don't talk while on work-Rafal Ji ..QUESTIONING

[Guest guest]

Friends,

 

A simple question arises in my mind.

What Rshis of yore wrote down was the final word on astrology?

 

I dare to say that NO.

 

They wrote what was appropriate for those times and conditions that prevailed

then.

It is universal truth that Gyana is not like a pond. Gnana is like flowing

Ganga river. It gathers strength as it moves forward.

 

I have interpreted the shastra as per what I have observed and seen in the

last 40 years of my limited experience dabbling in astrology.

I am not any Jyotish Guru. But my logical mind refuses to take anything

written in or about astrology as the LAST WORD.

 

Anyone who approaches any subject should have an open mind and ability to

question and glean Truth .

 

No one has right to advise anyone not to accept what does not conform to old

sahitya on any subject. This puts a full stop to evolution of mind.

 

It is true of Astrology also.

 

Gurutva comes with experience of decades or some times life long experiences.

Mere mastering some books or a branch of any subject cannot make a Guru.

 

 

Gurutva comes with inquiring mind and that is how Upnishads came about.

 

Hope people will understand this basic fact about ability and curiosity to

question.

 

Tatvam-Asi

 

Rafal Gendarz <starsuponme wrote:

*hare rama krsna*

 

Dear Saumya , Namaskar

 

Better stick to classics and ignore everything which is contradictory.

Work is represented by Budha, Surya, Guru and Shani. Budha is the

primary karaka as it shows learning, communication and skills. Mars

wants conclusion and altough it has digbal in tenth bhava it is enemy

for Buddha and will show obstruction to gaining new knowledge/curiosity.

Instead talking and communication is very helpful in finishing projects

(tenth bhava).

 

Some here say that Jupiter shows speech, while Budha is for memory. This

is against Rsis teaching.

 

Regards,

Rafal Gendarz

Sri Jagannath Center Guru

email: rafal

SkypeID: jyotraff1

Consultations & Articles: http://rohinaa.com

 

saumya ray chaudhuri napisa?(a):

>

> Respected Rafal Ji and other members,

> Since my childhood, I (most of us too) am familiar with the above

> dictum. I just want to justify the above saying from astrological

> point of view.

>

> Work means action which is represented by Mars. Talk or speech is

> goverened by Mercury. They are inimical to each other.

>

> Does it justify the above saying.

>

> Kindly criticize.

>

> Sincerely

> Pranam

> Saumya

>

> Saumya Ray Chaudhuri

> IMTECH,Sector 39A, Chandigarh-160036

> 09417727654

>

>

> Never miss a thing. Make your homepage.

>

>

[Guest guest]

Namaskar,

 

When classics are clear on some point there is no room for discussion

ot logic on that point. You can neither ignore classics not go

against classics. It all seems very fancy when you are in infancy

stage of astrology otherwise these ideas wash away as you progresses

in learning vedic astrology day by day. You cannot go against Rishis

when you are learning Vedic Astrology.

 

So I support Rafal ji at this point.

 

regards

sushil dikshit

 

 

 

 

 

vedic astrology , Tatvam-Asi <nameisego

wrote:

>

> Friends,

>

> A simple question arises in my mind.

> What Rshis of yore wrote down was the final word on astrology?

>

> I dare to say that NO.

>

> They wrote what was appropriate for those times and conditions

that prevailed then.

> It is universal truth that Gyana is not like a pond. Gnana is

like flowing Ganga river. It gathers strength as it moves forward.

>

> I have interpreted the shastra as per what I have observed and

seen in the last 40 years of my limited experience dabbling in

astrology.

> I am not any Jyotish Guru. But my logical mind refuses to take

anything written in or about astrology as the LAST WORD.

>

> Anyone who approaches any subject should have an open mind and

ability to question and glean Truth .

>

> No one has right to advise anyone not to accept what does not

conform to old sahitya on any subject. This puts a full stop to

evolution of mind.

>

> It is true of Astrology also.

>

> Gurutva comes with experience of decades or some times life long

experiences.

> Mere mastering some books or a branch of any subject cannot make

a Guru.

>

>

> Gurutva comes with inquiring mind and that is how Upnishads came

about.

>

> Hope people will understand this basic fact about ability and

curiosity to question.

>

> Tatvam-Asi

>

> Rafal Gendarz <starsuponme wrote:

> *hare rama krsna*

>

> Dear Saumya , Namaskar

>

> Better stick to classics and ignore everything which is

contradictory.

> Work is represented by Budha, Surya, Guru and Shani. Budha is the

> primary karaka as it shows learning, communication and skills. Mars

> wants conclusion and altough it has digbal in tenth bhava it is

enemy

> for Buddha and will show obstruction to gaining new

knowledge/curiosity.

> Instead talking and communication is very helpful in finishing

projects

> (tenth bhava).

>

> Some here say that Jupiter shows speech, while Budha is for memory.

This

> is against Rsis teaching.

>

> Regards,

> Rafal Gendarz

> Sri Jagannath Center Guru

> email: rafal

> SkypeID: jyotraff1

> Consultations & Articles: http://rohinaa.com

>

> saumya ray chaudhuri napisa?(a):

> >

> > Respected Rafal Ji and other members,

> > Since my childhood, I (most of us too) am familiar with the above

> > dictum. I just want to justify the above saying from astrological

> > point of view.

> >

> > Work means action which is represented by Mars. Talk or speech is

> > goverened by Mercury. They are inimical to each other.

> >

> > Does it justify the above saying.

> >

> > Kindly criticize.

> >

> > Sincerely

> > Pranam

> > Saumya

> >

> > Saumya Ray Chaudhuri

> > IMTECH,Sector 39A, Chandigarh-160036

> > 09417727654

> >

> >

> > Never miss a thing. Make your homepage.

> >

> >

[Guest guest]

Dear Sir,

 

Did the Rshis ask anyone to accept that whatever they wrote or said as the

final word and no one should seek further knowledge except what they theorised

and wrote?

And No one should question their teachings?

 

Has Parashar Muni or Varaha Mihira or Kalyana Verma or has any author ever

stated that only what they say is to be followed and accepted as the final word?

 

Tatvam-Asi

 

 

 

 

 

Never miss a thing. Make your homepage.

 

 

[Guest guest]

Namaste,

I think we were discussing graha kaaraka and not " Bhava graha " for 10th house/

jeevana sthaanam..

 

Tatvam-Asi <nameisego wrote: Dear Sir,

 

Did the Rshis ask anyone to accept that whatever they wrote or said as the

final word and no one should seek further knowledge except what they theorised

and wrote?

And No one should question their teachings?

 

Has Parashar Muni or Varaha Mihira or Kalyana Verma or has any author ever

stated that only what they say is to be followed and accepted as the final word?

 

Tatvam-Asi

 

 

Never miss a thing. Make your homepage.