Guest guest Posted March 24, 2004 Report Share Posted March 24, 2004 Om Krishna Guru Dear Jyotisha's I have a query about chara karaka replacement. In a given chart where the chara Gnati karaka(Jupiter) and chara Dara karaka(Venus) share the same degrees. So, when the replacement occurs Jupiter will be replaced by Venus and will leave the Dara karaka slot empty, if my understanding is correct. My question is the empty Dara karaka shall be replaced by which planet? As far as my knowledge it will be replaced by sthira karaka which in this case is Venus itself for Dara karaka, am I right? Or is it Jupiter will replace the slot if the chart belongs to female? Both Jupiter and Venus is placed in the lagna being Scorpio. Can anyone tell when the replacement shall occur? How will it impact the person's marriage life in this case? I hope someone will clarify further the princip of chara karaka replacement for my better understanding. Thanks in advance. Hare Krsna, Mofie Augustine Mofie Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 25, 2004 Report Share Posted March 25, 2004 || Hare Rama Krisha || Dear Mofie, Though I am a beginner in astrology, I would like to respond to your post. As per my understanding from Upadesa Sutra's of Jaimini Maharishi we can not give the status of Gnati Karaka and Dara Karaka for Jupiter and Venus if they both share the same degrees. Is it not both of them try to gain the Gnati Karakatwa and none of them is willing to be left behind? As per the Jaimini Maaharishi when two or planets share the same longitude (in degrees, minutes and seconds) then all them will merge into the same Karakatwa and the vacancy caused by the merging of two or more planets will be supplied by the Naisargika Karaka. As the Shtira Karaka (fixed significator) are used for the longevity or death (extent of survival of the physical body etc.) may not replace the Chara Karaka as Charakaraka scheme is used for analysisng the influence of others on us and our influence on others which is much more than Sthira Karaka scheme. Instead as Naisargika Karaka represents everything under the creation of Brahma, hence its scope is beyond what we can infer from the Chara Karaka, it is more logical if the Naisargika Karaka replaces the Karakatwa caused by mergning or two/more planets in the Chara Karaka scheme. I request Gurus and other learned members to please correct me. Regards, Prabhakar varahamihira , Mofie <mofie@m...> wrote: > > Om Krishna Guru > > Dear Jyotisha's > > I have a query about chara karaka replacement. In a given chart where > the chara Gnati karaka(Jupiter) and chara Dara karaka(Venus) share the > same degrees. So, when the replacement occurs Jupiter will be replaced > by Venus and will leave the Dara karaka slot empty, if my understanding > is correct. My question is the empty Dara karaka shall be replaced by > which planet? As far as my knowledge it will be replaced by sthira > karaka which in this case is Venus itself for Dara karaka, am I right? > Or is it Jupiter will replace the slot if the chart belongs to female? > Both Jupiter and Venus is placed in the lagna being Scorpio. Can anyone > tell when the replacement shall occur? How will it impact the person's > marriage life in this case? > > I hope someone will clarify further the princip of chara karaka > replacement for my better understanding. Thanks in advance. > > Hare Krsna, > Mofie Augustine Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 25, 2004 Report Share Posted March 25, 2004 || Hare Rama Krishna || Dear Mofie, In my previous post I assumed from your message that AK, AmK, BK, MK, PiK, PK have been already assigned to other planets based on their Longitudes and only Jupiter and Venus are at next to them in longitude for Gnati Karakatwa. Regards, Prabhakar varahamihira , " PK " <pkvirus99> wrote: > || Hare Rama Krisha || > > Dear Mofie, > > Though I am a beginner in astrology, I would like to respond to your > post. > > As per my understanding from Upadesa Sutra's of Jaimini Maharishi we > can not give the status of Gnati Karaka and Dara Karaka for Jupiter > and Venus if they both share the same degrees. Is it not both of them > try to gain the Gnati Karakatwa and none of them is willing to be > left behind? > > As per the Jaimini Maaharishi when two or planets share the same > longitude (in degrees, minutes and seconds) then all them will merge > into the same Karakatwa and the vacancy caused by the merging of two > or more planets will be supplied by the Naisargika Karaka. > > As the Shtira Karaka (fixed significator) are used for the longevity > or death (extent of survival of the physical body etc.) may not > replace the Chara Karaka as Charakaraka scheme is used for analysisng > the influence of others on us and our influence on others which is > much more than Sthira Karaka scheme. Instead as Naisargika Karaka > represents everything under the creation of Brahma, hence its scope > is beyond what we can infer from the Chara Karaka, it is more logical > if the Naisargika Karaka replaces the Karakatwa caused by mergning or > two/more planets in the Chara Karaka scheme. > > I request Gurus and other learned members to please correct me. > > Regards, > Prabhakar > > > > varahamihira , Mofie <mofie@m...> wrote: > > > > Om Krishna Guru > > > > Dear Jyotisha's > > > > I have a query about chara karaka replacement. In a given chart > where > > the chara Gnati karaka(Jupiter) and chara Dara karaka(Venus) share > the > > same degrees. So, when the replacement occurs Jupiter will be > replaced > > by Venus and will leave the Dara karaka slot empty, if my > understanding > > is correct. My question is the empty Dara karaka shall be replaced > by > > which planet? As far as my knowledge it will be replaced by sthira > > karaka which in this case is Venus itself for Dara karaka, am I > right? > > Or is it Jupiter will replace the slot if the chart belongs to > female? > > Both Jupiter and Venus is placed in the lagna being Scorpio. Can > anyone > > tell when the replacement shall occur? How will it impact the > person's > > marriage life in this case? > > > > I hope someone will clarify further the princip of chara karaka > > replacement for my better understanding. Thanks in advance. > > > > Hare Krsna, > > Mofie Augustine Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.