Jump to content
IndiaDivine.org

difference between pukhraj & topaz

Rate this topic


Guest guest

Recommended Posts

Guest guest

Jaya Jagannatha

 

Dear Pradeep,

 

Namaste

 

Hare Rama Krishna

 

Dear Swee ji,

 

In one of the old mails,

you differenited Pukhraj

from Topaz. On internet these two words are almost synonims. Will you please be kind to explain the difference

between

them?

 

Shata

Pranam,

Pradeep

 

I will quote from Garuòa

PurÄëa Pürva

Kaëda Chapter 70

kÄmaṃ cÄrutarÄù pañca jÄténÄ pratirüpakÄù|

vijÄ tayaù prayatnena

vidvÄṃstanupalakñayet||20

kalaÅ›apurodbhavasiṃhalatumburudeÅ›otthamuktapÄṇīyÄḥ|21a

 

Based on the above, Topaz is

categorized as spurious/alien. In the later chapter, the descriptions of the

myriad of colours from the corundum family are

described as below.

 

Chapter

74

patitÄyÄ himÄdrau tu tvacastasya suradviñaù|

prÄdurbhavanti tÄbhyastu

puñpa rÄgÄ

mahÄguëÄù||1

ÄpétapÄëòuruciraù pÄñÄëaù padmarÄgasaàjñastu|

kaukaëöakanÄmÄ syÄtsa

eva yadi lohitÄpétaù||2

Älohitastu

pétaù svacchaù kÄñÄyakaù

sa ekoktaù|

Änélaçuklavarëaù

snigdhaù somÄla

kaù saguëaù|3

atyantalohito yaù sa eva

khalu padmarÄgasaṃjñaù syÄt|

api cendranélasaṃjñaù sa eva kathitaù sunélaù

san||4

 

 

These colours

from the same corundum family are reclassified according to their names and colours. Pushparaga (“Yellowâ€

Sapphire); Padmaraga (Ruby) is actually stated in

there. Indranila (Blue Sapphire); Kaurandaka

(Crimson-Yellow/Padparascha?); Somanaka

(Light/Cornflour Blue); There can be several meanings

to this:

The yellow colour that is being

prescribed for Jupiter is not what has always been actually described. It maybe

the colour of yellow/orange with a tinge of red etc that is typical of Padparascha (description of this colour is from the

gemstone industry).

Grey is the colour typified in RÄhu (minute impurities especially from magma), so

generally any gemstone that has a greyish tinge

should be avoided. In order for the crafty jeweler to sell these rejects, they

heat them to enhance its colour or brilliance. Heated ones generally have a “glossy

glaze†about it. (This is from years of experience); though it is rather

difficult nowadays to prove that a gemstone is not heat treated whether the gem

is certified or not…..sorry to say.

 

Topaz has a typical grayish overtone

and its colour is enhanced through heat treatment. This is NOT allowed in the saçtras.

This brings ill luck to the owner (i.e., the person who wears/owns it), plus the

person who instructs the treatment or the man does this treatment.

 

Technicalities:

Besides clarity, the main criteria is its ability to refract.

Why is that? Simple Imagine a ray of

light entering obliquely into the gemstone, this refraction happens at the

interface of the two mediums. This amount of refraction is called the

refractive index which is really the proportionate relation between the speed of light into air to that in the gemstone.

A deviation of the light rays caused

by the double refractivity of that gem is not as conducive as the gemstone that

has the single refractive index.

So the difference is its absorption

spectrum is 50% higher than that of “Sapphires†so that’s a minus (for Topaz).

 

In the matter of hardness, Topaz is

softer than Pushparag (Yellow Sapphire). Topaz has a

perfect cleavage, so it has a tendency to shatter in perfect planes.

 

In different chapter on the

description of gemstones, different parts of Bala asura are allocated similar type of gems. Note the 74.1

says it is from his skin. (Mercury!).

Mercury when in strength can counteract

the evil caused by Rähu.

–Jataka Parijata Vol I Adhyaya II.73-

 

Compare it to this statement:

A

weak or malefic Jupiter causes sorrow due to the evil effects of maledictions

uttered by Preceptors, Devas, Parents and such other

venerable people

and Brähmänas. -Jataka Parijata Vol I Adhyaya II.74 and 79

(Mercury and Jupiter are neutral to one

another.)

 

Now we have ascertained that Yellow

Sapphire or gemstones from the Corundum family are more superior, the above

statement indicates that we can wear the gemstone to strengthen that particular

planet. It is also clear that we can also use it to nullify a curse from Guru,

revered personalities etc., treatment of skin disease etc as implied from the statement

74.1.

If this planet happens to be a

(functional malefic), you may offer it as an upaya by

gifting it besides the full arrangements for a proper pacification.

 

I am cc’ing

this to Varahamihira list and SJC. Perhaps other

experts can contribute J

 

Love,

Swee

www.brihaspati.net

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest



 

 

Jaya Jagannatha

Dear Swee

Truly brilliant. For some reason I could never understand why Topaz causes the user to be in a *heated up* state whereas the Pushparaaga is supposed to be cold and tends to *cool* and make calm. From your writing it is evident that the Pokhraj is undoubted the *only gemstone* and substitutes cannot really help as much. However if we are able to find a *cooling yellow gem* then it can be used as a substitute.

With best wishes and warm regards,

Sanjay Rath

* * *

Sri Jagannath Center®

15B Gangaram Hospital Road

New Delhi 110060, India

http://srath.com, +91-11-25717162

* * *

 

 

 

 

Swee Chan [swee] Thursday, March 31, 2005 8:22 PMastrocasual ; varahamihira ; Cc: Gaurav|Sri Varaha| difference between pukhraj & topaz

 

 

Jaya Jagannatha

 

Dear Pradeep,

 

Namaste

 

Hare Rama Krishna

 

Dear Swee ji,

 

In one of the old mails, you differenited Pukhraj from Topaz. On internet these two words are almost synonims. Will you please be kind to explain the difference

between them?

 

Shata Pranam,

Pradeep

 

I will quote from Garuòa PurÄëa Pürva Kaëda Chapter 70

kÄmaṃ cÄrutarÄù pañca jÄténÄ pratirüpakÄù|

vijÄ tayaù prayatnena vidvÄṃstanupalakñayet||20

kalaÅ›apurodbhavasiṃhalatumburudeÅ›otthamuktapÄṇīyÄḥ|21a

 

Based on the above, Topaz is categorized as spurious/alien. In the later chapter, the descriptions of the myriad of colours from the corundum family are described as below.

 

Chapter 74

patitÄyÄ himÄdrau tu tvacastasya suradviñaù|prÄdurbhavanti tÄbhyastu puñpa rÄgÄ mahÄguëÄù||1ÄpétapÄëòuruciraù pÄñÄëaù padmarÄgasaàjñastu|kaukaëöakanÄmÄ syÄtsa eva yadi lohitÄpétaù||2Älohitastu pétaù svacchaù kÄñÄyakaù sa ekoktaù|Änélaçuklavarëaù snigdhaù somÄla kaù saguëaù|3atyantalohito yaù sa eva khalu padmarÄgasaṃjñaù syÄt|api cendranélasaṃjñaù sa eva kathitaù sunélaù san||4

These colours from the same corundum family are reclassified according to their names and colours. Pushparaga (“Yellow†Sapphire); Padmaraga (Ruby) is actually stated in there. Indranila (Blue Sapphire); Kaurandaka (Crimson-Yellow/Padparascha?); Somanaka (Light/Cornflour Blue); There can be several meanings to this:

The yellow colour that is being prescribed for Jupiter is not what has always been actually described. It maybe the colour of yellow/orange with a tinge of red etc that is typical of Padparascha (description of this colour is from the gemstone industry).

Grey is the colour typified in RÄhu (minute impurities especially from magma), so generally any gemstone that has a greyish tinge should be avoided. In order for the crafty jeweler to sell these rejects, they heat them to enhance its colour or brilliance. Heated ones generally have a “glossy glaze†about it. (This is from years of experience); though it is rather difficult nowadays to prove that a gemstone is not heat treated whether the gem is certified or not…..sorry to say.

 

Topaz has a typical grayish overtone and its colour is enhanced through heat treatment. This is NOT allowed in the saçtras. This brings ill luck to the owner (i.e., the person who wears/owns it), plus the person who instructs the treatment or the man does this treatment.

 

Technicalities:

Besides clarity, the main criteria is its ability to refract.

Why is that? Simple Imagine a ray of light entering obliquely into the gemstone, this refraction happens at the interface of the two mediums. This amount of refraction is called the refractive index which is really the proportionate relation between the speed of light into air to that in the gemstone.

A deviation of the light rays caused by the double refractivity of that gem is not as conducive as the gemstone that has the single refractive index.

So the difference is its absorption spectrum is 50% higher than that of “Sapphires†so that’s a minus (for Topaz).

 

In the matter of hardness, Topaz is softer than Pushparag (Yellow Sapphire). Topaz has a perfect cleavage, so it has a tendency to shatter in perfect planes.

 

In different chapter on the description of gemstones, different parts of Bala asura are allocated similar type of gems. Note the 74.1 says it is from his skin. (Mercury!).

Mercury when in strength can counteract the evil caused by Rähu.

–Jataka Parijata Vol I Adhyaya II.73-

 

Compare it to this statement:

A weak or malefic Jupiter causes sorrow due to the evil effects of maledictions uttered by Preceptors, Devas, Parents and such other venerable people

and Brähmänas. -Jataka Parijata Vol I Adhyaya II.74 and 79

(Mercury and Jupiter are neutral to one another.)

 

Now we have ascertained that Yellow Sapphire or gemstones from the Corundum family are more superior, the above statement indicates that we can wear the gemstone to strengthen that particular planet. It is also clear that we can also use it to nullify a curse from Guru, revered personalities etc., treatment of skin disease etc as implied from the statement 74.1.

If this planet happens to be a (functional malefic), you may offer it as an upaya by gifting it besides the full arrangements for a proper pacification.

 

I am cc’ing this to Varahamihira list and SJC. Perhaps other experts can contribute J

 

Love,

Swee

www.brihaspati.net

 

 

|Om Tat Sat|http://www.varahamihira

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...