Jump to content
IndiaDivine.org

Osteoporosis from too much Protein?

Rate this topic


Guest guest

Recommended Posts

Hi all,

I'm new here and new to vegetarianism. I've always been a closet

vegetarian , but b/c I'm allergic to dairy , I never got out of the

closet. I still ate meat. Thinking it was neccessary for good health.

 

Then I recently read the book " May All Be Fed/Diet for a New World by

John Robbins. It was a light bulb moment if not a life-changing

revelation.

 

According to the book , too much protien can flush the calicum right

out of your system. They cited the example of an African tribe who

had a low calicum and protein intake,( they ate veg. but no

meat/dairy) and they had no osteoporosis.

 

My doctor is always yelling at me to take 1200mg. or more of calcium

daily since I can't drink milk. I've tried but can't b/c it just

slows down my digestive system and I'm miserable.

 

The book also mentioned that most vegetables/grains have enough

protein to sustain us,even with out doing the combination thing that

was one of the main ideas, in " Diet for a Small planet " . A book I

dearly loved and read twice,years ago.

 

John Robbins' book also said that " Diet for a Small Planet " was

updated and revised to stress the idea that the combination of beans

and rice and the amount of protein we actually need daily is not as

crucial as her first book stated.

I just got the revised " Diet for a Small Planet " from the library to

read , can't find mine, I think it's the older version .

 

Does anyone have more reading matieral on this subject or experince

on this subject, I'd appreciate hearing about.

Thanks,

Rosanne

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There is lots of protein in Broccoli, and it is more easily absorbed by our

bodies than protein from cows because it hasn't already been used to build the

cow.

Katie

 

rosieann69 <rosieann69 wrote:

Hi all,

I'm new here and new to vegetarianism. I've always been a closet

vegetarian , but b/c I'm allergic to dairy , I never got out of the

closet. I still ate meat. Thinking it was neccessary for good health.

 

Then I recently read the book " May All Be Fed/Diet for a New World by

John Robbins. It was a light bulb moment if not a life-changing

revelation.

 

According to the book , too much protien can flush the calicum right

out of your system. They cited the example of an African tribe who

had a low calicum and protein intake,( they ate veg. but no

meat/dairy) and they had no osteoporosis.

 

My doctor is always yelling at me to take 1200mg. or more of calcium

daily since I can't drink milk. I've tried but can't b/c it just

slows down my digestive system and I'm miserable.

 

The book also mentioned that most vegetables/grains have enough

protein to sustain us,even with out doing the combination thing that

was one of the main ideas, in " Diet for a Small planet " . A book I

dearly loved and read twice,years ago.

 

John Robbins' book also said that " Diet for a Small Planet " was

updated and revised to stress the idea that the combination of beans

and rice and the amount of protein we actually need daily is not as

crucial as her first book stated.

I just got the revised " Diet for a Small Planet " from the library to

read , can't find mine, I think it's the older version .

 

Does anyone have more reading matieral on this subject or experince

on this subject, I'd appreciate hearing about.

Thanks,

Rosanne

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Fussy? Opinionated? Impossible to please? Perfect. Join 's user panel and

lay it on us.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Roseanne

 

Your body will tell you better than any doctor. Just pay attention

to what your body tells you. I think those African tribesmen are so

healthy because they digest everything they eat.Overeating causes

toxins. The only proven method of prolonging life is reducing

calorie intake.

 

GB

,

" rosieann69 " <rosieann69 wrote:

>

> Hi all,

> I'm new here and new to vegetarianism. I've always been a closet

> vegetarian , but b/c I'm allergic to dairy , I never got out of the

> closet. I still ate meat. Thinking it was neccessary for good

health.

>

> Then I recently read the book " May All Be Fed/Diet for a New World

by

> John Robbins. It was a light bulb moment if not a life-changing

> revelation.

>

> According to the book , too much protien can flush the calicum

right

> out of your system. They cited the example of an African tribe who

> had a low calicum and protein intake,( they ate veg. but no

> meat/dairy) and they had no osteoporosis.

>

> My doctor is always yelling at me to take 1200mg. or more of

calcium

> daily since I can't drink milk. I've tried but can't b/c it just

> slows down my digestive system and I'm miserable.

>

> The book also mentioned that most vegetables/grains have enough

> protein to sustain us,even with out doing the combination thing

that

> was one of the main ideas, in " Diet for a Small planet " . A book I

> dearly loved and read twice,years ago.

>

> John Robbins' book also said that " Diet for a Small Planet " was

> updated and revised to stress the idea that the combination of

beans

> and rice and the amount of protein we actually need daily is not as

> crucial as her first book stated.

> I just got the revised " Diet for a Small Planet " from the library

to

> read , can't find mine, I think it's the older version .

>

> Does anyone have more reading matieral on this subject or experince

> on this subject, I'd appreciate hearing about.

> Thanks,

> Rosanne

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

When you take calcium, you also need to take magnesium or the calcium

will constipate you. The proportions are approximately 2 parts

calcium [preferably citrate] to one part magnesium [preferably

citrate] depending on how your body tolerates the effects of the

magnesium. I cannot take citrates because of an ulcer, but most

people can tolerate them and they are much more absorbent.

 

Best Wishes

 

Kathleen

Eureka CA

 

> My doctor is always yelling at me to take 1200mg. or more of calcium

> daily since I can't drink milk. I've tried but can't b/c it just

> slows down my digestive system and I'm miserable.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...