Guest guest Posted May 21, 2007 Report Share Posted May 21, 2007 Elchanan seems to be a nice person who takes tons of time to respond. I think the attack on Elchanan was unkind and chills the group effort. I have enjoyed reading Elchanan and hope Elchanan continues to post. thanks for listening take care, lynda Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 21, 2007 Report Share Posted May 21, 2007 i saw no attack on elchanan. i saw an observation of something that had crossed my mind as well. If i thought it others had to have also. im glad it was brought up for clarification and thats it. We need to move on because the lack of understanding of the original intent is getting tiresome. im sure elchanan appreciates all the support. now...about raw fooooood......... 8=) anna On 5/20/07, lhmcmaken <lhmcmaken wrote: > Elchanan seems to be a nice person who takes tons of time to respond. > I think the attack on Elchanan was unkind and chills the > group effort. I have enjoyed reading Elchanan and hope Elchanan > continues to post. thanks for listening > take care, > lynda > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 21, 2007 Report Share Posted May 21, 2007 After reading all these comments I have to just chime in. Elchanan has been posting in this group for quite a while, I think over 2 years. He is not being pushy, he is offering his thoughts to questions and problems that people post. If you don't want to listen to him, believe him, try his suggestions, or whatever, don't. No one is forcing you to do anything. Nobody is judging you except you. He helps a lot of people out on his time and not just through the groups. As far as the PathOfHealth and the donations in exchange to participate, he just spent a considerable amount of that money to purchase upgraded audio equipment for the free teleconferences so that they would be more professional recordings. And don't forget in the past, he has posted the invites to those teleconferences on this group and invited everyone to joing. Kim rawfood , " sarah shaw " <hppymummy wrote: > > I agree with this I am ready to leave this group over this person because of > the coments he makes it feels as though he is pressuring you into following > his way. I became vegan 3 months ago and am now mostly raw I am trying to > change my family's habbits as well but in baby steps. I felt as though I > was some sort of idiot because I didn't know anything he was talking about. > I have read many books on nutrition and infants and toddler nutrition and > have been doing the best I can with the resorces I have. I just dont like > his pushy comments I guess, and I can not find any reasearch to back up what > he is saying. It does feel like some kid of cult! > > > > " Anna Bishop " <mowthpeece > >rawfood > >rawfood > >Re: [Raw Food] Out of balance > >Sat, 19 May 2007 06:37:46 -0700 > > > >laura > > > >i think you missed the point... > > > >too much by just one gives the impression that this isnt a discussion > >group but a following. > > > >i am not a follower of elchanan. Im here to listen to all of you and > >help if i can...but when someone first joins one has to wonder if they > >didnt join a private rawfood cult led by someone named elchanan. > > > >it is unbalanced. > >this discussion is probably clearing up months of confusion for > >people. Im glad it was brought up. > > > >peace > >anna > > > >On 5/19/07, laura b. <ladymomma wrote: > > > i have to say.......i am a little floored by this. so are you saying > >that > > > members of this group should refrain from responding to every post. is > > > there a limit to the number of posts one can respond to...and what > >length > > > they should be? if there is to be a varied exchange among members, well > > > then that's up to each member isn't it...to jump in there and join the > > > discussion, this is a discussion group isn't it? > > > > > > there is no charge to be part of the path of health unless one CHOOSES > >to > > > stay after the first 2 months...this is my understanding. no one, not > > > wal-mart, mcdonald's, nature's first law, NO ONE stands to profit from > > > anything, EVER unless OTHERS CHOOSE to make it so. that said, the > > " profits " > > > are used for the betterment of the group. > > > > > > i am not saying you should not have expressed your feelings about > >this. > > > as i told my daughter yesterday....i am proud that you know how to tell > >me > > > your feelings....everyone has the right to express themselves. i think > >just > > > your bringing it up will provide an opportunity for discussion of such > > > things as freedom of expression and choice. > > > > > > i believe all input has value. if what is being put out there is not > >of > > > use to you, then you simply disregard it. i hope you can find peace > >with > > > that. > > > > > > in light and love, > > > laura > > > > > > guinevieve wrote: > > > > > > Dear Group Members, > > > > > > This is my opinion, but I feel this group is being dominated by one > >poster > > > Elchanan who responds to nearly every post with lengthy opinions stated > >as > > > truths. I see that some of you like his input (if it is male) and > >appreciate > > > his > > > knowledge, but I would prefer a more varied exchange among members > >without > > > the constant responses by Elchanan. > > > > > > By the way, he stands to profit if you choose to pay for his services. > >If > > > you join his Path of Health you will find in the files > >section > > > information about these services and their cost > > > > > > I wish to provoke no controversy for or against these posts, but just > >state > > > my feelings that things seem out of balance to me. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > ************************************** See what's free at > > > http://www.aol.com. > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.