FW: [Vaideekam] Sodhakumba Shraadham & Prathyaptika Shraaddham on a same day

[Guest guest]

Dear Swamin

 

Thank you for your guidance on Vaideekam matters.

 

 

 

But, whenever you advise any action on Anushtanam subjects, would it not be

authentic if you refer to the relevant authority from the scriptures and better

still, quote the exact text in support.

 

 

 

Any advice without such PramaaNam would render the advice as " Personal opinion "

or mere speculation and will be rightfully trashed.

 

 

 

Hope you will take it in the right spirit.

 

Thank you for your understanding and co-opeartion.

 

Dasoham

 

Anbil Ramaswamy

 

 

 

***

For most of the questions I am giving answers from my practical experience only.

Many times I had explained it to the group members,

that do not take my answers as authentic always, use it for immediate remedy and

get confirmation with some other vidwans.

I am giving references whenever I found it from the text books available with

me.

nvs

[Guest guest]

This has been my observation also. When Sriman Vasu Vadhyar has provided information he has quoted the source when known, and otherwise very frankly stated why he believes that to be the case, whether it is through experience or if he has heard it.

 

That very frank, clear and open presentation of responses has been much appreciated by myself.

 

Thank you.

 

Sreekanth--- On Tue, 6/9/09, Ram Anbil <Ramanbil wrote:

Ram Anbil <RamanbilFW: [Vaideekam] Sodhakumba Shraadham & Prathyaptika Shraaddham on a same day"vaideekam " <vaideekam >Cc: "Madhava Kannan Vasudevan" <srivaishnavan, "Sadagopan Varadachari" <yennappan, ramanbilDate: Tuesday, June 9, 2009, 9:55 AM

 

 

Dear SwaminThank you for your guidance on Vaideekam matters.But, whenever you advise any action on Anushtanam subjects, would it not be authentic if you refer to the relevant authority from the scriptures and better still, quote the exact text in support. Any advice without such PramaaNam would render the advice as "Personal opinion" or mere speculation and will be rightfully trashed.Hope you will take it in the right spirit.Thank you for your understanding and co-opeartion.DasohamAnbil Ramaswamy ***For most of the questions I am giving answers from my practical experience only.Many times I had explained it to the group members, that do not take my answers as authentic always, use it for immediate remedy and get confirmation with some other vidwans.I am giving references whenever I found it from the text books available with

me.nvs

[Guest guest]

dear swaminaha,

 

while such pramanams are doubtless useful, but shastras also contain a huge

number of sampradaya which are handed down orally too. such oral writ does also

have some validity and may be useful in interpreting the written text. we

should not always insisit on written pramanam alone and take it as the only

ultimate authority. this is my feeling.

 

dasoham

vitahavya

 

 

 

 

 

vaideekam , Ram Anbil <Ramanbil wrote:

>

> Dear Swamin

>

> Thank you for your guidance on Vaideekam matters.

>

>

>

> But, whenever you advise any action on Anushtanam subjects, would it not be

authentic if you refer to the relevant authority from the scriptures and better

still, quote the exact text in support.

>

>

>

> Any advice without such PramaaNam would render the advice as " Personal

opinion " or mere speculation and will be rightfully trashed.

>

>

>

> Hope you will take it in the right spirit.

>

> Thank you for your understanding and co-opeartion.

>

> Dasoham

>

> Anbil Ramaswamy

>

>

>

> ***

> For most of the questions I am giving answers from my practical experience

only.

> Many times I had explained it to the group members,

> that do not take my answers as authentic always, use it for immediate remedy

and get confirmation with some other vidwans.

> I am giving references whenever I found it from the text books available with

me.

> nvs

>