Addendum: New footage of British Circus Elephants being abused.

[Guest guest]

Please see the below email for excellent feedback from CCFJ members and animal advocacy friends across the pond. Thanks to Michael and Sheila Medlar for this valuable information. Margaret Morin, Founder CCFJ, SaveJennyNow.com--- On Fri, 8/21/09, Michael Medlar wrote:

Michael Medlar Re: [concernedcitizensforjenny] New footage of British Circus Elephants being abused.concernedcitizensforjenny-owner Date: Friday, August 21, 2009, 4:42 AM

 Good morning Margaret - from the UK.

 

Thank you for sending this.

 

We have been involved with the campaign against the employment of the 3 elephants from Germany by the GBC ever since the news broke that they were coming to the UK. We have attended protests with other local activists, written to Church leaders (the Dean of Southwell and Nottingham and the Archbishop of York - since their local representatives have been "blessing" the circus), to our Member of Parliament, to Jim Fitzpatrick MP at DEFRA, to local and national media. On wild/captive elephant matters in general (and our special concern for the 8 elephants incarcerated in the St. Louis Zoo), we have also written to HRH The Prince of Wales.

 

Other than the myriad of our regional small animal rights protest groups, the UK organisation which, to us, appears to be the most active and forceful is CAPS (the Captive Animals' Protection Society), headed by Craig Redmond. We are members of CAPS, and are most impressed by their work.

Here is a link to CAPS' report on the current GBC abuse issue:

http://www.captiveanimals.org/news/2009/gbc_video.html

 

Do you know The Elephant Commentator website? We see that CCFJ material has been posted there, so you probably do.

We are members, and post under the name "Space4Eles". CAPS is also a member and posts here.

Under their zoo forum, there is a theme for Dallas Zoo, which we started on the 23rd March 2009:

http://elecom.ipbfree.com/index.php?showtopic=769 & st=0

 

Under their circus forum, there is a theme for the GBC, which was started on the 23rd February 2009 by "SpiritiedLulu".

We try to keep it up to date with the news as it comes in:

http://elecom.ipbfree.com/index.php?showtopic=671

 

Our current feeling is that all the blame for this abuse is being levelled at the "groom", and GBC seems to think that, since the groom was sacked instantly, the matter is finished.

We're also concerned that there are 2 people involved here that have been kept out of the press, but who must shoulder blame along with everyone else - Lars and Christine Holscher, the German "trainers" of Sonja, Delhi and Vana Mana. Maybe these 2 don't speak any English, so are not being interviewed. But they need also to be brought into the spotlight.

 

On the GBC's website home page, it is stated in red that the GBC is a member of the European Circus Association. We have looked at the ECA website and at the circuses listed as members - at least 4 of them have performing elephants (Cirque de Monte Carlo in Monaco, Cirque Medrano in France, Gran Circo Mundial in Spain and Cirkus Merano in Norway). We found video footage of the elephants at these circuses elsewhere on the web - GRIM VIEWING!

 

Margaret - we had intended to keep this e-mail short as we know how busy you are. We failed.

 

Thank you for taking the time to read it, and we send our sincere regards to you and all at CCFJ. Be strong.

 

Michael and Sheila Medlar - for the elephants.

 

 

 

 

-

Margaret Morin

Concerned Citizens for Jenny ; VNOD

Thursday, August 20, 2009 6:44 PM

[concernedcitizensforjenny] New footage of British Circus Elephants being abused.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Here is a very disturbing report on elephant abuse in England (see below). Also, below is my correspondence with Born Free UK and their recommendations for what we can do to help. The more I learn about elephants and the abuse they suffer at human hands in Zoos and Circuses, the more I am opposed to elephants being in these venues at all. Thanks. Margaret--- On Thu, 8/20/09, Tricia Holford wrote:

 

 

 

Hello Margaret

 

Has Will had time to reply to you yet?

If you have a look at our web site, you will see our comment on this disgusting footage, http://www.bornfree .org.uk/campaign s/zoo-check/ circuses- performing- animals/circus- elephants/

As you will see, we are urging people to write to our Department of Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (DEFRA), calling for wild animals to be banned from British circuses. Strange though it may seem, such circuses are still legal in our country!

If you look at the ADI website, you will see the worker has been sacked. http://www.ad- international. org/animals_ in_entertainment /go.php?id= 1625 & ssi=10 However, as ADI explain, this does not go far enough.

All the best.

Tricia

Tricia Holford Co-ordinator, Activate / Rescue Programme Born Free Foundation www.bornfree. org.uk

KEEP WILDLIFE IN THE WILD

 

 

 

 

 

Join stars of music and entertainment at the Royal Albert Hall to commemorate Born Free’s 25th Anniversary and help save the lives of over 25,000 animals! For more information visit www.bornfree. org.uk/wildandli ve

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Margaret Morin [dogs_ good ] 19 August 2009 00:54Will TraversNew footage of British Circus Elephants being abused.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Dear Will, Have you or anyone in Born Free UK heard of these incidents or seen this article from the Wednesday August 19, 2009 Daily Express?

 

 

 

Could you let me know what will be done in the UK , and/or any action Born Free is recommending animal advocates in the USA take, so I may inform my group, please? Thank you. Margaret Morin, Concerned Citizens for Jenny (and Gypsy)

 

 

 

http://www.express. co.uk/posts/ view/121291/ Beaten-and- hit-with- hooks-cruel- fate-of-our- circus-elephants

 

 

UK NEWS

 

BEATEN AND HIT WITH HOOKS, CRUEL FATE OF OUR CIRCUS ELEPHANTS

 

 

 

 

Trainer Lars Holsher and his elephants are one of the main attractions of the Great British Circus

 

Wednesday August 19,2009

 

By John Ingham

 

SHOCKING images of circus elephants being beaten sparked fresh calls yesterday for a ban on wild animals in the Big Top.

 

An undercover video shot by Animal Defenders International shows three elephants crying out after being hit on the head with a big metal hook, a broom and a pitchfork.

 

A circus worker is also seen twisting an elephant’s tail.

 

The animals, part of the Great British Circus, were said to be left chained up for 11 hours at a time.

It is also claimed that when the circus moved five miles from Watford to Bushey the elephants were kept in a trailer for more than seven hours.

 

In the film, an African elephant called Sonja, born in the wild but bought after her mother was shot in a cull, shows the classic signs of mental disturbance – including rocking, swaying and head bobbing – which are often seen in animals held in captivity.

ADI, which used a hidden camera to make the film, claims it witnessed “a staggeringly high level of casual violence†in just a few days at the circus.

The pressure group’s chief e xecutive Jan Creamer said: “In the name of entertainment these elephants are beaten, jabbed with hooks, chained up for hours a day and pushed into a metal box each week where they remain for hours on end while the circus moves.

“This is an indictment of the circus industry and also the Government, who have failed to fulfil their commitment to ban the use of wild animals in travelling circuses. This investigation shows how animals like elephants suffer in the circus.

 

“The public wants a ban, Parliament wants a ban, animal protection groups want a ban.

 

“Surely it is time for the Government to take action to stop this suffering right now.â€

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

SEARCH UK NEWS for:

 

A spokesman for the Great British Circus, which stars elephant trainer Lars Holsher and also features lions, tigers, reindeer and camels, refused to comment on the allegations without seeing the footage.

 

But he said: “The campaigners’ refusal to let the circus see the material shows that they do not want to give us the chance to defend ourselves fairly. It is a legal requirement that the trainer of any animal has the means of restraining it and the accepted way of restraining an elephant is to use a hook. “It would be irresponsible and contrary to health and safety requirements to have an animal in public without adequate means of control. “It is perfectly acceptable for elephants to wait in their purpose-built travel accommodation with food and water while their stable is erected.†The circus’s website describes claims of maltreatment as “laughableâ€. It says their trained movements “are based on natural behaviour†and adds: “Patience and reward are the secrets of success.

“No one here hits animals – doing that would confuse them and prevent them learning.†It claims that the elephants spend only three hours on average once a fortnight in their transporters. A spokesman for the Environment Department said: “Work is under way on whether the Government should regulate the use of wild animals in circuses and is due to be completed later this year.

“This does not stop anyone who is aware of a problem from reporting it now.â€