Jump to content
IndiaDivine.org

RE: Turkey Day

Rate this topic


Guest guest

Recommended Posts

Hi Cindy,

We are in San Diego County, too - in North County. Do you know of any

vegetarian play groups/family groups around here? I know we've talked

on this list about getting southern Orange County/Riverside County/San

Diego folks together, since we don't have much like this down here, but

nothing that I know has happened on that front yet. We'd really love to

have more vegetarians in our son's life. ('Course, he sometimes gets

vegetarian confused with organic, and if someone says something isn't

organic, he gets all indignant that he won't eat it . . . we smile and

take out his organic snacks.) :-) Anyway, great to see someone from

the hood (or at least a nearby hood - or at least one within an hour's

drive). :-)

Have a great day,

Lorraine

 

 

On

Behalf Of Cindy K.

Tuesday, November 18, 2008 7:20 AM

 

" Turkey Day "

 

One different take we have on the whole Turkey Day thing is from Native

Americans, who saw turkey as a symbol of give-away. It sure helps to

tell and retell that story to my kids.

 

We have tried hard to create traditions involving gratidude and because

we are blessed to live in San Diego, we are usually able to incorporate

a hike into our day.

 

But I do hate the whole holiday revolving around food, especially a

dead bird. And the weird songs and games that they teach the kids in

school. If the kids really knew that the poor turkey was going to be

killed and that they would be eating a dead bird....

 

My friend (NOT a vegetarian) told me her son said isn't it funny that

there's an animal called a chicken and a food we eat called chicken...?

Yeah, funny.

 

At least if my kids do start eating meat someday, they will know where

it came from.

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You know, I hear that all the time: " But they're farmed for the special purpose

of eating " - so I think that to most adults, they aren't REAL animals. When I

make the point that to me, they may as well be eating their dog, their cat, or

any other beloved pet, I get a lot of weird looks and some derision. But aren't

they all animals? What's really the difference? I don't get it.

 

 

 

 

________________________________

Jacqueline Bodnar <jb

 

Tuesday, November 18, 2008 4:03:57 PM

RE: " Turkey Day "

 

 

 

Cindy wrote: " My friend (NOT a vegetarian) told me her son said isn't

it funny that

there's an animal called a chicken and a food we eat called chicken...?

Yeah, funny. "

 

This reminds me of my sister. When my niece was little I took her to see

the movie Babe (on purpose because of the message). She was curious and

asking me questions. I was honest and told her what hamburger, hot dogs,

etc. were. My sister was very mad at me when I dropped my niece off at

home and she told my sister that she no longer wanted to eat animals. My

sister's response was to look at me and say " she'll eat meat if I have

to shove it down her throat. "

 

So what my sister did was create a big lie... she taught my niece that

they were not actual cows. They were " special cows. " Meat didn't come

from real cows, it came from " special cows. " And that's what my niece

thought as a child. She removed the connection so she wouldn't know it

was the animal, not from the animal, etc. So in my nieces little world

there were two different kinds of cow in the world - one that grazed and

one that was not real, but a special source of food.

 

Sick I tell you. If you have to lie to your kids there's something

wrong...

 

Jacqueline

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Jenni,

My grandparents had a farm up until I was around 10 - the rule for us

and for my mom's generation was to never name the farm animals, so you

won't become attached. My uncle (who lived and helped on the farm in

the later years) went one further and suggested that we not count the

babies, since you never know what might happen. (There was definitely a

family belief that farm animals were different than others.) 'Course,

as soon as we heard about a birthing, us kids would run up and count and

name the babies. (We weren't kids for a lot of rules, regardless.) :-)

What this did was some very interesting things - many of us became

vegetarians, some just stopped eating the animals from the farm, and

part of my family is in the cattle industry. Everyone used the

info/experiences on the farm to make their own decisions.

 

In answer to your question - I think the difference is that some people

see humans as better than other animals, and thus worthy of better

treatment and the use/abuse/eating/wearing/etc. of the other animals . .

.. but pets are often excluded from this belief. I see a cat as a human

as a dog as a gorilla, but not everyone does. I don't understand the

lack of that belief among vegetarians, either, but it's not universal.

I guess the real answer is something like what happened in my farming

family - some vegetarians believe one thing, some believe another thing,

but in this case, we all can just love our common ground: not eating our

friends. :-)

Have a great day!

Lorraine

 

 

On

Behalf Of jenni claire garverick

Wednesday, November 19, 2008 5:28 AM

 

Re: " Turkey Day "

 

You know, I hear that all the time: " But they're farmed for the special

purpose of eating " - so I think that to most adults, they aren't REAL

animals. When I make the point that to me, they may as well be eating

their dog, their cat, or any other beloved pet, I get a lot of weird

looks and some derision. But aren't they all animals? What's really the

difference? I don't get it.

 

________________________________

Jacqueline Bodnar <jb@jacquelinebodnar

<jb%40jacquelinebodnar.com> .com>

@gro <%40> ups.com

Tuesday, November 18, 2008 4:03:57 PM

RE: " Turkey Day "

 

Cindy wrote: " My friend (NOT a vegetarian) told me her son said isn't

it funny that

there's an animal called a chicken and a food we eat called chicken...?

Yeah, funny. "

 

This reminds me of my sister. When my niece was little I took her to see

the movie Babe (on purpose because of the message). She was curious and

asking me questions. I was honest and told her what hamburger, hot dogs,

etc. were. My sister was very mad at me when I dropped my niece off at

home and she told my sister that she no longer wanted to eat animals. My

sister's response was to look at me and say " she'll eat meat if I have

to shove it down her throat. "

 

So what my sister did was create a big lie... she taught my niece that

they were not actual cows. They were " special cows. " Meat didn't come

from real cows, it came from " special cows. " And that's what my niece

thought as a child. She removed the connection so she wouldn't know it

was the animal, not from the animal, etc. So in my nieces little world

there were two different kinds of cow in the world - one that grazed and

one that was not real, but a special source of food.

 

Sick I tell you. If you have to lie to your kids there's something

wrong...

 

Jacqueline

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hey Lorraine and Cindy,

 

Sorry I don't usually post here, I just had to butt in. I am in Riverside

County, near Temecula. We haven't met a lot of veg*n people around here and

would love to know more. We do have a meetup group in Temecula for vegans. It is

a small, new group, but there are some kids in the group! If you ever get

something local started, I would love to know about it. Thanks!

 

Jane

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Jane,

We're in San Marcos, north central San Diego County -- so not super far

from Temecula. I'd love to know about when your group meets -- and I'd

love to let you know if/when something happens with a group in this

area. Every time I get excited about the idea, I get bogged down with

work and just can't even attend anything, let alone help put it

together. I know there's a need for a like-minded group like that

here, though.

Hope to meet you and your family sometime!

Lorraine

 

 

 

On

Behalf Of Jane Park

Wednesday, November 19, 2008 3:26 PM

 

Re: " Turkey Day "

 

 

 

Hey Lorraine and Cindy,

 

Sorry I don't usually post here, I just had to butt in. I am in

Riverside County, near Temecula. We haven't met a lot of veg*n people

around here and would love to know more. We do have a meetup group in

Temecula for vegans. It is a small, new group, but there are some kids

in the group! If you ever get something local started, I would love to

know about it. Thanks!

 

Jane

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hey Lorraine and other So Cal veg*ns,

 

My husband and I are actually from San Diego county, Poway actually, so we

are quite familiar with San Diego suburbs. If you would like to join our vegan

meetup group, here is the link: http://vegan.meetup.com/517/. We welcome

vegetarians but ask that they bring vegan food for potlucks. We have only had

one meet up so far but I think we will try to do about 1 meetup a month. There

is a San Diego veg*n meet up group too. Here is their link

http://www.meetup.com/SD-Vegetarians-Unite/

 

It is great to meet more veg people, very empowering, just makes you realize

you are not alone. I can let you know the next time we have a meetup here and

maybe you can come up and join us. Nice to meet you!

Jane Park

 

 

Fun and Funky Bows for Any Princess

PrincessMonkeyBowtique.com

jmpark26.etsy.com

-

Lorraine

Wednesday, November 19, 2008 10:28 PM

RE: " Turkey Day "

 

 

Hi Jane,

We're in San Marcos, north central San Diego County -- so not super far

from Temecula. I'd love to know about when your group meets -- and I'd

love to let you know if/when something happens with a group in this

area. Every time I get excited about the idea, I get bogged down with

work and just can't even attend anything, let alone help put it

together. I know there's a need for a like-minded group like that

here, though.

Hope to meet you and your family sometime!

Lorraine

 

 

On

Behalf Of Jane Park

Wednesday, November 19, 2008 3:26 PM

Re: " Turkey Day "

 

Hey Lorraine and Cindy,

 

Sorry I don't usually post here, I just had to butt in. I am in

Riverside County, near Temecula. We haven't met a lot of veg*n people

around here and would love to know more. We do have a meetup group in

Temecula for vegans. It is a small, new group, but there are some kids

in the group! If you ever get something local started, I would love to

know about it. Thanks!

 

Jane

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Jane,

Thanks! I'll definitely check out these links and hopefully meet you

all at some point!

Have a great weekend,

Lorraine

 

 

On

Behalf Of Jane Park

Friday, November 21, 2008 3:29 PM

 

Re: " Turkey Day "

 

Hey Lorraine and other So Cal veg*ns,

 

My husband and I are actually from San Diego county, Poway actually, so

we are quite familiar with San Diego suburbs. If you would like to join

our vegan meetup group, here is the link: http://vegan.

<http://vegan.meetup.com/517/> meetup.com/517/. We welcome vegetarians

but ask that they bring vegan food for potlucks. We have only had one

meet up so far but I think we will try to do about 1 meetup a month.

There is a San Diego veg*n meet up group too. Here is their link

http://www.meetup. <http://www.meetup.com/SD-Vegetarians-Unite/>

com/SD-Vegetarians-Unite/

 

It is great to meet more veg people, very empowering, just makes you

realize you are not alone. I can let you know the next time we have a

meetup here and maybe you can come up and join us. Nice to meet you!

Jane Park

 

Fun and Funky Bows for Any Princess

PrincessMonkeyBowtique.com

jmpark26.etsy.com

-

Lorraine

@gro <%40> ups.com

Wednesday, November 19, 2008 10:28 PM

RE: " Turkey Day "

 

Hi Jane,

We're in San Marcos, north central San Diego County -- so not super far

from Temecula. I'd love to know about when your group meets -- and I'd

love to let you know if/when something happens with a group in this

area. Every time I get excited about the idea, I get bogged down with

work and just can't even attend anything, let alone help put it

together. I know there's a need for a like-minded group like that

here, though.

Hope to meet you and your family sometime!

Lorraine

 

 

@gro <%40> ups.com

[@gro <%40>

ups.com] On

Behalf Of Jane Park

Wednesday, November 19, 2008 3:26 PM

@gro <%40> ups.com

Re: " Turkey Day "

 

Hey Lorraine and Cindy,

 

Sorry I don't usually post here, I just had to butt in. I am in

Riverside County, near Temecula. We haven't met a lot of veg*n people

around here and would love to know more. We do have a meetup group in

Temecula for vegans. It is a small, new group, but there are some kids

in the group! If you ever get something local started, I would love to

know about it. Thanks!

 

Jane

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...