Guest guest Posted July 4, 2004 Report Share Posted July 4, 2004 Hari Om Namo Viswarupaya ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Namaste, I have revisited the Upagraha chapter in BPHS and other books. The general consensus is Gulika=Mandi, yet I know this is not the case as Sanjayji has discussed otherwise. I have looked at several past posts, (see one below + post 11905, 11728, etc if there is interest) and wondered if a Guru can spend a paragraph on current thinking. - What are the key differences between Gulika and Mandi? - Are both derivatives of Sani? - Are there good Positions for Gulika and Mandi - Sanjay suggests Gulika in the 10th is a good position; this too is confirmed in BPHS by G.C.Sharma, yet Pandit Sharma also says Gulika=Mandi) Pranams, Frank in San Diego _________________ ( From Sanjayji to Narasimha) > Yes. I was teaching Parasara upagrahas and after an extensive study when I > did that class, it was totally clear that the Upagrahas or rather Aprakasa > grahas must rise at the end of the period of the planets as per the weekday > order..rest is fine. About Mandi, I am still in the middle of my research > and will tell you when I am done. > We had to use Yamaghantaka with the Lagna for determining Santana Guru and > Santana Guru Tithi..I did this yesterday in SJC Puri class. So it was clear > that it has to be the end of the period. This is consistent with your > earlier findings in this issue. > With best regards, Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 4, 2004 Report Share Posted July 4, 2004 Dear Frank, My personal opinion is that they are synonymous. The reason for the confusion is, perhaps, that "Prashna Marga" gives different definitions for calculating Mandi and Gulika. Other Sages have not distinguished between them. Regards, Chandrashekhar. fls999999999 wrote: Hari Om Namo Viswarupaya ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Namaste, I have revisited the Upagraha chapter in BPHS and other books. The general consensus is Gulika=Mandi, yet I know this is not the case as Sanjayji has discussed otherwise. I have looked at several past posts, (see one below + post 11905, 11728, etc if there is interest) and wondered if a Guru can spend a paragraph on current thinking. - What are the key differences between Gulika and Mandi? - Are both derivatives of Sani? - Are there good Positions for Gulika and Mandi - Sanjay suggests Gulika in the 10th is a good position; this too is confirmed in BPHS by G.C.Sharma, yet Pandit Sharma also says Gulika=Mandi) Pranams, Frank in San Diego _________________ ( From Sanjayji to Narasimha) > Yes. I was teaching Parasara upagrahas and after an extensive study when I > did that class, it was totally clear that the Upagrahas or rather Aprakasa > grahas must rise at the end of the period of the planets as per the weekday > order..rest is fine. About Mandi, I am still in the middle of my research > and will tell you when I am done. > We had to use Yamaghantaka with the Lagna for determining Santana Guru and > Santana Guru Tithi..I did this yesterday in SJC Puri class. So it was clear > that it has to be the end of the period. This is consistent with your > earlier findings in this issue. > With best regards, |Om Tat Sat| http://www.varahamihira Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 6, 2004 Report Share Posted July 6, 2004 || Om Gurave Namah || Dear Dhira Krsna, I have not read any text about saturn's children. But I just refered the MW Dictionary. and found the following clue. Gulika = Name of a Hunter in Brihan Naaradiya Puraana If somebody has that purana maybe they can qoute the hunter's story. Which would give clue. Also I came across the following interesting information at http://www.ignca.nic.in/ps_01021.htm About Kerala Fisher Folks. Gulikan: Ethereal Element Gulikan or Mandi is propitiated by the Hindu fishermen all over Kerala. The Gulikan is connected with diseases and death. Horoscopes are cast by every Hindu of Kerala in which the position of the Gulikan is clearly indicated. The Gulikan's position indicates when the person will die. When death occurs in a fisherman's house, it is customary to plant a stone outside the house representing the Gulikan. An informant informed me that stone representing the Gulikan will never be installed in the room reserved for ancestors or in any of the house. However, the fishermen believe that once the Gulikan is propitiated by installing a stone on the earthen platform, it will prevent death. The Gulikan is generally worshipped to get big fishes like etta and avoli. They vow to conduct a special puja in honour of the Gulikan by offering etta and avoli. They fulfil their vow by making votive offerings when they get these species of fish. The Gulikan is periodically propitiated by the offer of kuruthi (water mixed with turmeric and lime), today, bananas and flowers. A wick lamp is lighted for the worship. A red fowl and a ram are sacrificed in the Gulikan's honour on important festive occasions like Omam and Vishu. Sometimes, the oracle of the Gulikan, in trance, directs the fishermen to handle times of crisis. The oracle reveals the causes of illness and discloses the remedy. The Mukkuvans of Malabar believe that there are four kinds of Gulikans: Brahma Gulikan,Vishnu Gulikan, Abhimanyu Gulikan, Asura Gulikan. They further believe that if the Asura Gulikan is displeased tensions in the family are bound to arise, besides infights among the members of the crew. In such cases the Mukkuvans consult the kaniyan (village astrologer) and seek their advice to ward off the wrath of the enraged Asura Gulikan. The kaniyan prescribes the remedy in the form of a magical rite called Puramneekkal which is similar to Uzhinhu Vangal. A magician is invited to conduct this rite. The articles required for the purpose prescribed by the magician and the astrologer are: a cooked fried fish (etta, aikkora, and narimeen), coconut oil, potato, lady-finger, bengal gram, beaten rice, puffed rice, etc. A thigh of the cock is roasted in the fire and given to the Asura Gulikan. The total expenditure for conducting the rite comes to Rs. 100. Brahma Gulikan: Ethereal Element The Brahma Gulikan is worshipped for getting bumper catches and also for warding off the misfortunes and illness caused by him. Sometimes the Mukkuvans call the Brahma Gulikan as Brahma Yakshasu, the spirit of a dead Brahman. The Mukkuvans believe that the Brahma Gulikan is capable of causing separation of a husband and wife. An amulet is prepared by the magician and given to the patient to wear or a Puramneekkal ceremony is conducted to appease him. Sometimes the mantram `Oh Gulika, Brahma Gulika, Vishnu Gulika, Asmara Gulika and Abhimanyu Gulika' is chanted for 21 times over a string for putting on the waist of the patient. The same mantram is written 21 times on a copper plate and an amulet is prepared for wearing. Sometimes rice powder mixed with molasses is given to the Brahma Gulikan to appease his wrath. The Mukkuvans say that the Vishnu Gulikan and Abhimanyu Gulikan are not wicked. The Abhimanyu Gulikan is the spirit of Abhimanyu, son of Arjuna, who died in the Kurukshetra war. Warm Regards Sanjay Prabhakaran Om Tat Sat varahamihira , " Dhira Krsna BCS " <Dhira.Krsna.BCS@p...> wrote: > Dear Frank and others, > > I was meditating on this topic also last few days. It would be interesting > if one of the learned Pandits could tell the Puranic story or refer to > some scripture where the story is mentioned how Sani begot his son (s) > Mandi-Gulik. We know the story how Sani became son of Surya, Budha became > son of Chandra etc, but how did Mandi-Gulik become son of Sani? > > Btw, Mandi means " son of Manda " (Manda=Sani) and Gulik will be another > name for him, according to my opinion. I also use end of respective > portions for the Upagrahas. > > Another question, all graha have one son, why only Sani would have 2 to > determine the Upagraha? > > Yours, > Dhira Krsna dasa, > Jyotishi > http://www.radhadesh.com > http://www.geocities.com/dvdd1008/Jyotisha.html Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.