Guest guest Posted September 30, 2002 Report Share Posted September 30, 2002 SrI: ChithrabhAnu , KanyA Maasam , PurattAsi 13: Krishna Paksha Ashtami , Mrugaseersha Nakshathram shrI: shrImate vakuLabhUShaNa mahAdeshikAya nama: shrImate rAmAnujAya nama: shrImate nigamAnta mahAdeshiKAya nama: shrImad GopAlArya mahAdeshikaiH anugRihItam shrI deshika divya sahasranAma stotram shrImannigamAnta mahA deshika - divyasahasranAmAvaLi:( 101-1008) *************************************************************** Dear Swamy Desika BhakthAs: From nAmAs 101 to 439, Thirukkudanthai Desikan covers the intricate doctrines housed by Swamy Desikan in the great Vaadha grantham of Satha DhUshaNi , PrakaraNa granthams ,Taathparya Chandrikai and Tatthva Muktha KalApam .In the previous posting , adiyEn mentioned that we will postpone the coverage of the nAmAs 101-439 and follow the order described below and priorotize for coverage , nAmAs 440-792 in the following order: 440-478: Saccharithra RakshA 479-492: NikshEpa RakshA 493-523: Rahasya RakshA 524-680: PaancharAthra RakshA 681-705: Sankalpa SooryOdhayam 706-720: Incidents in Swamy's Life and the creation of PaadhukA Sahasram 721-792: ChillaRai RahasyangaL 409-439: Satha DhUshaNi and Tatthva Muktha KalApam et al 793-1006: SrImath Rahasya Thraya Saaram 1007: VirOdha ParihAram 1008: Swamy Desikan's ascent to SrI Vaikuntam. AdiyEn will continue to follow closely the brilliant Tamil commentary of U.Ve. Dr.V.VasudEvAcchAr Swamy and add special notes as needed from a variety of sources to clarify fundamental doctrines. 440. (PraNavam) RaamAnujeeya-siddhAntha sarvOthkrushtatthva- saadhakAya nama: Salutations to that SadAchAryan , who established firmly that Bhagavath RaamAnuja SiddhAntham triumphs over all other contending siddhAnthams ! Swamy Desikan's unique and towering contribution is the assembly of the tatthvams associated with Bahgavath RaamAnuja SiddhAntham and defense of them with appropriate analysis of the deficencies of other siddhAnthams from the point of view of consistency with the VedAs and Brahma SoothrAs. Why is RaamAnuja SiddhAntham " SarvOthkrushtam ? " ********************************************** The philosophy of VisishtAdvaithA is recognized as having been taught in ancient times to disciples of BodhAyana (viz)., Tanka , Dramida , GuhadEva ,Kapardi , BhAruchi and others . For quite some time thereafter, these doctrines of VisishtAdvaitham rooted in Brahma SoothrAs remained obscure and latent . With Swamy NammAzhwAr's anugraham , AchArya Naatha Muni brought this darsanam to light and handed it over to his grandson (ALavanthAr)through his disciple to nourish them further(9-10th Century C.E) ; these doctrines were protected thereafter by AchArya RaamAnujA . Swamy Desikan absorbed the intricate aspects of this glorious darsanam and its unique doctrines from AchAryAs belonging to RaamAnujA's lineage and made it available to us all through his own illustrious sishya paramparai and profound SrI Sookthis.Through these rich contributions , Swamy Desikan established clearly that SrI Bhagavath RaamAnuja Darsanam is unassailable in terms of its superiority over the other darsanams since it faithfully adheres to the true purport of Sage BadarAyaNA's Brahma soothrams . Using the triad of Prathyaksham , anumAnam and sabdham , SrI RaamAnuja Darsanam reveals the correctness of the VisishtAdvathic doctrines without a shadow of doubt . SrI RaamAnuja darsanam banishes thus the darkness of nescience (ajn~Anam) and viparitha Jn~Anam. It helps us gain true Jn~Anam and thus becomes SarvOthkrushtam . Special Notes on the Triad as the main sources of knowledge(pramANAs). The Three PramANAs of VisishtAdhvaitham **************************************** VisishtAdvaitham accepts Prathayksham (perception), anumAnam (inference based on perception ) and scriptural testimony ( Sabda /Sruthi/Vedic texts ) as THE three main authoritative sources of knowledge (PramANAs).The nature and validity of these and other PramANAs such as UpamAna (Comparison ), arthApatti ( presumption ) and anupalabdhi ( non-apprehension) has been rigorously examined by Swamy Desikan . He accepts the three pramANAs , Prathyaksha, anumAna and Sabdha , and rejects the others . Even among these three pramANAs , he examines their nature and content in Tatthva Muktha Kalapa and identifies the acceptable cannons of these three pramANams from a VisishtAdhvathin point of view. We will come across these in the naamAs relating to Satha dhUshaNi and Tatthva Muktha KalApam (NaamAs 101-439 )later. VisishtAdhvaithins also accepts the Smruthis ( Manu Smruthi, MahA BharatA with its treaure of Bhagavath GitA inside , VishNu PurANam and the two VaishNavite AagamAs ( PaancharAthram and VaikhAnasam ) AS LONG AS THEY ARE IN CONFORMITY WITH VEDIC TEXTS. 1. Prathyaksha: Our darsanam does not reject the validity of sense perception (prathyaksha pramANam )like Advaithin , who senses the world , does business with it and yet dismisses it as unreal . Their reasoning is that senses can not always to be relied upon because of illusions and hallucinations (Brama).Examples for such illusion(PrathibhAshika Bhrama) are given as the mirage in the desert and the silver-hued shell , which is mistaken for the real silver.Another type of Bhrama cited by Adhvaitins is that of VyavahArika bhrama , where the world experienced by our senses as unreal until Brahman is realized by the Self. Such examples are used to dismiss the sensory perceptions as unreliable sources of primary knowledge (pramANAs).As a result, Advaithin holds the Vedic Texts as being superior to prathyaksha as valid pramAnAs. Vaikunta Vaasi Dr. V.N.Seshadri AchArya observes in this context: " VisishtAdvaithin maintains that the sense-perception (prathyaksha) is as valid as the Sruthi itself so long as what is percieved is not sublated or shown to be false by a later perception. Further ,VisishtAdvaithin states that if in any context , the text of Sruthi seems to contradict what is percieved by Prathyaksha , the Sruthi text has to be intrepreted in a way that will not be in conflict with what is actually perceived by the senses. This is one of the cardinal points of difference between the Advaithin and VisishtAdvaithin " . Of the three pramANAs , Prathyaksha is accepted as the most important and basic source of knowledge since the other two (anumAnam and Sabdha ) are dependent on prathyaksha. 2. AnumAna PramANam: VisishtAdhvaithins follow the simplicity (laagavam) of anumAna pramANam. NyAya-VisEshikA system of philosophy prefers anumAna over sabdha (vedam). This system however attempts to prove the existence of God as the Creator of the world by inference . VisishtAdvaithin rejects such views , which create elaborate structures like a mansion of cards through the tortured extensions of anumAnam (e.g: Guruthvam as a GuNam and Visesham as a padhArtham) .VisishtAdhvathin rejects these as superflous . VisishtAdhvaithins stay away from unnecsaary loops and labrinths and use anumAnam for only matters that need to be clarified . 3. Veda PramANam: VisishtAdhvaithins accept Sabdha as pramANam and so do others.This is the third and most significant source of knowledge. It is subdivided into (a) empirical (laukika) and non-empirical (aloukika). The aloukika sabdha includes VedAs, Upanishads and the two Aagamas. Swamy Desikan discards the Buddhists view that Sabdha is not a separate pramANa and proves in a rational manner the authority of VedAs as aloukika sabdha. In summary, Pratayaksha , anumAna and Sabdha are the only three pramANAs for VisishtAdvaithins ; the additional ones accepted by the other schools of philosophy are considered as the subsets of the above three. VAzhi vyAkhyAmuddirak kai !!! VedAnthasUri charaNau sharaNam prapadye !!! SrI LakshmI HayagrIva ParabrahmaNE nama: Daasan , Oppiliappan Koil VaradAchAri SaThakOpan Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.