Guest guest Posted February 15, 2004 Report Share Posted February 15, 2004 Mary, My replies are interspersed within your message: ===================================== , " Mary " <mhysmith@e...> wrote: > Tom, > > I liked your site. I wanted to make a few comments though. I used baking > soda and salt for many years, as well as the water irrigation. All were > suggested by a dentist back when my problems starting getting serious. They > helped but did not cure. In the problems with my teeth and peridontal > disease, I also started losing the enamel on my teeth a few years ago. My > dentist can't figure it out - says she has one other patient she has that > this has also happened to. I've found nothing on it to explain it and > suspect the salt and soda as possibly being too abrasive over too long a > period of time. I could be wrong but I no longer use them to brush for this > reason. ========================================= Baking Soda is highly soluable in liquid (water, saliva) and is not abrasive. Table salt is only slightly less soluable. Toothpastes, however, contain silica for the purpose of abrasion and I would consider them more abrasive than either baking soda or table salt. On the tooth surface there is a constant demineralization and remineralization taking place. For REmineralization to take place (regaining enamel) there are six conditions which need to be present to allow this ionization transfer. This is covered in an article at our site: http://mizar5.com/demin.htm . Is it possible that you are not meeting one or more of these conditions? ========================================= > I have battled serious problems with peridontal disease for 15 years now. > Peridontal disease also runs in my family as it does in the other Mary's. > My father lost a lot of teeth to it and not from lack of neglect or > cleanliness. There is no way anyone will convince me that it is simply a > matter of good cleaning hygiene though I agree that is very important. I > believed it was only about hygiene until just recently. I actually never > had a cavity until I was in my twenties. At the time of my first peridontal > surgery, I don't think I had a total of 5 fillings in my mouth. Very likely > cleanliness was the reason for that but it didn't prevent the peridontal > problems. Microbes are there in everyones bodies, especially mouths. You > don't have to kiss, just open up and in they will come. What you are > implying is that peridontal disease is contagious - I don't think you really > mean to say that. ============================================ I absolutely mean to say that! You are not born with srep mutans or p. gingivitis floating around in your mouth. They don't float around in the air waiting for you (they are anaerobic, remember), rather are passed from person to person. This is not NEWS to periodontology. Monitor the dental hygienist or periodontal groups right here at if you need some witnesses... ============================================ In those with peridontal disease, there is greater growth > of particular bacteria. Smokers for example have higher rates of it. There > has to be something systemically that feeds the growth of this particular > bacteria and certainly, our immune system is there to fight such growth so > you need to consider it as a factor. ============================================ I certainly consider the auto-immune system as a facter in fighting this disease and a serious one at that. The AIS may have a big role in how an individual is is affected by these microbes and smoking could hinder that, along with a host of other things a person does to or does not do for the body. Many drugs create an effect of drying the mouth or hindering the flow of saliva, for example. This is PERFECT for a lot of these microbes! Remember amphetamines back in the 60's and 70's? They were notorious for drying the mouth. Ever hear of 'cotton-mouth'? I'll tell you what, if you aren't old enough to remember, just keep you eye out these days as they are busting meth-labs left and right anymore... MANY prescription medicines have the same effect! ============================================ We tend to think of sugar and teeth > as the sugar getting on the teeth and causing decay because it sits there on > them. So just brush it off - keep them clean? No there is more to it. > Sugar actually does quite a bit more to the body's physiological > functioning, and affects the immune system. It can cause higher blood sugar > levels and free radicals. What does this bacteria particularly like to > grow? It is there in the tissue - what does it get from the tissues that it > likes so much? What is in some's tissues and not others? ============================================ The sugars alone do not cause decay. The microbes doing the damage feed on the sugars and excrete acids. Acids cause the decay! Not the sugars. What I'm trying to say is that we need to cut off the supply - the source of nutrition to the microbe. As we get older, certain starchy foods also convert to the complex sugars that the microbes thrive on. I do not believe you are wrong in that certain enzymes may be extracted from the tissues in SOME cases, but the culprit is the microbe, excreting acids and causing decay. ============================================= If you put > diabetes and peridontal disease both into a search engine, you'll find > plenty to show correlation of the two problems occurring together. Wounds > actually don't heal well in diabetics - clean or not. Diabetes is by the > way, about sugar. I really don't think associating sugar and peridontal > disease is bullshit. > > Mary ========================================= I did not say that associating sugar and periodontal disease is BS. I meant that the 'party line': " brush twice a day, see your dentist twice a year and avoid sugar " is BS. That is the propaganda we were always taught. The key is proper cleaning of the surface of the tooth, under the gumline and in the case of deeper pockets cleaning with an oral irrigator, because you cannot reach down more than a millimeter or two with the brush and floss. Tom Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.