Ayurveda plaigiarism

[Guest guest]

The following email was received by moderators of this group in

response to

http://health.ayurveda/message/10649

especially with regards to the moderator post script.

If anything this proves the need for more people helping with

moderation of group messages as it is not possible for only 2 people

to verify each and every message and especially to check for

plaigiarism.

Since moderators have approved the posting of the plaigiariser we

reproduce the email sent to us by a alert member Mr. Todd Caldecott

in its entirety.

Also we appeal for more members to help us with moderation to avoid

further incidents like this.

Comments from Dr. Rahul will be most welcome.

 

Cybervaidya

 

_

ahh, i see my BS detector is in good working order!

i was intrigued by the idea that an ayurvedic physician recommends

immunizations, but then i find that dr. rahul is perhaps at best an

unrepentant " copy-and-paster "

 

 

http://www.growingwell.com/bchild/vaccination1.htm

http://www.drrahulgupta.page.tl/-imunization-Schedules.htm

 

 

to what degree can we comment on dr. rahul's " gold medal "

expertise? at the very least, writing his own web material is

definitely NOT his

probing a little closer, one finds that ALL of the material i

checked on dr. rahul's site is taken from another with credit or

citation

 

 

see:

 

 

http://www.motherherbs.com/abelmoschus-moschatus.html

http://www.drrahulgupta.page.tl/Abelmoschus-Moschatus.htm

 

 

http://www.motherherbs.com/history-of-herbs.html

http://www.drrahulgupta.page.tl/history-of-ayurvedic-herbs.htm

 

 

http://www.aarogya.com/Complementary/Ayurveda/origin.asp

http://www.drrahulgupta.page.tl/ayurveda.htm

 

 

http://www.ayurvediccollege.com/why.html

http://www.drrahulgupta.page.tl/why-ayurveda.htm

 

 

http://www.ayurveda-herbs.com/ayurveda-diet.htm

http://www.drrahulgupta.page.tl/Ayurvedic-Diet.htm

 

 

http://www.aarogya.com/Complementary/Meditation/

http://www.drrahulgupta.page.tl/Meditation.htm

 

 

http://www.aarogya.com/Complementary/Naturopathy/

http://www.drrahulgupta.page.tl/Naturopathy.htm

 

 

there is nothing wrong with self-promotion

but this is nothing other than blatant deception

 

 

best... todd

_

 

ok, i DO have better things to do, but this takes the cake

stealing other practitioner's case histories???

 

see dr. rahul's site:

http://www.drrahulgupta.page.tl/achievements.htm

and compare with: http://www.ayurvedamrita.com/casestudies.htm

Caldecott

_____

[Guest guest]

> i was intrigued by the idea that an ayurvedic physician recommends

> immunizations, but then i find that dr. rahul is perhaps at best an

> unrepentant " copy-and-paster "

 

All in keeping with ancient tradition, obviously!

 

Vagbhata was a bit of a " copy-and-paster " too!

 

Cheers,

Gerald

[Guest guest]

Dear Gerald,

I do not agaree with you.

 

Vagbhata was a 100% copy and paster.

Dr Rahul is a bit copy and paster.

 

Vagbhata wrote this small old book some 5000 years back.

Dr Rahul's is the ultra modern website.

 

Vagbhata has himself announced his copying in the beginning of his book.

Dr Rahul's work of copying has been highlighted by some of his friends.

 

Vagbhata blended the same science of Ayurveda told by two different persons.

Dr Rahul is trying to blend two different sciences, one from India & the other

from the modern world. This work is not possible in the near future, I think.

 

Cheers

kkganesh