Guest guest Posted May 2, 2001 Report Share Posted May 2, 2001 Dear Krushna - Oops! I'm sorry, Krushna. I gave you an older version of the calculator by mistake. This is the corrected one. I will label it 1.1 to differentiate it from the others. In your example for Lesson 21 however, even though my calculator comes up with 22:25:25 for the ayanamsha and you come up with 22:25:32, why is there still a difference of even 7 seconds if the constant is at 50.33 seconds? And although I have a little table where you can enter your old ayanamsha from your table on P. 32, the difference is now 1 minute and 10 seconds, not just 10 seconds between them. This is one of the reasons that I need to have the exact calculations you use to come up with this 22:25:32, so I can adjust it accordingly in mine. There's obviously a step that either you or I are leaving out. Thanks- Donna Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 2, 2001 Report Share Posted May 2, 2001 Dear Donna, The Difference in Ayanansha is due to the yearly speed ( Ayan Chalan). We have taken it constant for ease of the work. Following are the value of the speed per year Year Speed of ayanansha ( Ayan Chalan) 0400 49.60 0500 49.65 0600 49.70 0700 49.75 0800 49.80 0900 48.85 1000 49.90 1100 49.95 1200 50.00 1600 50.20 1800 50.25 1900 50.27 2000 50.39 3000 56.70 The speed will be maximum when Ayanansha will reach near to 90 degrees. Again it will reduce to 46.00 when Ayanansha will be 180 degree (it will take some 13500 years Aproximatly)( Values given here are aproximate.) It is not constant. For our work We have taken it as 50.33 average value. Which gives maximum difference of about 6 Seconds. Which is very tolerable limit. So donot bother for that. I have not the time to check each and every value. But it seems to be correct. Krushna , DQuinn12@A... wrote: > Dear Krushna - > > Oops! I'm sorry, Krushna. I gave you an older version of the calculator > by mistake. This is the corrected one. I will label it 1.1 to differentiate > it from the others. > > In your example for Lesson 21 however, even though my calculator comes up > with 22:25:25 for the ayanamsha and you come up with 22:25:32, why is there > still a difference of even 7 seconds if the constant is at 50.33 seconds? And > although I have a little table where you can enter your old ayanamsha from > your table on P. 32, the difference is now 1 minute and 10 seconds, not just > 10 seconds between them. This is one of the reasons that I need to have the > exact calculations you use to come up with this 22:25:32, so I can adjust it > accordingly in mine. There's obviously a step that either you or I are > leaving out. > > Thanks- > Donna Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 4, 2001 Report Share Posted May 4, 2001 Dear Krushna - It is not constant. For our work We have taken it as 50.33 average value. Which gives maximum difference of about 6 Seconds. Which is very tolerable limit. So donot bother for that. I have not the time to check each and every value. But it seems to be correct. OK, I can understand that you are using an average here which is still within the tolerable limits. But still, you yourself do not seem to be using this method of calculation to average out YOUR ayanamsha, which is ALWAYS off by a few seconds from our avergae calculated one! This means that you must still be doing "something" different in order to arrive at that particular figure, right? Do you for instance use the 50.33 average for every year or do you personally try to figure it out specifically for each and every different year? Please clarify by giving step by step calculations as to how you arrived at the ayanamsha for the example you gave in Lesson 21. This way we can see where the difference comes in between yours and the calculated version. Thanks, Krushna - Donna Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 6, 2001 Report Share Posted May 6, 2001 Dear Donna, Sorry for late reply. I was out of station for two days. Today I have checked your sheet. The yearly speed of Ayanansha you have taken is wrong. it is in decimal 50.33 seconds. You have taken 33 as 60th part of a second. The ayanansha defers from Raman is about 25: 54 I have told it differes aproximately by 25 min from Raman's ayanansha. Some body else have found that it differs from Lahiri some 1:1: and some seconds or so. To day I checked it is not so the yearly speed for Lahiry is rounded 50 seconds, where as Raman have taken about 50.32 seconds it is also in decimal. Any how I will give you complete chart rectified. Please give me two days. thanks krushna --- DQuinn12 wrote: > Dear Krushna - > > > > > > > > It is not constant. For our work We have > taken it as 50.33 > > average value. Which gives maximum difference of > about 6 Seconds. > > Which is very tolerable limit. > > > > So donot bother for that. I have not the > time to check each > > and every value. But it seems to be correct. > > > > OK, I can understand that you are using an average > here which is still within > the tolerable limits. But still, you yourself do not > seem to be using this > method of calculation to average out YOUR ayanamsha, > which is ALWAYS off by a > few seconds from our avergae calculated one! This > means that you must still > be doing " something " different in order to arrive at > that particular figure, > right? Do you for instance use the 50.33 average for > every year or do you > personally try to figure it out specifically for > each and every different > year? > > Please clarify by giving step by step calculations > as to how you arrived at > the ayanamsha for the example you gave in Lesson 21. > This way we can see > where the difference comes in between yours and the > calculated version. > > Thanks, Krushna - > Donna > __________ For regular News updates go to http://in.news. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.