Astrologer's Guru's Negligent- Answers Mr. Prashantji, Pathiji, Narasimhaji etc. 3/6

[Guest guest]

Very good message Prashant Kumar jee!

 

RR

 

vedic astrology , Prashant kumar-Mee Shuba Vela

<pkgoteti wrote:

>

> Ramesh,

>

>

> BEFORE I COME TO UR CASE LET ME STET THIS UP FOR U AND IN NEXT REPLY  do the

othr part.

>

> if u can ask the same quesion to a doctor

>

> the same disorder/disease why ANY 2 diff doctors even if classmates,

benchmates wth the same sylabus, teachers differed in their prescriptions,

diagnosis

>

> why  any 2 or more lawyers difered in their case analysis say why must anyone

loose a case after all same law books same courts, same codes as well why?

>

> will any 2 architects, 2 cops differ in their assesments of any situation come

with different approaches

>

> pl do the survey and get back will surely answer this in greater detail

>

> Jyotishya is a divine science with no structtured and teaching order and

patronage as others have yet contribute a long way insolving  many issues OFTEN

COMBINING THE ROLES OF A FRIEND, PHILOSOPHER, GUIDE, Counsellor, a therapist, a

healher, a pep talk/morale booster a pyschiatrist and a doctor etc and yet get

the kind of stuff ppl like u dish out so oten why should we prove to u all we

can do or don;t do

>

> if u can get answers for the above may be we will too

>

> REMEMBER JYOTISHYA IS A SCIENCE OF HOPE, COUNSELLING a direction finder

>

> gives u a clue that there is LIGHT AT THE END OF THE TUNNEL, how far/long it

takes to get there and start afresh

>

>  when in distress and a emotional bridge between tough and good times without

wich expensive treatments, counsellings and even worse situations can come up if

we can;t complete it but all these we roll in to one and still...

>

> Best wishes

>

> Prashant

>  

> G B Prashant Kumar

>

> Pl give personal data with verifable life event dates=jobs, marriage, family,

kids, high/low times. Picture or 2  for Lagna features check to my

ID pkgoteti, Services of this astrologer in the group only are FREE!

personal consultations ARE CHARGEABLE! Mobile 09840051861 Chennai, India  Me

Shuba Vela!

>

>

>

>

> ________________________________

> ramesh hasija <rameshhasija

> vedic astrology

> Wednesday, June 3, 2009 6:42:53 AM

> [vedic astrology] Astrologer's Guru's Negligent- Answers Mr.

Prashantji, Pathiji, Narasimhaji etc.

>

>

>

>

>

> Dear Guru's and Astrologers,

>  

> Why does the definition and knowledge of astrology differs from one astrologer

to another? Same question about the same person has  different answers when the

persons horoscope is studied by different astrologers? Is this something that

some astroguru's are not enough knowledgable? Its confounding to me since

everyone of them studies the same basic concepts of astrology (though it may

have different forms)

>  

> Question Asked : Whether the following person should pursue Phd or a MBA

degree? Which among these two can be accomplished as per his astro horoscope?

Which is more beneficial for his career?

>  

> DOB : 23rd Sept, 1979

> Place : Faridabad, Haryana

> TOB  : 11:23 PM (23:23)

>  

> I am still trying to understand why the definition of astrology varies. I look

forward to answer of  the above question from astro guru's and astroexperts from

this group and that would give me some more with furrther comparison into the

confusion I have.

>  

> Regards,

> Ramesh 

>

>

[Guest guest]

Dee kumar ji,

 

Well many onvious things r not understood by a few who instead of asking what

they want to know and sort out the answers they get from their own eperiences,

doubt and cast aspertions even before their questions come in is what prompted

me t o put it as firmly as possible, but will reply yp his case asap

 

in case u can alsoit is  welcome

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

________________________________

Dee Kumar <dharmco

vedic astrology

Wednesday, June 3, 2009 10:56:39 AM

Re: [vedic astrology] Re: [va] Astrologer's Guru's Negligent- Answers

Mr. Prashantji, Pathiji, Narasimhaji etc. 3/6

 

 

 

 

 

Dear G B Prashant Kumar

 

Your observation is True and correct. Human mind differ from each other their

common problems and its solutions also differes in each and every case.

 

Dee  kumar

 

____________ _________ _________ __

Prashant kumar-Mee Shuba Vela <pkgoteti >

vedic astrology

Wednesday, June 3, 2009 7:42:36 AM

[vedic astrology] Re: [va] Astrologer's Guru's Negligent- Answers Mr.

Prashantji, Pathiji, Narasimhaji etc. 3/6

 

Ramesh,

 

BEFORE I COME TO UR CASE LET ME STET THIS UP FOR U AND IN NEXT REPLY  do the

othr part.

 

if u can ask the same quesion to a doctor

 

the same disorder/disease why ANY 2 diff doctors even if classmates, benchmates

wth the same sylabus, teachers differed in their prescriptions, diagnosis

 

why  any 2 or more lawyers difered in their case analysis say why must anyone

loose a case after all same law books same courts, same codes as well why?

 

will any 2 architects, 2 cops differ in their assesments of any situation come

with different approaches

 

pl do the survey and get back will surely answer this in greater detail

 

Jyotishya is a divine science with no structtured and teaching order and

patronage as others have yet contribute a long way insolving  many issues OFTEN

COMBINING THE ROLES OF A FRIEND, PHILOSOPHER, GUIDE, Counsellor, a therapist, a

healher, a pep talk/morale booster a pyschiatrist and a doctor etc and yet get

the kind of stuff ppl like u dish out so oten why should we prove to u all we

can do or don;t do

 

if u can get answers for the above may be we will too

 

REMEMBER JYOTISHYA IS A SCIENCE OF HOPE, COUNSELLING a direction finder

 

gives u a clue that there is LIGHT AT THE END OF THE TUNNEL, how far/long it

takes to get there and start afresh

 

 when in distress and a emotional bridge between tough and good times without

wich expensive treatments, counsellings and even worse situations can come up if

we can;t complete it but all these we roll in to one and still...

 

Best wishes

 

Prashant

 

G B Prashant Kumar

 

Pl give personal data with verifable  life event dates=jobs, marriage, family,

kids, high/low times. Picture or 2  for Lagna features check to my

ID pkgoteti , Services of this astrologer in the group only are FREE!

personal consultations ARE CHARGEABLE! Mobile 09840051861 Chennai, India  Me

Shuba Vela!

 

____________ _________ _________ __

ramesh hasija <rameshhasija@ >

vedic astrology

Wednesday, June 3, 2009 6:42:53 AM

[vedic astrology] Astrologer's Guru's Negligent- Answers Mr.

Prashantji, Pathiji, Narasimhaji etc.

 

Dear Guru's and Astrologers,

 

Why does the definition and knowledge of astrology differs from one astrologer

to another? Same question about the same person has  different answers when the

persons horoscope is studied by different astrologers? Is this something that

some astroguru's are not enough knowledgable? Its confounding to me since

everyone of them studies the same basic concepts of astrology (though it may

have different forms)

 

Question Asked : Whether the following person should pursue Phd or a MBA degree?

Which among these two can be accomplished as per his astro horoscope? Which is

more beneficial for his career?

 

DOB : 23rd Sept, 1979

Place : Faridabad, Haryana

TOB  : 11:23 PM (23:23)

 

I am still trying to understand why the definition of astrology varies. I look

forward to answer of  the above question from astro guru's and astroexperts from

this group and that would give me some more with furrther comparison into the

confusion I have.

 

Regards,

Ramesh 

 

 

[Guest guest]

Dear Mr. Ramesh,

 

I agree with Shree Prashant Kumar and other well known astrologers on their

reply to your question.  Since mention of my name is in your list referred to, I

send my reply as below:

 

Astrology is a very deep and fathomless ocean of a subject and none could claim

that they had 'conquered' the frontiers with 'comprehensive' knowledge. From the

days of yore, much before 'framing' the 'constitution' of religions  - for

us 'Vedas' and for others, 'Bible' or 'Kuran' etc, - with multi-faceted pointers

directing to 'salvation', Astrology was practiced in various societies with

various theories.  In centuries, many changes had come, as well as new

innovations and introductions to and for basic rules of Astrology. These were

added to the 'main frame' with human reasons and events. So, we eventually feel

this had expanded in size, concept, interpretations and reasoning.  Then an

astrologer would be a 'scared' rat to arrive at the right 'path' for any answer

to a question. 

 

Astrologer must have correct data before him, for finding factors to answer a

question.  To quote my experience, one told me that she was told by her mother

that she was born when the milkman came to her house in the morning of a given

date.

She added she married twice in three years.  With this nothing can be said by an

astrologer.  Even in the provision of data lot of errors are/could be there.

 

Astrologer is human with an environment.  His emotions are subjected to varied

circumstances.  While it is his profession, he makes all efforts to be 'correct'

in his readings within his prowess in the subject.  There are many areas an

astrologer may not be proficient also.  Like a doctor who is good as a

orthopaedist, could not be an expert in Oncology.  The person who approaches an

astrologer, believes, the astrologer knows everything.  This is were the error

starts to creep in.  However, the person studied astrology and is competent to

analyze the chart.  Perhaps, he could not confirm exactly to the answer demanded

by the question. An astrologer writes an answer paper with a chart before him,

every time, perhaps every day.

He cannot be answering correctly all the time. But his existence depends on that

profession.

 

One who approaches an astrologer believes that he can 'solve' all problems with

package of remedies.  Then he should go directly to God and ask him rather

asking an Astrologer!! A remedy recommended by him may not be the exact remedy

offered in the original texts.

 

Blessings.

A.V.Pathi,  

Astrologer,

 

 

 

________________________________

Prashant kumar-Mee Shuba Vela <pkgoteti

vedic astrology

Wednesday, June 3, 2009 6:41:27 AM

[vedic astrology] [va] Astrologer's Guru's Negligent- Answers Mr.

Prashantji, Pathiji, Narasimhaji etc. 3/6

 

 

 

 

 

Dee kumar ji,

 

Well many onvious things r not understood by a few who instead of asking what

they want to know and sort out the answers they get from their own eperiences,

doubt and cast aspertions even before their questions come in is what prompted

me t o put it as firmly as possible, but will reply yp his case asap

 

in case u can alsoit is  welcome

 

 

 

 

____________ _________ _________ __

Dee Kumar <dharmco >

vedic astrology

Wednesday, June 3, 2009 10:56:39 AM

Re: [vedic astrology] Re: [va] Astrologer's Guru's Negligent- Answers

Mr. Prashantji, Pathiji, Narasimhaji etc. 3/6

 

Dear G B Prashant Kumar

 

Your observation is True and correct. Human mind differ from each other their

common problems and its solutions also differes in each and every case.

 

Dee  kumar

 

____________ _________ _________ __

Prashant kumar-Mee Shuba Vela <pkgoteti >

vedic astrology

Wednesday, June 3, 2009 7:42:36 AM

[vedic astrology] Re: [va] Astrologer's Guru's Negligent- Answers Mr.

Prashantji, Pathiji, Narasimhaji etc. 3/6

 

Ramesh,

 

BEFORE I COME TO UR CASE LET ME STET THIS UP FOR U AND IN NEXT REPLY  do the

othr part.

 

if u can ask the same quesion to a doctor

 

the same disorder/disease why ANY 2 diff doctors even if classmates, benchmates

wth the same sylabus, teachers differed in their prescriptions, diagnosis

 

why  any 2 or more lawyers difered in their case analysis say why must anyone

loose a case after all same law books same courts, same codes as well why?

 

will any 2 architects, 2 cops differ in their assesments of any situation come

with different approaches

 

pl do the survey and get back will surely answer this in greater detail

 

Jyotishya is a divine science with no structtured and teaching order and

patronage as others have yet contribute a long way insolving  many issues OFTEN

COMBINING THE ROLES OF A FRIEND, PHILOSOPHER, GUIDE, Counsellor, a therapist, a

healher, a pep talk/morale booster a pyschiatrist and a doctor etc and yet get

the kind of stuff ppl like u dish out so oten why should we prove to u all we

can do or don;t do

 

if u can get answers for the above may be we will too

 

REMEMBER JYOTISHYA IS A SCIENCE OF HOPE, COUNSELLING a direction finder

 

gives u a clue that there is LIGHT AT THE END OF THE TUNNEL, how far/long it

takes to get there and start afresh

 

 when in distress and a emotional bridge between tough and good times without

wich expensive treatments, counsellings and even worse situations can come up if

we can;t complete it but all these we roll in to one and still...

 

Best wishes

 

Prashant

 

G B Prashant Kumar

 

Pl give personal data with verifable  life event dates=jobs, marriage, family,

kids, high/low times. Picture or 2  for Lagna features check to my

ID pkgoteti , Services of this astrologer in the group only are FREE!

personal consultations ARE CHARGEABLE! Mobile 09840051861 Chennai, India  Me

Shuba Vela!

 

____________ _________ _________ __

ramesh hasija <rameshhasija@ >

vedic astrology

Wednesday, June 3, 2009 6:42:53 AM

[vedic astrology] Astrologer's Guru's Negligent- Answers Mr.

Prashantji, Pathiji, Narasimhaji etc.

 

Dear Guru's and Astrologers,

 

Why does the definition and knowledge of astrology differs from one astrologer

to another? Same question about the same person has  different answers when the

persons horoscope is studied by different astrologers? Is this something that

some astroguru's are not enough knowledgable? Its confounding to me since

everyone of them studies the same basic concepts of astrology (though it may

have different forms)

 

Question Asked : Whether the following person should pursue Phd or a MBA degree?

Which among these two can be accomplished as per his astro horoscope? Which is

more beneficial for his career?

 

DOB : 23rd Sept, 1979

Place : Faridabad, Haryana

TOB  : 11:23 PM (23:23)

 

I am still trying to understand why the definition of astrology varies. I look

forward to answer of  the above question from astro guru's and astroexperts from

this group and that would give me some more with furrther comparison into the

confusion I have.

 

Regards,

Ramesh 

 

 

[Guest guest]

Dear Mr. Prashantji,

 

I certainly get your point. Thanks for throwing light on this. Probably I may

have come across few astroguru's in regards to my question who are not up to the

task or do not possess sufficient knowledge or provided very different opinions

due to their understanding of astroscience.

 

I look forward to your answer on this question.

 

 

Thanks,

Ramesh

 

--- On Tue, 6/2/09, Prashant kumar-Mee Shuba Vela <pkgoteti wrote:

 

 

Prashant kumar-Mee Shuba Vela <pkgoteti

[vedic astrology] Re: [va] Astrologer's Guru's Negligent- Answers Mr.

Prashantji, Pathiji, Narasimhaji etc. 3/6

vedic astrology

Tuesday, June 2, 2009, 8:12 PM

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Ramesh,

 

BEFORE I COME TO UR CASE LET ME STET THIS UP FOR U AND IN NEXT REPLY  do the

othr part.

 

if u can ask the same quesion to a doctor

 

the same disorder/disease why ANY 2 diff doctors even if classmates, benchmates

wth the same sylabus, teachers differed in their prescriptions, diagnosis

 

why  any 2 or more lawyers difered in their case analysis say why must anyone

loose a case after all same law books same courts, same codes as well why?

 

will any 2 architects, 2 cops differ in their assesments of any situation come

with different approaches

 

pl do the survey and get back will surely answer this in greater detail

 

Jyotishya is a divine science with no structtured and teaching order and

patronage as others have yet contribute a long way insolving  many issues OFTEN

COMBINING THE ROLES OF A FRIEND, PHILOSOPHER, GUIDE, Counsellor, a therapist, a

healher, a pep talk/morale booster a pyschiatrist and a doctor etc and yet get

the kind of stuff ppl like u dish out so oten why should we prove to u all we

can do or don;t do

 

if u can get answers for the above may be we will too

 

REMEMBER JYOTISHYA IS A SCIENCE OF HOPE, COUNSELLING a direction finder

 

gives u a clue that there is LIGHT AT THE END OF THE TUNNEL, how far/long it

takes to get there and start afresh

 

 when in distress and a emotional bridge between tough and good times without

wich expensive treatments, counsellings and even worse situations can come up if

we can;t complete it but all these we roll in to one and still...

 

Best wishes

 

Prashant

 

G B Prashant Kumar

 

Pl give personal data with verifable  life event dates=jobs, marriage, family,

kids, high/low times. Picture or 2  for Lagna features check to my

ID pkgoteti , Services of this astrologer in the group only are FREE!

personal consultations ARE CHARGEABLE! Mobile 09840051861 Chennai, India  Me

Shuba Vela!

 

____________ _________ _________ __

ramesh hasija <rameshhasija@ >

vedic astrology

Wednesday, June 3, 2009 6:42:53 AM

[vedic astrology] Astrologer's Guru's Negligent- Answers Mr.

Prashantji, Pathiji, Narasimhaji etc.

 

Dear Guru's and Astrologers,

 

Why does the definition and knowledge of astrology differs from one astrologer

to another? Same question about the same person has  different answers when the

persons horoscope is studied by different astrologers? Is this something that

some astroguru's are not enough knowledgable? Its confounding to me since

everyone of them studies the same basic concepts of astrology (though it may

have different forms)

 

Question Asked : Whether the following person should pursue Phd or a MBA degree?

Which among these two can be accomplished as per his astro horoscope? Which is

more beneficial for his career?

 

DOB : 23rd Sept, 1979

Place : Faridabad, Haryana

TOB  : 11:23 PM (23:23)

 

I am still trying to understand why the definition of astrology varies. I look

forward to answer of  the above question from astro guru's and astroexperts from

this group and that would give me some more with furrther comparison into the

confusion I have.

 

Regards,

Ramesh