Guest guest Posted April 19, 2001 Report Share Posted April 19, 2001 Dear Krushna - There is difference in Karkatva and karak. Karakatva is action, and karak means planet doing it. Karakatva for any event goes to the 8th house from any house, and karak is lord of that house, and planets residing in that house with more points. Thanks for the clarification. I will put this in the next notebook update. Donna Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 20, 2001 Report Share Posted April 20, 2001 Dear Peter - When you say "the house that indicates having the Karkatva" do you mean the house that contains the Karkatva, in this case would it be the ruler of A???. I'm sure Krushna explained this to you satisfactorily enough. I will put a further note into the next page that will be a little more specific and explain the Karkatva like Krushna did to you. Donna Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 20, 2001 Report Share Posted April 20, 2001 Dear Donna and Peterji, Karak = doer, maker Karkatva = Activity proper to person/institution , Mode of action or activity by which things fulfil its purpose. krushna --- DQuinn12 wrote: > Dear Peter - > > > > When you say " the house that indicates having the > Karkatva " do you mean the > > house that contains the Karkatva, in this case > would it be the ruler of > > A???. > > > I'm sure Krushna explained this to you > satisfactorily enough. I will put a > further note into the next page that will be a > little more specific and > explain the Karkatva like Krushna did to you. > > Donna > > __________ For regular News updates go to http://in.news. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 20, 2001 Report Share Posted April 20, 2001 Dear Donna, Yes Krushna did explain quite well the difference between the karkatva and the Karaka. However it is the wording of Note 4 which does not make sense to me. In Note 4 you say " The house that indicates having the Karkatva for any event also indicates the end of that particular thing." Now - using the comments by Krushna - the house which indicates having the karkatva for any event is in fact House A - so Note 4 would indicate that House A is also the end of that thing. This to me does not make sense. In the case of children using house5 as B then house 12 would be the karkatva for the event. According to your Note 4 it would also indicate the death of the child but this is not true as this would be the 8th from the 12 or if you like the 3rd from the 5th which is house 7. This is where I am getting mixed up. It is the words "indicates having the karkatva' which is confusing. Does it mean "is" the Karaktva or has the ruler of the karkatva or what. Perhaps when you revise it the meaning will become more clear. Probably it is just me that is dumb but I am completely unable to follow the meaning of that particular note. By the way do not think I am criticising your work because I think you do a famtastic job which I would not like to have to do myself./ Its just that every now and again I get so that I can only see one meaning and it seems to take a sledge hammer to knock the true meaning into my concrete skull - in other word on my "dumb" days Peter Namaste Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 21, 2001 Report Share Posted April 21, 2001 Respected Peterji, You are very brillient, I know it. No body can dare to call you " ..... " . Deliberately you may play a role of '.....' so Your questions should help other members to get doubts clear. I will try to clearify the thing. Suppose we are considering about the personality, self Individuality of any person. It should be taken from first house as B. So 8th house of the chart becames house A. Now same house is considered for death as B. Now here 8th house is having karkatva for 1st house, and also indicating the death of the person. So Donna have written it is also the end of the thing also indicated by the same house. 2nd Example: For Child we consider 5th house as 'B' so 12th house becames house 'A' which is having the karkatva for child birth. Now as it is 8th house from 5th so also indicates death of the child ( house 'B' ) 3rd Example : 7th house (as B) indicates the marriage so its karkatva goes to 2nd house (as A). Now ast the same time it is being 8th from 7th house indicates death of spouse (as B) " SO THE HOUSE WHICH INDICATES THE KARKATVA FOR ANY EVENT ALSO INDICATES THE END OF THAT EVENT. " This is what Donna wants to explain. krushna -- In , " Peter Sutcliffe " <petermay@p...> wrote: > Dear Donna, > Yes Krushna did explain quite well the difference between the karkatva and the Karaka. However it is the wording of Note 4 which does not make sense to me. In Note 4 you say " The house that indicates having the Karkatva for any event also indicates the end of that particular thing. " > Now - using the comments by Krushna - the house which indicates having the karkatva for any event is in fact House A - so Note 4 would indicate that House A is also the end of that thing. This to me does not make sense. > In the case of children using house5 as B then house 12 would be the karkatva for the event. According to your Note 4 it would also indicate the death of the child but this is not true as this would be the 8th from the 12 or if you like the 3rd from the 5th which is house 7. This is where I am getting mixed up. > It is the words " indicates having the karkatva' which is confusing. Does it mean " is " the Karaktva or has the ruler of the karkatva or what. > Perhaps when you revise it the meaning will become more clear. > Probably it is just me that is dumb but I am completely unable to follow the meaning of that particular note. > By the way do not think I am criticising your work because I think you do a famtastic job which I would not like to have to do myself./ Its just that every now and again I get so that I can only see one meaning and it seems to take a sledge hammer to knock the true meaning into my concrete skull - in other word on my " dumb " days > > Peter > Namaste Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 21, 2001 Report Share Posted April 21, 2001 Dear Peter - " SO THE HOUSE WHICH INDICATES THE KARKATVA FOR ANY EVENT ALSO INDICATES THE END OF THAT EVENT." This is what Donna wants to explain. Exactly. . . . ) Donna Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.