Guest guest Posted October 11, 2008 Report Share Posted October 11, 2008 Dear  Friends, I humbly mention that Mr Narshiman has not understood the meaning of two opening Verses oF BPHS neither in letter or spirit: Pt Sitaram Jha was great Sanskrit scholar and Principal of most famous Astrological Institute in Varanasi . I will give below the translation given by him : First verse :Same as translated by Narshiman This is also in line with Sutra 1.1.10 Thus it is clear that both schemes are applicable , only it is to be decided as to which scheme will apply in which situation. Second Verse:Mr Narshiman has not translated it properly , as such his inferences needs to be examined with care and can not be accepted strait away. Let us examine the translation of Pt Sitaram Jha: " Some authorities hold the opinion that in 7 char karka scheme , when two karka 's are on same degree ,  in such a situation Rahu is to be considered , and other say that 8 char Karka scheme including Rahu should be considered INDEPENDENTLY " BPHS DOES NOT DISCARD THE ABOVE VIEW IN ANY MANNER.  This defines the role of Rahu in seven char karka scheme. Jaimini sutra 1.1.19 says that putra karka is merged in matru karka (obiously in seven char karka scheme). This means that seven char karka scheme is applicable in Mundane affairs ant not on nativities of living being. Bphs clearly indicates the names of eight char karka including Putra karka. It also specify the rules for replacement of char karka by sthir Karkas. A careful study of this chapter reveals that in case of char karka REPLACEMENT in seven char karka scheme , first replacement will be introduced by Rahu -a karka of confusion and decite. Bphs further says that out of three constituents of Mahraja yoga , one is provided by the conjuction of AK ans PUTK. As progeny is only possible in the case of living being , eight karka scheme is applicable for living being only. SEVEN KARKA SCHEME SHOULD BE APPLIED ON MUNDANE CHARTS. Regards,  G.K.GOEL Ph: 09350311433 Add: L-409, SARITA VIHAR NEW DELHI-110 076 INDIA Add more friends to your messenger and enjoy! Go to http://messenger./invite/ Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted October 13, 2008 Report Share Posted October 13, 2008 Respected Goel Ji, This is intriguing. What do you suggest and follow. I was just curious to see this in my case. What I found that Rahu becomes AK and Me is AmK under chara karaka 8 while Me becomes AK and Mars is AmK under Chara Karaka scheme 7. This will influence the prediction a lot. So, Kindly advise us. The other day, I could n't meet you. Let me see, if I could come by this month. Thank you With personal regards Saumya --- On Sat, 10/11/08, Gopal Goel <gkgoel1937 wrote: > Gopal Goel <gkgoel1937 > [vedic astrology] cHAR kARKA 7 OR/AND 8 > sohamsa > Cc: Indian_Astrology_Group_Daily_Digest , vedic astrology > Saturday, October 11, 2008, 3:49 PM > Dear Friends, > I humbly mention that Mr Narshiman has not understood the > meaning > of two opening Verses oF BPHS neither in letter or spirit: > Pt Sitaram Jha was great Sanskrit scholar and Principal of > most famous > Astrological Institute in Varanasi . I will give below the > translation given by > him : > First verse :Same as translated by Narshiman > This is also in line with Sutra 1.1.10 > Thus it is clear that both schemes are applicable , only it > is to be decided as to which scheme will apply in which > situation. > Second Verse:Mr Narshiman has not translated it properly , > as such his inferences > needs to be examined with care and can not be accepted > strait away. > Let us examine the translation of Pt Sitaram Jha: > " Some authorities hold the opinion that in 7 char > karka scheme , when two karka 's > are on same degree , in such a situation Rahu is to be > considered , and other say > that 8 char Karka scheme including Rahu should be > considered INDEPENDENTLY " > > BPHS DOES NOT DISCARD THE ABOVE VIEW IN ANY MANNER. > > This defines the role of Rahu in seven char karka scheme. > Jaimini sutra 1.1.19 says that putra karka is merged in > matru karka (obiously in > seven char karka scheme). This means that seven char karka > scheme is applicable > in Mundane affairs ant not on nativities of living being. > Bphs clearly indicates the names of eight char karka > including Putra karka. > It also specify the rules for replacement of char karka by > sthir Karkas. > A careful study of this chapter reveals that in case of > char karka REPLACEMENT in seven char karka scheme , first > replacement will be introduced by Rahu -a karka of confusion > and decite. > Bphs further says that out of three constituents of Mahraja > yoga , one is provided by > the conjuction of AK ans PUTK. > As progeny is only possible in the case of living > being , eight karka scheme is applicable for living being > only. > > SEVEN KARKA SCHEME SHOULD BE APPLIED ON MUNDANE CHARTS. > Regards, > > > > G.K.GOEL > Ph: 09350311433 > Add: L-409, SARITA VIHAR > NEW DELHI-110 076 > INDIA > > > Add more friends to your messenger and enjoy! Go to > http://messenger./invite/ > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.