Thirunedunthaandakam - Swamy Desikan - Appullar

[Guest guest]

Dear Padmanaban swamin,

 

It is well known that one of the reasons for Udaiyavar not giving a

vyakyanam for Azhwar srisookthis is that people usually dont comment

on a moolam which Udaiyavar already had commented. Thus Udaiyavar did

not want to stop the divyanubhavams of his sishyas from pouring out as

vyakyanams. If PVP swamin's commentary has to be the only commentary

and all anubhavams should be revolving about it then it would mean

that Swami Desikan had committed apacharam by writing Nigama Parimalam.

 

Coming to the parrot episode. Swami Desikan in Sampradaya prakriya

bhaagam of Srimad Rahasya Traya Saram mentions that he is a mere

parrot who was taught to speak by Appullar. Appullar and Swami Desikan

are Acharya purushaas belong to our Emperumaanaar Darsanam. So it is

apt to mention the anubhavam of Uthamoor swami alluding to Desikan and

Appullar. When Madhavakannan swami clearly mentions that he is giving

us the divyanubhavams of Uthamoor swami, there is no reason for

confusion. Those who feel that Uthamoor swami's vyakyanams are

saampradayic would relish others would skip it.

 

Dasan,

Aravindalochanadasanudasan