Guest guest Posted June 2, 2002 Report Share Posted June 2, 2002 Lafcadio Hearn: Japan, An Attempt At Interpretation. See also Yoji Hasegawa and Inagaki`s Daughter of the Samurai for attitudes on flesh-eating. See also The Raven for August this year, when it comes out, where a suicide is related, the purpose of which is to stop a grandson going into the cattle business (Inagaki) - Dave Shishkoff <dave arthur_cravan <anthonykarl Tuesday, June 11, 2002 5:20 AM Re: Imperial edict of the Emperor of Japan, A.D. 675: > Do you have a source for this? > > - Dave > > - > " arthur_cravan " <anthonykarl > > Monday, June 10, 2002 7:37 PM > Imperial edict of the Emperor of Japan, A.D. 675: > > > > " That the people are forbidden to kill and eat: kine, barnyard fowl, > > horses, dogs, cats and all four-legged beings; that traps are > > forbidden: nooses, snares in the catching of animals of any kind. " > > > > This law remained in force until 1868. > > > > > > > > Post message: > > Subscribe: - > > Un: - > > List owner: -owner > > > > Shortcut URL to this page: > > /community/ > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 2, 2002 Report Share Posted June 2, 2002 Sea-life isn`t mentioned, though I doubt very much whale was hunted. The means did not exist anywhere near the extent of today`s commercial whaling and feudal Japan was very limited in this regard, scarcely possessing a navy until Will Adams came along, and then for military purposes (as you know, the taking of human life never posed a moral problem for the Shoguns!)... Basho ate fish, but the Buddhist clergy did not. Japanese did not drink milk, which they termed akin to blood, and the tofu they ate so much of was mistakenly thought to be cheese by the Dutch! Fowl was eaten by samurai on campaign, but snaring was forbidden, and all " game " had to be shot with bow and arrow, giving " fair chance " to the bird. Seaside communities depended on fish. There were no butchers, and those who did kill and skin small " game " were ostracised and made to live apart. After 1868 (which impoverished over 2 million samurai, driving them onto the streets as beggars!) beef-farming was introduced with a vengeance and samurai were forced to become butchers in order to make a living: which resulted in many suicides. Hokkaido was cleared for cattle. Foxes were sacred, more than any other creature (the subject of my short story, " Manyemon " , is the Inari Fox cult) and to kill one, even accidentally (?) meant a grisly death awaited the perpetrator. I am aware that these strictures never stretched to mainland Asia and the Chinese always had one of the worst records for animal cruelty. In the Ming classic " The Water Margin " , the protagonists gorge themselves page after page on beef, in grotesque fashion, and this raises the question of this being deliberate satire. - Dave Shishkoff Anthony Walker ; Tuesday, June 11, 2002 5:18 PM Re: Imperial edict of the Emperor of Japan, A.D. 675: > Lafcadio Hearn: Japan, An Attempt At Interpretation. > See also Yoji Hasegawa and Inagaki`s Daughter of the Samurai for attitudes > on flesh-eating. Thanks Anthony, tho it sounds like land-only flesh, is sea life mentioned at all? - Dave Post message: Subscribe: - Un: - List owner: -owner Shortcut URL to this page: /community/ Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 4, 2002 Report Share Posted June 4, 2002 - xxx_suicidal_vegan_xxx Wednesday, June 12, 2002 11:52 PM Re: Imperial edict of the Emperor of Japan, A.D. 675: What happened in 1868 to make them change the law? It was in fact a capitalist revolution. The western samurai clans of Choshu and Satsuma feared that Japan would share China`s fate unless Japan modernised. They rose up and overthrew the Shogunate in a bloody war (not the cosy phenomenon depicted by travel books!)but then saw they had cut the ground from beneath their own feet. Japan`s capitalist class became master following this and the samurai were expropriated. The new order " restored " the Emperor as figurehead and Japan frantically embraced all western habits and technology, including meat-eating (the profits to be had from it ~ the sale of meat). In 1876 the samurai rebelled against THIS NEW order, under Prince Saigo, who had originally supported Meiji, and were blown to pieces. From then on, they all slowly perished and the nouveau-riche moved in. Military and commercial expansion followed and your 20th century history tells you the rest. Ex-samurai were noted for stirring up socialist and trade-union activity after that in the factories of Japan`s new masters. The government brought in the " Thought Police " and repression intensified until fascism proper set in, in the 1930s. Ex-samurai in the forces were notorious for their contempt of patriotism, calling Hirohito sneeringly " Emp " . Others became responsible for launching a glorious renaissance, in the 1950s, of literature, turning to writing. The confused patriot, Mishima, was from a samurai family. Ah so. My Junior Wallchart of History says that in 1868 the Shogunate dynasty comes to an end when young Prince Mejii, AGED FIFTEEN, becomes Emperor, and Japan begins to modernize. Guess he sent out for a burger and fries. Too bad. Chris X > " Anthony Walker " > " Dave Shishkoff " >CC: >Re: Imperial edict of the Emperor of Japan, A.D. 675: >Sun, 2 Jun 2002 19:22:14 +0100 > >Sea-life isn`t mentioned, though I doubt very much whale was hunted. The means did not exist anywhere near the extent of today`s commercial whaling and feudal Japan was very limited in this regard, scarcely possessing a navy until Will Adams came along, and then for military purposes (as you know, the taking of human life never posed a moral problem for the Shoguns!)... Basho ate fish, but the Buddhist clergy did not. Japanese did not drink milk, which they termed akin to blood, and the tofu they ate so much of was mistakenly thought to be cheese by the Dutch! >Fowl was eaten by samurai on campaign, but snaring was forbidden, and all " game " had to be shot with bow and arrow, giving " fair chance " to the bird. Seaside communities depended on fish. There were no butchers, and those who did kill and skin small " game " were ostracised and made to live apart. After 1868 (which impoverished over 2 million samurai, driving them onto the streets as beggars!) beef-farming was introduced with a vengeance and samurai were forced to become butchers in order to make a living: which resulted in many suicides. Hokkaido was cleared for cattle. >Foxes were sacred, more than any other creature (the subject of my short story, " Manyemon " , is the Inari Fox cult) and to kill one, even accidentally (?) meant a grisly death awaited the perpetrator. >I am aware that these strictures never stretched to mainland Asia and the Chinese always had one of the worst records for animal cruelty. In the Ming classic " The Water Margin " , the protagonists gorge themselves page after page on beef, in grotesque fashion, and this raises the question of this being deliberate satire. Post message: Subscribe: - Un: - List owner: -owner Shortcut URL to this page: /community/ Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 11, 2002 Report Share Posted June 11, 2002 " That the people are forbidden to kill and eat: kine, barnyard fowl, horses, dogs, cats and all four-legged beings; that traps are forbidden: nooses, snares in the catching of animals of any kind. " This law remained in force until 1868. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 11, 2002 Report Share Posted June 11, 2002 > Lafcadio Hearn: Japan, An Attempt At Interpretation. > See also Yoji Hasegawa and Inagaki`s Daughter of the Samurai for attitudes > on flesh-eating. Thanks Anthony, tho it sounds like land-only flesh, is sea life mentioned at all? - Dave Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 12, 2002 Report Share Posted June 12, 2002 What happened in 1868 to make them change the law? Ah so. My Junior Wallchart of History says that in 1868 the Shogunate dynasty comes to an end when young Prince Mejii, AGED FIFTEEN, becomes Emperor, and Japan begins to modernize. Guess he sent out for a burger and fries. Too bad. Chris X > " Anthony Walker " > " Dave Shishkoff " >CC: >Re: Imperial edict of the Emperor of Japan, A.D. 675: >Sun, 2 Jun 2002 19:22:14 +0100 > >Sea-life isn`t mentioned, though I doubt very much whale was hunted. The means did not exist anywhere near the extent of today`s commercial whaling and feudal Japan was very limited in this regard, scarcely possessing a navy until Will Adams came along, and then for military purposes (as you know, the taking of human life never posed a moral problem for the Shoguns!)... Basho ate fish, but the Buddhist clergy did not. Japanese did not drink milk, which they termed akin to blood, and the tofu they ate so much of was mistakenly thought to be cheese by the Dutch! >Fowl was eaten by samurai on campaign, but snaring was forbidden, and all " game " had to be shot with bow and arrow, giving " fair chance " to the bird. Seaside communities depended on fish. There were no butchers, and those who did kill and skin small " game " were ostracised and made to live apart. After 1868 (which impoverished over 2 million samurai, driving them onto the streets as beggars!) beef-farming was introduced with a vengeance and samurai were forced to become butchers in order to make a living: which resulted in many suicides. Hokkaido was cleared for cattle. >Foxes were sacred, more than any other creature (the subject of my short story, " Manyemon " , is the Inari Fox cult) and to kill one, even accidentally (?) meant a grisly death awaited the perpetrator. >I am aware that these strictures never stretched to mainland Asia and the Chinese always had one of the worst records for animal cruelty. In the Ming classic " The Water Margin " , the protagonists gorge themselves page after page on beef, in grotesque fashion, and this raises the question of this being deliberate satire. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.