Guest guest Posted November 19, 2000 Report Share Posted November 19, 2000 Greatness of Bhagavad RAmAnuja Darsanam (GRD 1 A) AN INTRODUCTION (Anbil Ramaswamy) ======================================================================= Dear Bhagavatas: Greatness of Bhagavad Ramanuja Darsanam is presented by critically examining the philosophies of ADVAITA (MONISM), DVAITA (DUALISM) AND VISISHTADVAITA (QUALIFIED MONISM - CUM-DUALISM) Let me hasten to assure that these are not meant to create any controversies but meant to enlighten the general readership on the salient points of differences to help a better understanding of the various streams of philosophy. The views expressed herein are -- not entirely mine -- but are derived from 1. Swami Desika's " Para Matha Bhangam " (i) by Villivalam Sri Narayanachar Swami (Poorvasrama elder brother of the Prakritam HH Azhagiyasinghar) (ii) by Abhinava Desika Uttamur Swami. 2. Swami Desika's " Satha DushaNi " an excellent Introduction by Sri Srivatsankachariar Swami for which a brilliant foreword was provided in English (PP 50.and 64 and p.xii in Preface) - by Sri R. Kesava Iyengar, Senior Advocate, Supreme Court of India. 3. " AadhyAtmika sAra: " by Dr. SokkanAvur .V.NarasimhAchArya M.A, PhD, AasthAna VidwAn, Srimad AhObila matam, published by Sri G.K.Dikshit, Trichy. 4. " Sri BhAshyArtha Deepikai " (translation of " Sri BhAshyArtaha maNIpravALa Deepikai " of HH 40th Jeeyar of Sri Ahobila Mutt by above Sri SokkanAvur .V. NarasimhAchArya. 5. " Bhagavad Vishayam " - " First 2 Tiruvoimozhi " - " Mudal Sriya:pathi " published by Puttur Sri Krishnaswami Iyengar Swami containing the famous Vyakhyanams like Eedu 36000, Adaiyavalanjan Arumpadaurai, Jeeyar Arumpadaurai etc. dealing with the various philosophies. 6. Sri RamAnuja on " Tattvamasi " and " Neti Neti " by Prof. K.S. NarayanAchArya, Aasthana Vidwan, Sri ParakAla Mutt, Mysore and Head of Dept. of English, Karnataka Arts College, Dharwad, published by Veda Vidya Prakashana, Malola, Kalyananagar, Dharwad in February 1989. 7. " Brahma VidyA " (in six parts) by Sri S. Jagannarayanan, Deputy Secretary Ministry of Finance, Govt. Of India, Chennai 28, published from 1986 to 1990. 8. " Sri BhAshya sArAswAdhinee " by Vidwan Tirupputkuzhi Narasimha Tatachariar of Sri Hayagriva Vidya Peetam, Tharamani, Chennai 113, published in 1988. 9. " Sri BhAshya sAram " by Sri T.S. Rajagopalan Headmaster, Hindu High School, Triplicane, Chennai 5, published by AzhwArgal Amudha Nilayam, Komaleeswaranpet, Chennai 2 (1993) 10. " Life Divine " by Aurobindo, (Chapter II p7) 11. " Sri BAshya -on the philosophy of Brahma Sutra " by Prof. RaghavAchAr (p.204) 12. " Indian Philosophy " by Dr. Vatsyayan published by Kedar Nath Ram Nath, Meerut. 13. " Hindu View of Life " by Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan, Former President of India. published by MCM, NY, 1968 (pp.50 and 51) 14. " Hinduism " by Prof. Troy Wilson Organ published by Barron's Educational Series, Inc, 1974. (p.50 and p.281) 15. " 3 Ms -Man, Myth and Magic " - The illustrated Encyclopedia of Mythology, Religion and the Unknown, Marshall Cavendish, New York, London, Toranto, 1985, 12 Volumes, NY 1985 Vol.5 / p.1313 16. Tukaram Sant, poem translated by John S Huyland, " An Indian peasant mystic " London, Allenson & co] 17. Sathapatha BrAhmana, translated by Sir Monier- Williams and quoted by Gerber, (p.3) 18. LOUIS RENOU in " Great Religions of Man " ) published by George Brazillier Inc, NY, 1961. 19. THIBHAUT, G: The Vedanta Sutras-with Sankara Baashyam and Ramanuja's Sri Baashyam, Sacred books of the East, Oxford, 1879-1896. 20. Bhagavad Ramanuja’s “VedArtha Sangraha” by Veerapuram Sadagopachariar Swami, 1997. 21. Points explained by various AchAryas during Kalakshepams, which I had the Bhaghyam to attend during more than half-a-century. ======================================================================= This presentation forming part of my book entitled " Hinduism Rediscovered " has been reviewed by the venerable HH Azhagiya Singhar, Prakritam Jeeyar of Ahobila Mutt, HH Srimad Andavan of Poundarikapuram Ashramam, as can be noticed from their Srimukhams. (Copies already posted in the various nets) and other AchAryas. Several Bhagavatas like Sri M.K.Sudarshan, Sri Karalapakkam Anand, Sri Madhava Kannan, Sri Chandrasekaran and others have carefully scrutinized the manuscripts and have offered valuable suggestions, which have been incorporated. My heartfelt thanks to these Bhagavatas for their time, patience and efforts in improving this presentation. I would request Bhagavatas to kindly read through the entire series and feel free to offer feedback and constructive comments. I will gratefully acknowledge them and possibly incorporate in my next edition. Dasoham Anbil Ramaswamy ===================================================================== QUOTABLE QUOTES " The worship of Vishnu reveals the agreeable and happy aspects of Hinduism. In fact, as a religion, in the strict sense of the term, HINDUISM can be summarized as VISHNUISM " (Louis Renou - Vide 1tem 18 above (p37) ===================================================================== " In some important points, Ramanuja's commentary more accurately interprets the Vedanta Sutras than does Sankara's " (George Thibaut - Vide item 19 above Volume 34 (p.cxxv) ===================================================================== CONTENTS PROFILE SECTION 1 : INTRODUCTION SECTION 2 : SRUTI PASSAGES IN SUPPORT OF THE THREE STREAMS OF PHILOSOPHY. SECTION 3 :ADVAITA VIS-A-VIS OTHER SCHOOLS. (A) NONDUALITY (B) NIRGUNA, NIRAKARA, NIRAVAYAVA, NIRVISESHA (NETI, NETI etc) © THE CONCEPT OF MAYA OR ILLUSION (D) TRANSITORINESS (E) TRUTH EMERGING FROM UNTRUTH (F) ARE DREAMS REAL? (G) LIBERATION THROUGH KNOWLEDGE (H) JEEVAN MUKTI (LIBERATION WHILE LIVING) SECTION 4 : COMMON GROUNDS BETWEEN THE 3 STREAMS SECTION 5 : DVAITA VIS-A-VIS OTHER SCHOOLS. SECTION 6: CONCLUSION - Comparing and Contrasting the three streams. ==================================================================== _______________________ Get Your Private, Free E-mail from MSN Hotmail at http://www.hotmail.com. Share information about yourself, create your own public profile at http://profiles.msn.com. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.