Your postings

[Guest guest]

srimate ramanujaya nama:

Sadagopan,

 

You were first asking money for ratnangi kainkaryam

for the lord of tiruvahindrapuram by writing from the

work of sri vaishnava acharayas. Now I see you writing

from kritis of a advaitin musician asking for money. Has not that

tiyagaraja written that devatantra sivan is great in his kritis? He

has sung about other devatantarams also which a paramaikantin

will never think about. You are comparing that advaitin's

kritis with the works of great acharyas like srimath

parasara bhattar and it is a sin. None of our purva acharyas

have commented upon these advaitin kritis to explain

the divine sri suktis of our purva acharays. It is

horrible to see your mails in various email networks

propagating wrong things. Have you undergone traditional

learning at the feet of acharays? Do you have any knowledge of

that tiyagaraja's mode of sanayasa which is advaita sampradaya

param? Do you know the cheap value that advaitins have for

bhakti and saguna brahaman? I am copiying this to

ramanuja/desikasampradaya fourm because they sincerly enjoy

azhwars prabandams and they must be informed about this.

Why don't you restrict your sangeeta postings to your

sangeeta lists! sri sampradayam is great and acharyas

do not like silly things getting mixed up with it.

Most of your postings look like translations from

books without you having undergone traditional adyayanam.

Most of your postings do not make sense. You also

once wrote offending bhaktas of Shree manavala mamunigal swami

commenting on tiruman shape etc and then apologized

for name-sake. Please write if you are a sincere devotee

and do not project yourself as an authority that too with

wrong things in various lists. Please read arti-prabandam

of swami atleast once; then you yourself will stop

writing comparing advaitin bhakti with the bhakti of

our acharyas. Follow tiru-malizai azwar who visited all

darsanams and then set perfect example for parmaikantitvam.

 

Mamunigal dasan Manvalan R

22 April 2003

As my previous mail to ramanuja grps etc did not get appear,

I am sending it again.

 

_______________

MSN Instyle. Keeps you in sync. http://server1.msn.co.in/instyle/index.asp

Always!

[Guest guest]

Respect sree Manavalan,

I would like to bring to your attention that Sadagopan mama

is an elderly member of our forum. Although he is extremely

knowledgeable about our sampradayam, he has never claimed

to be a master about anything. He merely shares what he has

learnt about our Acharyas from acharyas. I would recommend

the before saying something about someone on this group or

any group, you please check your facts.

 

It is Saint Tyagaraja who wrote

" Nidhi Chala sukhama ramuni sannidhi seva sukhama "

meaning What is more important money or the sannidyam

of Sri Rama. I agree that Tyagaraja wrote about some

annya devata which were earlier in his life. Towards

the end of his life he wrote only about Rama. Please

watch your language when making suggestions or comments.

 

All the groups, whether it is Ramanuja, Bhakti list, Malolanet

Desikasampradayam want all members to be respectful to each other.

It would be greatly appreciated if you would kindly

be respectful to elderly members who are close to the age

of our parents.

 

I have personally met Sadagopan mama and know for a fact his

convictions and understand his love for Sriman Narayana.

 

Once again, please read your posts prior to posting. Emails

have a tendency of easily hurting people.

 

Thanks

Ramanuja Daasi

Manjula Sriram