[SoHamsa] Limitations of Ashtak Varaga - KAS or ANY BODY

[Guest guest]

om namo bhagavate paramguraveDear LalitNamasteMy humble request to you is to please focus on the astrology and not the astrologer.  You have made some serious allegations and  this is not the forum to express this. Like they say ..... 'Play the Ball - not the Man'.  Like some members have suggested, why dont you start a thread about your various theories and post case studies with charts of these various discoveries you have made and those interested can join that thread.  Im afraid that all your good knowledge would not be rightfully appreciated here if your posts are moderated or members choose to mark your mails as spam which would be most unfortunate.

All forums have certain minimum codes of conduct, so please respect this for the benefit of others.  Lets change the tone on the forum to one of enlightenment, discovery, accomplishment and positive thoughts so that we embrace this beautiful language of our Seers called Jyotish. 

Best WishesBipin On 2 April 2010 23:12, litsol <mishra.lalit wrote:

 

 

 

 

 

 

Late Sri CS Patel who was an authority in Ashtak Verga, Navamsa and Nadi astrology has written in one of his book that his predictions on the basis of Ashtak Varga don't come true, I have checked the same on my and some more charts, This is true that Ashtak Varga has a very limited appliction.

That KAS by manually adjustments in Ashtaks of known charts in order to fit his theory into post event analysis has become a buzz word. Ask him to predict 5 future event of any 5 people's life, the baloon will get punctured, Once I challanged either to him or to his chief shishya who runs his group and he left our group.

Astrologers like Rohini Ranjan who gets Guru-Chandaal yoga in their charts has only one agenda, confuse everybody, tell lies to distract people from the right path and make some name for them.

Ashtak Varga is static in it's nature, therefore, It's can not be relied upon for accurate predictions, only use of ashtak verga is assessment of strength of a house and a planet.

Solar returns and Tajaka are inital crude attempts by curious peopple to understand impact of transit, again they have a limited application.

Lal Kitab is wrong after a point, Just assess what's said about 10'th house for Jup in the light of real life's cases, not every thing seems to be said by a spirit.

Only Vedic Astrology is eternal and it works universally.

Lalit Mishra

[Guest guest]

om gurave namah

Dear Lalit

If Late Dr. C.S.Patel has written in his book that the predictions based on the Astakavarga do not come true, then it simply means that all that he has written in his book on Astakavarga is to be used for understand what does not work and what works. It cannot be used as a *text* for learning the basics. It also means that he is not the authority on the subject as then he would have given the authoritative solution to the astakavarga.

I can say that it works and in the future will provide the authority for the same.

 

You also have to decide what to use - Parashara or Varahamihira

 

You are right on the other points. I have saying this for years now. Keep the lamp burning.

Best wishes

Sanjay Rath

 

 

 

litsol

Saturday, April 03, 2010 2:42 AM

sohamsa

[soHamsa] Limitations of Ashtak Varaga - KAS or ANY BODY

 

Late Sri CS Patel who was an authority in Ashtak Verga, Navamsa and Nadi astrology has written in one of his book that his predictions on the basis of Ashtak Varga don't come true, I have checked the same on my and some more charts, This is true that Ashtak Varga has a very limited appliction.

That KAS by manually adjustments in Ashtaks of known charts in order to fit his theory into post event analysis has become a buzz word. Ask him to predict 5 future event of any 5 people's life, the baloon will get punctured, Once I challanged either to him or to his chief shishya who runs his group and he left our group.

Astrologers like Rohini Ranjan who gets Guru-Chandaal yoga in their charts has only one agenda, confuse everybody, tell lies to distract people from the right path and make some name for them.

Ashtak Varga is static in it's nature, therefore, It's can not be relied upon for accurate predictions, only use of ashtak verga is assessment of strength of a house and a planet.

Solar returns and Tajaka are inital crude attempts by curious peopple to understand impact of transit, again they have a limited application.

Lal Kitab is wrong after a point, Just assess what's said about 10'th house for Jup in the light of real life's cases, not every thing seems to be said by a spirit.

Only Vedic Astrology is eternal and it works universally.

Lalit Mishra