant trust you, your arguments and claims has no base of

truth, you are wrong. Hope you are having benefits of lessons. Utkal

P.

, " utkal.panigrahi "

<utkal.panigrahi wrote:

>

> Dear Mr Kaul, You wanted to know where names of planets are given in

> vedic texts, I am surprised to see why you never tried to find out

them

> and why you falsely stood to claim that vedic texts doesn't mention

name

> of planets, pls stop circulating such mails. I give you the reference

> of Boudhayan Dharma Sutra, 2nd Prashna, 5th Adhayaya, 9th khand. In

9th

> khand, TARPAN Vidhi explaind, 9th sutra says - Aum Adityam (Sun)

> Tarpayami Somam (Moon) Tarpayami Angarakam (Mars) Tarpayami Budham

> (Merc) Tarpayami Brihaspatim (Jup) Tarpayami Sukram (Venus) Tarpayami

> Sanaischarm ( Sat ) Tarpayami Rahum Tarpayami, Ketum Tarpayami. Aum

> Keshavam Tarpayami, Narayanam Tarpayami, Govindam Tarpayami.... Hope

it

> gives light, Utkal.

> , " jyotirved " jyotirved@ wrote:

> >

> > Shri Utkal Panigrahiji,

> >

> > Jai shri Ram!

> >

> > Your not addressing the posts to anybody means you are addressing it

> to

> > every member in the forum.

> >

> > In other words, all the members of the forum, excepting you, have

> > absolutely no knowledge of shastras or even predictive gimmicks,

which

> you

> > call Vedic astrology.

> >

> >

> >

> > If this post is addressed to me, since you have given the topic as

> Lesson 1

> > A K Kaul would you please quote my exact words and then and then

> only

> > your counter arguments in refutation of the same.

> >

> > Could it be that you are confusing nakshtras with

> > nakshatra-soochis/nakshatra-jeevis?

> >

> > For your kind perusal, I am posting my original mail about

> dharma-shastras

> > vis-à-vis predictive gimmicks titled Vedic astrologers rkead

> dharmashastras

> > upside down separately. Pl. counter the arguments there in one by

> one.

> >

> > Jai Shri Ram!

> >

> > A K Kaul

> >

> >

> >

> > Jai Shri Ram!

> >

> > You claimed that in the manusmriti nakschhtras are listed in Papa

> suchi,

> > in the same line you narrated that there is no reference in core

vedic

> > literature there is no reference to nakscchtras or jyotish with

> respect

> > to good and bad future.

> >

> > You are absolutely wrong and all of your claims are false.

> >

> > In the vedic literature, Dharma Sutras explains the rituals to be

done

> > on certain occasions,

> >

> >

> > Before giving references from Boudhayana Sutras to take you out of

> > your's life long darkenss, I w'd ask you to read SAPTAM KANDA OF

> > Taitreeya Samhita, In which mantras for Ashva Medha Yagyas are

listed,

> > in these mantras Rishis worships Nakstras also -

> >

> > Prithivya Svaha,

> > Antrikschhaya Svaha,

> > ....

> > Suryava Svaha,

> > Chandramase Sava,

> > Nakschhtrebhyam Svaha

> >

> > Open eyes and read above two - three times, Same Taitreeya Samhita

> gives

> > List of Nakschhtras

> >

> > =========== ( Reference to Use of Nakschtras in rituals for future

> > protection) =========

> >

> > #1. Find reference from Boudhayana Dharma Sutra - 3rd Prashna, 2nd

> > Adhyaya, Sutra 4,5,6

> >

> > Here rituals for Sandarshani Vritti for Brahmins are explained, It

> says

> > a Brahmin should take a " Danda " saying - " Sakha Ma Gopaya " and while

> > going out, he should invoke protection with a prayer or mantra -

> > " Prithvi (Earh), Antriksha (Space), Nakschhtras etc should protect

> him " .

> >

> >

> > #2. Find reference from Boudhayana Dharma Sutra - 3rd Prashna, 8'th

> > Adhyaya, Sutra 8, 9 and 10.

> >

> > Sutra explains various AHUTI'S allotted for completion of

Chandrayana

> > Vrata, 1st Ahuti is for Agni, 2nd Ahuti is for Tithi, 3 rd Ahuti is

> for

> > Nakschhtra and 4'th Ahuti is for Lord (Devta) of Nakschhatra.

> >

> > This should be eye opener for you, Nakhtras and Nakschtra lords

> (Devtas)

> > are inegral to Jyotish

> >

> >

> > #3. Want more reference, In the same Boudhayana Dharma Sutra - 3rd

> > Prashna, 30, 31, 32, 33 in the context of Purnamashi Vrata Sutra

> begins

> > with -

> >

> > !! Nakschatreyabhyash Sadaivatebhyah !!

> >

> > Here rituals are explained for doing Havans, again it's said that in

> the

> > day of Purnmasi, sthalipak's havan first Ahuti is for Agni, then

Tithi

> > then Nakschhtra then for Lord of Nakschhtra.

> >

> > Note Down : Sutra 33 refers to Abhijit Nakschhtra.

> >

> > Don't waste your life in reading downloadable free articles and

> thereby

> > making false assumptions and further circulating lie and stupidity

in

> > the name of scholastic articles.

> >

> > It's clear that you are ignorent of Vedic rituals and have never

> studied

> > core vedic literature, go and do more study.

> >

> >

> > Now, never say that in Vedic Shastras, Jyotish or Nakschtra are

never

> > used as asupecious means or for protection of the future life.

> >

> > You wish to know the truth yourself, go and read NARAD SAMHITA, YOU

> will

> > come to know names of vedic months are given on the nakschtra of

> > Poornmasi.

> >

> >

> >

> >