TP Chart Definition (India TP Chart 2008)

[Guest guest]

Pranaam Sanjay,

 

> If a person is born is adhika masa then as per their statement, the

> person shall have Tithi pravesh once in three years or so when there

> is an adhika masa!

 

That is incorrect. Suppose one is born in adhika Sraavana month. If a

particular year has adhika Sraavana month, then birthday is celebrated

in it. If not, birthday is celebrated in regular Sraavana month.

Regular Sraavana, nija Sraavana and adhika Sraavana are all one month

really and that is why they share a name.

 

Thus, one using soli-lunar months (Chaitra, Vaisakha etc) along with

soli-lunar days (tithis) in the determination of TP (instead of mixing

up solar months with soli-lunar days) will get one and exactly one

birthday every year.

 

> Secondly, whereas we all celebrate Rama Navami on Chaitra sukla

> Navami, the planet positions for Chaitra with Sun in Aries, Moon in

> Pusya and tithi as Navami do not really line up very well because we

> are using a more modern version of the Vedic calendar.

 

Are you saying that Hindu tradition today celebrates Sri Rama Navami,

Janmashtami etc on wrong days?

 

> When you make new rules discarding old and time

> tested ones, you are advised to think of all pro's and con's before

> suggesting it.

 

Let me remind you one thing from long back.

 

When you taught me TP more than a decade ago, you specifically

mentioned two approaches - one that relies on soli-lunar months fully

and the other mixing up with solar months. You specifically said that

you were not 100% sure which was correct. You told me to try out both.

However, you said sunsign based method was probably correct. But, the

bottomline is that you were not 100% sure then. But, we ended up using

what you preferred in all our papers and also in JHora.

 

However, your original instruction to me was that you were not 100%

sure and that you wanted me to experiment. I followed the instruction,

made my conclusion quite confidently, though it took some time.

Whether this is called my rule or your rule, whether this is accepted

or rejected is none of my concerns. I made my conclusion, shared it

with the world and made it available in the software. My dharma is

fulfilled and I can put one more issue to rest. What others do with

this is upto them. :-)

 

Best regards,

Narasimha

 

Do a Short Homam Yourself: http://www.VedicAstrologer.org/homam

Do Pitri Tarpanas Yourself: http://www.VedicAstrologer.org/tarpana

Spirituality:

Free Jyotish lessons (MP3): http://vedicastro.home.comcast.net

Free Jyotish software (Windows): http://www.VedicAstrologer.org

Sri Jagannath Centre (SJC) website: http://www.SriJagannath.org

 

 

sohamsa , " Sanjay Rath " <sjrath wrote:

>

> Dear Jyotisha

> An article on TP Charts of India of 1971 and 2008 are uploaded at my

> website at http://srath.com/ . You can see how the standard rules and

> methods of Jyotish have been used. I have not even used the special

> rules for TP Charts.

>

http://srath.com/om/index.php?option=com_content & view=article & id=211:india-tithi\

-pravesh-2008 & catid=42 & Itemid=74

>

> Secondly, whereas we all celebrate Rama Navami on Chaitra sukla

> Navami, the planet positions for Chaitra with Sun in Aries, Moon in

> Pusya and tithi as Navami do not really line up very well because we

> are using a more modern version of the Vedic calendar.

> I beleive that some astrologers have suggested a novel method of Tithi

> Pravesha where they completely ignore the Sun (sun sign) citing the

> celebration of festivals on tithi's inspite of sun being in different

> sign. Such celebrations are based on modern hinu calendar.

> If a person is born is adhika masa then as per their statement, the

> person shall have Tithi pravesh once in three years or so when there

> is an adhika masa! When you make new rules discarding old and time

> tested ones, you are advised to think of all pro's and con's before

> suggesting it. I believe that the Jagannath Hora 7.03 has this another

> novel method of TP in it.

>

> My suggestion: Have one standard Jagannath Hora software and another

> Jagannath Research software where you throw in everything you are

testing.

>

> Best Wishes

> Sanjay Rath