Jump to content
IndiaDivine.org

(IN) Fw: Complaint against Bombay SPCA

Rate this topic


Guest guest

Recommended Posts

Guest guest

--- On Wed, 4/15/09, Vishaya Kumtekar <kvishaya wrote:

 

 

Vishaya Kumtekar <kvishaya

Fw: kvishaya sent you a video: " Helping a Stray Kitten lead her into a

Big Trouble "

fiapo (AT) googl (DOT) com, aapn , awbi,

secretary.awbi, vspcadeep, anmlpepl

Wednesday, April 15, 2009, 6:52 PM

 

 

Dear Respected Jury

 

My name is Ms Vishaya Kumtekar residing at Khar Dandpada, Khar West, Mumbai

400052, India .

I have been rescuing injured animals including cat / dogs for treatment and

Spaying. Have also sterilized cats/dogs from my area with the help of IDA Ms

Goodicia and Fiza Shah.

 

Here I would like to inform all the Jury Members that I am  very disappointed

with BSPCA Parel Mumbai (Society for Prevention of Cruelty to Animals).  I

hereby submit a brief report which is as follow:

 

1)         I had admitted a 3 month old stray kitten for Rectom

Prostrate problem on 8th March 2009 Registration/Bill No 9876 at SPCA Mumbai and

also paid Rs. 500 as admission fee.... I regularly visited her and she was fine

after the operation. My last visit was on Friday 20th March and she was ok

while  the stitches were still intact. A note was left on her cage that she

should be strictly on Liquid Diet..... On Sunday 22nd March I was shocked to

hear that she was discharged and left in the Fish Market at Goregaon.  When I

approached the Manager Dr Yuvraj Kanigkar, he completely denied  and said they

must have left her in my area i.e Khar.  But the driver Mr Suresh Dholakia

clearly told us that it was the Manager who instructed to release the cats

alongwith 6 other Kittens in any of the fish market.  I was also told by the

Manager as per the new Rules and Regulation at BSPCA they have stopped calling

people and will not inform us at the time of discharge and they are suppose to

leave them on their own in the resptive area. I immediately questioned him that

the cat which I admitted belong to Khar area then why it was left at Goregaon 

and why I was not informed about the discharge since I paid for it...For that 

he replied we don't inform because we are running very high on telephone bills.

 

On Sunday I went to Goregaon to search the fish Market but could not  find the

cats.. On Monday 23rd March I again approached the Manager and told him to send

the Driver with me to find the cats.   When I reached the spot I was shocked

to see the place.. it was not a fish market but a huge Jungle and the driver had

left all the kitten on the main highway just next to the jungle. Upon

questioning the driver he said we can't help it because the fish market people

don't allow us to leave the cats so we just leave the animals at isolated

places.

 

Upon checking the entire bushes fortunately we could find one kitten but other 2

kittens including my kitten could not be found.  The Kitten which I have

rescued from Goregaon Jungle was in very bad shape and totally dehydrated and

could barely walk due to leg injury. Unfortunately the kitten died after 2

days.  (Attached Photo of the rescued Kitten)

 

I have a question to all the respective Jury.  when the animals belong to a

particular area it is mandatory that it should be released in that particular

area itself then why the animals should be release  in the Fish Market Or any

other random places??. And why the owners of the stray should not be informed?

 

I have reported this matter to the Committee Member  Madam Bakul Khatau who was

also very upset with the whole episode and apologised to me.

 

 

2.                  On 24th July 2008 I had admitted a Stray

puppy for Maggot wounds on his right ear. I had paid admission fee of Rs. 800.

Unfortunately the puppy died on 11th of Nov 2008 due to the negligence of SPCA.

I had regularly visited to check on the puppy. On 28th July I observed that the

puppy was limping and his right leg was dangling he could not walk.. I

approached the doctor but I was shocked when they told me that they are not

aware. The puppy’s right leg was full of absess…Till then the puppy was only

being treated for maggot wounds and was neglected for the leg injury.  I was

told that the absess was due to the injection which was given to the Puppy for 

maggot wounds.  In a week time the puppy was fully dehydrated and the hospital

had not even given him any tonics or proper medicine.. I had purchased all the

medicine and tonic on my own. Unfortunately the puppy had a very painful death

on 11thNov 2008 at SPCA.

Here I would like to highlight though Bombay SPCA claims they give free

treatment for strays animals I still paid the final bill of Rs. 4227. (attached

Bill Registration no 6369 dt 11/11/08 ) for the dead stray puppy. Also the

charges of Rs. 1000 for cremating the animals that too such a small puppy is

ridiculous.(Photo Attached of the puppy)

 

Also I would like to point out since ABC program is run through Government

Grant… why are we still charged Rs 1000/- for spaying/neuter.

 

Most of the time when we go to admit the animals we get a typical reply due to

space constraint we cannot admit the animals… and the animals are sent back.

Since SPCA is having such a huge land, why can’t they utilize the  land for

building more wards for the animals since the land is all vacant.

 

 

Bombay SPCA have also come up with New sets  of Rules for the stray animals. 

Whoever admits the animals have no right on the stray animals since it belongs

to SPCA. They will release the animals once it is discharged without even

informing the person who have admitted. This I believe is absolutely wrong and

it is the duty of  SPCA to inform the person  regarding the discharge of the

animals so that we can pick up the animals and release them in that particular

area since the animals are very familiar with the areas and can survive instead

of abandoning them at random places where there is no water or any other means

to survive. OR they should ensure that the animals are released in the

respective area they are picked up from… I strongly protest against this Rules

which is not in the better interest of our Animal Friends and which will risk

their life.

 

Have also noticed that the dogs especially the Strays are tied up in such a

cruel way with a fine rope instead of dog chain.. Some people have also donated

the belts and chains but disappears after few days. Upon questioning they have

typical answer “we don’t know what happened to the chains and beltsâ€. Hope

the SPCA Management is aware of this.

 

Other day I had visited the surgical cat ward. Two cats was kept in a small

basket for 4 days the reason was SPCA do not have enough cages/space.  How can

the cats be kept for days in such a small basket without proper ventilation and

water..  I could  see the cat struggling and immediately donated a cage and

shifted the cat.  

 

I very well remember previously the animals at SPCA was provided two meals  a

day. But now they are provided just one meal a day.. How about the animals who

are admitted after 2 pm, they have to go without any food till next morning 9

am.  This is not fair.

 

There are many more instances which I cannot put in writing because its is very

lengthy and very painful..

 

I am also attaching the Media report of Mid-Day  for yr ready reference.. and

also a complain by one more Gentleman Mr Joshi… For all the complains SPCA

have a typical answer.. “Whoever admits stray wants free treatmentâ€

 

I hope and request the Jury to kindly consider and take up the matter in the

better interest of our Animal friends. I strongly believe Rules and Regulations

to be set for the betterment of the animals and not to destroy them.

 

My Sincere Thanks to all the Respective Jury and all the people reading the

report.

 

Attached photographs of the rescued kitten and the puppy.

 

POST THIS REPORT, I MAY OR MAY NOT BE ALLOWED TO ENTER bOMBAY SPCA FOR ANY

FURTHER TREATMENT FOR THE ANIMALS. UNFORTUNATELY IN THE WHOLE OF BOMBAY WE HAVE

ONLY ONE ANIMAL HOSPITAL.

 

 

Best Regards

Ms Vishaya Kumtekar

Khar West

Mumbai India

 

 

--- On Wed, 4/8/09, YouTube Service <service wrote:

 

YouTube Service <service

kvishaya sent you a video: " Helping a Stray Kitten lead her into a Big

Trouble "

kvishaya

Wednesday, April 8, 2009, 5:05 PM

 

kvishaya has shared a video with you on YouTube:

 

pl read

 

 

Helping a Stray Kitten lead her into a Big Trouble

Vishya Kumtekar, an animal lover from Khar would have never thought that helping

a stray kitten would lead her into a such a big trouble that she has to once

again go in search for the same kitten. Kumtekar who works as a customer

representative with a shipping firm in Mahalakshmi has made an allegation that

the management from the Society For The Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (SPCA)

center in Parel has relocated the stray cat that she had admitted in the center

for treatment even after she had asked for her adoption..

 

Story & Video By - Urvashi Seth,Mid-Day

 

 

© 2009 YouTube, LLC

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

I am in knowledge of VALID similar complaints against a reputed New Delhi

based charitable veterinary care organisation.

The complainant had sent injured/ sick dogs to this rescue center. But is

surprised that even cases of limb fracture have died after admission.

Such matters need proper medical examinations and evidence to prove true.

 

I have already asked the complainant to take the matter with the AWBI as I

am not the right person to probe/ comment on something which could perhaps

be just plain and simple allegation.

 

 

 

On Wed, Apr 15, 2009 at 11:39 PM, Pradeep Nath <vspcadeepwrote:

 

>

>

>

> --- On Wed, 4/15/09, Vishaya Kumtekar

<kvishaya<kvishaya%40>>

> wrote:

>

> Vishaya Kumtekar <kvishaya <kvishaya%40>>

> Fw: kvishaya sent you a video: " Helping a Stray Kitten lead her

> into a Big Trouble "

> fiapo (AT) googl (DOT) com <fiapo%40googl>,

> aapn <aapn%40>,

awbi<awbi%40md3.vsnl.net.in>,

> secretary.awbi <secretary.awbi%40gmail.com>,

> vspcadeep <vspcadeep%40.co.in>,

anmlpepl<anmlpepl%40whidbey.com>

> Wednesday, April 15, 2009, 6:52 PM

>

> Dear Respected Jury

>

> My name is Ms Vishaya Kumtekar residing at Khar Dandpada, Khar West, Mumbai

> 400052, India .

> I have been rescuing injured animals including cat / dogs for treatment and

> Spaying. Have also sterilized cats/dogs from my area with the help of IDA Ms

> Goodicia and Fiza Shah.

>

> Here I would like to inform all the Jury Members that I am very

> disappointed with BSPCA Parel Mumbai (Society for Prevention of Cruelty to

> Animals). I hereby submit a brief report which is as follow:

>

> 1) I had admitted a 3 month old stray kitten for Rectom Prostrate

> problem on 8th March 2009 Registration/Bill No 9876 at SPCA Mumbai and also

> paid Rs. 500 as admission fee.... I regularly visited her and she was fine

> after the operation. My last visit was on Friday 20th March and she was ok

> while the stitches were still intact. A note was left on her cage that she

> should be strictly on Liquid Diet..... On Sunday 22nd March I was shocked to

> hear that she was discharged and left in the Fish Market at Goregaon. When

> I approached the Manager Dr Yuvraj Kanigkar, he completely denied and said

> they must have left her in my area i.e Khar. But the driver Mr Suresh

> Dholakia clearly told us that it was the Manager who instructed to release

> the cats alongwith 6 other Kittens in any of the fish market. I was also

> told by the Manager as per the new Rules and Regulation at BSPCA they have

> stopped calling people and will not inform us at the time of discharge and

> they are suppose to leave them on their own in the resptive area. I

> immediately questioned him that the cat which I admitted belong to Khar area

> then why it was left at Goregaon and why I was not informed about the

> discharge since I paid for it...For that he replied we don't inform because

> we are running very high on telephone bills.

>

> On Sunday I went to Goregaon to search the fish Market but could not find

> the cats.. On Monday 23rd March I again approached the Manager and told him

> to send the Driver with me to find the cats. When I reached the spot I was

> shocked to see the place.. it was not a fish market but a huge Jungle and

> the driver had left all the kitten on the main highway just next to the

> jungle. Upon questioning the driver he said we can't help it because the

> fish market people don't allow us to leave the cats so we just leave the

> animals at isolated places.

>

> Upon checking the entire bushes fortunately we could find one kitten but

> other 2 kittens including my kitten could not be found. The Kitten which I

> have rescued from Goregaon Jungle was in very bad shape and totally

> dehydrated and could barely walk due to leg injury. Unfortunately the kitten

> died after 2 days. (Attached Photo of the rescued Kitten)

>

> I have a question to all the respective Jury. when the animals belong to a

> particular area it is mandatory that it should be released in that

> particular area itself then why the animals should be release in the Fish

> Market Or any other random places??. And why the owners of the stray should

> not be informed?

>

> I have reported this matter to the Committee Member Madam Bakul Khatau who

> was also very upset with the whole episode and apologised to me.

>

>

> 2. On 24th July 2008 I had admitted a Stray puppy for

> Maggot wounds on his right ear. I had paid admission fee of Rs. 800.

> Unfortunately the puppy died on 11th of Nov 2008 due to the negligence of

> SPCA. I had regularly visited to check on the puppy. On 28th July I observed

> that the puppy was limping and his right leg was dangling he could not

> walk.. I approached the doctor but I was shocked when they told me that they

> are not aware. The puppy’s right leg was full of absess…Till then the puppy

> was only being treated for maggot wounds and was neglected for the leg

> injury. I was told that the absess was due to the injection which was given

> to the Puppy for maggot wounds. In a week time the puppy was fully

> dehydrated and the hospital had not even given him any tonics or proper

> medicine.. I had purchased all the medicine and tonic on my own.

> Unfortunately the puppy had a very painful death on 11thNov 2008 at SPCA.

> Here I would like to highlight though Bombay SPCA claims they give free

> treatment for strays animals I still paid the final bill of Rs. 4227.

> (attached Bill Registration no 6369 dt 11/11/08 ) for the dead stray puppy.

> Also the charges of Rs. 1000 for cremating the animals that too such a small

> puppy is ridiculous.(Photo Attached of the puppy)

>

> Also I would like to point out since ABC program is run through Government

> Grant… why are we still charged Rs 1000/- for spaying/neuter.

>

> Most of the time when we go to admit the animals we get a typical reply due

> to space constraint we cannot admit the animals… and the animals are sent

> back. Since SPCA is having such a huge land, why can’t they utilize the

> land for building more wards for the animals since the land is all vacant.

>

>

> Bombay SPCA have also come up with New sets of Rules for the stray

> animals. Whoever admits the animals have no right on the stray animals

> since it belongs to SPCA. They will release the animals once it is

> discharged without even informing the person who have admitted. This I

> believe is absolutely wrong and it is the duty of SPCA to inform the

> person regarding the discharge of the animals so that we can pick up the

> animals and release them in that particular area since the animals are very

> familiar with the areas and can survive instead of abandoning them at random

> places where there is no water or any other means to survive. OR they should

> ensure that the animals are released in the respective area they are picked

> up from… I strongly protest against this Rules which is not in the better

> interest of our Animal Friends and which will risk their life.

>

> Have also noticed that the dogs especially the Strays are tied up in such a

> cruel way with a fine rope instead of dog chain.. Some people have also

> donated the belts and chains but disappears after few days. Upon questioning

> they have typical answer “we don’t know what happened to the chains and

> belts”. Hope the SPCA Management is aware of this.

>

> Other day I had visited the surgical cat ward. Two cats was kept in a small

> basket for 4 days the reason was SPCA do not have enough cages/space. How

> can the cats be kept for days in such a small basket without proper

> ventilation and water.. I could see the cat struggling and immediately

> donated a cage and shifted the cat.

>

> I very well remember previously the animals at SPCA was provided two meals

> a day. But now they are provided just one meal a day.. How about the animals

> who are admitted after 2 pm, they have to go without any food till next

> morning 9 am. This is not fair.

>

> There are many more instances which I cannot put in writing because its is

> very lengthy and very painful..

>

> I am also attaching the Media report of Mid-Day for yr ready reference..

> and also a complain by one more Gentleman Mr Joshi… For all the complains

> SPCA have a typical answer.. “Whoever admits stray wants free treatment”

>

> I hope and request the Jury to kindly consider and take up the matter in

> the better interest of our Animal friends. I strongly believe Rules and

> Regulations to be set for the betterment of the animals and not to destroy

> them.

>

> My Sincere Thanks to all the Respective Jury and all the people reading the

> report.

>

> Attached photographs of the rescued kitten and the puppy.

>

> POST THIS REPORT, I MAY OR MAY NOT BE ALLOWED TO ENTER bOMBAY SPCA FOR ANY

> FURTHER TREATMENT FOR THE ANIMALS. UNFORTUNATELY IN THE WHOLE OF BOMBAY WE

> HAVE ONLY ONE ANIMAL HOSPITAL.

>

>

> Best Regards

> Ms Vishaya Kumtekar

> Khar West

> Mumbai India

>

> --- On Wed, 4/8/09, YouTube Service

<service<service%40youtube.com>>

> wrote:

>

> YouTube Service <service <service%40youtube.com>>

> kvishaya sent you a video: " Helping a Stray Kitten lead her into a

> Big Trouble "

> kvishaya <kvishaya%40>

> Wednesday, April 8, 2009, 5:05 PM

>

> kvishaya has shared a video with you on YouTube:

>

> pl read

>

> Helping a Stray Kitten lead her into a Big Trouble

> Vishya Kumtekar, an animal lover from Khar would have never thought that

> helping a stray kitten would lead her into a such a big trouble that she has

> to once again go in search for the same kitten. Kumtekar who works as a

> customer representative with a shipping firm in Mahalakshmi has made an

> allegation that the management from the Society For The Prevention of

> Cruelty to Animals (SPCA) center in Parel has relocated the stray cat that

> she had admitted in the center for treatment even after she had asked for

> her adoption..

>

> Story & Video By - Urvashi Seth,Mid-Day

>

> © 2009 YouTube, LLC

>

>

 

 

 

--

http://www.stopelephantpolo.com

http://www.freewebs.com/azamsiddiqui

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

I think its important that we voice our genuine complaints with the name of

the organisation, after recognising that all organisations do make mistakes

sometimes and also that they are dependant on staff that may be negligent

at times. But if the problem repeats itself many times it means something.

 

I am from the Pondicherry area and the SPCA here was pretty negligent a few

years ago while I was a member. I no longer have anything to do with them,

but at that time I did write to the AWBI and never heard back from them, nor

was any action taken. There is another organisation here which was even

worse - having got funds for an ambulance from the AWBI which was not being

used for animals. This too was reported. Although writing to the AWBI did

not help things, I think that making them public may help it a bit. So lets

not hide the names of offending organisations or incidents. I think writing

about it in forums like this and the FIAPO will help ­ at least people will

know which organisations not to trust with their animals. Although in

Mumbai, I must say there is not much of an alternative to the SPCA

sometimes.

 

Nandita

 

 

 

 

I am in knowledge of VALID similar complaints against a reputed New Delhi

based charitable veterinary care organisation.

The complainant had sent injured/ sick dogs to this rescue center. But is

surprised that even cases of limb fracture have died after admission.

Such matters need proper medical examinations and evidence to prove true.

 

I have already asked the complainant to take the matter with the AWBI as I

am not the right person to probe/ comment on something which could perhaps

be just plain and simple allegation.

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Smt. Maneka Gandhi, Chairperson People for Animals has been informed several

times of a Non-Functional, Defunct SPCA that claims to exist in the city of

Guwahati.The 'S' in the SPCA signifies that it is a 'Society'.

But in case of Guwahati since the time I knew of animal welfare in 1997, the

Guwahati-SPCA has been a 'One Man Show'.

It is one Mr. Singh (I forget his initials) who is in his 50s, an elderly

gentleman, who sits in one corner of the office of the Veterinary Director.

There is NO helpline for the SPCA here.

There is No publicity undertaken by the existing AWOs or the AWBI to make

people aware of atleast the existing de-funct SPCA of Guwahati.

It is just disgusting!

 

Following many such complaints of defunct SPCAs and AWOs, Smt. Maneka Gandhi

carried out Nationwide inspection.

And as the results were extremely pathetic and I also remember that during

the 2001 Master Trainer course this was an issue which was of deep concern.

I was personally asked by Smt. Gandhi to work with the administration and

start a fresh SPCA here. However due to professional time constraints and my

personal problems this move could not be initiated.

But there is already a petition lying with the Deputy Commissioner of Kamrup

metropolitan, where I have made an appeal to the administration for a new

SPCA and scrapping the existing defunct one.

 

So what I want to say is that Yes, there are many such issues involving

organsiations which are of concern that put us in bad light.

However I have never ever heard of any platform in INDIA which has made some

kind of a breakthrough in resolving these issues (IN_HOUSE).

When I say in-house, I mean a closed door conference/ seminar where the

allegations/ charges etc can be debated/ discussed in depth and solved

without the knowledge of the outside world.

It is quite similar to what the head of a family would have done of his

children may have done something not so good.

Doing so would certainly instill more responsibility, accountability and

would minimize the possibility of any vested interest.

But having said that I would still feel that we must encourage the ordinary

public to come out with grievances, criticisms, complaints, compliments on

their personal experiences with AWOs.

I do not see why AAPN should not be permitted to act as a redressal forum to

address these issues of complaints. In fact we can win back the people if

our esteemed members on AAPN (most of who are heading organisations which

carry a lot of goodwill) can respond to such incidents.

 

Azam

 

 

On Thu, Apr 16, 2009 at 11:06 PM, Nandita Shah <shahnandi wrote:

 

>

>

> I think its important that we voice our genuine complaints with the name of

> the organisation, after recognising that all organisations do make mistakes

> sometimes and also that they are dependant on staff that may be negligent

> at times. But if the problem repeats itself many times it means something.

>

> I am from the Pondicherry area and the SPCA here was pretty negligent a few

> years ago while I was a member. I no longer have anything to do with them,

> but at that time I did write to the AWBI and never heard back from them,

> nor

> was any action taken. There is another organisation here which was even

> worse - having got funds for an ambulance from the AWBI which was not being

> used for animals. This too was reported. Although writing to the AWBI did

> not help things, I think that making them public may help it a bit. So lets

> not hide the names of offending organisations or incidents. I think writing

> about it in forums like this and the FIAPO will help ­ at least people will

> know which organisations not to trust with their animals. Although in

> Mumbai, I must say there is not much of an alternative to the SPCA

> sometimes.

>

> Nandita

>

>

> I am in knowledge of VALID similar complaints against a reputed New Delhi

> based charitable veterinary care organisation.

> The complainant had sent injured/ sick dogs to this rescue center. But is

> surprised that even cases of limb fracture have died after admission.

> Such matters need proper medical examinations and evidence to prove true.

>

> I have already asked the complainant to take the matter with the AWBI as I

> am not the right person to probe/ comment on something which could perhaps

> be just plain and simple allegation.

>

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Before posting a complaint about any organisation, the organisation must be

given a chance to explain. Thereafter, both the complaint and the

explanation - if valid - can be posted on aapn.

 

There are very few organisations working for animals. We can destroy them

easily with a few words - but it takes years to build up a new organisation.

 

Let's be fair, folks.

 

Let's not destroy if we don't know the full story.

 

Nanditha Krishna

 

On Thu, Apr 16, 2009 at 11:06 PM, Nandita Shah <shahnandi wrote:

 

>

>

> I think its important that we voice our genuine complaints with the name of

> the organisation, after recognising that all organisations do make mistakes

> sometimes and also that they are dependant on staff that may be negligent

> at times. But if the problem repeats itself many times it means something.

>

> I am from the Pondicherry area and the SPCA here was pretty negligent a few

> years ago while I was a member. I no longer have anything to do with them,

> but at that time I did write to the AWBI and never heard back from them,

> nor

> was any action taken. There is another organisation here which was even

> worse - having got funds for an ambulance from the AWBI which was not being

> used for animals. This too was reported. Although writing to the AWBI did

> not help things, I think that making them public may help it a bit. So lets

> not hide the names of offending organisations or incidents. I think writing

> about it in forums like this and the FIAPO will help ­ at least people will

> know which organisations not to trust with their animals. Although in

> Mumbai, I must say there is not much of an alternative to the SPCA

> sometimes.

>

> Nandita

>

> I am in knowledge of VALID similar complaints against a reputed New Delhi

> based charitable veterinary care organisation.

> The complainant had sent injured/ sick dogs to this rescue center. But is

> surprised that even cases of limb fracture have died after admission.

> Such matters need proper medical examinations and evidence to prove true.

>

> I have already asked the complainant to take the matter with the AWBI as I

> am not the right person to probe/ comment on something which could perhaps

> be just plain and simple allegation.

>

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Why start a fresh SPCA when the ground work for an organisation already exists?

If no one is interested in the existing set-up, ten people can get

together and take it over and show others how it can be run properly.

 

If you are not part of the solution, you are part of the problem.

 

And no one said that the issues should not be discussed - the principles of

natural justice require that an opportunity be given to the other party to

respond to the charges.

 

S. Chinny Krishna

 

 

aapn [aapn ] On Behalf Of

azam24x7

17 April 2009 12:07

Nandita Shah

Cc: aapn

Re: Re: (IN) Fw: Complaint against Bombay SPCA

 

Smt. Maneka Gandhi, Chairperson People for Animals has been informed

several

times of a Non-Functional, Defunct SPCA that claims to exist in the city

of

Guwahati.The 'S' in the SPCA signifies that it is a 'Society'.

But in case of Guwahati since the time I knew of animal welfare in 1997,

the

Guwahati-SPCA has been a 'One Man Show'.

It is one Mr. Singh (I forget his initials) who is in his 50s, an

elderly

gentleman, who sits in one corner of the office of the Veterinary.

There is NO helpline for the SPCA here.

There is No publicity undertaken by the existing AWOs or the AWBI to

make

people aware of atleast the existing de-funct SPCA of Guwahati.

It is just disgusting!

 

Following many such complaints of defunct SPCAs and AWOs, Smt. Maneka

Gandhi

carried out Nationwide inspection.

And as the results were extremely pathetic and I also remember that

during

the 2001 Master Trainer course this was an issue which was of deep

concern.

I was personally asked by Smt. Gandhi to work with the administration

and

start a fresh SPCA here. However due to professional time constraints

and my

personal problems this move could not be initiated.

But there is already a petition lying with the Deputy Commissioner of

Kamrup

metropolitan, where I have made an appeal to the administration for a

new

SPCA and scrapping the existing defunct one.

 

So what I want to say is that Yes, there are many such issues involving

organsiations which are of concern that put us in bad light.

However I have never ever heard of any platform in INDIA which has made

some

kind of a breakthrough in resolving these issues (IN_HOUSE).

When I say in-house, I mean a closed door conference/ seminar where the

allegations/ charges etc can be debated/ discussed in depth and solved

without the knowledge of the outside world.

It is quite similar to what the head of a family would have done of his

children may have done something not so good.

Doing so would certainly instill more responsibility, accountability and

would minimize the possibility of any vested interest.

But having said that I would still feel that we must encourage the

ordinary

public to come out with grievances, criticisms, complaints, compliments

on

their personal experiences with AWOs.

I do not see why AAPN should not be permitted to act as a redressal

forum to

address these issues of complaints. In fact we can win back the people

if

our esteemed members on AAPN (most of who are heading organisations

which

carry a lot of goodwill) can respond to such incidents.

 

Azam

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...