Guest guest Posted September 27, 2007 Report Share Posted September 27, 2007 http://news./s/nm/20070926/india_nm/india297280 & printer=1;_ylt=AqpCmqlO\ cwSryzxHwHN2R0nfrGIF India's tigers need miracle to survive By Nita BhallaWed Sep 26, 10:32 AM ET India's dwindling tiger population will never recover and it will take a miracle to save those left from habitat destruction and poaching, a renowned expert said on Wednesday. Failure by authorities to understand the needs of tigers and provide protection has led to numbers falling to 1,300 now from around 3,700 in 2001/02, Valmik Thapar told Reuters ahead of the Reuters Environment Summit next week. " I believe that the government of the day failed the tigers of India and we cannot recover this population ever again, " said Thapar, who has spent the past three decades documenting the behaviour of tigers and crusading for their survival. " A miracle is required to save the Indian tiger. But I don't believe in miracles, as the commitment to save tigers is non-existent. " India has half the world's surviving tigers, but their populations have suffered, driven by a demand for tiger skins and bones in China for traditional medicines. Thapar, 55, has written 15 books about tigers and presented around 20 documentaries for broadcasters and channels such as the BBC, National Geographic, Discovery and Animal Planet. His close relationship over six or seven years with a tigress called " Macchli " -- meaning fish in Hindi due to a fish-like marking on her cheek -- is widely documented in his films. Thapar, also known as India's " Tiger man " , was also the first to document how male tigers behave in a family unit. " What is happening now is a great tragedy, " he said. " No one understands the needs of tigers. Committees set up to look after tigers are filled with people who know nothing about the tiger. " CO-EXISTENCE? The bushy-bearded conservationist said government initiatives like the setting up of a Tiger Conservation Authority and a Wildlife Crime Bureau were just " lip service " and " rhetoric " . He said the tiger's survival was dependent on rapid action, reform and strong protection of the animals and their habitat. But instead, Thapar said, the government was placing the animals under greater risk with a new law giving people rights over forest resources and advocating the co-existance of tigers and man. " Lions don't co-exist with people in Africa, jaguars don't co-exist with people in South America and tigers and leopards have never co-existed with people in India, " he said. " It's a myth. It's an illusion. It's the biggest disaster that the present government has started to believe. " The Recognition of Forest Rights Act, passed last year and expected to formally become law in the coming months, grants some of India's most impoverished and marginalised communities the right to own and live off resource-rich forests. But it has sparked debate amongst conservationists and the government who disagree on whether it will help save or further threaten tigers. Thapar said from 1850 to 1950 at least 100,000 tigers were killed by man, 25,000 people were killed by tigers and around one million livestock were killed by tigers, proving that there was a huge amount of conflict between man and tigers. " But our politicians have not understood this, " said Thapar. " They think you can cuddle tigers. " He said there would be no legal cover for national parks and wildlife sanctuaries, leaving them open to exploitation by forest dwellers as well as by timber and poaching mafias. " This is the end of forest India. It's like opening a bank and saying to the public come and loot. " Despite his distinguished career which was filled with thousands of memorable moments, Thapar said his life was a failure as he had failed in the battle to save India's tigers. " The most moving and memorable time was with a tigress and her three tiny cubs. I watched her in the early morning sun for two hours, it brought tears to my eyes. I wept in joy -- the joy of the devotion of a mother to her little ones, " he said. " But if you look at it today, those mothers are being killed and the cubs are dying as the mothers don't return home. " 2007 Reuters Limited. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of Reuters content is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of Reuters. Reuters shall not be liable for any errors or delays in the content, or for any actions taken in reliance thereon. 2007 Inc. All rights reserved. Questions or Comments Privacy Policy -Terms of Service - Copyright/IP Policy - Ad Feedback Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 27, 2007 Report Share Posted September 27, 2007 To and All, I very much echo the concerns raised by Valmik Thappar! Just for everybody's information. Over the last 2 weeks if I can remember right 1) fresh tiger pelt was found in Kerala last week(believed to be hunted from Karnataka), 2) one more poacher found with another fresh tiger skin -claws, bones also found (skin believed to be just a couple of weeks old) in and around Mysore (tiger believed to be shot in Bandipur reserves, Karnataka) 3) One more caught in a hunters noose-trap was hung to death in Karnataka again..... I think on Monday/ Tuesday this week. Well though I got this information through one of my wildlife crime investigation colleagues, an alarm call (to the world) this BOG has barely featured in any of the news channels. Only a passing mention of one of these incidents in some local newspapers. This is when the government decided to downsize the staffing at Bandipur by half, claiming that they were short of funds. Are the above instances a direct consequence of this? Dont the tigers deserve to be a matter of national debate or would it require a celeb to shoot them for people to step up, raise concerns and may be from an authoritative/ administrative/ political stand point do something about this. I dont think I need to describe what the " something " needs to be. I think its a losing battle for individuals trying to fight the cause alone, our way. We HAVE TO HAVE the authorities incharge to help us in this cause. If they do not have the spine or brain to implement strategies to save the tiger (or rhino or any other animal for that matter), they should step aside for people who are completely focussed and passionate about eradicating poaching and ONLY work for conservation........ to take the reins. Thanks, Pablo. On 9/27/07, Weintraub <weintraub wrote: > > > http://news./s/nm/20070926/india_nm/india297280 & printer=1;_ylt=AqpCmqlO\ cwSryzxHwHN2R0nfrGIF > > India's tigers need miracle to survive > By Nita BhallaWed Sep 26, 10:32 AM ET > > India's dwindling tiger population will never recover and it will take a > miracle to save those left from habitat destruction and poaching, a renowned > expert said on Wednesday. > > Failure by authorities to understand the needs of tigers and provide > protection has led to numbers falling to 1,300 now from around 3,700 in > 2001/02, Valmik Thapar told Reuters ahead of the Reuters Environment Summit > next week. > > " I believe that the government of the day failed the tigers of India and > we cannot recover this population ever again, " said Thapar, who has spent > the past three decades documenting the behaviour of tigers and crusading for > their survival. > > " A miracle is required to save the Indian tiger. But I don't believe in > miracles, as the commitment to save tigers is non-existent. " > > India has half the world's surviving tigers, but their populations have > suffered, driven by a demand for tiger skins and bones in China for > traditional medicines. > > Thapar, 55, has written 15 books about tigers and presented around 20 > documentaries for broadcasters and channels such as the BBC, National > Geographic, Discovery and Animal Planet. > > His close relationship over six or seven years with a tigress called > " Macchli " -- meaning fish in Hindi due to a fish-like marking on her cheek > -- is widely documented in his films. > > Thapar, also known as India's " Tiger man " , was also the first to document > how male tigers behave in a family unit. > > " What is happening now is a great tragedy, " he said. " No one understands > the needs of tigers. Committees set up to look after tigers are filled with > people who know nothing about the tiger. " > > CO-EXISTENCE? > > The bushy-bearded conservationist said government initiatives like the > setting up of a Tiger Conservation Authority and a Wildlife Crime Bureau > were just " lip service " and " rhetoric " . > > He said the tiger's survival was dependent on rapid action, reform and > strong protection of the animals and their habitat. > > But instead, Thapar said, the government was placing the animals under > greater risk with a new law giving people rights over forest resources and > advocating the co-existance of tigers and man. > > " Lions don't co-exist with people in Africa, jaguars don't co-exist with > people in South America and tigers and leopards have never co-existed with > people in India, " he said. > > " It's a myth. It's an illusion. It's the biggest disaster that the present > government has started to believe. " > > The Recognition of Forest Rights Act, passed last year and expected to > formally become law in the coming months, grants some of India's most > impoverished and marginalised communities the right to own and live off > resource-rich forests. > > But it has sparked debate amongst conservationists and the government who > disagree on whether it will help save or further threaten tigers. > > Thapar said from 1850 to 1950 at least 100,000 tigers were killed by man, > 25,000 people were killed by tigers and around one million livestock were > killed by tigers, proving that there was a huge amount of conflict between > man and tigers. > > " But our politicians have not understood this, " said Thapar. " They think > you can cuddle tigers. " > > He said there would be no legal cover for national parks and wildlife > sanctuaries, leaving them open to exploitation by forest dwellers as well as > by timber and poaching mafias. > > " This is the end of forest India. It's like opening a bank and saying to > the public come and loot. " > > Despite his distinguished career which was filled with thousands of > memorable moments, Thapar said his life was a failure as he had failed in > the battle to save India's tigers. > > " The most moving and memorable time was with a tigress and her three tiny > cubs. I watched her in the early morning sun for two hours, it brought tears > to my eyes. I wept in joy -- the joy of the devotion of a mother to her > little ones, " he said. > > " But if you look at it today, those mothers are being killed and the cubs > are dying as the mothers don't return home. " > > Copyright © 2007 Reuters Limited. All rights reserved. Republication or > redistribution of Reuters content is expressly prohibited without the prior > written consent of Reuters. Reuters shall not be liable for any errors or > delays in the content, or for any actions taken in reliance thereon. > > > Copyright © 2007 Inc. All rights reserved. > Questions or Comments > Privacy Policy -Terms of Service - Copyright/IP Policy - Ad Feedback > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.