Guest guest Posted November 17, 2008 Report Share Posted November 17, 2008 Dear Friends, I support the view of Neelam ji that we should use True Rahu , and may  like to give some background according to my understanding on nodes; 1. It is wrong to say that mean Nodes are always retrograde.When a planet is  moving in normal direction , but appears to be moving in opposite direction, only then it is called in retrograde mode.There are  special rules to judge retrograde planets and these rules are not applicable to mean nodes.It may be proper to say that Mean nodes always have reverse(Viloma) motion. 2. In all siddhantas , Mean Rahu is calculated , and from mean Rahu , the mean longitudes  of other planets.are calculated.  Mean values so obtained are converted to true values. In ancient days , there €was  no way to find out True values  of nodes. The eclipse can only be predicted with the help of True Rahu. As in ancient times it was not possible to calculate True Rahu , they had adopted some effective supplementary methods. 3. Now , it is possible to calculate the true nodes there is no point to continue with old practise.True nodes moves in reverse direction , some times they appear to be in direct mode.When they are in direct mode they behave like other retrograde planets and becomes very powerful.Sometimes , the longitudinal difference in true and mean extends to as large as 1deg. 45 min.The approximate method of calculating True Rahu from mean Rahu is given in the Lahiri's Ephemeris.CD of these calculations can be obtained from Positional Astronomical centre in Kolkata or Paris. Regards,  G.K.GOEL Ph: 09350311433 Add: L-409, SARITA VIHAR NEW DELHI-110 076 INDIA ________________________________ neelam gupta <neelamgupta07 Monday, 17 November, 2008 1:55:55 PM Re: RE: Re: Rahu and The Sun Dear Chakraborty ji, All the planets have a mean motion and a true motion and we use the true motion for all. The traditional teaching says that we should use true motion for Rahu also. This factor is important because true and mean Rahu can sometimes be in different signs, different navamshas or other vargas. In some dashas also, there comes a difference in calculations. The results depend on the motion/speed as well as sign/varga obtained for any planet… so is for Rahu. And if we have true motion available with us, why use mean motion for Rahu? With mean motion, Rahu is always retrograde. This cannot happen with true nodes. That is why many feel comfortable with mean rahu and use only mean motion of rahu for predictions. Now about your wife: She has shown an interest in a different culture, despite Guru in 9H in pisces and mars aspecting own house from 10th. That means Rahu is strong and she might've got her Rahu dasha also. If Rahu gets Leo navamsh, she probably would stick to her religion as sun is 2L and most probably it is in Taurus in fixed sign. But if Rahu goes to virgo, it goes to 3H of rashi and a dual sign which would allow her to change her ideas. Rahu is strong in virgo. If her mercury is also retrograde, which is 12L and navamsha depositor of Rahu, aspecting it, could give her unconventional emotional make up, specially towards spirituality as scorpio rises in 5H. She might get initiated into ways and mantra chantings etc. of 'unconventional thoughts' if rahu dasha is also operative. This would also get rubbed on to your children. Mer is also the 8L from 5H. Regards Neelam Add more friends to your messenger and enjoy! Go to http://messenger./invite/ Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 17, 2008 Report Share Posted November 17, 2008 om namo bhagavate narasimhaya Dear Gopal, Namaskar When I am listening to these new node theories I always have in mind one chart: September 18, 1958 Time: 18:10:18 Time Zone: 2:00:00 (East of GMT) Place: 16 E 39' 00", 50 N 27' 00" Person is very spiritual so is Rahu DK in eight or AK in ninth - MKS of AK,AmK,BK gives spiritual person, compare Visti chart and His all life is Puja (Ak in ninth) - he is devoted to mission (Amk with Mo) but the atma sits in dharma not karma bhava. Also his ego issues are related to Guru only (knowledge ego) not to Ve/Me (which are in kendra). Finally wife (UL) doesnt share the trait of Rahu but the rahu issue is problem in marriage (rahu in ninth instead of eight for mean node). Also AmK must be Shani to give Jupiterian work as its Moon yuti - he is teacher, whilst for true nodes AmK is Budha which sits with Shukra - this should give Shani jobs. His marriage was not sudden as can be deducted from true nodes rahu dk. There are also many more..like Ra/Gu in 2 from UL gives bad dentition for wife etc. I have also few others with Rahu AK in ninth. Here is also Rahu-Ak in ninth - spiritual astrologer. December 4, 1967 Time: 0:20:00 Time Zone: 1:00:00 (East of GMT) Place: 17 E 02' 00", 51 N 06' 00" Wroclaw, Poland Person devoted to spiritual book distribution, very dedicated member of Polish Iskcon. May 3, 1963 Time: 21:06:58 Time Zone: 1:00:00 (East of GMT) Place: 20 E 32' 10", 50 N 31' 10" All them have Rahu AK in ninth. Regards, Rafal Gendarz ----------------------------- http://rohinaa.com rafal Gopal Goel pisze: Dear Friends, I support the view of Neelam ji that we should use True Rahu , and may like to give some background according to my understanding on nodes; 1. It is wrong to say that mean Nodes are always retrograde.When a planet is moving in normal direction , but appears to be moving in opposite direction, only then it is called in retrograde mode.There are special rules to judge retrograde planets and these rules are not applicable to mean nodes.It may be proper to say that Mean nodes always have reverse(Viloma) motion. 2. In all siddhantas , Mean Rahu is calculated , and from mean Rahu , the mean longitudes of other planets.are calculated. Mean values so obtained are converted to true values. In ancient days , there €was no way to find out True values of nodes. The eclipse can only be predicted with the help of True Rahu. As in ancient times it was not possible to calculate True Rahu , they had adopted some effective supplementary methods. 3. Now , it is possible to calculate the true nodes there is no point to continue with old practise.True nodes moves in reverse direction , some times they appear to be in direct mode.When they are in direct mode they behave like other retrograde planets and becomes very powerful.Sometimes , the longitudinal difference in true and mean extends to as large as 1deg. 45 min.The approximate method of calculating True Rahu from mean Rahu is given in the Lahiri's Ephemeris.CD of these calculations can be obtained from Positional Astronomical centre in Kolkata or Paris. Regards, G.K.GOEL Ph: 09350311433 Add: L-409, SARITA VIHAR NEW DELHI-110 076 INDIA neelam gupta <neelamgupta07 > Monday, 17 November, 2008 1:55:55 PM Re: RE: Re: Rahu and The Sun Dear Chakraborty ji, All the planets have a mean motion and a true motion and we use the true motion for all. The traditional teaching says that we should use true motion for Rahu also. This factor is important because true and mean Rahu can sometimes be in different signs, different navamshas or other vargas. In some dashas also, there comes a difference in calculations. The results depend on the motion/speed as well as sign/varga obtained for any planet… so is for Rahu. And if we have true motion available with us, why use mean motion for Rahu? With mean motion, Rahu is always retrograde. This cannot happen with true nodes. That is why many feel comfortable with mean rahu and use only mean motion of rahu for predictions. Now about your wife: She has shown an interest in a different culture, despite Guru in 9H in pisces and mars aspecting own house from 10th. That means Rahu is strong and she might've got her Rahu dasha also. If Rahu gets Leo navamsh, she probably would stick to her religion as sun is 2L and most probably it is in Taurus in fixed sign. But if Rahu goes to virgo, it goes to 3H of rashi and a dual sign which would allow her to change her ideas. Rahu is strong in virgo. If her mercury is also retrograde, which is 12L and navamsha depositor of Rahu, aspecting it, could give her unconventional emotional make up, specially towards spirituality as scorpio rises in 5H. She might get initiated into ways and mantra chantings etc. of 'unconventional thoughts' if rahu dasha is also operative. This would also get rubbed on to your children. Mer is also the 8L from 5H. Regards Neelam Connect with friends all over the world. Get India Messenger. Checked by AVG - http://www.avg.com Version: 8.0.175 / Virus Database: 270.9.4/1791 - Release 2008-11-15 18:57 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 25, 2009 Report Share Posted April 25, 2009 pranam Punitji Sir I am confused about true and mean Rahu concept as I am new to this subject.Please elaborate on this. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 27, 2009 Report Share Posted April 27, 2009 Dear Deepak ji, It is very important question in the preparation of KP Charts. In this connection I request you to go thru the article written by Sri Tinwin ji, wherein he has given full information which is in the files section of this forum. However we normally use Mean Rahu instead of True Rahu which is a point but not a planet in the zodiac. Regards OVN MURTHY Company Secretary, 040-23232212 , " deepak_prizm " <deepak_prizm wrote: > > pranam Punitji > Sir I am confused about true and mean Rahu concept > as I am new to this subject.Please elaborate on this. > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 27, 2009 Report Share Posted April 27, 2009 Dear Sir, Please refer the old K.P.E-zine , published by Sri.Kanak Bosmiah Ji and also Astro-vision, published by Sri. MK.Viswanath ji. You will definitely find an article Under the caption "A Note on Mean Nodes vs True Nodes. by the Senior most astrologer (i.e) Sri.Tin Win Ji. If you donot find the above mentioned magazines, Please directly contact with Sri.Tin Win Ji. His e-mail ID is given hereunder. tw853 Astrologically Yours, Mr.VSN. Murthy, K.P.Astrologer,Sri Datta Sai Ram Astro Centre,#404, Teja Gardens Apartments,Prakashnagar, KURNOOL-518004.Cell:-09449220874; 09293138387;Phone:-08518-324184; 08518-276286.E-mail I.D.:-vsnm_vdl--- On Sat, 25/4/09, deepak_prizm <deepak_prizm wrote: deepak_prizm <deepak_prizm true and mean Rahu Date: Saturday, 25 April, 2009, 11:50 AM pranam PunitjiSir I am confused about true and mean Rahu conceptas I am new to this subject.Please elaborate on this. Bollywood news, movie reviews, film trailers and more! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 28, 2009 Report Share Posted April 28, 2009 Please check this -http://logy.astrosage.com/Home/kp-#TOC-Which-Rahu-Ketu-calculation-is-corr Thanks & Regards,Punit Pandey On Mon, Apr 27, 2009 at 11:33 PM, satyanarayana murthy <vsnm_vdl wrote: Dear Sir, Please refer the old K.P.E-zine , published by Sri.Kanak Bosmiah Ji and also Astro-vision, published by Sri. MK.Viswanath ji. You will definitely find an article Under the caption " A Note on Mean Nodes vs True Nodes. by the Senior most astrologer (i.e) Sri.Tin Win Ji. If you donot find the above mentioned magazines, Please directly contact with Sri.Tin Win Ji. His e-mail ID is given hereunder. tw853 Astrologically Yours, Mr.VSN. Murthy, K.P.Astrologer,Sri Datta Sai Ram Astro Centre,#404, Teja Gardens Apartments,Prakashnagar, KURNOOL-518004.Cell:-09449220874; 09293138387;Phone:-08518-324184; 08518-276286. E-mail I.D.:-vsnm_vdl--- On Sat, 25/4/09, deepak_prizm <deepak_prizm wrote: deepak_prizm <deepak_prizm true and mean Rahu Date: Saturday, 25 April, 2009, 11:50 AM pranam PunitjiSir I am confused about true and mean Rahu conceptas I am new to this subject.Please elaborate on this. Bollywood news, movie reviews, film trailers and more! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.