Bruce Wagman's life work -- protecting the underserved

[Guest guest]

http://sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2007/06/17/CMGC2PVS5H1.DTL

 

Bruce Wagman's life work -- protecting the underserved

Sam Whiting

Sunday, June 17, 2007

 

Bruce Wagman knows he will lose a lot of cases. Wagman, a partner at Schiff

Hardin in San Francisco, is an attorney representing animals against humans.

Those are tough cases to try but Wagman, 50, has an obligation.

 

THE LIGHTBULB: I¹ve only had one revelation in my life. That was in August,

1992 at the American Bar Association Conference in San Francisco. I attended

a session on animal rights law. I walked about 20 feet and said to my wife,

³That¹s it. It¹s over.² I meant our prior life as meat-eaters and leather

wearers.

 

I was a nurse for seven years and switched species. My first day as a

lawyer, in November, 1992, I started sending letters, probably nearly 100,

to every animal protection group in America, saying, " I'm here. Can I help? "

I began doing work on a pro bono basis. The first case I did involved an

effort to protect the tule elk that live in Point Reyes National Seashore.

We didn't succeed in changing anything for the tule elk.

 

Many cases for animal lawyers are not a success because we're trying to

change the world. I like to think of it as animal law. It covers a broader

range than animal rights or animal welfare or animal protection. For the

last three and a half years, it's been 95 percent of my practice. In 2005, I

represented the Animal Legal Defense Fund in a case in North Carolina. We

rescued 330 dogs from a hoarding situation, with disease rampant and

suffering on a daily basis. It was the biggest civil rescue ever, in the

country. We have fostered out every single one of those dogs.

 

Hoarding is a national epidemic and the largest threat to companion animals

in America. It's akin to people who collect bottle caps. The big difference

is they're affecting the lives of sentient beings. Hoarding cases seem very

obvious, but they are difficult cases to bring. One of the big problems is

that hoarders are not intentional abusers. If my neighbor hits my dog with a

bat, that's a pretty straightforward case of cruelty. Hoarders are involved

in severe neglect. The animals are suffering, but it's only by neglect. It's

by omission as opposed to intent, so it requires an incredible amount of

evidence to prove that suffering is ongoing.

 

I was recently involved in a case in which, ultimately, we rescued four

chimpanzees and shut down an abuser who claimed to be training chimpanzees

for use in the entertainment industry. I've oddly enough developed a

subniche of chimpanzee law. There are between 2,000 and 3,000 chimpanzees

living around the country, mostly in entertainment facilities or private

homes. That's separate from research chimpanzees.

 

I've got eight animals at home, in Stinson Beach, so I do have rescue

animals, but none of them are from the cases I've handled. They've all come

from local animal shelters. I have three dogs and five cats, currently, and

one wife. The limit in Marin County is three dogs and that's why I have

three dogs. There is no limit on the number of cats.

 

I am involved tangentially in animal protection legislation. We're trying to

get a bill into the legislature, which will allow for a civil remedy for

cruelty so that animal protection organizations can protect the interest of

animals. It doesn't have a sponsor yet.

 

I think the animals in society deserve a level of protection that they're

clearly not getting yet. That's why I've made it my life's work. I don't

think they should be allowed to freely run down the street and vote and

drive cars. But they should be free from abuse. Ten billion animals are

killed in this country for our food, and 10 billion of those, minus a

thousand, are treated inhumanely at every level of their lives. Dairy cows

probably suffer a lot more than beef cows.

 

They live a very tortured life and virtually every dairy cow in America ends

up in a fast food hamburger.

 

We are looking for Bay Area people with innovative ideas who have put them

to use. Please e-mail candidates to brightideas.

 

wargasm wargasm one two three

pit bull, pit bull, one two three

wave those flags high in the air

as long as it takes place over there