Guest guest Posted January 16, 2005 Report Share Posted January 16, 2005 Hi Ien, > Thanks for the history lesson Butch. Welcome for sure. > How do you remember it all? I remembered the French decision because it is one of the classic bad decisions in military history .. every professional officer in every country in the world is familiar with that decision. > I just remembered the sentence because it was so funny, not > the details. It was a classic example of how chauvinism can get out of hand and why civilians should not try to make tactical decisions for armed forces. > As for this: >>Freedom to say that one would like to do away with armies came from >>armies having given one that freedom .. > > True, but only because there was another army there that took away > the freedom in the first place, etc etc. You know better than that. ;-) The history of mankind is not a history that placed a lot of emphasis on human rights .. human rights were won by MIGHT .. not by RIGHT! True it is that the idea of human rights sprang originally from the Judeo-Christian teachings .. but it was military power that insured them .. mankind was not born into the world with inalienable rights .. such ideas resulted from social revolutions that were backed by military power. Peace through superior firepower! > We can dream, can't we? Some folks can .. but folks like me would have failed in our missions if we had dreamed .. we had to deal with the realities. And while we were dealing with those realities .. we also gave folks like you the freedom and security to be able to dream. ;-) Mankind is NOT equal in all respects .. at least when comparisons are made in an attempt to understand other societies/cultures. It would be practicing racism to say that one culture was inferior to another since the criteria used to make that determination would, by necessity, be chauvinistic .. but it is foolish and irresponsible for leaders to not pay attention to the fundamental differences between cultures. Religion is usually a driver in this regard .. it determines man's place in the world and in nature .. and on the value that culture places on human life. It would be an unforgivable oversight for a leader to not take into consideration the fact that some cultures are not as civilized as others .. and are motivated by ideas that are more than foreign .. and downright dangerous .. to other cultures. Unless one has lived in .. been immersed in .. the cultural extremes I speak of there is no way they can understand what I am writing here and they will never agree with me. They will want it to be as they wish it were rather than how it is .. and they will continue to dream. The major difference between young folks and more experienced mature folks is .. those young folks who accept that there are differences and work to close the gaps are usually successful in life .. those who close their eyes to the realities and try to live as if there were no inherent differences are usually the ones who fail. The major difference between inexperienced and experienced mature folks is that the former are normally grouchy, opinionated, wrong thinking old geezers and broads and the latter are the ones the wise young folks will turn to for counseling and advice. If wishes were horses all beggars could ride. ;-) Y'all keep smiling. :-) Butch http://www.AV-AT.com Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.