Evaluation of replies (Jesus Christ Chart)

October 17, 2001

Pranaam Sanjay ji,

Thank you very much for your appreciation of my attempt.

You will be a great scholar one day as you like to go into such details and have a systematic approach.

I feel you are too generous in your appreciation.

Your work is the most comprehensive so far, but not conclusive. (In this case conclusion is difficult I agree).

I am still probing and feeling my way around in this ocean of divine knowledge and am not too sure of my facts or their applications.

Specifically, I am confused while applying the significations of various planets, rasis, etc.

Hence my analysis is not conclusive.

you are trying to stretch the rules towards the end in trying to find the Sun..point is you are not satisfied this chart.....

Yes - I too feel the same way. But then, this has been my feeling for all the earlier Ishta Devata exercises too - that is when one knows the answer before-hand, the analysis is not done honestly.

In such cases, one tends to overlook, ignore or even suppress facts, indications, etc. which go contrary to the known facts, or expected answers. On the other hand, one tends to strech, or even twist the arguments which are favourable.

This may be done sub-consiously, or even deliberately,

You would have noticed a significant difference in the responces to the first query - about your own chart. People who knew that it was your chart were much more accurate than the others (I, unfortunately, belong to the second group).

My submission is that we should analyse unknown charts - blind analysis - It will be more challenging.

With sincere regards,

Shailesh