TP Chart Definition (India TP Chart 2008)

[Guest guest]

Dear All,

 

Nothing to do with TP, but how people born on 29th Feb (leap year)

would celebrate their birthdays in non-leap years?

 

Best Regards,

SS

 

 

 

 

sohamsa , " Narasimha Rao " <pvr wrote:

>

> Pranaam Sanjay,

>

> > If a person is born is adhika masa then as per their statement,

the

> > person shall have Tithi pravesh once in three years or so when

there

> > is an adhika masa!

>

> That is incorrect. Suppose one is born in adhika Sraavana month. If

a

> particular year has adhika Sraavana month, then birthday is

celebrated

> in it. If not, birthday is celebrated in regular Sraavana month.

> Regular Sraavana, nija Sraavana and adhika Sraavana are all one

month

> really and that is why they share a name.

>

> Thus, one using soli-lunar months (Chaitra, Vaisakha etc) along with

> soli-lunar days (tithis) in the determination of TP (instead of

mixing

> up solar months with soli-lunar days) will get one and exactly one

> birthday every year.

>

> > Secondly, whereas we all celebrate Rama Navami on Chaitra sukla

> > Navami, the planet positions for Chaitra with Sun in Aries, Moon

in

> > Pusya and tithi as Navami do not really line up very well because

we

> > are using a more modern version of the Vedic calendar.

>

> Are you saying that Hindu tradition today celebrates Sri Rama

Navami,

> Janmashtami etc on wrong days?

>

> > When you make new rules discarding old and time

> > tested ones, you are advised to think of all pro's and con's

before

> > suggesting it.

>

> Let me remind you one thing from long back.

>

> When you taught me TP more than a decade ago, you specifically

> mentioned two approaches - one that relies on soli-lunar months

fully

> and the other mixing up with solar months. You specifically said

that

> you were not 100% sure which was correct. You told me to try out

both.

> However, you said sunsign based method was probably correct. But,

the

> bottomline is that you were not 100% sure then. But, we ended up

using

> what you preferred in all our papers and also in JHora.

>

> However, your original instruction to me was that you were not 100%

> sure and that you wanted me to experiment. I followed the

instruction,

> made my conclusion quite confidently, though it took some time.

> Whether this is called my rule or your rule, whether this is

accepted

> or rejected is none of my concerns. I made my conclusion, shared it

> with the world and made it available in the software. My dharma is

> fulfilled and I can put one more issue to rest. What others do with

> this is upto them. :-)

>

> Best regards,

> Narasimha

>

> Do a Short Homam Yourself: http://www.VedicAstrologer.org/homam

> Do Pitri Tarpanas Yourself: http://www.VedicAstrologer.org/tarpana

> Spirituality:

> Free Jyotish lessons (MP3): http://vedicastro.home.comcast.net

> Free Jyotish software (Windows): http://www.VedicAstrologer.org

> Sri Jagannath Centre (SJC) website: http://www.SriJagannath.org

>

>

> sohamsa , " Sanjay Rath " <sjrath@> wrote:

> >

> > Dear Jyotisha

> > An article on TP Charts of India of 1971 and 2008 are uploaded at

my

> > website at http://srath.com/ . You can see how the standard rules

and

> > methods of Jyotish have been used. I have not even used the

special

> > rules for TP Charts.

> >

> http://srath.com/om/index.php?

option=com_content & view=article & id=211:india-tithi-pravesh-

2008 & catid=42 & Itemid=74

> >

> > Secondly, whereas we all celebrate Rama Navami on Chaitra sukla

> > Navami, the planet positions for Chaitra with Sun in Aries, Moon

in

> > Pusya and tithi as Navami do not really line up very well because

we

> > are using a more modern version of the Vedic calendar.

> > I beleive that some astrologers have suggested a novel method of

Tithi

> > Pravesha where they completely ignore the Sun (sun sign) citing

the

> > celebration of festivals on tithi's inspite of sun being in

different

> > sign. Such celebrations are based on modern hinu calendar.

> > If a person is born is adhika masa then as per their statement,

the

> > person shall have Tithi pravesh once in three years or so when

there

> > is an adhika masa! When you make new rules discarding old and time

> > tested ones, you are advised to think of all pro's and con's

before

> > suggesting it. I believe that the Jagannath Hora 7.03 has this

another

> > novel method of TP in it.

> >

> > My suggestion: Have one standard Jagannath Hora software and

another

> > Jagannath Research software where you throw in everything you are

> testing.

> >

> > Best Wishes

> > Sanjay Rath

>