Landmark verdict in Jaipur elephant case

[Guest guest]

From ANIMAL PEOPLE, January-February 2007:

 

 

Landmark verdict in Jaipur elephant case

 

JAIPUR--Eighteen years after a jeep killed an elephant used

to give tourists rides up the narrow, winding road to the Amer

Palace overlooking Jaipur, the Rajasthan High Court on December 20,

2006 upheld a 1993 ruling by the Motor Accident Tribunal of Jaipur

that elephant owner Saddique Khan should be compensated the same

amount as if the elephant had been a human being.

The sum, about $12,500 U.S. plus interest, is to be paid by

the New India Insurance Company. The company contended that it

should only pay the standard rate for livestock of equivalent size,

about $41.50 as of 1988, when the accident happened.

The case was judged as controversy and attempted litigation

continued over elephant polo, played in Jaipur since 1975, but only

protested since September 2006, when British author Mark Shand began

promoting a match to benefit his charity, The Elephant Family, and

the Jaipur-based animal charity Help In Suffering. The November 18

match was played without the traditional use of the ankus, or

" elephant hook, " to demonstrate that it could be done.

Shand is brother of Camilla Parker Bowles, wife of Prince

Charles of Britain.

Activists , of Kolkata, and Azam Siddique,

a television reporter in Assam state, orchestrated global Internet

protest against the match. PETA organized a protest at the scene,

by activists wearing elephant masks. The Haryana chapter of People

for Animals sought an injunction to halt the match, further elephant

polo games, and most film making use of elephants.

But the match was resolutely de-fended by Help In Suffering

head trustee Christine Townend, who with philosopher Peter Singer

cofounded the Australian animal rights group Animal Liberation in

1978, and has conducted annual elephant care clinics for the working

elephants of Jaipur since 2000.

Wrote Townend, " A number of groups objected to the practice

of alternative elephant polo, a slow and ambling game in which

elephants walk across a soft field in cool of evening, in the winter

months, under command of bare feet and voice only.

" For example, PETA claimed that the match should not take

place because the elephants in Jaipur live in terrible conditions.

This is exactly why Help in Suffering believes that alternative

elephant polo should be encouraged, so that these elephants have

enrichment in their lives.

" In a photo circulated to the media, the caption read,

'Elephant with marks from a steel hook showing on its truck and

belly (Photo courtesy PETA-India).' We know this elephant well, "

Townend said. " We twice saved her life, when she was suffering from

a urinary tract infection. The marks on her belly are patches of

depigmentation due to a skin disease she had long ago.

" Alternative elephant polo was endorsed by the Animal Welfare

Board of India and the Forest Department of Rajasthan, " Townend

continued. " We were honoured that the chair, Major General Kharb,

and his wife, attended the event, along with many other dignitaries

who deeply care about the miserable conditions under which the Jaipur

elephants live at present, who want to see their lives improved and

enriched. "

 

 

 

--

Merritt Clifton

Editor, ANIMAL PEOPLE

P.O. Box 960

Clinton, WA 98236

 

Telephone: 360-579-2505

Fax: 360-579-2575

E-mail: anmlpepl

Web: www.animalpeoplenews.org

 

[ANIMAL PEOPLE is the leading independent newspaper providing

original investigative coverage of animal protection worldwide,

founded in 1992. Our readership of 30,000-plus includes the

decision-makers at more than 10,000 animal protection organizations.

We have no alignment or affiliation with any other entity. $24/year;

for free sample, send address.]