Guest guest Posted October 30, 2008 Report Share Posted October 30, 2008 Dear Khurana ji, YOU ARE RIGHT. When 16 Varga chart are casted , Birth sign chart acts as one of the bhava chart . This is a very effective technique. This does not mean the savants who are constructing bhava chalit charts ( no doubt their are many ways to do it and some of them are not at all convincing or logical ) do not have logic or utility. We must learn their use also. On higher latitudes , the utility of chalit chars are doubtful.In such cases equal house division comes to rescue. Regards,  G.K.GOEL ________________________________ khurana_satpal <khurana_satpal Monday, 27 October, 2008 10:52:08 PM Re: Bhava Chalit - Part 2 Sirs, Chalit kundali is derived after a mathematical step known as Bhav- spashtha technique. If we can accept divisional charts, which are a mathematical derivation of the natal chart, then why can’t we accept yet another derivation of the natal chart known as Chalit chart. As the divisional charts are generated from the natal chart, so is the Chalit chart. This gives us yet another tool for studying a kundali. No body says that the natal chart be set aside and a Chalit chart alone be studied. I consider a Chalit chart as a refinement. Chalit chart also takes into account, to some extent, the difference in the people born an hour apart but in the same lagna. Bhava means mood/attitude/ feeling (like bhava-bhakti) . Therefore studying a house or Bhav in a Chalit kundali makes us understand the attitude of the planet placed in that bhav towards the significations the bhav represents. Sincerely, S P Khurana ancient_indian_ astrology, " kishore patnaik " <kishorepatnaik09@ ...> wrote: > > Dear Bhaskarji, > > With due regard to the sentiments of those who use the chalit chakra, I > personally feel > chalit chakra (usally called Bhava chart also) is not all that useful as it > is made out to be. > > More often than not, I have seen it being misused, either how a person > suffered or enjoyed inspite of these not being obvious in his natal chart > or more abusively, to explain away why a particular piece of prophecy did > not come true. > > I recall B V Raman's dictum in this connection: " What is not promised by > natal chart, can not happen " > > I believe that Divisional charts will confirm the strength of readings made > out from the Natal chart and we really do not require anything else for a > good prophecy. > > This is my personal thinking and I do not mean to degrade or hurt any > Learned member. > > with best regards, > > Kishore patnaik > > > > I > Add more friends to your messenger and enjoy! Go to http://messenger./invite/ Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted October 30, 2008 Report Share Posted October 30, 2008 Dear Khurana ji, YOU ARE RIGHT. When 16 Varga chart are casted , Birth sign chart acts as one of the bhava chart . This is a very effective technique. This does not mean the savants who are constructing bhava chalit charts ( no doubt their are many ways to do it and some of them are not at all convincing or logical ) do not have logic or utility. We must learn their use also. On higher latitudes , the utility of chalit chars are doubtful.In such cases equal house division comes to rescue. Regards, G.K.GOEL khurana_satpal <khurana_satpal Sent: Monday, 27 October, 2008 10:52:08 PM Re: Bhava Chalit - Part 2 Sirs,Chalit kundali is derived after a mathematical step known as Bhav-spashtha technique. If we can accept divisional charts, which are a mathematical derivation of the natal chart, then why can’t we accept yet another derivation of the natal chart known as Chalit chart. As the divisional charts are generated from the natal chart, so is the Chalit chart. This gives us yet another tool for studying a kundali. No body says that the natal chart be set aside and a Chalit chart alone be studied. I consider a Chalit chart as a refinement. Chalit chart also takes into account, to some extent, the difference in the people born an hour apart but in the same lagna. Bhava means mood/attitude/ feeling (like bhava-bhakti) . Therefore studying a house or Bhav in a Chalit kundali makes us understand the attitude of the planet placed in that bhav towards the significations the bhav represents.Sincerely,S P Khuranaancient_indian_ astrology, "kishore patnaik" <kishorepatnaik09@ ...> wrote:>> Dear Bhaskarji,> > With due regard to the sentiments of those who use the chalit chakra, I> personally feel> chalit chakra (usally called Bhava chart also) is not all that useful as it> is made out to be.> > More often than not, I have seen it being misused, either how a person> suffered or enjoyed inspite of these not being obvious in his natal chart> or more abusively, to explain away why a particular piece of prophecy did> not come true.> > I recall B V Raman's dictum in this connection: " What is not promised by> natal chart, can not happen"> > I believe that Divisional charts will confirm the strength of readings made> out from the Natal chart and we really do not require anything else for a> good prophecy.> > This is my personal thinking and I do not mean to degrade or hurt any> Learned member.> > with best regards,> > Kishore patnaik> > > > I> Be the first one to try the new Messenger 9 Beta! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.