Jump to content
IndiaDivine.org

case in point

Rate this topic


Guest guest

Recommended Posts

63 y/o type 2 diabetic, of jewish descent

10 year diagnosis, taking metformin and diabeta

blood sugars uncontrolled, doctors prescribing insulin

after less than one week on a restricted carb diet, called me up

blood sugars normal, feels great

 

Caldecott, Dip. Cl.H, RH(AHG)

Ayurvedic practitioner, Medical Herbalist

203 - 1750 East 10th Ave

Vancouver, BC V5N 5K4 CANADA

web: http//:www.toddcaldecott.com

email: todd

tel: (1)778.896.8894

fax: (1)866.703.2792

Link to comment
Share on other sites

> 63 y/o type 2 diabetic, of jewish descent

10 year diagnosis, taking metformin and diabeta

blood sugars uncontrolled, doctors prescribing insulin

after less than one week on a restricted carb diet, called me up

blood sugars normal, feels great<

 

 

Any diet that restricts rapidly digesting carbohydrates can be used to

resinsitize Insulin receptor sites. A very popular diet is the one

advocated by Dr Joseph Mercola which is a no grain diet - that diet is

essentially meat, eggs, fish, and vegetables (excluding rapidly

digesting starchy vegetables like potato)- this type of diet will very

quickly stabalize Insulin functions - and is excellent for meat

eaters. But such diets are in no way the only way to resolve Insulin

resistance - most people in the world who have resolved their Insulin

Resistance through diet have followed a mixed diet of animal and

vegetable proteins along with complex carbohydrates from whole grains

and vegetables - this is the mainstream diet advocated in western

countries and Japan for type 2 diabetes- in China this type of diet is

considered an essential component in healing type 2 diabetes - this

diet and it's vegetarian version (which replaces the animal foods with

beans and legumes)has been used by large number of people to resolve IR.

 

The essential elements of a diet to resolve Insulin Resistance are to

cut out all high glycemic foods (above 50 on the glycemic scale) one

does not need to refer to glycemic tables to achieve this simply cut

out all sugar, honey, white flour products and all refined grains,

rapidly digesting vegetables and fruits and their juices - increase

fiber in the diet (eating whole grains naturally does this)- cut out

all refined oils in the diet and keep oil consumption at a lower

level, avoid chiles. One other point to consider and that is that

there are studies showing that milk and it's products contribute to

type 2 diabetes - so if one would like to experiment with this try

leaving off milk and it's products for a week or two and see if it

helps to stabalize blood sugar - there is a certain logic to this

since milk is kapha forming and is Ama forming in a large percentage

of people - do not overeat this is big stress on the pancreas - eat

reguarly never allow yourself to get hungry - five small meals a day

are best - try to keep sugar levels as steady as possible - this is

the secret.

 

It has been claimed here that one can not follow such a diet in

western contries because it does not suit their ancesteral habits -

this is simply not true since this diet is the diet most used to

resolve Insulin problems. I have seen many cases resolved with this

type of diet in both it's meat containing form and in the vegetarian

form.

 

There are many famous clinics around the world that use high complex

carbohydrate diet to resolve IR - many have been following these

regimes for decades - like many clinics and hospitals in India - I

mentioned the late Dr Karup before - the Bircher-Benner Clinic in

Europe - I remember one Naturopath Dr Ramakrishna who had a well

regarded clinic in Juhu, Bombay - I myself went to Jindal Nagar,

Bangalore to the Institute of Naturopathy and Yogic Sciences and was

told that they have excellent results with type 2 diabetes - as is

well known all of the leading Ayurvedic hospitals in India follow

strict vegetarian diet to resolve sugar problems - many of those

institutions even use white rice - this is also true in Japan and

China. I would not reccomend white rice since I think that the high

fiber in whole grains is very helpful in these cases since whole

grains digest at a slower rate than refined grains. The key to that

issue - if one is using white rice then be sure to take some protein

and fat with the rice everytime you eat it - best eat whole grains.

For those who take kanni as the evening meal please leave it off until

the blood sugar has been stabalized for three months.

 

Sugar metabolism problems are easily solved using both meat diets and

vegetarian diets - dozens of studies and experience confirm this. It

must be remembered that both the meat diet and the vegetarian diet

must be followed absolutely correctly otherwise they do not work -

especially in the beginning where any rapidly digesting carbohydrate

food will negate the effects of the diet - herbs are helpful during

this phase.

 

Dr Vinod Kumar

Link to comment
Share on other sites

> Any diet that restricts rapidly digesting carbohydrates can be used to

> resinsitize Insulin receptor sites. A very popular diet is the one

> advocated by Dr Joseph Mercola which is a no grain diet - that diet is

> essentially meat, eggs, fish, and vegetables (excluding rapidly

> digesting starchy vegetables like potato)- this type of diet will very

> quickly stabalize Insulin functions - and is excellent for meat

> eaters. But such diets are in no way the only way to resolve Insulin

> resistance - most people in the world who have resolved their Insulin

> Resistance through diet have followed a mixed diet of animal and

> vegetable proteins along with complex carbohydrates from whole grains

> and vegetables - this is the mainstream diet advocated in western

> countries and Japan for type 2 diabetes- in China this type of diet is

> considered an essential component in healing type 2 diabetes - this

> diet and it's vegetarian version (which replaces the animal foods with

> beans and legumes)has been used by large number of people to

> resolve IR.

 

that's funny, because this is exactly the kind of diet that is

recommended and yet the rates of diabetes continues to climb upwards

it also forms a good portion of my patient base that have tried this

approach but find that it DOES NOT WORK

 

i am very skeptical, because as part of my training, we were all

taught to emphasize the high carb, whole grain vegetarian diet for

obesity, CVD and diabetes

 

however, after trying to implement this diet for several years in my

practice, i cannot recall a single case where people achieved any

significant improvement, without the person adopting a very rigorous

exercise regimen, and then even then, they continued to have 5-10 lbs

of truncal weight that they could not lose

 

it took a lot of soul-searching, investigation and a reassessment of

the predominant bias for me to finally arrive at an effective solution

trust me, it would be a lot easier for me to tow the party line on

this, but i cannot do this with good conscience

perhaps it is easier for me because i do not follow a spiritual path

that dictates my diet - i understand your conundrum, but it shouldn't

blind us to the evolutionary realities of the human diet

 

living in a non-indian climate with people whose ancestry evolved

with a non-vegetarian diet, a low carb approach is demonstrably the

most effective method to reduce obesity, as well as the risk and

indicators of IR, CVD and diabetes

 

>

> The essential elements of a diet to resolve Insulin Resistance are to

> cut out all high glycemic foods (above 50 on the glycemic scale) one

> does not need to refer to glycemic tables to achieve this simply cut

> out all sugar, honey, white flour products and all refined grains,

> rapidly digesting vegetables and fruits and their juices - increase

> fiber in the diet (eating whole grains naturally does this)- cut out

> all refined oils in the diet and keep oil consumption at a lower

> level, avoid chiles.

 

 

people will often complain about the restrictiveness the low carb

approach, but i find that those who do find that their sugar cravings

drop off dramatically after the first couple weeks - the link here

with ecological disturbances such as candida that modulates appetite

and craving also plays a factor

 

however, those who follow a peasant-style vegetarian diet rarely do

it effectively, as we can see very clearly in 99% of the ayurvedic

doctors i have met who are all prediabetic - they know better but

they cannot resist

 

this is because even a whole grain high carb diet will still cause

the blood sugar to follow a roller-coaster pattern, and hypoglycemia

still seems to be at play for many, esp. if their prakriti revolves

around vata

 

which brings us to:

 

 

> five small meals a day

> are best - try to keep sugar levels as steady as possible - this is

> the secret.

 

which is a method to medicate hypoglycemia - just measure the blood

sugar throughout the day and graph it out

all this achieves is a chronically elevated blood sugar state, which

precipitates insulin resistance

 

except athletes who expend a lot of calories, people rarely achieve

their weight loss target with this method, and as they age inevitably

fall into the IR pattern and display the tell-tale signs of truncal-

abdominal obesity

 

it also goes against everything i understand about proper digestion

from an ayurvedic perspective, which is to allow the stomach to clear

itself regularly

 

eating 5 small meals a day ensures that the stomach always has food

in it, and this is not conducive to good digestion, as per ayurveda

 

somebody correct me if i am wrong and tell me the shloka that says we

must eat 5 times a day for health

 

everything that has ever been said in any authentic health tradition

from ayurveda, chinese medicine, unani, etc says we need to eat LESS

often, not MORE often

 

if people eat the way i recommend, they need only eat twice a day

maybe with a small snack like an apple at most

 

this way you can be productive without to worry about eating all day

long to medicate your blood sugar irregularities, while achieving

your weight loss goals, and reducing your risk of diabetes, cancer

and CVD

 

Caldecott, Dip. Cl.H, RH(AHG)

Ayurvedic practitioner, Medical Herbalist

203 - 1750 East 10th Ave

Vancouver, BC V5N 5K4 CANADA

web: http//:www.toddcaldecott.com

email: todd

tel: (1)778.896.8894

fax: (1)866.703.2792

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...