Jump to content
IndiaDivine.org

Comparisons

Rate this topic


Guest guest

Recommended Posts

Well call me obsessive - I've been looking up some of the herbs in the two

liver formulas I have used on the horse (below), trying to compare the TCM

properties. Anyone have any further info on any of these? I need a good

materi medica!

 

I am trying to see if I can get any clues from why he reacted so badly to

both the Bu Zhong AND the Chai Hu Qing Gan Tang, and so well to the

Ayurvedic . My herbalist told me the Bu Zhong could be heating, too yang,

but the second is supposed to clear heat?? Anyone have any

contra-indications for Chai Hu Qing Gan tang listed anywhere?

 

Jackie (giving herself tense dreams about 'making order out of chaos')

 

 

AYURVEDIC

1 Eclipta alba - Han Lian Cao

Tonifies Liver and Kidney Yin

Clears Deficiency Heat, Cools the Blood and Stops Bleeding

2 Terminalia Chebula - He Zi , Ke Zi?

bitter, sour, astringent, warm

astringe the intestines and stop diarrhea.

3 Terminalia Arjuna,

4 Ichnocarpus Frutescens

5 Aphanamixis Rohituka

6 Andrographis Paniculata - Chuan Xin Lian

Bitter, cold

clear heat and toxins, cool blood, reduce swelling, relieve inflammation

*Insulin resistance!

7 Boerhaavia Diffusa

The alkaloid fraction of the root of Boerhaavia diffusa has a dramatic

effect in buffering against elevation of plasma cortisol levels under

stressful conditions. Subsequent to this buffering of cortisol, Boerhaavia

alkaloids also prevent a drop in immune system performance. Indicating a

bi-directional adaptogenic activity, these same plant alkaloids also act to

reverse the depletion of adrenal cortisol associated with adrenal

exhaustion. Since blood type A (and B) is most impacted by the tendency to

over produce cortisol, this herb is tailor made for these blood types.

8 Phyllanthus Niruri,

9 Fumaria Parviflora

10 Azadirachta Indica -Yin du ku lian

11 Sida Cordifolia - Ma Huang

Contraindicated in yin deficiency or adrenal weakness - adrenal stimulant

12 Swertia chirata,

13 Tephrosia Purpurea

14 Canscora Decussata

 

CHINESE - Chai Hu Qing Gan Tang - Clears heat

1 Chai Hu 4.5 Bupleurum

Cool, spicy, bitter

Clears heat, regulates liver qi, raises the yang. For some, especially those

with a tendency to yin deficiency, it can bring up unwarranted feelings of

anger

2 Shen Di Huang 4.5 Rehmannia

Heat caused by lack of fluids (yin deficiency), fire rising

3 Dang Gui 6 Tangkuei - Angelica sinensis

Warm; bitter, sweet, slightly pungent; attributive to liver and spleen,

tonic

Contra yin deficiency,

4 Chi Shao 4.5 Red Peony - Radix Paeoniae Rubra

Rec Kidney yin deficiency, circulate blood, Lessens perspiration, purifies

yin, night sweats, fever

5 Chuan Xiong 3 Lingusticum

Moves blood

6 Lian Qiao 6 Forsythia

Properties: bitter in flavour, slightly cold in property, acting on the

lung, heart and gallbladder channels.

Effects: clearing away heat, detoxicating, subduing swelling and dissolving

lumps.

7 Niu Bang Zi 4.5 Arctium lappa - Burdock root

Pungent and cold

All " wind-heat " ailments

9 Huang Qin 3 Scutellariae baicalensis - chinese skullcap

Properties: bitter in flavour, cold in property, acting on the lung,

gallbladder, stomach and large intestine channels.

Effects: clearing away heat and dampness, purging fire, detoxicating,

stopping bleeding, and preventing miscarriage.

9 Tian Hua Fen 3 Trichosanthes kirilowii - Tricosanthus root

sweet in flavor and cold in nature

good at promoting production of body fluids, It clears evil Phlegm and

moistens Dryness of the Lung

10 Fang Fen 3 Ledebouriellae divaricatae - siler divaricatum

11 Gan Cao 3 Licorice

Properties: sweet in flavour, neutral in property, acting on the heart,

lung, spleen and stomach channels.

Effects: Invigorating the spleen, replenishing qi, eliminating phlegm,

arresting cough, clearing away heat and toxins, relieving spasm and pain,

and moderating the properties of other herbs.

12 Zhi Zi 4.5 Gardenia - Gardeniae jasminoidis

Properties: bitter in flavour, cold in property, acting on the heart, lung,

stomach and sanjiao channels

Effects: purging fire, relieving dysphoria, clearing away heat, promoting

diuresis, removing heat from the blood and stopping bleeding.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hey, Jackie.

 

What is it that told you " he reactred so badly " ? What was the reaction?

That would help us know what the problem was.

 

-al.

 

jackie wrote:

>

> Well call me obsessive - I've been looking up some of the herbs in the two

> liver formulas I have used on the horse (below), trying to compare the TCM

> properties. Anyone have any further info on any of these? I need a good

> materi medica!

>

> I am trying to see if I can get any clues from why he reacted so badly to

> both the Bu Zhong AND the Chai Hu Qing Gan Tang, and so well to the

> Ayurvedic . My herbalist told me the Bu Zhong could be heating, too yang,

> but the second is supposed to clear heat?? Anyone have any

> contra-indications for Chai Hu Qing Gan tang listed anywhere?

>

> Jackie (giving herself tense dreams about 'making order out of chaos')

>

> AYURVEDIC

> 1 Eclipta alba - Han Lian Cao

> Tonifies Liver and Kidney Yin

> Clears Deficiency Heat, Cools the Blood and Stops Bleeding

> 2 Terminalia Chebula - He Zi , Ke Zi?

> bitter, sour, astringent, warm

> astringe the intestines and stop diarrhea.

> 3 Terminalia Arjuna,

> 4 Ichnocarpus Frutescens

> 5 Aphanamixis Rohituka

> 6 Andrographis Paniculata - Chuan Xin Lian

> Bitter, cold

> clear heat and toxins, cool blood, reduce swelling, relieve inflammation

> *Insulin resistance!

> 7 Boerhaavia Diffusa

> The alkaloid fraction of the root of Boerhaavia diffusa has a dramatic

> effect in buffering against elevation of plasma cortisol levels under

> stressful conditions. Subsequent to this buffering of cortisol, Boerhaavia

> alkaloids also prevent a drop in immune system performance. Indicating a

> bi-directional adaptogenic activity, these same plant alkaloids also act to

> reverse the depletion of adrenal cortisol associated with adrenal

> exhaustion. Since blood type A (and B) is most impacted by the tendency to

> over produce cortisol, this herb is tailor made for these blood types.

> 8 Phyllanthus Niruri,

> 9 Fumaria Parviflora

> 10 Azadirachta Indica -Yin du ku lian

> 11 Sida Cordifolia - Ma Huang

> Contraindicated in yin deficiency or adrenal weakness - adrenal stimulant

> 12 Swertia chirata,

> 13 Tephrosia Purpurea

> 14 Canscora Decussata

>

> CHINESE - Chai Hu Qing Gan Tang - Clears heat

> 1 Chai Hu 4.5 Bupleurum

> Cool, spicy, bitter

> Clears heat, regulates liver qi, raises the yang. For some, especially those

> with a tendency to yin deficiency, it can bring up unwarranted feelings of

> anger

> 2 Shen Di Huang 4.5 Rehmannia

> Heat caused by lack of fluids (yin deficiency), fire rising

> 3 Dang Gui 6 Tangkuei - Angelica sinensis

> Warm; bitter, sweet, slightly pungent; attributive to liver and spleen,

> tonic

> Contra yin deficiency,

> 4 Chi Shao 4.5 Red Peony - Radix Paeoniae Rubra

> Rec Kidney yin deficiency, circulate blood, Lessens perspiration, purifies

> yin, night sweats, fever

> 5 Chuan Xiong 3 Lingusticum

> Moves blood

> 6 Lian Qiao 6 Forsythia

> Properties: bitter in flavour, slightly cold in property, acting on the

> lung, heart and gallbladder channels.

> Effects: clearing away heat, detoxicating, subduing swelling and dissolving

> lumps.

> 7 Niu Bang Zi 4.5 Arctium lappa - Burdock root

> Pungent and cold

> All " wind-heat " ailments

> 9 Huang Qin 3 Scutellariae baicalensis - chinese skullcap

> Properties: bitter in flavour, cold in property, acting on the lung,

> gallbladder, stomach and large intestine channels.

> Effects: clearing away heat and dampness, purging fire, detoxicating,

> stopping bleeding, and preventing miscarriage.

> 9 Tian Hua Fen 3 Trichosanthes kirilowii - Tricosanthus root

> sweet in flavor and cold in nature

> good at promoting production of body fluids, It clears evil Phlegm and

> moistens Dryness of the Lung

> 10 Fang Fen 3 Ledebouriellae divaricatae - siler divaricatum

> 11 Gan Cao 3 Licorice

> Properties: sweet in flavour, neutral in property, acting on the heart,

> lung, spleen and stomach channels.

> Effects: Invigorating the spleen, replenishing qi, eliminating phlegm,

> arresting cough, clearing away heat and toxins, relieving spasm and pain,

> and moderating the properties of other herbs.

> 12 Zhi Zi 4.5 Gardenia - Gardeniae jasminoidis

> Properties: bitter in flavour, cold in property, acting on the heart, lung,

> stomach and sanjiao channels

> Effects: purging fire, relieving dysphoria, clearing away heat, promoting

> diuresis, removing heat from the blood and stopping bleeding.

>

>

>

> Post message: Chinese Traditional Medicine

> Subscribe: Chinese Traditional Medicine-

> Un: Chinese Traditional Medicine-

> List owner: Chinese Traditional Medicine-owner

>

> Shortcut URL to this page:

> /community/Chinese Traditional Medicine

>

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

> Hey, Jackie.

>

> What is it that told you " he reactred so badly " ? What was the reaction?

> That would help us know what the problem was.

..

Well I separated the two - the Bu Zhong made him really hyper-energetic, but

much more fearful and jumpy so that when he did meet a real fright, he was

starting to panic. With a horse that means rear, buck, run blindly - that

kind of thing, I nearly lost him out hacking (riding another and leading

him), he was only just controllable (and he's 640kg!).

 

The Chai Hu made him hyper, hyper-irritable and aggressive, and I think made

his stomach acid, so I started seeing abnormal appetite retuning, tearing

into food like a fasted dog almost. Signs I haven't seen for a year since he

had a course of antacids. I also think it exacerbated his laminitis - which

is an inflammatory/vaso-constrictive condition of the feet often associated

with circulating toxins. At any rate, it got rapidly worse over the week he

was on it, and rapidly better when it ceased.

 

The thing that stunned me with both is that it was like turning a switch on

and off - huge responses, both ways, overnight. And that was at 10g a day,

but still pretty strong at 5g.

 

The Ayurvedic tonic makes him calm and happier than I have seen him for a

long time, more playful and wanting to be touched. It gave him lots of

energy on a loading dose at first, but does not quite hold on a lower

maintenance dose. That was 50ml tincture, sorry I don't know what strength,

down to about 20ml. I'm trying 30g of the powdered whole herb version, but I

don't know equivalence yet.

 

Also started 10g of whole ground ashwaganda. He was on an ashwaganda extract

when he did really well on the ayervedic tonic, but I didn't see any

response to that alone in the first week, and didn't trust it was good

stuff, so I went over to the real thing.

 

Jackie

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...