Reply to Chandrashekhar Ji on Vivekananda's Chart !!

October 12, 2009

Resp ChandraShekhar ji and All. In order to prevail truth, had you translated that very 1 page of Jyotish Ratnakar, w'd have been better, We all know that it's not true that Sun changes it's transit from Dhanu to Makar only on 14'th Jan, It has never been a universal truth.. Pls do not misuse people's innocent faith. Brave Babu Devakinandan Singh gives entire account of how he got a horoscope of Makar Lagna and how the other Dhanu Lagna horoscope came into existence, he has written that Sri Ganesh Chandra MukhoPadhaya in his book "Jeevani Sangrah" has given Swami ji's birth time as 6.33 am, Life to Dhanu lagna chart is limited to that vary "Jeevani Sangrah" only. Babu Devakinandan Singh also narrates that in the Swami Ji's BioGraphy which was printed by his friends, no birth time is mentioned, Friends only mentioned that Swami Ji was born on 12 Jan 1863's morning, that was the day when Makar Sankranti was celebrated in Bengal, Pls do not cast shadow of doubt that on 12'th jan 1863 there was no Makar Sankranti, this is not going to help we Indians. On the day of Makar Sankranti, Makar Lagna begins at very first hour of Sunrise, and Sun moves to Makara at noon, Now, Babu DevakiNandan Singh puzzles with 100 yrs long question what could be correct birth time of Swami Ji, though, He is convinced that It could be Makara only but at what time - at noon or before noon, he had no information as he got a chart with Makar Lagna but that was without Birth Time, He has printed that Makar Lagna chart in his book.

You have chosen not to answer the questions that Devakinandan Singh raised in that very analysis 1. Physic 2. Marriage of Swami Ji. This is not answerd by either Sri BV Raman or by Prof KN Rao. We Indians want answers, which are not with Dhanu lagna, unless one distorts some principle of Jyotish. It's better for everybody to buy and read Jyotish Ratnakar to understand degree of doubts over Swami Vivekananda's chart and kind of practice our renowned astrologers have done, If a person contemporary to grand father of BV Raman quotes two charts, It was moral responsibility of BV Raman also to quote both to find answers that Dhanu Lagna chart doesn't have and then establish Swami Ji was born with Makar Lagna or Dhanu Lagna, If we dont have time and sicerety for Swami Ji's chart, we are an ingrate society and nation

I m ready to undergo all the criticism for Swami ji's sake, I have that courage and confidence and If I am found wrong, I will post unconditional apology to you and to everybody.

regards,Lalit.