Guest guest Posted October 25, 2008 Report Share Posted October 25, 2008 Dear Friend, Why bring Pt. Sanjay Rath , place your views independently. I have again gone through the article of Rath ji and your article carefully.I got the impression , that you are try to advocate your views instead of trying to understand the real intent of BPH. I may like to bring following points to your kind attention: 1. Rath ji is your guru , never show disrespect to your guru. Such attitude will bring your downfall. Rishi Yajvalkya ,Jaimni sometimes taken different line of thinking , but with the permission and with due respect to his guru.I think you are in USA too long. that is why you do not like to stick these simple norms. 2. Parasara had refereed higher authorities in BPHS KIKE 'SEER GARG' 3. BPHS INTENDS THAT THERE ARE TWO DISTINCT SCHEMES OF CHAR KARKAS-7 AS WELL AS 8 4 In 7 char karka scheme Rahu is not considered .However , if two planets are same zodiac degree in their respective signs, then char Karka replacement occurs and Rahu takes its place as sthir Karka of confusion and deceit.Seven (7 )CHAR KARKA SCHEME IS FOR MUNDANE CHARTS, THAT IS WHY PUTRA kARKA IS ABSENT AND RAHU AS STHIR kARKA DOES NOT REPRESENT ANY LIVING PERSON BUT DECEIT ETC. 5. 8 CHAR KARKA SCHEME IS FOR LIVING BEING . BPHS CLEARLY STATES 8 kARKA IN SERIAL ORDER-AK,AMK, BK, MK, PITK,PUTK,GK AND DK.THERE IS ABSOLUTELY ON AMBIGUITY OR CONFUSION. 6. kindly TRY TO UNDERSTAND THE PURPORT AND REASON BEHIND REPLACEMENT OF CHAR KARKA WITH STHIR KARKA. THIS IS VERY IMPORTANT AND CRUCIAL TO UNDERSTAND THE SIGNIFICANCE ,AS TO WHY CHAR KARKA ARE REPLACED BY STHIR KARKAS.IN FACT THIS CHAPTER OF BPHS DEALS IN ALL KINDS OF KARKAS ACCEPT NAISARGIKA KARKAS. THE SLOKAS IN THIS CHAPTER ARE LIKE SUTRA AND LOT OF CO-RELATION IS REQUIRED TO DECIPHER THEM. CHAR KARKA INDICATE THE HELP AND SUSTENANCE PROVIDED BY OTHER LIVING BEING OR LACK OF IT DUE TO THE ACTIONS OF PAST BIRTHS.STHIR KARKA INDICATE WHEN SUCH LIVING BEING WILL PUT TO GRIEF . 6. I urge , kindly read the article written by Rathji . It will show the light. Regards, G.K.GOELPh: 09350311433Add: L-409, SARITA VIHARNEW DELHI-110 076INDIA Get rid of Add-Ons in your email ID. Get yourname. Sign up now! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.