Guest guest Posted December 21, 2000 Report Share Posted December 21, 2000 Respected Krushna, I am trying to understand the rationale and principles of the worksheet. One thing that I find difficult to understand is the addition of points for the planets in fourth place from other planets. Row 5 always shows a SINGLE planet with the lowest points receiving the 4th house planets points. This is easy to understand. However, what I find difficult to comprehend is that where there are TWO or more 4/10 aspects which have NOTHING to do with each other, why do these aspects not generate the same result. Logic suggests that independent 4/10 relationships would be treated the same way. ie. in the Example Worksheet on page 35 Venus is shown as being in 4th place to the Moon. The Moon has 2 points the same as Saturn in the other 4/10 relationship. I can understand why Saturn would be chosen over the Moon as the SINGLE planet to receive points in line 5 (because it is a natural malefic) However my question is why do other INDEPENDANT 4/10 relationships not attract points? Ron Gaunt Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 21, 2000 Report Share Posted December 21, 2000 Dear Ron, I could be wrong but I just checked page 35, and that certainly looks like an error to me in the Worksheet - I mean the Moon should be getting the 10 points from Venus because the Moon only has 2 bindus, and Venus is in the 4th from the Moon, while Jupiter's 14 points go to Saturn rather than the Sun because of order of " natural " malefics. Venus, however, is an entirely separate matter and stands alone with no competition for its points. I believe your logic is fine... I think it is a calculation error. When the List first started, it was like " the blind leading the blind " with Worksheet matters, because Krushna always calculated by hand and we (the list members) were trying to use a Worksheet to make things easier, while none of us at that point had a real " clear " grasp of the principles. Anyway, it is my understanding that the points for any ONE planet can only go to ONE other planet, however, there can be more than one planet receiving the points from another unrelated planet. ~Namaste~ Sandy http://www.jupitersweb.com/ Ron Gaunt [arjee] Thursday, December 21, 2000 6:03 PM Lesson 7 Questions - Krushna Respected Krushna, I am trying to understand the rationale and principles of the worksheet. One thing that I find difficult to understand is the addition of points for the planets in fourth place from other planets. Row 5 always shows a SINGLE planet with the lowest points receiving the 4th house planets points. This is easy to understand. However, what I find difficult to comprehend is that where there are TWO or more 4/10 aspects which have NOTHING to do with each other, why do these aspects not generate the same result. Logic suggests that independent 4/10 relationships would be treated the same way. ie. in the Example Worksheet on page 35 Venus is shown as being in 4th place to the Moon. The Moon has 2 points the same as Saturn in the other 4/10 relationship. I can understand why Saturn would be chosen over the Moon as the SINGLE planet to receive points in line 5 (because it is a natural malefic) However my question is why do other INDEPENDANT 4/10 relationships not attract points? Ron Gaunt Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 22, 2000 Report Share Posted December 22, 2000 Respected Ron, 4:10 relation is when Malefic planet is in 10 place from any planet. Malefic Planet means the planet having less then 4 points. Moon is not considered as malefic in any case, even if it has less then 4 points. The malefic planet in tenth place gets support of the planet in the fourth place. The points of the planet in house A+B+C are added to the planet in tenth place. If two or more planets are in tenth place, then the most malefic will get the points. If two or more planets are in fourth place, then the planet in tenth place will get points from all planets. The Moon being fast changing planet can not be treated as malefic for 10th house from any planet. krushna >Ron Gaunt <arjee > > > Lesson 7 Questions - Krushna >Fri, 22 Dec 2000 10:03:17 +1100 > >Respected Krushna, > >I am trying to understand the rationale and principles of the >worksheet. One thing that I find difficult to understand is the >addition of points for the planets in fourth place from other >planets. Row 5 always shows a SINGLE planet with the lowest >points receiving the 4th house planets points. This is easy to >understand. However, what I find difficult to comprehend is >that where there are TWO or more 4/10 aspects which have NOTHING >to do with each other, why do these aspects not generate the same >result. Logic suggests that independent 4/10 relationships would >be treated the same way. ie. in the Example Worksheet on page 35 >Venus is shown as being in 4th place to the Moon. The Moon has 2 >points the same as Saturn in the other 4/10 relationship. >I can understand why Saturn would be chosen over the Moon as the >SINGLE planet to receive points in line 5 (because it is a >natural malefic) However my question is why do other >INDEPENDANT 4/10 relationships not attract points? > > >Ron Gaunt _______________________ Get Your Private, Free E-mail from MSN Hotmail at http://www.hotmail.com. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 22, 2000 Report Share Posted December 22, 2000 Dear Sandy, Please read my answer to Ron. thanks krushna > " Sandy Crowther " <sandy > > >RE: Lesson 7 Questions - Krushna >Thu, 21 Dec 2000 20:38:49 -0500 > >Dear Ron, > >I could be wrong but I just checked page 35, and that certainly looks like >an error to me in the Worksheet - I mean the Moon should be getting the 10 >points from Venus because the Moon only has 2 bindus, and Venus is in the >4th from the Moon, while Jupiter's 14 points go to Saturn rather than the >Sun because of order of " natural " malefics. Venus, however, is an entirely >separate matter and stands alone with no competition for its points. I >believe your logic is fine... I think it is a calculation error. > >When the List first started, it was like " the blind leading the blind " with >Worksheet matters, because Krushna always calculated by hand and we (the >list members) were trying to use a Worksheet to make things easier, while >none of us at that point had a real " clear " grasp of the principles. > >Anyway, it is my understanding that the points for any ONE planet can only >go to ONE other planet, however, there can be more than one planet >receiving >the points from another unrelated planet. > > ~Namaste~ > Sandy >http://www.jupitersweb.com/ > > > Ron Gaunt [arjee] >Thursday, December 21, 2000 6:03 PM > > Lesson 7 Questions - Krushna > >Respected Krushna, > >I am trying to understand the rationale and principles of the >worksheet. One thing that I find difficult to understand is the >addition of points for the planets in fourth place from other >planets. Row 5 always shows a SINGLE planet with the lowest >points receiving the 4th house planets points. This is easy to >understand. However, what I find difficult to comprehend is >that where there are TWO or more 4/10 aspects which have NOTHING >to do with each other, why do these aspects not generate the same >result. Logic suggests that independent 4/10 relationships would >be treated the same way. ie. in the Example Worksheet on page 35 >Venus is shown as being in 4th place to the Moon. The Moon has 2 >points the same as Saturn in the other 4/10 relationship. >I can understand why Saturn would be chosen over the Moon as the >SINGLE planet to receive points in line 5 (because it is a >natural malefic) However my question is why do other >INDEPENDANT 4/10 relationships not attract points? > > >Ron Gaunt > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 22, 2000 Report Share Posted December 22, 2000 On Fri, 22 Dec 2000 21:25:52 +0530, you wrote: Respected Krushna, Thank you for the explanation that Moon cannot be considered Malefic, I didn't know that and I suspect the same goes for most of the other members. I am still uncertain as to whether and why, where there are TWO or more 4/10 aspects which have NOTHING to do with each other, why do these aspects not generate the same result? For example on page 35 if Mars was in the position of the Moon would we have to add 12 points (the spreadsheet shows 10 but as agreed in previous mails, house C for Venus should show 4 points and not 2) to Mars in Line 5, presuming Saturn retains its 14 points from Jupiter? Ron Gaunt >Respected Ron, > 4:10 relation is when Malefic planet is in 10 place from any planet. >Malefic Planet means the planet having less then 4 points. Moon is not >considered as malefic in any case, even if it has less then 4 points. The >malefic planet in tenth place gets support of the planet in the fourth >place. The points of the planet in house A+B+C are added to the planet in >tenth place. If two or more planets are in tenth place, then the most >malefic will get the points. If two or more planets are in fourth place, >then the planet in tenth place will get points from all planets. > The Moon being fast changing planet can not be treated as malefic >for 10th house from any planet. >krushna > > >>Ron Gaunt <arjee >> >> >> Lesson 7 Questions - Krushna >>Fri, 22 Dec 2000 10:03:17 +1100 >> >>Respected Krushna, >> >>I am trying to understand the rationale and principles of the >>worksheet. One thing that I find difficult to understand is the >>addition of points for the planets in fourth place from other >>planets. Row 5 always shows a SINGLE planet with the lowest >>points receiving the 4th house planets points. This is easy to >>understand. However, what I find difficult to comprehend is >>that where there are TWO or more 4/10 aspects which have NOTHING >>to do with each other, why do these aspects not generate the same >>result. Logic suggests that independent 4/10 relationships would >>be treated the same way. ie. in the Example Worksheet on page 35 >>Venus is shown as being in 4th place to the Moon. The Moon has 2 >>points the same as Saturn in the other 4/10 relationship. >>I can understand why Saturn would be chosen over the Moon as the >>SINGLE planet to receive points in line 5 (because it is a >>natural malefic) However my question is why do other >>INDEPENDANT 4/10 relationships not attract points? >> >> >>Ron Gaunt > >_______________________ >Get Your Private, Free E-mail from MSN Hotmail at http://www.hotmail.com. > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 22, 2000 Report Share Posted December 22, 2000 Dear Krushna, Thanks...I wasn't aware of any of this information - I must have missed something somewhere along the way. We're learning more of the details of this system all the time, and the details bring more questions and sometimes confusion...;-)) So let me ask you this - Suppose the ONLY planet in the fourth from another is Venus - and it is fourth from the Moon, and the Moon had 2 bindus. If I understand you correctly, this would mean that the Moon would NOT get the points from Venus, because the planet has to be a malefic in order for this to occur, and the Moon, even when only having 2 points, is never considered malefic? And if the above is true, are there any other planets, when having less than 4 bindus, are also never considered malefic? Thanks for your patience with us...;-)) ~Namaste~ Sandy http://www.jupitersweb.com/ krushna kalani J.K. [krushanain] Friday, December 22, 2000 10:56 AM Re: Lesson 7 Questions - Krushna Respected Ron, 4:10 relation is when Malefic planet is in 10 place from any planet. Malefic Planet means the planet having less then 4 points. Moon is not considered as malefic in any case, even if it has less then 4 points. The malefic planet in tenth place gets support of the planet in the fourth place. The points of the planet in house A+B+C are added to the planet in tenth place. If two or more planets are in tenth place, then the most malefic will get the points. If two or more planets are in fourth place, then the planet in tenth place will get points from all planets. The Moon being fast changing planet can not be treated as malefic for 10th house from any planet. krushna >Ron Gaunt <arjee > > > Lesson 7 Questions - Krushna >Fri, 22 Dec 2000 10:03:17 +1100 > >Respected Krushna, > >I am trying to understand the rationale and principles of the >worksheet. One thing that I find difficult to understand is the >addition of points for the planets in fourth place from other >planets. Row 5 always shows a SINGLE planet with the lowest >points receiving the 4th house planets points. This is easy to >understand. However, what I find difficult to comprehend is >that where there are TWO or more 4/10 aspects which have NOTHING >to do with each other, why do these aspects not generate the same >result. Logic suggests that independent 4/10 relationships would >be treated the same way. ie. in the Example Worksheet on page 35 >Venus is shown as being in 4th place to the Moon. The Moon has 2 >points the same as Saturn in the other 4/10 relationship. >I can understand why Saturn would be chosen over the Moon as the >SINGLE planet to receive points in line 5 (because it is a >natural malefic) However my question is why do other >INDEPENDANT 4/10 relationships not attract points? > > >Ron Gaunt _______________________ Get Your Private, Free E-mail from MSN Hotmail at http://www.hotmail.com. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 22, 2000 Report Share Posted December 22, 2000 Dear Sandy, Only Moon and Moon is there, which can not get points when it is in the tenth place from any planet. thanks krushna > " Sandy Crowther " <sandy > > >RE: Lesson 7 Questions - Krushna >Fri, 22 Dec 2000 17:43:04 -0500 > >Dear Krushna, > >Thanks...I wasn't aware of any of this information - I must have missed >something somewhere along the way. We're learning more of the details of >this system all the time, and the details bring more questions and >sometimes >confusion...;-)) > >So let me ask you this - Suppose the ONLY planet in the fourth from another >is Venus - and it is fourth from the Moon, and the Moon had 2 bindus. If I >understand you correctly, this would mean that the Moon would NOT get the >points from Venus, because the planet has to be a malefic in order for this >to occur, and the Moon, even when only having 2 points, is never considered >malefic? > >And if the above is true, are there any other planets, when having less >than >4 bindus, are also never considered malefic? Thanks for your patience with >us...;-)) > > > ~Namaste~ > Sandy >http://www.jupitersweb.com/ > krushna kalani J.K. [krushanain] >Friday, December 22, 2000 10:56 AM > >Re: Lesson 7 Questions - Krushna > >Respected Ron, > 4:10 relation is when Malefic planet is in 10 place from any >planet. >Malefic Planet means the planet having less then 4 points. Moon is not >considered as malefic in any case, even if it has less then 4 points. The >malefic planet in tenth place gets support of the planet in the fourth >place. The points of the planet in house A+B+C are added to the planet in >tenth place. If two or more planets are in tenth place, then the most >malefic will get the points. If two or more planets are in fourth place, >then the planet in tenth place will get points from all planets. > The Moon being fast changing planet can not be treated as malefic >for 10th house from any planet. >krushna > > > >Ron Gaunt <arjee > > > > > > Lesson 7 Questions - Krushna > >Fri, 22 Dec 2000 10:03:17 +1100 > > > >Respected Krushna, > > > >I am trying to understand the rationale and principles of the > >worksheet. One thing that I find difficult to understand is the > >addition of points for the planets in fourth place from other > >planets. Row 5 always shows a SINGLE planet with the lowest > >points receiving the 4th house planets points. This is easy to > >understand. However, what I find difficult to comprehend is > >that where there are TWO or more 4/10 aspects which have NOTHING > >to do with each other, why do these aspects not generate the same > >result. Logic suggests that independent 4/10 relationships would > >be treated the same way. ie. in the Example Worksheet on page 35 > >Venus is shown as being in 4th place to the Moon. The Moon has 2 > >points the same as Saturn in the other 4/10 relationship. > >I can understand why Saturn would be chosen over the Moon as the > >SINGLE planet to receive points in line 5 (because it is a > >natural malefic) However my question is why do other > >INDEPENDANT 4/10 relationships not attract points? > > > > > >Ron Gaunt > >_______________________ >Get Your Private, Free E-mail from MSN Hotmail at http://www.hotmail.com. > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 22, 2000 Report Share Posted December 22, 2000 Dear Ron, Any planet except Moon, if it is in tenth house, and perticularly with less then 4 points, it will get points from the planet in fourth place. The planet with 4 points, which means it can give result on both side, or we treat as nuetral. In special case if it is lord of D or E then it is eager to gives the result of house B, in such case if there is any planet in fourth house from it we add the points. In the chart under study, If we solve for sixth house, Venus is with 4 points and is lord of D ( for B as 6th house) here we added points of Jupiter (18) to Venus. final points it get 41. Same for 5th house, 10th house, and first house. In all these cases we have added points of Jupiter to venus. krushna >Ron Gaunt <arjee > > >Re: Lesson 7 Questions - Krushna >Sat, 23 Dec 2000 08:39:34 +1100 > >On Fri, 22 Dec 2000 21:25:52 +0530, you wrote: > >Respected Krushna, > >Thank you for the explanation that Moon cannot be considered >Malefic, I didn't know that and I suspect the same goes for most >of the other members. I am still uncertain as to whether and >why, where there are TWO or more 4/10 aspects which have NOTHING >to do with each other, why do these aspects not generate the same >result? For example on page 35 if Mars was in the position of >the Moon would we have to add 12 points (the spreadsheet shows 10 >but as agreed in previous mails, house C for Venus should show 4 >points and not 2) to Mars in Line 5, presuming Saturn retains its >14 points from Jupiter? > > >Ron Gaunt > > > > > >Respected Ron, > > 4:10 relation is when Malefic planet is in 10 place from any >planet. > >Malefic Planet means the planet having less then 4 points. Moon is not > >considered as malefic in any case, even if it has less then 4 points. The > >malefic planet in tenth place gets support of the planet in the fourth > >place. The points of the planet in house A+B+C are added to the planet in > >tenth place. If two or more planets are in tenth place, then the most > >malefic will get the points. If two or more planets are in fourth place, > >then the planet in tenth place will get points from all planets. > > The Moon being fast changing planet can not be treated as malefic > >for 10th house from any planet. > >krushna > > > > > >>Ron Gaunt <arjee > >> > >> > >> Lesson 7 Questions - Krushna > >>Fri, 22 Dec 2000 10:03:17 +1100 > >> > >>Respected Krushna, > >> > >>I am trying to understand the rationale and principles of the > >>worksheet. One thing that I find difficult to understand is the > >>addition of points for the planets in fourth place from other > >>planets. Row 5 always shows a SINGLE planet with the lowest > >>points receiving the 4th house planets points. This is easy to > >>understand. However, what I find difficult to comprehend is > >>that where there are TWO or more 4/10 aspects which have NOTHING > >>to do with each other, why do these aspects not generate the same > >>result. Logic suggests that independent 4/10 relationships would > >>be treated the same way. ie. in the Example Worksheet on page 35 > >>Venus is shown as being in 4th place to the Moon. The Moon has 2 > >>points the same as Saturn in the other 4/10 relationship. > >>I can understand why Saturn would be chosen over the Moon as the > >>SINGLE planet to receive points in line 5 (because it is a > >>natural malefic) However my question is why do other > >>INDEPENDANT 4/10 relationships not attract points? > >> > >> > >>Ron Gaunt > > > >_______________________ > >Get Your Private, Free E-mail from MSN Hotmail at http://www.hotmail.com. > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 23, 2000 Report Share Posted December 23, 2000 On Sat, 23 Dec 2000 10:10:06 +0530, you wrote: Respected Krushna, Thank you for your explanation. From this I take it that where there are two independant 4/10 aspects having the correct conditions, BOTH will add points to the planets in their respective 10th places. Ron Gaunt >Dear Ron, > Any planet except Moon, if it is in tenth house, and perticularly >with less then 4 points, it will get points from the planet in fourth place. > The planet with 4 points, which means it can give result on both >side, or we treat as nuetral. In special case if it is lord of D or E then >it is eager to gives the result of house B, in such case if there is any >planet in fourth house from it we add the points. In the chart under study, >If we solve for sixth house, Venus is with 4 points and is lord of D ( for B >as 6th house) here we added points of Jupiter (18) to Venus. final points it >get 41. Same for 5th house, 10th house, and first house. In all these cases >we have added points of Jupiter to venus. >krushna > > >>Ron Gaunt <arjee >> >> >>Re: Lesson 7 Questions - Krushna >>Sat, 23 Dec 2000 08:39:34 +1100 >> >>On Fri, 22 Dec 2000 21:25:52 +0530, you wrote: >> >>Respected Krushna, >> >>Thank you for the explanation that Moon cannot be considered >>Malefic, I didn't know that and I suspect the same goes for most >>of the other members. I am still uncertain as to whether and >>why, where there are TWO or more 4/10 aspects which have NOTHING >>to do with each other, why do these aspects not generate the same >>result? For example on page 35 if Mars was in the position of >>the Moon would we have to add 12 points (the spreadsheet shows 10 >>but as agreed in previous mails, house C for Venus should show 4 >>points and not 2) to Mars in Line 5, presuming Saturn retains its >>14 points from Jupiter? >> >> >>Ron Gaunt >> >> >> >> >> >Respected Ron, >> > 4:10 relation is when Malefic planet is in 10 place from any >>planet. >> >Malefic Planet means the planet having less then 4 points. Moon is not >> >considered as malefic in any case, even if it has less then 4 points. The >> >malefic planet in tenth place gets support of the planet in the fourth >> >place. The points of the planet in house A+B+C are added to the planet in >> >tenth place. If two or more planets are in tenth place, then the most >> >malefic will get the points. If two or more planets are in fourth place, >> >then the planet in tenth place will get points from all planets. >> > The Moon being fast changing planet can not be treated as malefic >> >for 10th house from any planet. >> >krushna >> > >> > >> >>Ron Gaunt <arjee >> >> >> >> >> >> Lesson 7 Questions - Krushna >> >>Fri, 22 Dec 2000 10:03:17 +1100 >> >> >> >>Respected Krushna, >> >> >> >>I am trying to understand the rationale and principles of the >> >>worksheet. One thing that I find difficult to understand is the >> >>addition of points for the planets in fourth place from other >> >>planets. Row 5 always shows a SINGLE planet with the lowest >> >>points receiving the 4th house planets points. This is easy to >> >>understand. However, what I find difficult to comprehend is >> >>that where there are TWO or more 4/10 aspects which have NOTHING >> >>to do with each other, why do these aspects not generate the same >> >>result. Logic suggests that independent 4/10 relationships would >> >>be treated the same way. ie. in the Example Worksheet on page 35 >> >>Venus is shown as being in 4th place to the Moon. The Moon has 2 >> >>points the same as Saturn in the other 4/10 relationship. >> >>I can understand why Saturn would be chosen over the Moon as the >> >>SINGLE planet to receive points in line 5 (because it is a >> >>natural malefic) However my question is why do other >> >>INDEPENDANT 4/10 relationships not attract points? >> >> >> >> >> >>Ron Gaunt >> > >> >_______________________ >> >Get Your Private, Free E-mail from MSN Hotmail at http://www.hotmail.com. >> > >> > >> > >> > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 24, 2000 Report Share Posted December 24, 2000 Respected Ron, Yes you are correct. krushna >Ron Gaunt <arjee > > >Re: Lesson 7 Questions - Krushna >Sun, 24 Dec 2000 16:17:49 +1100 > >On Sat, 23 Dec 2000 10:10:06 +0530, you wrote: > >Respected Krushna, > >Thank you for your explanation. From this I take it that where >there are two independant 4/10 aspects having the correct >conditions, BOTH will add points to the planets in their >respective 10th places. > >Ron Gaunt > > > >Dear Ron, > > Any planet except Moon, if it is in tenth house, and perticularly > >with less then 4 points, it will get points from the planet in fourth >place. > > The planet with 4 points, which means it can give result on both > >side, or we treat as nuetral. In special case if it is lord of D or E >then > >it is eager to gives the result of house B, in such case if there is any > >planet in fourth house from it we add the points. In the chart under >study, > >If we solve for sixth house, Venus is with 4 points and is lord of D ( >for B > >as 6th house) here we added points of Jupiter (18) to Venus. final points >it > >get 41. Same for 5th house, 10th house, and first house. In all these >cases > >we have added points of Jupiter to venus. > >krushna > > > > > >>Ron Gaunt <arjee > >> > >> > >>Re: Lesson 7 Questions - Krushna > >>Sat, 23 Dec 2000 08:39:34 +1100 > >> > >>On Fri, 22 Dec 2000 21:25:52 +0530, you wrote: > >> > >>Respected Krushna, > >> > >>Thank you for the explanation that Moon cannot be considered > >>Malefic, I didn't know that and I suspect the same goes for most > >>of the other members. I am still uncertain as to whether and > >>why, where there are TWO or more 4/10 aspects which have NOTHING > >>to do with each other, why do these aspects not generate the same > >>result? For example on page 35 if Mars was in the position of > >>the Moon would we have to add 12 points (the spreadsheet shows 10 > >>but as agreed in previous mails, house C for Venus should show 4 > >>points and not 2) to Mars in Line 5, presuming Saturn retains its > >>14 points from Jupiter? > >> > >> > >>Ron Gaunt > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> >Respected Ron, > >> > 4:10 relation is when Malefic planet is in 10 place from any > >>planet. > >> >Malefic Planet means the planet having less then 4 points. Moon is not > >> >considered as malefic in any case, even if it has less then 4 points. >The > >> >malefic planet in tenth place gets support of the planet in the fourth > >> >place. The points of the planet in house A+B+C are added to the planet >in > >> >tenth place. If two or more planets are in tenth place, then the most > >> >malefic will get the points. If two or more planets are in fourth >place, > >> >then the planet in tenth place will get points from all planets. > >> > The Moon being fast changing planet can not be treated as >malefic > >> >for 10th house from any planet. > >> >krushna > >> > > >> > > >> >>Ron Gaunt <arjee > >> >> > >> >> > >> >> Lesson 7 Questions - Krushna > >> >>Fri, 22 Dec 2000 10:03:17 +1100 > >> >> > >> >>Respected Krushna, > >> >> > >> >>I am trying to understand the rationale and principles of the > >> >>worksheet. One thing that I find difficult to understand is the > >> >>addition of points for the planets in fourth place from other > >> >>planets. Row 5 always shows a SINGLE planet with the lowest > >> >>points receiving the 4th house planets points. This is easy to > >> >>understand. However, what I find difficult to comprehend is > >> >>that where there are TWO or more 4/10 aspects which have NOTHING > >> >>to do with each other, why do these aspects not generate the same > >> >>result. Logic suggests that independent 4/10 relationships would > >> >>be treated the same way. ie. in the Example Worksheet on page 35 > >> >>Venus is shown as being in 4th place to the Moon. The Moon has 2 > >> >>points the same as Saturn in the other 4/10 relationship. > >> >>I can understand why Saturn would be chosen over the Moon as the > >> >>SINGLE planet to receive points in line 5 (because it is a > >> >>natural malefic) However my question is why do other > >> >>INDEPENDANT 4/10 relationships not attract points? > >> >> > >> >> > >> >>Ron Gaunt > >> > > >> > >_______________________ > >> >Get Your Private, Free E-mail from MSN Hotmail at >http://www.hotmail.com. > >> > > >> > > >> > > >> > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.