Why standardize herbal formula is running wrong hypothesis develop wrong result?

[Guest guest]

Dear group,especially for Alon,

 

I assume that every one of you all known modern

scientific research methods very well.

 

In scientific research,the first steps is define

variables,set independent variables and dependent

variables.Make hypothesis,prove factors/(indenpendent

)variables causes/or the correlation of

results(dependent variables),and some others.

 

Therefore,

1.one single variable cause one result.

2.Ten independent variables may/may not gather into

factors and affect the results in many ways.

3.Each single independent variable of ten variables

changed,the final results also changed,too.

4.One single herbal formula(if you treat it as a

variable) cause one treatment effect.

 

A.

An extremely excellent TCM doctor who create herbal

formula for each patient.Each single person use one

single herbal formula he create and he will adjust the

herbal formula according to the patient's need,add

some herbs or delete some.Sometimes,One single herbal

the doctor changed,the patient got dramatic develop

for the disease and get well immediately.

 

If he is excellent enough,each patient has own herbal

formula and personal adjust by the doctor.

 

If you request every herbal formula should have

scientific evidence,how many variables the doctor have

 

to do research for the scientific evidences.

 

B.most new doctor use ancient TCM master's formula to

be a standard to cure patient.He might use it to be a

basic standrad and add some/delete some herbs

according to the need of the patient.How could he

add/delete the standardize herbal formula such as

lio-wei-di-houng-wen and others.

 

C.sometimes,the doctor combind three or four herbal

formula in to one formula or combined partial herbal

of those(three or four)herbal formula into one

formula.

How could he turn the pill or mixed powder into

seprate herbs.

 

d.while we cooked raw herbal formula,we need

hor-ho(the fire degree).(Japan scientific researcher

had

been check the effect of charcoal fire,the result was

 

the charcoal fire the greatest fire while you do BBQ).

according to my experience,If your herbal formula is

effect for the petient,while you cooked the raw herbal

formula and the formula is cooked in just fine

condition,the smell you have from the pot will make

patient feel comfortable.

 

There are some herbs need to cook first;some herbs

need to wait until the cook almot complete.How cloud

standardize formula reach that goal.

 

e.Concoct:some herbs have to concoct before

use.Sometimes,ginger need to stired fry in soil,stir

fry with wine,or turn it into charcoal...it all rely

on the concoct according to the patient's conditions.

 

f.how many understand in western about the single

herb's effect and the combined herbal formula chemical

effect if you didn't follow the ancient TCM

approaches.

 

g.the technology to turn herbal drink into pills or

powder still can't in 100 % good.

 

7.someothers I didn't mentioned.

 

I am not deny all the function of western approach

..Those question above should have new ideas to solve

the problem in the not far future.

 

I hope those western pharmacy experts should pay

more attention on how tradition chinese medicine

approach make herbal formula,as close as possible,

Not in western approach to make TCM herbal powder or

pill.

 

Standardize herbal formula will limited the flexible

of TCM.Western should figure out the solution methods

in TCM approcah,not in western approach.

 

Therefore ,I would like to invide the western experts

to get the whole pictures of TCM,after that, create

the real TCM herbal formula powder or pill in western

approach.

 

If western ignore the primary step while do TCM

pharmacy, may I say as Alon's thinking process,

You are not objective.You miss too many detail of

varibles changed while you do scientific evidences.

 

Jean

 

=====

 

 

--------------------------------

< ¨C¤Ñ³£ ©_¼¯ > www..tw