Editorial: Developing compassion for feral pigs

[Guest guest]

From ANIMAL PEOPLE, January/February 2007:

 

 

Developing compassion for feral pigs

 

Here come the pigs! See page one and the constellation of

related sidebars beginning on page 12 for particulars.

Nobody expected feral pigs and street pigs to become a

ubiquitous humane concern in the early 21st century--but not because

of indifference toward pigs. Most people just didn't think of pigs

as a free-roaming species who might turn up almost anywhere, capable

of thriving without human help. But the timing is right for feral

pigs and street pigs to claim humane attention. More pigs may be at

large today, worldwide, than ever before. Certainly more pigs are

at large in North America.

Pig hunters are all but exempt from most of the laws that

govern other forms of hunting, since pigs are considered a

non-native invasive nuisance. So-called hog/dog rodeo, in which

packs of pit bull terriers are set upon captive feral pigs, has only

been illegal in many Southern states for under two years, and--like

dogfighting and cockfighting--still has a substantial following.

The technology exists to control and perhaps eliminate

unwanted feral pig populations without bloodshed. The leading

immunocontraceptive approach to animal birth control is based on

porcine zona pellucida, PZP for short, a slaughterhouse byproduct.

Though PZP proved ineffective and impractical for use with dogs and

cats, it is now widely used to control wild horse herds, zoo animal

fecundity, and--experimentally--urban deer. Zona pellucida cells

from another species would be needed to achieve immunocontraception

among pigs, but at this point there are few animals, including

humans, whose reproductive biochemistry is better understood than

that of pigs.

Most important, while pigs are institutionally mistreated by

the pork industry at the rate of 60 million per year in the U.S.

alone, almost entirely out of public view, the climate of public

opinion has never been more favorable to individual pigs, with names

and familiar faces, like many of the " problem pigs " now patrolling

semi-rural suburbs.

The classic children's story Charlotte's Web, by E.B. White,

has raised compassion for pigs since 1952-first as a book, then as a

1973 animated film, now in 2006 as a computer-generated live action

film, endorsed and promoted by the Humane Society of the U.S.

Increasing humane awareness of pigs was already an integral

if indirect aspect of producing the newest version of Charlotte's

Web, after Paramount Pictures donated a substantial but undisclosed

sum to Animals Australia in exchange for help in adopting out the 40

trained pigs used to make the film. In early November 2006, Animals

Australia and allied organizations reportedly invested $500,000

Australian dollars in billboard and women's magazine advertising

against factory pig farming. Eight magazines and one billboard

company rejected the ads, which were then published in newspapers

instead--and the fracas attracted newspaper coverage.

Three other films featuring pigs who evade slaughter have

become recent hits: Babe (1995), Gordy (1995), and Babe: Pig In

The City (1998). Actor James Cromwell, who starred in the Babe

films as Farmer Hoggett, became a vegetarian and animal advocate.

Such pro-pig popular literature has a long pedigree.

Twenty-five years before E.B. White produced Charlotte's Web, Walter

R. Brooks from 1927 to 1958 raised consciousness about pigs in his

28-volume series about the adventures of Freddy the Pig and his

upstate New York farmyard friends, who evaded slaughter time and

again by acting as human-like as possible. Meat-eaters in the early

stories, Freddy and the farm owners, Mr. and Mrs. Bean, eventually

became somewhat reluctant and inconsistent quasi-vegetarians. Soon

afterward, the Freddy books lapsed from favor as longtime staples of

school libraries.

Humane literature evolved into addressing how real-life pigs

are raised and slaughtered after the 1964 publication of Animal

Factories, by Ruth Harrison, and the 1967 formation of Compassion

In World Farming by the late Peter Roberts. Banning gestation

crates, in which pregnant and nursing sows are imprisoned, was for

Roberts an enduring focus.

Pet pigs splashed into humane awareness after the Vietnam

War, when the pampered potbellied pigs carried to safety by some of

the Vietnamese " boat people " fleeing the Communist regime attracted

media coverage, caught the fancy of pet breeders, and became a

heavily promoted fad animal. A network of mostly overwhelmed and

underfunded pig sanctuaries formed in response to frequent pig

abandonment.

The sanctuaries that survived the inevitable shakeout are now

" finding an increased number of rescued farm pigs needing sanctuary

space, " explained Pig Preserve founders Richard and Laura Hoyle in

an October 2006 letter to ANIMAL PEOPLE. " As the public becomes more

attuned to the plight of the factory farmed pigs, " the Hoyles wrote,

" many more are being rescued by animal rights groups and private

citizens. So now, in addition to rescuing and caring for the

thousands of " dumped " miniature pigs, we are asked to take in a

steadily increasing number of full-sized farm pigs. "

Feral pigs emerged as an early concern of the Fund for

Animals, during the 25-year effort of the U.S. Navy, Nature

Conservancy, and National Park Service to extirpate pigs from San

Clemente Island and the Channel Islands, off the southern California

coast. Some rescued pigs from the California coastal islands were

transported to the Black Beauty Ranch in northeastern Texas during

the 1970s and 1980s, but their rescues attracted far less attention

than the Fund's earlier rescues of burros from San Clemente and the

Grand Canyon.

Later, in 1991-1993, PETA cofounder Alex Pacheco tried to

drum up opposition to Nature Conservancy tactics against feral pigs

in Hawaii, including aerial shooting and setting snares in which

caught pigs died slowly, over many days. In Defense of Animals

protested against cruel methods of pig extermination in the hills

surrounding San Francisco Bay. The Suwanna Ranch sanctuary operated

by the Humane Farming Association took in several pigs who went feral

after escaping from human custody or being abandoned.

Yet feral pigs as a nationally spreading ecological issue and

animal welfare problem largely eluded the humane community--and

largely eluded wildlife managers, as well, whose first recognition

of the presence of feral pigs has usually come several pig

generations after they became established, when they emerge as a

widely distributed public nuisance.

No set of institutions enthusiastically claims responsibility

for feral pigs in the U.S., as in most of the world. While licensed

pig hunting may generate some revenue, feral pig activities tend to

be more problematic than lucrative. Agricultural agencies see feral

pigs as an uncontrolled and unpredictable disease vector. Public

health and safety agencies want someone to respond to pig complaints,

as to dog and cat complaints, but even when animal control is under

their umbrella, animal control agencies mostly lack experienced pig

catchers and handlers, holding facilities suitable for pigs, and

vehicles that can haul them.

The advent of central garbage collection and enclosed sewage

systems eliminated free-roaming pigs from most U.S. and European

cities many decades ago. Until recently, feral pigs were found only

in remote rural regions, like the hills of Arkansas, whose wild

razorbacks were considered a quaint artifact.

But that was before long-haul pig trucking and frequent

highway accidents gave thousands of pigs the opportunity to bolt from

ruptured trailers in habitat of every sort, before raising European

boars for confined hunting operations became commonplace, and before

hints emerged that some ardent pig-hunters might be deliberately

translocating feral pigs to try to expand pig hunting opportunities.

That was also before free-roaming dogs declined from 30% of

the U.S. dog population circa 1950 to about 25% in the mid-1970s, to

under 5% today.

Dogs, rats, & pigs

Nature abhors a void, so when dogs no longer roam at large,

their habitat niches are claimed by other species.

Usually the first replacements are cats, already present and

relatively abundant. Where free-roaming dogs dominate the habitat by

day, consuming most of the edible refuse, catching many of the rats

and mice, cats tend to be nocturnal, inclined to live on roofs and

balconies, rarely descending to risk canine pursuit. As soon as the

dogs disappear, however, many cats become diurnal, replacing dogs

at a typical ratio of three cats for each dog who is no longer

there--about the body mass ratio of average cats to typical street

dogs.

Communities that never before noticed cats may suddenly

discover that they have enough feral cats to be problematic.

Examples include Hong Kong, the developed parts of Costa Rica, much

of the U.S. during the past 20 years, and the many Indian cities

where Animal Birth Control programs have sharply reduced the

abundance of street dogs.

But cats are not quite a perfect replacement for dogs. The

very attributes that enable cats to coexist among street dogs tend to

leave significant habitat niches vacant. For example, as pure

predators, cats rarely scavenge. When dogs are removed from urban

habitat, most of the scavenging role may be left to mice and rats,

who formerly were among the dogs' prey.

Mice and rats quickly breed up to the newly expanded carrying

capacity of any habitat from which dogs have been removed--especially

if dogs are no longer eating them. However, even if humans

refrained from poisoning mice and rats in response to any visible

abundance, mice and rats are not well-adapted to holding habitat.

Instead, they attract other predators such as jackals, coyotes,

foxes, and birds of prey in place of dogs, while accessible refuse

draws in larger or more evasive scavengers--such as pigs, monkeys,

and gulls--who can fend off or escape the predators.

In effect, the previous role of dogs as scavengers and

rodent predators is replaced by mice-plus-cats-plus-rats-plus

whatever else comes. The simple scavenging habitat niche becomes a

complex food chain, in which the especially complex role of rats

tends to be overlooked because it mostly occurs beyond human view.

Like dogs, rats will eat almost anything. Also like dogs,

rats can become predators if conditions favor predation. Where mice

are abundant, rats tend to become voracious nest predators of

" pinky " mice.

Further, the rat population may be virtually unchecked by

cats, no matter how many cats there are, because while cats are

probably the most efficient of all predators of adult mice, few cats

will risk pouncing on a full-grown rat if other food is available.

Rats could in theory totally replace the roles of street

dogs, and in cities with modern sanitation, where the scavenging

niche is reduced and scattered to the point that roving dogs have a

hard time making a living, this is what tends to happen. Where dogs

once roamed the streets, rats patrol inside the walls of high-rise

buildings. Though feral cats are more visible, rats outnumber them,

thousands to one.

Until the scavenging niche is reduced and diminished,

however, removing dogs from the habitat has a different outcome.

In Asian, African, and Latin American cities, especially

those without closed sewage systems and frequent trash collection,

where refuse remains sufficiently accessible to support street dogs,

pigs and monkeys tend to be the ultimate beneficiaries of reducing

the dog population. Though both pigs and monkeys can kill dogs in

fights which could go either way, pigs and monkeys tend to run from

dogs rather than take chances. Otherwise, the major threats to pigs

and monkeys in most urban habitat are motor vehicles. Neither pigs

nor monkeys have anything to fear from cats, or rats.

Neither do pigs and monkeys tend to be very afraid of people,

unless the people are armed. Then, both pigs and monkeys tend to

learn how to distinguish armed people from unarmed people, just as

they learn to distinguish vulnerable humans carrying groceries from

those who have nothing edible to drop, who may fight back if menaced.

In U.S. cities, where closed sewage systems and frequent

refuse collection prevail, the food sources most accessible to urban

wildlife tend to be yard vegetation. While dogs do not eat yard

plants, they do chase other animals out of yards and out of the

neighborhood, if they can. Removing free-roaming dogs from the

habitat typically allows urban wildlife to exploit the vegetation

undisturbed, if they just stay out of the fenced yards where dogs

remain.

Raccoons, occupying approximately the same habitat niche in

North America that monkeys hold in India, are among the most

ubiquitous beneficiaries. Nowhere in the wild are raccoons as

abundant as they have become in U.S. suburbs, at population

densities as great as 300 per square mile in parts of New England.

Other species who are now more abundant in U.S. suburbs than

in the wild include both whitetailed and blacktailed deer, and

opossums, whose expansion of range into the northern half of the

U.S. closely followed the construction of the interstate highway

system in the 1950s and 1960s. Occupying a relatively limited

habitat niche at first, opossums have proliferated during the past

several decades in approximate inverse to the frequency with which

dogs are picked up for running at large.

The conditions conducive to pig proliferation in the U.S.,

Britain, and other developed nations where fast-expanding feral pig

populations have become troublesome are not quite the same as the

conditions that enable pigs to take over vacated dog habitat in much

of Asia. Yet there are similarities.

To a pig, a marketplace full of discarded fruits and

vegetables differs little from a yard full of windfallen fruit from

ornamental trees and hedges. Muddy roadside ditches are wonderful

travel corridors.

Pigs make themselves equally at home among cornfields,

orchards, refuse piles, and forests full of fallen acorns and

fungi. Almost anywhere suits a pig, if the pig has food, mud, and

companions. A combination of high intelligence, easy satisfaction,

and litter sizes averaging more than twice the average dog litter

size make pigs at least as potentially ubiquitous as dogs.

If tolerated, pigs will sleep in the sunshine, in full view

of all. If responded to with humane consideration, pigs can become

good neighbors, occupying their present limited ecological niche,

potentially controlled by immunocontraceptive baits.

If pigs are hunted, on the other hand, they will spend

daytime in deep dens, foraging and traveling only at night. The

cleverness and reproductive potential that enabled pigs to evade

extermination on small rocky islands for 25 years will ensure that

even the most aggressive and ruthless efforts to kill them all will

fail--indeed, pigs have never been lastingly extirpated from any

habitat other than small islands--and will ensure, as well, that

the plight of feral pigs will attract increasing humane attention in

coming decades.

Beyond practical considerations, demonstrating concern for

feral pigs could help to set a persuasive example to the public and

to agribusiness of how pigs ought to be treated--and perhaps hasten

the day when pig-eating is looked upon with the same revulsion that

most of the world now feels toward dog and cat eating.

 

 

 

--

Merritt Clifton

Editor, ANIMAL PEOPLE

P.O. Box 960

Clinton, WA 98236

 

Telephone: 360-579-2505

Fax: 360-579-2575

E-mail: anmlpepl

Web: www.animalpeoplenews.org

 

[ANIMAL PEOPLE is the leading independent newspaper providing

original investigative coverage of animal protection worldwide,

founded in 1992. Our readership of 30,000-plus includes the

decision-makers at more than 10,000 animal protection organizations.

We have no alignment or affiliation with any other entity. $24/year;

for free sample, send address.]