Guest guest Posted May 15, 2001 Report Share Posted May 15, 2001 Respected Krushnaji, Finally, I have gone through the previous lessons and I have time for a few questions. I hope you can find the time to answer these. I am trying to check some events in a chart that I have. The chart is of a Pisces ascendant and Mercury and Venus are in the 12th house. The main period is that of Mercury. Mercury is the lord of 4th and 7th and is in 12th with 5 points. Venus is the lord of 3 and 8 and is in 12th with 4 points. The sub period is that of Moon. Moon has 4 points and is placed in the 5th house. Moon is natural samdharmi to Mars so this sub can represent that also. Moon is not samdharmi to any other planet in the chart. Since Moon has only 4 points, it can signify matters related to only the 8th and 12th houses where it is lord of D and E. Mars also has only one point so it can signify matters related to 4, 5, 9 and 12 where it is the lord of D or E. The functional karaka for the 4th and 5th house is Saturn. For 8th it is Venus, for 9th and 12th it is Mercury. Since Saturn is neither the main lord or its samdharmi, the emphasis in this period must be restricted to 8th, 9th, and 12th houses. The events related to 8th, 9th and 12th houses will occur during this period and these will be with the support of the 3rd, 4th, 7th, and 8th houses (lordship of the main period lord and its samdharmi). Please advise if this reasoning is correct. Venus is natural samdharmi to Saturn. However, we are using Venus as a samdharmi to the main period lord, Mercury. Can we use this period for events related to 4th and 5th houses also since Saturn is the karak for these and is samdharmi to Venus? Your reply would be highly appreciated. Kind regards Sanjay Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 15, 2001 Report Share Posted May 15, 2001 Dear Sanjay, After a long time you are in the group. Realy I missed you. No body ask me questions like you. My answers/ comments are in block letters... , " Sanjay Jaggia " <sanjaygg@l...> wrote: > Respected Krushnaji, > > Finally, I have gone through the previous lessons and I have time for a few > questions. I hope you can find the time to answer these. > > I am trying to check some events in a chart that I have. The chart is of a > Pisces ascendant and Mercury and Venus are in the 12th house. > > The main period is that of Mercury. Mercury is the lord of 4th and 7th and > is in 12th with 5 points. SO IT IS F.K. OF 9TH AND 12TH HOUSE. SO OVER ALL RESULTS GIVEN BY THE SUB PERIOD SHOULD HAVE SOME CONNECTION WITH 9TH 12TH AND 5TH HOUSE ( MERCURY BEING IN 12TH WITH MORE POINTS) AND IT IS NOT ASPECTING ANY OF THE UPCHAY HOUSES RELATED TO THESE HOUSES. Venus is the lord of 3 and 8 and is in 12th with 4 > points. O.K. > > The sub period is that of Moon. Moon has 4 points and is placed in the 5th > house. Moon is natural samdharmi to Mars so this sub can represent that > also. Moon is not samdharmi to any other planet in the chart. > ( THIS SHOULD BE CHECKED WITH NAVAMANSHA CHART, YOU MUST HAVE CHECKED IT, IT MEANS NO PLANET IS IN THE NAVAMANSHA OF MOON) > Since Moon has only 4 points, it can signify matters related to only the 8th and 12th houses where it is lord of D and E. CORRECT. Mars also has only one point so it can signify matters related to 4, 5, 9 and 12 where it is the lord of D or E. CORRECT. ( WHERE MARS IS SITUATED?) > > The functional karaka for the 4th and 5th house is Saturn. For 8th it is > Venus, for 9th and 12th it is Mercury. (ALSO FOR 5TH) > > Since Saturn is neither the main lord or its samdharmi (IT MEANS MERCURY IS NOT IN THE NAVAMANSHA OF SATURN, AND SATURN IS NOT SITUATED IN 9TH OR 3RD HOUSE) , the emphasis in this period must be restricted to 8th, 9th, and 12th houses. AS PER WORK SHEET HOW MANY POINTS MOON IS GETING FOR OTHER HOUSES. IT WILL GIVE GOOD RESULTS FOR HOUSES HAVING MORE POINTS AND MALEFIC RESULTS FOR HOUSES HAVING LESS POINTS. ALL THE RESULTS WILL BE CONNECTED TO 5,9,12TH HOUSES. RESULTS OF DIFFERENT HOUSES WILL BE EXPERIENCED AS PER THE 17 MONTHS PERIOD OF MOON IN MERCURY. THE EVENT DATES WILL BE RELATED TO OTHER PLANETS HAVING RELATIVE POINTS AND TRANSIT OF SUN IN THOSE SIGN OR CONSTELLATIONS. > > The events related to 8th, 9th and 12th houses will occur during this period > and these will be with the support of the 3rd, 4th, 7th, and 8th houses(PERTICULARLY FOR THE RESULT OF 11TH HOUSE , 4TH HOUSE,AND 2ND HOUSE) ( DUE TO MOON'S SIGHT ON 11TH HOUSE) > (lordship of the main period lord and its samdharmi). > > Please advise if this reasoning is correct. YOUR REASONING IS CORRECT, > > Venus is natural samdharmi to Saturn. However, we are using Venus as a > samdharmi to the main period lord, Mercury. Can we use this period for > events related to 4th and 5th houses also since Saturn is the karak for > these and is samdharmi to Venus? VENUS CAN BE USED IF YOU ARE FINDING THE RESULT OF 2ND HOUSE , SIXTH HOUSE, 11TH HOUSE. WHERE VENUS BEING SAMDHARMI TO MERCURY WILL COME FORWARD. (DUE TO SIGHT OF MERCURY ON 6TH HOUSE) > > Your reply would be highly appreciated. > IF YOU GIVE COMPLETE CHART IT WILL BE EASY TO ANSWER, IF ANY POINT LEFT OUT. ........KRUSHNA > Kind regards > Sanjay Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 16, 2001 Report Share Posted May 16, 2001 Respected Krushnaji, Thank you for your prompt reply. The relevant chart details are as follows: Ascendant - Pisces. Sun in 11th house (5 points) , Moon in 5th (4 points), Mars in 9th (2 points), Mercury in 12th (5 points), Jupiter in 2nd (4 points), Venus in 12th (4 points), Saturn in 10th (4 points), Rahu in lagna and Ketu in 7th. Navamsha lagna - Aquarius. Sun in Gemini, Moon in Libra, Mars in Aquarius, Mercury in Scorpio, Jupiter in Aries, Venus in Gemini, Saturn in Taurus, Rahu in Cancer, and Ketu in Capricorn. I am attaching the worksheet summary for you to see if you need to. There is no specific event that I am trying to prove. I am just trying to understand your system of picking up the relevant areas of life. Having given this background, I have some queries on your reply which I hope you will see below and answer. My original questions are preceded by '>', your reply is in capitals, and my new questions are marked by '>>>'. <krushanain Tuesday, May 15, 2001 11:03 PM Dear Sanjay, After a long time you are in the group. Realy I missed you. No body ask me questions like you. >>> Thank you. It is nice to be back. About the questions, I suppose I am just dumber than the other members :-) > Finally, I have gone through the previous lessons and I have time for a few questions. I hope you can find the time to answer these. I am trying to check some events in a chart that I have. The chart is of a Pisces ascendant and Mercury and Venus are in the 12th house. The main period is that of Mercury. Mercury is the lord of 4th and 7th and is in 12th with 5 points. SO IT IS F.K. OF 9TH AND 12TH HOUSE. SO OVER ALL RESULTS GIVEN BY THE SUB PERIOD SHOULD HAVE SOME CONNECTION WITH 9TH 12TH AND 5TH HOUSE ( MERCURY BEING IN 12TH WITH MORE POINTS) AND IT IS NOT ASPECTING ANY OF THE UPCHAY HOUSES RELATED TO THESE HOUSES >>> I thought planets with 5 points or more were relevant when they are in D or E. 12th house is D or E for the 3rd and 7th houses and Mercury should become eager to give results for these. Why should it give results related to 5th for which is only the lord of A? > Venus is the lord of 3 and 8 and is in 12th with 4 points. O.K. > The sub period is that of Moon. Moon has 4 points and is placed in the 5th house. Moon is natural samdharmi to Mars so this sub can represent that also. Moon is not samdharmi to any other planet in the chart. THIS SHOULD BE CHECKED WITH NAVAMANSHA CHART, YOU MUST HAVE CHECKED IT, IT MEANS NO PLANET IS IN THE NAVAMANSHA OF MOON) >>> Actually only Rahu is in the navamsha of Moon. Do planets become samdharmi to their dispositor in Rashi and Navamsha both or only in Navamsha? Would this not lead to too many samdharmis so that any event might be explained? > Since Moon has only 4 points, it can signify matters related to only the 8th and 12th houses where it is lord of D and E. CORRECT. >Mars also has only one point so it can signify matters related to 4, 5, 9 and 12 where it is the lord of D or E. CORRECT. ( WHERE MARS IS SITUATED?) >>> It is in the 9th house. > The functional karaka for the 4th and 5th house is Saturn. For 8th it is Venus, for 9th and 12th it is Mercury. (ALSO FOR 5TH) >>> I thought we were only to look for the functional karakas for the houses signified by the sub period lord or its samdharmi. I also thought the karak is the lord of the 8th house. Is a planet in the 8th house with 5 poitns or more also a karak for that house? > Since Saturn is neither the main lord or its samdharmi (IT MEANS MERCURY IS NOT IN THE NAVAMANSHA OF SATURN, AND SATURN IS NOT SITUATED IN 9TH OR 3RD HOUSE) , >>> All these conditions are true as you would see from the chart. However, if Saturn was in one of the conditions nnnmentioned by you, what would be the significance? >...the emphasis in this period must be restricted to 8th, 9th, and 12th houses. AS PER WORK SHEET HOW MANY POINTS MOON IS GETING FOR OTHER HOUSES. IT WILL GIVE GOOD RESULTS FOR HOUSES HAVING MORE POINTS AND MALEFIC RESULTS FOR HOUSES HAVING LESS POINTS. ALL THE RESULTS WILL BE CONNECTED TO 5,9,12TH HOUSES. RESULTS OF DIFFERENT HOUSES WILL BE EXPERIENCED AS PER THE 17 MONTHS PERIOD OF MOON IN MERCURY. THE EVENT DATES WILL BE RELATED TO OTHER PLANETS HAVING RELATIVE POINTS AND TRANSIT OF SUN IN THOSE SIGN OR CONSTELLATIONS. >>> Moon has less than 12 points for all house except 8th where it has 12 points. Does this mean that bad results will be felt for all these houses? Or will these be restricted to the 9th or 12th houses. >>> I am still having soem problem in understanding how the events will be related to the 5th house instead of the 8th house. > The events related to 8th, 9th and 12th houses will occur during this period and these will be with the support of the 3rd, 4th, 7th, and 8th houses (PERTICULARLY FOR THE RESULT OF 11TH HOUSE , 4TH HOUSE,AND 2ND HOUSE) ( DUE TO MOON'S SIGHT ON 11TH HOUSE) > (lordship of the main period lord and its samdharmi). >>> Could you please advise how would the results be related to the 11th 4th and 2nd houses? > Please advise if this reasoning is correct. YOUR REASONING IS CORRECT, > Venus is natural samdharmi to Saturn. However, we are using Venus as a samdharmi to the main period lord, Mercury. Can we use this period for events related to 4th and 5th houses also since Saturn is the karak for these and is samdharmi to Venus? VENUS CAN BE USED IF YOU ARE FINDING THE RESULT OF 2ND HOUSE , SIXTH HOUSE, 11TH HOUSE. WHERE VENUS BEING SAMDHARMI TO MERCURY WILL COME FORWARD. (DUE TO SIGHT OF MERCURY ON 6TH HOUSE) >>> I am only looking here for the main period lord indications and looked to Venus as Mercury is samdharmi to it. As far as I understand, the sight of a main period lord is not relevant and only that of a subperiod lord is relevant. > Your reply would be highly appreciated. > IF YOU GIVE COMPLETE CHART IT WILL BE EASY TO ANSWER, IF ANY POINT LEFT OUT. ........KRUSHNA >>> The chart details as well as worksheet is enclosed. Once again, I have no specific queries relating to this chart. I am only trying to understand the principles you mentioned. Kind regards Sanjay Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted May 31, 2001 Report Share Posted May 31, 2001 Dear Sanjay, My answers are in serial no. 1. No you are not, as you called your self. You have done a very nice thing for the list. The work sheet you have made, is very help ful. It is realy a wonderful job you have done. 2. Mercury is in house A with more points for house 5 as B. We consider lord of the house and planets situated in any house with more then 4 points. 3. Yes there can be more then one samdharmi, We have to select the powerful out of those. Here Moon is malefic for this chart, as it is having very less points for all houses. Only for 8th house it is with 12 points. So Rahu sub will give malefic result. 4. 5. as per ans 2nd. Some time the planets situated in the house becomes more powerful FK. 6. Saturn would have been samdharmi to Mercury. 7. Yes. even Rahu being samdharmi to moon also do the same thing. 8 The main Dasha lord lord is Mercury, and it is F.K. for 5,9.and 12 houses. ( for 5th house it is being with more points in 8th house) Here I mean the result must have some connection with these house. The Moon being sub lord, so in it's sub period it will give malefic result for all the houses. Those results should have some connection with 5th 9th and 12th houses. for example 9th and 12th house denotes some travel. So person may loose some money, or theft in traveling. for 5th house loss in lottery, gambling. Some loss or bad fortune due to children etc. 9. Result for 11th house in moon sub, it is having only 9 points, In moon sub there will not be any achivement for 11th house, and the reasoning may be Children, father of the jatak, or 12th house matter. 4th house: Some problem for 4th house, loss of happiness in family, reason may be as above. 2nd similar result for 2nd house. 10. Yes we do not consider the sight of main period lord for our calculation purpose. but the result for 6th house, will not be related to 5, 9 and 12th house. because mercury the main period lord is aspecting 6th house. Any malefic result in Moon sub for 6th house, will not have any connection with the houses, for those mercury is FK. Sorry Sanjay, The delay was not deliberate. For this or that reason delay was causing. Yes you can blame me, that I answered others qu, and not yours. One thing the I can say in excuse that this message became more complecated, due to your and mine write up. I think, it is much easy to ask separate qu. instead of using the same. Any how I was having tension, for not answering your queries. Any how it is now 2:35 Am., and I have done it. Now tension free. thanks krushna --- Sanjay Jaggia <sanjaygg wrote: <HR> <html><body> <tt> Respected Krushnaji,<BR> <BR> Thank you for your prompt reply. The relevant chart details are as follows:<BR> <BR> Ascendant - Pisces. Sun in 11th house (5 points) , Moon in 5th (4 points),<BR> Mars in 9th (2 points), Mercury in 12th (5 points), Jupiter in 2nd (4<BR> points), Venus in 12th (4 points), Saturn in 10th (4 points), Rahu in lagna<BR> and Ketu in 7th.<BR> <BR> Navamsha lagna - Aquarius. Sun in Gemini, Moon in Libra, Mars in Aquarius,<BR> Mercury in Scorpio, Jupiter in Aries, Venus in Gemini, Saturn in Taurus,<BR> Rahu in Cancer, and Ketu in Capricorn.<BR> <BR> I am attaching the worksheet summary for you to see if you need to.<BR> <BR> There is no specific event that I am trying to prove. I am just trying to<BR> understand your system of picking up the relevant areas of life.<BR> <BR> Having given this background, I have some queries on your reply which I hope<BR> you will see below and answer. My original questions are preceded by ' & gt;',<BR> your reply is in capitals, and my new questions are marked by ' & gt; & gt; & gt;'.<BR> <BR> & lt;krushanain & gt;<BR> To: & lt; & gt;<BR> Tuesday, May 15, 2001 11:03 PM<BR> <BR> Dear Sanjay,<BR> & nbsp; & nbsp; & nbsp; After a long time you are in the group. Realy I missed you. No<BR> body ask me questions like you.<BR> <BR> & gt; & gt; & gt; Thank you. It is nice to be back. About the questions, I suppose I am<BR> just dumber than the other members :-)<BR> <BR> & gt; Finally, I have gone through the previous lessons and I have time<BR> for a few questions. I hope you can find the time to answer these.<BR> I am trying to check some events in a chart that I have. The chart<BR> is of a Pisces ascendant and Mercury and Venus are in the 12th house.<BR> The main period is that of Mercury. Mercury is the lord of 4th and<BR> 7th and is in 12th with 5 points.<BR> <BR> SO IT IS F.K. OF 9TH AND 12TH HOUSE. SO OVER ALL RESULTS GIVEN BY THE SUB<BR> PERIOD SHOULD HAVE SOME CONNECTION<BR> WITH 9TH 12TH AND 5TH HOUSE ( MERCURY BEING IN 12TH WITH MORE POINTS) AND IT<BR> IS NOT ASPECTING ANY OF THE UPCHAY HOUSES RELATED TO THESE HOUSES<BR> <BR> & gt; & gt; & gt; I thought planets with 5 points or more were relevant when they are in D<BR> or E. 12th house is D or E for the 3rd and 7th houses and Mercury should<BR> become eager to give results for these. Why should it give results related<BR> to 5th for which is only the lord of A?<BR> <BR> & gt; Venus is the lord of 3 and 8 and is in 12th with 4 points. O.K.<BR> & gt; The sub period is that of Moon. Moon has 4 points and is placed in<BR> the 5th house. Moon is natural samdharmi to Mars so this sub can represent<BR> that also. Moon is not samdharmi to any other planet in the chart.<BR> THIS SHOULD BE CHECKED WITH NAVAMANSHA CHART, YOU MUST HAVE CHECKED IT, IT<BR> MEANS NO PLANET IS IN THE NAVAMANSHA OF MOON)<BR> <BR> & gt; & gt; & gt; Actually only Rahu is in the navamsha of Moon. Do planets become<BR> samdharmi to their dispositor in Rashi and Navamsha both or only in<BR> Navamsha? Would this not lead to too many samdharmis so that any event might<BR> be explained?<BR> <BR> & gt; Since Moon has only 4 points, it can signify matters related to<BR> only the 8th and 12th houses where it is lord of D and E. CORRECT.<BR> <BR> & gt;Mars also has only one point so it can signify matters related to 4,<BR> 5, 9 and 12 where it is the lord of D or E. CORRECT. ( WHERE MARS IS<BR> SITUATED?)<BR> <BR> & gt; & gt; & gt; It is in the 9th house.<BR> <BR> & gt; The functional karaka for the 4th and 5th house is Saturn. For 8th<BR> it is Venus, for 9th and 12th it is Mercury. (ALSO FOR 5TH)<BR> <BR> & gt; & gt; & gt; I thought we were only to look for the functional karakas for the houses<BR> signified by the sub period lord or its samdharmi. I also thought the karak<BR> is the lord of the 8th house. Is a planet in the 8th house with 5 poitns or<BR> more also a karak for that house?<BR> <BR> & gt; Since Saturn is neither the main lord or its samdharmi (IT MEANS<BR> MERCURY IS NOT IN THE NAVAMANSHA OF SATURN, AND SATURN IS NOT SITUATED IN<BR> 9TH OR 3RD HOUSE) ,<BR> <BR> & gt; & gt; & gt; All these conditions are true as you would see from the chart. However,<BR> if Saturn was in one of the conditions nnnmentioned by you, what would be<BR> the significance?<BR> <BR> & gt;...the emphasis in this period must be restricted to & nbsp; 8th, 9th, and<BR> 12th houses.<BR> AS PER WORK SHEET HOW MANY POINTS MOON IS GETING FOR<BR> OTHER HOUSES. IT WILL GIVE GOOD RESULTS FOR HOUSES HAVING MORE POINTS AND<BR> MALEFIC RESULTS FOR HOUSES HAVING LESS POINTS. ALL THE RESULTS WILL BE<BR> CONNECTED TO 5,9,12TH HOUSES. RESULTS OF DIFFERENT HOUSES WILL BE<BR> EXPERIENCED AS PER THE 17 MONTHS PERIOD OF MOON IN MERCURY. THE EVENT DATES<BR> WILL BE RELATED TO OTHER PLANETS HAVING RELATIVE POINTS AND TRANSIT OF SUN<BR> IN THOSE SIGN OR CONSTELLATIONS.<BR> <BR> & gt; & gt; & gt; Moon has less than 12 points for all house except 8th where it has 12<BR> points. Does this mean that bad results will be felt for all these houses?<BR> Or will these be restricted to the 9th or 12th houses.<BR> <BR> & gt; & gt; & gt; I am still having soem problem in understanding how the events will be<BR> related to the 5th house instead of the 8th house.<BR> <BR> & gt; The events related to 8th, 9th and 12th houses will occur during<BR> this period and these will be with the support of the 3rd, 4th, 7th, and 8th<BR> houses (PERTICULARLY FOR THE RESULT OF 11TH HOUSE , 4TH HOUSE,AND 2ND HOUSE)<BR> ( DUE TO MOON'S SIGHT ON 11TH HOUSE) & gt; (lordship of the main period lord and<BR> its samdharmi).<BR> <BR> & gt; & gt; & gt; & nbsp; Could you please advise how would the results be related to the 11th<BR> 4th and 2nd houses?<BR> <BR> & gt; Please advise if this reasoning is correct. YOUR REASONING IS<BR> CORRECT,<BR> <BR> & gt; Venus is natural samdharmi to Saturn. However, we are using Venus<BR> as a samdharmi to the main period lord, Mercury. Can we use this period<BR> for events related to 4th and 5th houses also since Saturn is the karak<BR> for these and is samdharmi to Venus? VENUS CAN BE USED IF YOU ARE<BR> FINDING THE RESULT OF 2ND HOUSE , SIXTH HOUSE, 11TH HOUSE. WHERE VENUS BEING<BR> SAMDHARMI TO MERCURY WILL COME FORWARD. (DUE TO SIGHT OF MERCURY ON 6TH<BR> HOUSE)<BR> <BR> & gt; & gt; & gt; I am only looking here for the main period lord indications and looked<BR> to Venus as Mercury is samdharmi to it. As far as I understand, the sight of<BR> a main period lord is not relevant and only that of a subperiod lord is<BR> relevant.<BR> <BR> & gt; Your reply would be highly appreciated.<BR> & gt; IF YOU GIVE COMPLETE CHART IT WILL BE EASY TO ANSWER, IF ANY POINT LEFT<BR> OUT. ........KRUSHNA<BR> <BR> & gt; & gt; & gt; The chart details as well as worksheet is enclosed.<BR> <BR> Once again, I have no specific queries relating to this chart. I am only<BR> trying to understand the principles you mentioned.<BR> <BR> Kind regards<BR> Sanjay<BR> </tt> <br> <!-- |**|begin egp html banner|**| --> <table border=0 cellspacing=0 cellpadding=2> <tr bgcolor=#FFFFCC> <td align=center><font size= " -1 " color=#003399><b> Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 1, 2001 Report Share Posted June 1, 2001 Respected Krushnaji, Thank you for the answers. I am sorry that I caused the tension. I am now studying your answers as well as the several exchanges that you had with Peter which seem to be very illuminating. I am sure that I will come back with more questions. I will take your advice and try to ask separate questions. The problem is that everything seems to be linked with everything else initially until you start clarifying the issues. Thanks again. Kind regards Sanjay - " krushna jugalkalani " <krushanain Friday, June 01, 2001 4:16 AM Re: Re: Picking up the relevant items in a chart for a sub period Dear Sanjay, My answers are in serial no. 1. No you are not, as you called your self. You have done a very nice thing for the list. The work sheet you have made, is very help ful. It is realy a wonderful job you have done. 2. Mercury is in house A with more points for house 5 as B. We consider lord of the house and planets situated in any house with more then 4 points. 3. Yes there can be more then one samdharmi, We have to select the powerful out of those. Here Moon is malefic for this chart, as it is having very less points for all houses. Only for 8th house it is with 12 points. So Rahu sub will give malefic result. 4. 5. as per ans 2nd. Some time the planets situated in the house becomes more powerful FK. 6. Saturn would have been samdharmi to Mercury. 7. Yes. even Rahu being samdharmi to moon also do the same thing. 8 The main Dasha lord lord is Mercury, and it is F.K. for 5,9.and 12 houses. ( for 5th house it is being with more points in 8th house) Here I mean the result must have some connection with these house. The Moon being sub lord, so in it's sub period it will give malefic result for all the houses. Those results should have some connection with 5th 9th and 12th houses. for example 9th and 12th house denotes some travel. So person may loose some money, or theft in traveling. for 5th house loss in lottery, gambling. Some loss or bad fortune due to children etc. 9. Result for 11th house in moon sub, it is having only 9 points, In moon sub there will not be any achivement for 11th house, and the reasoning may be Children, father of the jatak, or 12th house matter. 4th house: Some problem for 4th house, loss of happiness in family, reason may be as above. 2nd similar result for 2nd house. 10. Yes we do not consider the sight of main period lord for our calculation purpose. but the result for 6th house, will not be related to 5, 9 and 12th house. because mercury the main period lord is aspecting 6th house. Any malefic result in Moon sub for 6th house, will not have any connection with the houses, for those mercury is FK. Sorry Sanjay, The delay was not deliberate. For this or that reason delay was causing. Yes you can blame me, that I answered others qu, and not yours. One thing the I can say in excuse that this message became more complecated, due to your and mine write up. I think, it is much easy to ask separate qu. instead of using the same. Any how I was having tension, for not answering your queries. Any how it is now 2:35 Am., and I have done it. Now tension free. thanks krushna --- Sanjay Jaggia <sanjaygg wrote: <HR> <html><body> <tt> Respected Krushnaji,<BR> <BR> Thank you for your prompt reply. The relevant chart details are as follows:<BR> <BR> Ascendant - Pisces. Sun in 11th house (5 points) , Moon in 5th (4 points),<BR> Mars in 9th (2 points), Mercury in 12th (5 points), Jupiter in 2nd (4<BR> points), Venus in 12th (4 points), Saturn in 10th (4 points), Rahu in lagna<BR> and Ketu in 7th.<BR> <BR> Navamsha lagna - Aquarius. Sun in Gemini, Moon in Libra, Mars in Aquarius,<BR> Mercury in Scorpio, Jupiter in Aries, Venus in Gemini, Saturn in Taurus,<BR> Rahu in Cancer, and Ketu in Capricorn.<BR> <BR> I am attaching the worksheet summary for you to see if you need to.<BR> <BR> There is no specific event that I am trying to prove. I am just trying to<BR> understand your system of picking up the relevant areas of life.<BR> <BR> Having given this background, I have some queries on your reply which I hope<BR> you will see below and answer. My original questions are preceded by ' & gt;',<BR> your reply is in capitals, and my new questions are marked by ' & gt; & gt; & gt;'.<BR> <BR> & lt;krushanain & gt;<BR> To: & lt; & gt;<BR> Tuesday, May 15, 2001 11:03 PM<BR> <BR> Dear Sanjay,<BR> & nbsp; & nbsp; & nbsp; After a long time you are in the group. Realy I missed you. No<BR> body ask me questions like you.<BR> <BR> & gt; & gt; & gt; Thank you. It is nice to be back. About the questions, I suppose I am<BR> just dumber than the other members :-)<BR> <BR> & gt; Finally, I have gone through the previous lessons and I have time<BR> for a few questions. I hope you can find the time to answer these.<BR> I am trying to check some events in a chart that I have. The chart<BR> is of a Pisces ascendant and Mercury and Venus are in the 12th house.<BR> The main period is that of Mercury. Mercury is the lord of 4th and<BR> 7th and is in 12th with 5 points.<BR> <BR> SO IT IS F.K. OF 9TH AND 12TH HOUSE. SO OVER ALL RESULTS GIVEN BY THE SUB<BR> PERIOD SHOULD HAVE SOME CONNECTION<BR> WITH 9TH 12TH AND 5TH HOUSE ( MERCURY BEING IN 12TH WITH MORE POINTS) AND IT<BR> IS NOT ASPECTING ANY OF THE UPCHAY HOUSES RELATED TO THESE HOUSES<BR> <BR> & gt; & gt; & gt; I thought planets with 5 points or more were relevant when they are in D<BR> or E. 12th house is D or E for the 3rd and 7th houses and Mercury should<BR> become eager to give results for these. Why should it give results related<BR> to 5th for which is only the lord of A?<BR> <BR> & gt; Venus is the lord of 3 and 8 and is in 12th with 4 points. O.K.<BR> & gt; The sub period is that of Moon. Moon has 4 points and is placed in<BR> the 5th house. Moon is natural samdharmi to Mars so this sub can represent<BR> that also. Moon is not samdharmi to any other planet in the chart.<BR> THIS SHOULD BE CHECKED WITH NAVAMANSHA CHART, YOU MUST HAVE CHECKED IT, IT<BR> MEANS NO PLANET IS IN THE NAVAMANSHA OF MOON)<BR> <BR> & gt; & gt; & gt; Actually only Rahu is in the navamsha of Moon. Do planets become<BR> samdharmi to their dispositor in Rashi and Navamsha both or only in<BR> Navamsha? Would this not lead to too many samdharmis so that any event might<BR> be explained?<BR> <BR> & gt; Since Moon has only 4 points, it can signify matters related to<BR> only the 8th and 12th houses where it is lord of D and E. CORRECT.<BR> <BR> & gt;Mars also has only one point so it can signify matters related to 4,<BR> 5, 9 and 12 where it is the lord of D or E. CORRECT. ( WHERE MARS IS<BR> SITUATED?)<BR> <BR> & gt; & gt; & gt; It is in the 9th house.<BR> <BR> & gt; The functional karaka for the 4th and 5th house is Saturn. For 8th<BR> it is Venus, for 9th and 12th it is Mercury. (ALSO FOR 5TH)<BR> <BR> & gt; & gt; & gt; I thought we were only to look for the functional karakas for the houses<BR> signified by the sub period lord or its samdharmi. I also thought the karak<BR> is the lord of the 8th house. Is a planet in the 8th house with 5 poitns or<BR> more also a karak for that house?<BR> <BR> & gt; Since Saturn is neither the main lord or its samdharmi (IT MEANS<BR> MERCURY IS NOT IN THE NAVAMANSHA OF SATURN, AND SATURN IS NOT SITUATED IN<BR> 9TH OR 3RD HOUSE) ,<BR> <BR> & gt; & gt; & gt; All these conditions are true as you would see from the chart. However,<BR> if Saturn was in one of the conditions nnnmentioned by you, what would be<BR> the significance?<BR> <BR> & gt;...the emphasis in this period must be restricted to & nbsp; 8th, 9th, and<BR> 12th houses.<BR> AS PER WORK SHEET HOW MANY POINTS MOON IS GETING FOR<BR> OTHER HOUSES. IT WILL GIVE GOOD RESULTS FOR HOUSES HAVING MORE POINTS AND<BR> MALEFIC RESULTS FOR HOUSES HAVING LESS POINTS. ALL THE RESULTS WILL BE<BR> CONNECTED TO 5,9,12TH HOUSES. RESULTS OF DIFFERENT HOUSES WILL BE<BR> EXPERIENCED AS PER THE 17 MONTHS PERIOD OF MOON IN MERCURY. THE EVENT DATES<BR> WILL BE RELATED TO OTHER PLANETS HAVING RELATIVE POINTS AND TRANSIT OF SUN<BR> IN THOSE SIGN OR CONSTELLATIONS.<BR> <BR> & gt; & gt; & gt; Moon has less than 12 points for all house except 8th where it has 12<BR> points. Does this mean that bad results will be felt for all these houses?<BR> Or will these be restricted to the 9th or 12th houses.<BR> <BR> & gt; & gt; & gt; I am still having soem problem in understanding how the events will be<BR> related to the 5th house instead of the 8th house.<BR> <BR> & gt; The events related to 8th, 9th and 12th houses will occur during<BR> this period and these will be with the support of the 3rd, 4th, 7th, and 8th<BR> houses (PERTICULARLY FOR THE RESULT OF 11TH HOUSE , 4TH HOUSE,AND 2ND HOUSE)<BR> ( DUE TO MOON'S SIGHT ON 11TH HOUSE) & gt; (lordship of the main period lord and<BR> its samdharmi).<BR> <BR> & gt; & gt; & gt; & nbsp; Could you please advise how would the results be related to the 11th<BR> 4th and 2nd houses?<BR> <BR> & gt; Please advise if this reasoning is correct. YOUR REASONING IS<BR> CORRECT,<BR> <BR> & gt; Venus is natural samdharmi to Saturn. However, we are using Venus<BR> as a samdharmi to the main period lord, Mercury. Can we use this period<BR> for events related to 4th and 5th houses also since Saturn is the karak<BR> for these and is samdharmi to Venus? VENUS CAN BE USED IF YOU ARE<BR> FINDING THE RESULT OF 2ND HOUSE , SIXTH HOUSE, 11TH HOUSE. WHERE VENUS BEING<BR> SAMDHARMI TO MERCURY WILL COME FORWARD. (DUE TO SIGHT OF MERCURY ON 6TH<BR> HOUSE)<BR> <BR> & gt; & gt; & gt; I am only looking here for the main period lord indications and looked<BR> to Venus as Mercury is samdharmi to it. As far as I understand, the sight of<BR> a main period lord is not relevant and only that of a subperiod lord is<BR> relevant.<BR> <BR> & gt; Your reply would be highly appreciated.<BR> & gt; IF YOU GIVE COMPLETE CHART IT WILL BE EASY TO ANSWER, IF ANY POINT LEFT<BR> OUT. ........KRUSHNA<BR> <BR> & gt; & gt; & gt; The chart details as well as worksheet is enclosed.<BR> <BR> Once again, I have no specific queries relating to this chart. I am only<BR> trying to understand the principles you mentioned.<BR> <BR> Kind regards<BR> Sanjay<BR> </tt> <br> <!-- |**|begin egp html banner|**| --> <table border=0 cellspacing=0 cellpadding=2> <tr bgcolor=#FFFFCC> <td align=center><font size= " -1 " color=#003399><b> Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 1, 2001 Report Share Posted June 1, 2001 Dear Sanjay, You are welcome with more questions. Please ask one or two questions in a mail. More questions in one mail, results in keeping it pending. I came to this fact, after thinking over the matter. Big mail or more questions remains pending, only because answering small mail or one question is easy. So after answering all small mail, it is too late, so big mails are kept pending, with a thought I will answer it tomarrow. and tommarrow never comes. krushna , " Sanjay Jaggia " <sanjaygg@l...> wrote: > Respected Krushnaji, > > Thank you for the answers. I am sorry that I caused the tension. > > I am now studying your answers as well as the several exchanges that you had > with Peter which seem to be very illuminating. I am sure that I will come > back with more questions. > > I will take your advice and try to ask separate questions. The problem is > that everything seems to be linked with everything else initially until you > start clarifying the issues. > > Thanks again. > > Kind regards > Sanjay > - > " krushna jugalkalani " <krushanain> > > Friday, June 01, 2001 4:16 AM > Re: Re: Picking up the relevant items in > a chart for a sub period > > > Dear Sanjay, > My answers are in serial no. > 1. No you are not, as you called your self. You have > done a very nice thing for the list. The work sheet > you have made, is very help ful. It is realy a > wonderful job you have done. > 2. Mercury is in house A with more points for house 5 > as B. We consider lord of the house and planets > situated in any house with more then 4 points. > 3. Yes there can be more then one samdharmi, We have > to select the powerful out of those. Here Moon is > malefic for this chart, as it is having very less > points for all houses. Only for 8th house it is with > 12 points. So Rahu sub will give malefic result. > 4. > 5. as per ans 2nd. Some time the planets situated in > the house becomes more powerful FK. > 6. Saturn would have been samdharmi to Mercury. > 7. Yes. even Rahu being samdharmi to moon also do the > same thing. > 8 The main Dasha lord lord is Mercury, and it is > F.K. for 5,9.and 12 houses. ( for 5th house it is > being with more points in 8th house) Here I mean the > result must have some connection with these house. The > Moon being sub lord, so in it's sub period it will > give malefic result for all the houses. Those results > should have some connection with 5th 9th and 12th > houses. for example 9th and 12th house denotes some > travel. So person may loose some money, or theft in > traveling. for 5th house loss in lottery, gambling. > Some loss or bad fortune due to children etc. > 9. Result for 11th house in moon sub, it is having > only 9 points, In moon sub there will not be any > achivement for 11th house, and the reasoning may be > Children, father of the jatak, or 12th house matter. > 4th house: Some problem for 4th house, loss of > happiness in family, reason may be as above. > 2nd similar result for 2nd house. > 10. Yes we do not consider the sight of main period > lord for our calculation purpose. but the result for > 6th house, will not be related to 5, 9 and 12th house. > because mercury the main period lord is aspecting 6th > house. Any malefic result in Moon sub for 6th house, > will not have any connection with the houses, for > those mercury is FK. > Sorry Sanjay, The delay was not deliberate. For > this or that reason delay was causing. Yes you can > blame me, that I answered others qu, and not yours. > One thing the I can say in excuse that this message > became more complecated, due to your and mine write > up. > I think, it is much easy to ask separate qu. > instead of using the same. > Any how I was having tension, for not answering > your queries. Any how it is now 2:35 Am., and I have > done it. Now tension free. > thanks > krushna > > --- Sanjay Jaggia <sanjaygg@l...> wrote: > <HR> > <html><body> > <tt> > Respected Krushnaji,<BR> > <BR> > Thank you for your prompt reply. The relevant chart > details are as follows:<BR> > <BR> > Ascendant - Pisces. Sun in 11th house (5 points) , > Moon in 5th (4 points),<BR> > Mars in 9th (2 points), Mercury in 12th (5 points), > Jupiter in 2nd (4<BR> > points), Venus in 12th (4 points), Saturn in 10th (4 > points), Rahu in lagna<BR> > and Ketu in 7th.<BR> > <BR> > Navamsha lagna - Aquarius. Sun in Gemini, Moon in > Libra, Mars in Aquarius,<BR> > Mercury in Scorpio, Jupiter in Aries, Venus in Gemini, > Saturn in Taurus,<BR> > Rahu in Cancer, and Ketu in Capricorn.<BR> > <BR> > I am attaching the worksheet summary for you to see if > you need to.<BR> > <BR> > There is no specific event that I am trying to prove. > I am just trying to<BR> > understand your system of picking up the relevant > areas of life.<BR> > <BR> > Having given this background, I have some queries on > your reply which I hope<BR> > you will see below and answer. My original questions > are preceded by ' & gt;',<BR> > your reply is in capitals, and my new questions are > marked by ' & gt; & gt; & gt;'.<BR> > <BR> > krushanain@h...<BR> > To: > <BR> > Tuesday, May 15, 2001 11:03 PM<BR> > <BR> > Dear Sanjay,<BR> > & nbsp; & nbsp; & nbsp; After a long time you are in the > group. Realy I missed you. No<BR> > body ask me questions like you.<BR> > <BR> > & gt; & gt; & gt; Thank you. It is nice to be back. About > the questions, I suppose I am<BR> > just dumber than the other members :-)<BR> > <BR> > & gt; Finally, I have gone through the previous lessons > and I have time<BR> > for a few questions. I hope you can find the time to > answer these.<BR> > I am trying to check some events in a chart that I > have. The chart<BR> > is of a Pisces ascendant and Mercury and Venus are in > the 12th house.<BR> > The main period is that of Mercury. Mercury is the > lord of 4th and<BR> > 7th and is in 12th with 5 points.<BR> > <BR> > SO IT IS F.K. OF 9TH AND 12TH HOUSE. SO OVER ALL > RESULTS GIVEN BY THE SUB<BR> > PERIOD SHOULD HAVE SOME CONNECTION<BR> > WITH 9TH 12TH AND 5TH HOUSE ( MERCURY BEING IN 12TH > WITH MORE POINTS) AND IT<BR> > IS NOT ASPECTING ANY OF THE UPCHAY HOUSES RELATED TO > THESE HOUSES<BR> > <BR> > & gt; & gt; & gt; I thought planets with 5 points or more > were relevant when they are in D<BR> > or E. 12th house is D or E for the 3rd and 7th houses > and Mercury should<BR> > become eager to give results for these. Why should it > give results related<BR> > to 5th for which is only the lord of A?<BR> > <BR> > & gt; Venus is the lord of 3 and 8 and is in 12th with > 4 points. O.K.<BR> > & gt; The sub period is that of Moon. Moon has 4 points > and is placed in<BR> > the 5th house. Moon is natural samdharmi to Mars so > this sub can represent<BR> > that also. Moon is not samdharmi to any other planet > in the chart.<BR> > THIS SHOULD BE CHECKED WITH NAVAMANSHA CHART, YOU MUST > HAVE CHECKED IT, IT<BR> > MEANS NO PLANET IS IN THE NAVAMANSHA OF MOON)<BR> > <BR> > & gt; & gt; & gt; Actually only Rahu is in the navamsha of > Moon. Do planets become<BR> > samdharmi to their dispositor in Rashi and Navamsha > both or only in<BR> > Navamsha? Would this not lead to too many samdharmis > so that any event might<BR> > be explained?<BR> > <BR> > & gt; Since Moon has only 4 points, it can signify > matters related to<BR> > only the 8th and 12th houses where it is lord of D and > E. CORRECT.<BR> > <BR> > & gt;Mars also has only one point so it can signify > matters related to 4,<BR> > 5, 9 and 12 where it is the lord of D or E. CORRECT. ( > WHERE MARS IS<BR> > SITUATED?)<BR> > <BR> > & gt; & gt; & gt; It is in the 9th house.<BR> > <BR> > & gt; The functional karaka for the 4th and 5th house > is Saturn. For 8th<BR> > it is Venus, for 9th and 12th it is Mercury. (ALSO FOR > 5TH)<BR> > <BR> > & gt; & gt; & gt; I thought we were only to look for the > functional karakas for the houses<BR> > signified by the sub period lord or its samdharmi. I > also thought the karak<BR> > is the lord of the 8th house. Is a planet in the 8th > house with 5 poitns or<BR> > more also a karak for that house?<BR> > <BR> > & gt; Since Saturn is neither the main lord or its > samdharmi (IT MEANS<BR> > MERCURY IS NOT IN THE NAVAMANSHA OF SATURN, AND SATURN > IS NOT SITUATED IN<BR> > 9TH OR 3RD HOUSE) ,<BR> > <BR> > & gt; & gt; & gt; All these conditions are true as you > would see from the chart. However,<BR> > if Saturn was in one of the conditions nnnmentioned by > you, what would be<BR> > the significance?<BR> > <BR> > & gt;...the emphasis in this period must be restricted > to & nbsp; 8th, 9th, and<BR> > 12th houses.<BR> > AS PER WORK SHEET HOW MANY POINTS MOON IS GETING > FOR<BR> > OTHER HOUSES. IT WILL GIVE GOOD RESULTS FOR HOUSES > HAVING MORE POINTS AND<BR> > MALEFIC RESULTS FOR HOUSES HAVING LESS POINTS. ALL THE > RESULTS WILL BE<BR> > CONNECTED TO 5,9,12TH HOUSES. RESULTS OF DIFFERENT > HOUSES WILL BE<BR> > EXPERIENCED AS PER THE 17 MONTHS PERIOD OF MOON IN > MERCURY. THE EVENT DATES<BR> > WILL BE RELATED TO OTHER PLANETS HAVING RELATIVE > POINTS AND TRANSIT OF SUN<BR> > IN THOSE SIGN OR CONSTELLATIONS.<BR> > <BR> > & gt; & gt; & gt; Moon has less than 12 points for all > house except 8th where it has 12<BR> > points. Does this mean that bad results will be felt > for all these houses?<BR> > Or will these be restricted to the 9th or 12th > houses.<BR> > <BR> > & gt; & gt; & gt; I am still having soem problem in > understanding how the events will be<BR> > related to the 5th house instead of the 8th house.<BR> > <BR> > & gt; The events related to 8th, 9th and 12th houses > will occur during<BR> > this period and these will be with the support of the > 3rd, 4th, 7th, and 8th<BR> > houses (PERTICULARLY FOR THE RESULT OF 11TH HOUSE , > 4TH HOUSE,AND 2ND HOUSE)<BR> > ( DUE TO MOON'S SIGHT ON 11TH HOUSE) & gt; (lordship of > the main period lord and<BR> > its samdharmi).<BR> > <BR> > & gt; & gt; & gt; & nbsp; Could you please advise how would > the results be related to the 11th<BR> > 4th and 2nd houses?<BR> > <BR> > & gt; Please advise if this reasoning is correct. YOUR > REASONING IS<BR> > CORRECT,<BR> > <BR> > & gt; Venus is natural samdharmi to Saturn. However, we > are using Venus<BR> > as a samdharmi to the main period lord, Mercury. Can > we use this period<BR> > for events related to 4th and 5th houses also since > Saturn is the karak<BR> > for these and is samdharmi to Venus? VENUS CAN BE USED > IF YOU ARE<BR> > FINDING THE RESULT OF 2ND HOUSE , SIXTH HOUSE, 11TH > HOUSE. WHERE VENUS BEING<BR> > SAMDHARMI TO MERCURY WILL COME FORWARD. (DUE TO SIGHT > OF MERCURY ON 6TH<BR> > HOUSE)<BR> > <BR> > & gt; & gt; & gt; I am only looking here for the main > period lord indications and looked<BR> > to Venus as Mercury is samdharmi to it. As far as I > understand, the sight of<BR> > a main period lord is not relevant and only that of a > subperiod lord is<BR> > relevant.<BR> > <BR> > & gt; Your reply would be highly appreciated.<BR> > & gt; IF YOU GIVE COMPLETE CHART IT WILL BE EASY TO > ANSWER, IF ANY POINT LEFT<BR> > OUT. ........KRUSHNA<BR> > <BR> > & gt; & gt; & gt; The chart details as well as worksheet is > enclosed.<BR> > <BR> > Once again, I have no specific queries relating to > this chart. I am only<BR> > trying to understand the principles you mentioned.<BR> > <BR> > Kind regards<BR> > Sanjay<BR> > </tt> > > <br> > > <!-- |**|begin egp html banner|**| --> > > <table border=0 cellspacing=0 cellpadding=2> > <tr bgcolor=#FFFFCC> > <td align=center><font size= " -1 " > color=#003399><b> Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 2, 2001 Report Share Posted June 2, 2001 Respected Krushnaji, I have studied your answer. While everything is not crystal clear, it seems that there can be some rules that we can follow from your explanations. These are: 1. A planet is functional karak (FK) for the house for it is the lord of the 8th from it. It is also the FK for which it is in 8th from B with more than 4 points. 2. If planet A is in the rashi or navamsha of B - then A is samdharmi to B. That is, it can give the result for B. But B is not samdharmi to it. B would not give the result for A unless it was samdharmi sue to some other reason. - A and B are samdharmi to each other Please advise which of the above is correct. 3. At a particular time, there may be results related to any house B. However, these results will not be related to houses for which the main lord is FK if the main lord has sight on B. I will not ask any more questions as this takes too much of your time. But I would request you to answer these. As I have many many more questions, I would highly appreciate if you could illustrate these concepts by showing more examples. At your own convenience, of course. Thanks and kind regards Sanjay - <krushanain Friday, June 01, 2001 6:30 PM Re: Picking up the relevant items in a chart for a sub period Dear Sanjay, You are welcome with more questions. Please ask one or two questions in a mail. More questions in one mail, results in keeping it pending. I came to this fact, after thinking over the matter. Big mail or more questions remains pending, only because answering small mail or one question is easy. So after answering all small mail, it is too late, so big mails are kept pending, with a thought I will answer it tomarrow. and tommarrow never comes. krushna , " Sanjay Jaggia " <sanjaygg@l...> wrote: > Respected Krushnaji, > > Thank you for the answers. I am sorry that I caused the tension. > > I am now studying your answers as well as the several exchanges that you had > with Peter which seem to be very illuminating. I am sure that I will come > back with more questions. > > I will take your advice and try to ask separate questions. The problem is > that everything seems to be linked with everything else initially until you > start clarifying the issues. > > Thanks again. > > Kind regards > Sanjay > - > " krushna jugalkalani " <krushanain> > > Friday, June 01, 2001 4:16 AM > Re: Re: Picking up the relevant items in > a chart for a sub period > > > Dear Sanjay, > My answers are in serial no. > 1. No you are not, as you called your self. You have > done a very nice thing for the list. The work sheet > you have made, is very help ful. It is realy a > wonderful job you have done. > 2. Mercury is in house A with more points for house 5 > as B. We consider lord of the house and planets > situated in any house with more then 4 points. > 3. Yes there can be more then one samdharmi, We have > to select the powerful out of those. Here Moon is > malefic for this chart, as it is having very less > points for all houses. Only for 8th house it is with > 12 points. So Rahu sub will give malefic result. > 4. > 5. as per ans 2nd. Some time the planets situated in > the house becomes more powerful FK. > 6. Saturn would have been samdharmi to Mercury. > 7. Yes. even Rahu being samdharmi to moon also do the > same thing. > 8 The main Dasha lord lord is Mercury, and it is > F.K. for 5,9.and 12 houses. ( for 5th house it is > being with more points in 8th house) Here I mean the > result must have some connection with these house. The > Moon being sub lord, so in it's sub period it will > give malefic result for all the houses. Those results > should have some connection with 5th 9th and 12th > houses. for example 9th and 12th house denotes some > travel. So person may loose some money, or theft in > traveling. for 5th house loss in lottery, gambling. > Some loss or bad fortune due to children etc. > 9. Result for 11th house in moon sub, it is having > only 9 points, In moon sub there will not be any > achivement for 11th house, and the reasoning may be > Children, father of the jatak, or 12th house matter. > 4th house: Some problem for 4th house, loss of > happiness in family, reason may be as above. > 2nd similar result for 2nd house. > 10. Yes we do not consider the sight of main period > lord for our calculation purpose. but the result for > 6th house, will not be related to 5, 9 and 12th house. > because mercury the main period lord is aspecting 6th > house. Any malefic result in Moon sub for 6th house, > will not have any connection with the houses, for > those mercury is FK. > Sorry Sanjay, The delay was not deliberate. For > this or that reason delay was causing. Yes you can > blame me, that I answered others qu, and not yours. > One thing the I can say in excuse that this message > became more complecated, due to your and mine write > up. > I think, it is much easy to ask separate qu. > instead of using the same. > Any how I was having tension, for not answering > your queries. Any how it is now 2:35 Am., and I have > done it. Now tension free. > thanks > krushna > > --- Sanjay Jaggia <sanjaygg@l...> wrote: > <HR> > <html><body> > <tt> > Respected Krushnaji,<BR> > <BR> > Thank you for your prompt reply. The relevant chart > details are as follows:<BR> > <BR> > Ascendant - Pisces. Sun in 11th house (5 points) , > Moon in 5th (4 points),<BR> > Mars in 9th (2 points), Mercury in 12th (5 points), > Jupiter in 2nd (4<BR> > points), Venus in 12th (4 points), Saturn in 10th (4 > points), Rahu in lagna<BR> > and Ketu in 7th.<BR> > <BR> > Navamsha lagna - Aquarius. Sun in Gemini, Moon in > Libra, Mars in Aquarius,<BR> > Mercury in Scorpio, Jupiter in Aries, Venus in Gemini, > Saturn in Taurus,<BR> > Rahu in Cancer, and Ketu in Capricorn.<BR> > <BR> > I am attaching the worksheet summary for you to see if > you need to.<BR> > <BR> > There is no specific event that I am trying to prove. > I am just trying to<BR> > understand your system of picking up the relevant > areas of life.<BR> > <BR> > Having given this background, I have some queries on > your reply which I hope<BR> > you will see below and answer. My original questions > are preceded by ' & gt;',<BR> > your reply is in capitals, and my new questions are > marked by ' & gt; & gt; & gt;'.<BR> > <BR> > krushanain@h...<BR> > To: > <BR> > Tuesday, May 15, 2001 11:03 PM<BR> > <BR> > Dear Sanjay,<BR> > & nbsp; & nbsp; & nbsp; After a long time you are in the > group. Realy I missed you. No<BR> > body ask me questions like you.<BR> > <BR> > & gt; & gt; & gt; Thank you. It is nice to be back. About > the questions, I suppose I am<BR> > just dumber than the other members :-)<BR> > <BR> > & gt; Finally, I have gone through the previous lessons > and I have time<BR> > for a few questions. I hope you can find the time to > answer these.<BR> > I am trying to check some events in a chart that I > have. The chart<BR> > is of a Pisces ascendant and Mercury and Venus are in > the 12th house.<BR> > The main period is that of Mercury. Mercury is the > lord of 4th and<BR> > 7th and is in 12th with 5 points.<BR> > <BR> > SO IT IS F.K. OF 9TH AND 12TH HOUSE. SO OVER ALL > RESULTS GIVEN BY THE SUB<BR> > PERIOD SHOULD HAVE SOME CONNECTION<BR> > WITH 9TH 12TH AND 5TH HOUSE ( MERCURY BEING IN 12TH > WITH MORE POINTS) AND IT<BR> > IS NOT ASPECTING ANY OF THE UPCHAY HOUSES RELATED TO > THESE HOUSES<BR> > <BR> > & gt; & gt; & gt; I thought planets with 5 points or more > were relevant when they are in D<BR> > or E. 12th house is D or E for the 3rd and 7th houses > and Mercury should<BR> > become eager to give results for these. Why should it > give results related<BR> > to 5th for which is only the lord of A?<BR> > <BR> > & gt; Venus is the lord of 3 and 8 and is in 12th with > 4 points. O.K.<BR> > & gt; The sub period is that of Moon. Moon has 4 points > and is placed in<BR> > the 5th house. Moon is natural samdharmi to Mars so > this sub can represent<BR> > that also. Moon is not samdharmi to any other planet > in the chart.<BR> > THIS SHOULD BE CHECKED WITH NAVAMANSHA CHART, YOU MUST > HAVE CHECKED IT, IT<BR> > MEANS NO PLANET IS IN THE NAVAMANSHA OF MOON)<BR> > <BR> > & gt; & gt; & gt; Actually only Rahu is in the navamsha of > Moon. Do planets become<BR> > samdharmi to their dispositor in Rashi and Navamsha > both or only in<BR> > Navamsha? Would this not lead to too many samdharmis > so that any event might<BR> > be explained?<BR> > <BR> > & gt; Since Moon has only 4 points, it can signify > matters related to<BR> > only the 8th and 12th houses where it is lord of D and > E. CORRECT.<BR> > <BR> > & gt;Mars also has only one point so it can signify > matters related to 4,<BR> > 5, 9 and 12 where it is the lord of D or E. CORRECT. ( > WHERE MARS IS<BR> > SITUATED?)<BR> > <BR> > & gt; & gt; & gt; It is in the 9th house.<BR> > <BR> > & gt; The functional karaka for the 4th and 5th house > is Saturn. For 8th<BR> > it is Venus, for 9th and 12th it is Mercury. (ALSO FOR > 5TH)<BR> > <BR> > & gt; & gt; & gt; I thought we were only to look for the > functional karakas for the houses<BR> > signified by the sub period lord or its samdharmi. I > also thought the karak<BR> > is the lord of the 8th house. Is a planet in the 8th > house with 5 poitns or<BR> > more also a karak for that house?<BR> > <BR> > & gt; Since Saturn is neither the main lord or its > samdharmi (IT MEANS<BR> > MERCURY IS NOT IN THE NAVAMANSHA OF SATURN, AND SATURN > IS NOT SITUATED IN<BR> > 9TH OR 3RD HOUSE) ,<BR> > <BR> > & gt; & gt; & gt; All these conditions are true as you > would see from the chart. However,<BR> > if Saturn was in one of the conditions nnnmentioned by > you, what would be<BR> > the significance?<BR> > <BR> > & gt;...the emphasis in this period must be restricted > to & nbsp; 8th, 9th, and<BR> > 12th houses.<BR> > AS PER WORK SHEET HOW MANY POINTS MOON IS GETING > FOR<BR> > OTHER HOUSES. IT WILL GIVE GOOD RESULTS FOR HOUSES > HAVING MORE POINTS AND<BR> > MALEFIC RESULTS FOR HOUSES HAVING LESS POINTS. ALL THE > RESULTS WILL BE<BR> > CONNECTED TO 5,9,12TH HOUSES. RESULTS OF DIFFERENT > HOUSES WILL BE<BR> > EXPERIENCED AS PER THE 17 MONTHS PERIOD OF MOON IN > MERCURY. THE EVENT DATES<BR> > WILL BE RELATED TO OTHER PLANETS HAVING RELATIVE > POINTS AND TRANSIT OF SUN<BR> > IN THOSE SIGN OR CONSTELLATIONS.<BR> > <BR> > & gt; & gt; & gt; Moon has less than 12 points for all > house except 8th where it has 12<BR> > points. Does this mean that bad results will be felt > for all these houses?<BR> > Or will these be restricted to the 9th or 12th > houses.<BR> > <BR> > & gt; & gt; & gt; I am still having soem problem in > understanding how the events will be<BR> > related to the 5th house instead of the 8th house.<BR> > <BR> > & gt; The events related to 8th, 9th and 12th houses > will occur during<BR> > this period and these will be with the support of the > 3rd, 4th, 7th, and 8th<BR> > houses (PERTICULARLY FOR THE RESULT OF 11TH HOUSE , > 4TH HOUSE,AND 2ND HOUSE)<BR> > ( DUE TO MOON'S SIGHT ON 11TH HOUSE) & gt; (lordship of > the main period lord and<BR> > its samdharmi).<BR> > <BR> > & gt; & gt; & gt; & nbsp; Could you please advise how would > the results be related to the 11th<BR> > 4th and 2nd houses?<BR> > <BR> > & gt; Please advise if this reasoning is correct. YOUR > REASONING IS<BR> > CORRECT,<BR> > <BR> > & gt; Venus is natural samdharmi to Saturn. However, we > are using Venus<BR> > as a samdharmi to the main period lord, Mercury. Can > we use this period<BR> > for events related to 4th and 5th houses also since > Saturn is the karak<BR> > for these and is samdharmi to Venus? VENUS CAN BE USED > IF YOU ARE<BR> > FINDING THE RESULT OF 2ND HOUSE , SIXTH HOUSE, 11TH > HOUSE. WHERE VENUS BEING<BR> > SAMDHARMI TO MERCURY WILL COME FORWARD. (DUE TO SIGHT > OF MERCURY ON 6TH<BR> > HOUSE)<BR> > <BR> > & gt; & gt; & gt; I am only looking here for the main > period lord indications and looked<BR> > to Venus as Mercury is samdharmi to it. As far as I > understand, the sight of<BR> > a main period lord is not relevant and only that of a > subperiod lord is<BR> > relevant.<BR> > <BR> > & gt; Your reply would be highly appreciated.<BR> > & gt; IF YOU GIVE COMPLETE CHART IT WILL BE EASY TO > ANSWER, IF ANY POINT LEFT<BR> > OUT. ........KRUSHNA<BR> > <BR> > & gt; & gt; & gt; The chart details as well as worksheet is > enclosed.<BR> > <BR> > Once again, I have no specific queries relating to > this chart. I am only<BR> > trying to understand the principles you mentioned.<BR> > <BR> > Kind regards<BR> > Sanjay<BR> > </tt> > > <br> > > <!-- |**|begin egp html banner|**| --> > > <table border=0 cellspacing=0 cellpadding=2> > <tr bgcolor=#FFFFCC> > <td align=center><font size= " -1 " > color=#003399><b> Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 7, 2001 Report Share Posted June 7, 2001 Dear Sanjay, My comments in block letters. krushna > Respected Krushnaji, > > I have studied your answer. While everything is not crystal clear, it seems > that there can be some rules that we can follow from your explanations. > These are: > > 1. A planet is functional karak (FK) for the house for it is the lord of the 8th from it. CORRECT It is also the FK for which it is in 8th from B with more than > 4 points. IT ACTS AS SAMDHARMI TO FK. FOR MERCURY IT IS MORE TRUE. mERCURY ACTS AS PER THE SIGN LORD, AND FOR THE PLANET IT IS SITUATED WITH. > > 2. If planet A is in the rashi or navamsha of B then A is samdharmi to B. That is, it can give the result for B.CORRECT. But B is not samdharmi to it. B would not give the result for A unless it was samdharmi sue to some other reason. CORRECT > > - A and B are samdharmi to each other Please advise which of the above is correct. ABOVE IS CORRECT > > 3. At a particular time, there may be results related to any house B. However, these results will not be related to houses for which the main lord is FK if the main lord has sight on B. OR SIGHT ON A OR C ALSO. THIS ABOUT MAIN DASHA LORD. RESULT WILL RELATED TO THE HOUSES FOR WHOM SAMDHARMI PLANET IS LORD. > I will not ask any more questions as this takes too much of your time. But I would request you to answer these. U ARE WELCOME > > As I have many many more questions, I would highly appreciate if you could > illustrate these concepts by showing more examples. At your own convenience, > of course. YES I WILL TRY TO GIVE. .......KRUSHNA > > Thanks and kind regards > Sanjay > - > <krushanain@h...> > > Friday, June 01, 2001 6:30 PM > Re: Picking up the relevant items in a > chart for a sub period > > > Dear Sanjay, > You are welcome with more questions. Please ask one or two > questions in a mail. More questions in one mail, results in keeping > it pending. I came to this fact, after thinking over the matter. Big > mail or more questions remains pending, only because answering small > mail or one question is easy. So after answering all small mail, it > is too late, so big mails are kept pending, with a thought I will > answer it tomarrow. and tommarrow never comes. > krushna > > , " Sanjay Jaggia " <sanjaygg@l...> > wrote: > > Respected Krushnaji, > > > > Thank you for the answers. I am sorry that I caused the tension. > > > > I am now studying your answers as well as the several exchanges > that you had > > with Peter which seem to be very illuminating. I am sure that I > will come > > back with more questions. > > > > I will take your advice and try to ask separate questions. The > problem is > > that everything seems to be linked with everything else initially > until you > > start clarifying the issues. > > > > Thanks again. > > > > Kind regards > > Sanjay > > - > > " krushna jugalkalani " <krushanain> > > > > Friday, June 01, 2001 4:16 AM > > Re: Re: Picking up the relevant > items in > > a chart for a sub period > > > > > > Dear Sanjay, > > My answers are in serial no. > > 1. No you are not, as you called your self. You have > > done a very nice thing for the list. The work sheet > > you have made, is very help ful. It is realy a > > wonderful job you have done. > > 2. Mercury is in house A with more points for house 5 > > as B. We consider lord of the house and planets > > situated in any house with more then 4 points. > > 3. Yes there can be more then one samdharmi, We have > > to select the powerful out of those. Here Moon is > > malefic for this chart, as it is having very less > > points for all houses. Only for 8th house it is with > > 12 points. So Rahu sub will give malefic result. > > 4. > > 5. as per ans 2nd. Some time the planets situated in > > the house becomes more powerful FK. > > 6. Saturn would have been samdharmi to Mercury. > > 7. Yes. even Rahu being samdharmi to moon also do the > > same thing. > > 8 The main Dasha lord lord is Mercury, and it is > > F.K. for 5,9.and 12 houses. ( for 5th house it is > > being with more points in 8th house) Here I mean the > > result must have some connection with these house. The > > Moon being sub lord, so in it's sub period it will > > give malefic result for all the houses. Those results > > should have some connection with 5th 9th and 12th > > houses. for example 9th and 12th house denotes some > > travel. So person may loose some money, or theft in > > traveling. for 5th house loss in lottery, gambling. > > Some loss or bad fortune due to children etc. > > 9. Result for 11th house in moon sub, it is having > > only 9 points, In moon sub there will not be any > > achivement for 11th house, and the reasoning may be > > Children, father of the jatak, or 12th house matter. > > 4th house: Some problem for 4th house, loss of > > happiness in family, reason may be as above. > > 2nd similar result for 2nd house. > > 10. Yes we do not consider the sight of main period > > lord for our calculation purpose. but the result for > > 6th house, will not be related to 5, 9 and 12th house. > > because mercury the main period lord is aspecting 6th > > house. Any malefic result in Moon sub for 6th house, > > will not have any connection with the houses, for > > those mercury is FK. > > Sorry Sanjay, The delay was not deliberate. For > > this or that reason delay was causing. Yes you can > > blame me, that I answered others qu, and not yours. > > One thing the I can say in excuse that this message > > became more complecated, due to your and mine write > > up. > > I think, it is much easy to ask separate qu. > > instead of using the same. > > Any how I was having tension, for not answering > > your queries. Any how it is now 2:35 Am., and I have > > done it. Now tension free. > > thanks > > krushna > > > > --- Sanjay Jaggia <sanjaygg@l...> wrote: > > <HR> > > <html><body> > > <tt> > > Respected Krushnaji,<BR> > > <BR> > > Thank you for your prompt reply. The relevant chart > > details are as follows:<BR> > > <BR> > > Ascendant - Pisces. Sun in 11th house (5 points) , > > Moon in 5th (4 points),<BR> > > Mars in 9th (2 points), Mercury in 12th (5 points), > > Jupiter in 2nd (4<BR> > > points), Venus in 12th (4 points), Saturn in 10th (4 > > points), Rahu in lagna<BR> > > and Ketu in 7th.<BR> > > <BR> > > Navamsha lagna - Aquarius. Sun in Gemini, Moon in > > Libra, Mars in Aquarius,<BR> > > Mercury in Scorpio, Jupiter in Aries, Venus in Gemini, > > Saturn in Taurus,<BR> > > Rahu in Cancer, and Ketu in Capricorn.<BR> > > <BR> > > I am attaching the worksheet summary for you to see if > > you need to.<BR> > > <BR> > > There is no specific event that I am trying to prove. > > I am just trying to<BR> > > understand your system of picking up the relevant > > areas of life.<BR> > > <BR> > > Having given this background, I have some queries on > > your reply which I hope<BR> > > you will see below and answer. My original questions > > are preceded by ' & gt;',<BR> > > your reply is in capitals, and my new questions are > > marked by ' & gt; & gt; & gt;'.<BR> > > <BR> > > krushanain@h...<BR> > > To: > > <BR> > > Tuesday, May 15, 2001 11:03 PM<BR> > > <BR> > > Dear Sanjay,<BR> > > & nbsp; & nbsp; & nbsp; After a long time you are in the > > group. Realy I missed you. No<BR> > > body ask me questions like you.<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; & gt; & gt; Thank you. It is nice to be back. About > > the questions, I suppose I am<BR> > > just dumber than the other members :-)<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; Finally, I have gone through the previous lessons > > and I have time<BR> > > for a few questions. I hope you can find the time to > > answer these.<BR> > > I am trying to check some events in a chart that I > > have. The chart<BR> > > is of a Pisces ascendant and Mercury and Venus are in > > the 12th house.<BR> > > The main period is that of Mercury. Mercury is the > > lord of 4th and<BR> > > 7th and is in 12th with 5 points.<BR> > > <BR> > > SO IT IS F.K. OF 9TH AND 12TH HOUSE. SO OVER ALL > > RESULTS GIVEN BY THE SUB<BR> > > PERIOD SHOULD HAVE SOME CONNECTION<BR> > > WITH 9TH 12TH AND 5TH HOUSE ( MERCURY BEING IN 12TH > > WITH MORE POINTS) AND IT<BR> > > IS NOT ASPECTING ANY OF THE UPCHAY HOUSES RELATED TO > > THESE HOUSES<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; & gt; & gt; I thought planets with 5 points or more > > were relevant when they are in D<BR> > > or E. 12th house is D or E for the 3rd and 7th houses > > and Mercury should<BR> > > become eager to give results for these. Why should it > > give results related<BR> > > to 5th for which is only the lord of A?<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; Venus is the lord of 3 and 8 and is in 12th with > > 4 points. O.K.<BR> > > & gt; The sub period is that of Moon. Moon has 4 points > > and is placed in<BR> > > the 5th house. Moon is natural samdharmi to Mars so > > this sub can represent<BR> > > that also. Moon is not samdharmi to any other planet > > in the chart.<BR> > > THIS SHOULD BE CHECKED WITH NAVAMANSHA CHART, YOU MUST > > HAVE CHECKED IT, IT<BR> > > MEANS NO PLANET IS IN THE NAVAMANSHA OF MOON)<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; & gt; & gt; Actually only Rahu is in the navamsha of > > Moon. Do planets become<BR> > > samdharmi to their dispositor in Rashi and Navamsha > > both or only in<BR> > > Navamsha? Would this not lead to too many samdharmis > > so that any event might<BR> > > be explained?<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; Since Moon has only 4 points, it can signify > > matters related to<BR> > > only the 8th and 12th houses where it is lord of D and > > E. CORRECT.<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt;Mars also has only one point so it can signify > > matters related to 4,<BR> > > 5, 9 and 12 where it is the lord of D or E. CORRECT. ( > > WHERE MARS IS<BR> > > SITUATED?)<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; & gt; & gt; It is in the 9th house.<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; The functional karaka for the 4th and 5th house > > is Saturn. For 8th<BR> > > it is Venus, for 9th and 12th it is Mercury. (ALSO FOR > > 5TH)<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; & gt; & gt; I thought we were only to look for the > > functional karakas for the houses<BR> > > signified by the sub period lord or its samdharmi. I > > also thought the karak<BR> > > is the lord of the 8th house. Is a planet in the 8th > > house with 5 poitns or<BR> > > more also a karak for that house?<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; Since Saturn is neither the main lord or its > > samdharmi (IT MEANS<BR> > > MERCURY IS NOT IN THE NAVAMANSHA OF SATURN, AND SATURN > > IS NOT SITUATED IN<BR> > > 9TH OR 3RD HOUSE) ,<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; & gt; & gt; All these conditions are true as you > > would see from the chart. However,<BR> > > if Saturn was in one of the conditions nnnmentioned by > > you, what would be<BR> > > the significance?<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt;...the emphasis in this period must be restricted > > to & nbsp; 8th, 9th, and<BR> > > 12th houses.<BR> > > AS PER WORK SHEET HOW MANY POINTS MOON IS GETING > > FOR<BR> > > OTHER HOUSES. IT WILL GIVE GOOD RESULTS FOR HOUSES > > HAVING MORE POINTS AND<BR> > > MALEFIC RESULTS FOR HOUSES HAVING LESS POINTS. ALL THE > > RESULTS WILL BE<BR> > > CONNECTED TO 5,9,12TH HOUSES. RESULTS OF DIFFERENT > > HOUSES WILL BE<BR> > > EXPERIENCED AS PER THE 17 MONTHS PERIOD OF MOON IN > > MERCURY. THE EVENT DATES<BR> > > WILL BE RELATED TO OTHER PLANETS HAVING RELATIVE > > POINTS AND TRANSIT OF SUN<BR> > > IN THOSE SIGN OR CONSTELLATIONS.<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; & gt; & gt; Moon has less than 12 points for all > > house except 8th where it has 12<BR> > > points. Does this mean that bad results will be felt > > for all these houses?<BR> > > Or will these be restricted to the 9th or 12th > > houses.<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; & gt; & gt; I am still having soem problem in > > understanding how the events will be<BR> > > related to the 5th house instead of the 8th house.<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; The events related to 8th, 9th and 12th houses > > will occur during<BR> > > this period and these will be with the support of the > > 3rd, 4th, 7th, and 8th<BR> > > houses (PERTICULARLY FOR THE RESULT OF 11TH HOUSE , > > 4TH HOUSE,AND 2ND HOUSE)<BR> > > ( DUE TO MOON'S SIGHT ON 11TH HOUSE) & gt; (lordship of > > the main period lord and<BR> > > its samdharmi).<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; & gt; & gt; & nbsp; Could you please advise how would > > the results be related to the 11th<BR> > > 4th and 2nd houses?<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; Please advise if this reasoning is correct. YOUR > > REASONING IS<BR> > > CORRECT,<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; Venus is natural samdharmi to Saturn. However, we > > are using Venus<BR> > > as a samdharmi to the main period lord, Mercury. Can > > we use this period<BR> > > for events related to 4th and 5th houses also since > > Saturn is the karak<BR> > > for these and is samdharmi to Venus? VENUS CAN BE USED > > IF YOU ARE<BR> > > FINDING THE RESULT OF 2ND HOUSE , SIXTH HOUSE, 11TH > > HOUSE. WHERE VENUS BEING<BR> > > SAMDHARMI TO MERCURY WILL COME FORWARD. (DUE TO SIGHT > > OF MERCURY ON 6TH<BR> > > HOUSE)<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; & gt; & gt; I am only looking here for the main > > period lord indications and looked<BR> > > to Venus as Mercury is samdharmi to it. As far as I > > understand, the sight of<BR> > > a main period lord is not relevant and only that of a > > subperiod lord is<BR> > > relevant.<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; Your reply would be highly appreciated.<BR> > > & gt; IF YOU GIVE COMPLETE CHART IT WILL BE EASY TO > > ANSWER, IF ANY POINT LEFT<BR> > > OUT. ........KRUSHNA<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; & gt; & gt; The chart details as well as worksheet is > > enclosed.<BR> > > <BR> > > Once again, I have no specific queries relating to > > this chart. I am only<BR> > > trying to understand the principles you mentioned.<BR> > > <BR> > > Kind regards<BR> > > Sanjay<BR> > > </tt> > > > > <br> > > > > <!-- |**|begin egp html banner|**| --> > > > > <table border=0 cellspacing=0 cellpadding=2> > > <tr bgcolor=#FFFFCC> > > <td align=center><font size= " -1 " > > color=#003399><b> Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 8, 2001 Report Share Posted June 8, 2001 Respected Krushnaji, Thank you for your answers. I will come with more questions after I come back from a 3 week trip starting tomorrow. Kind regards Sanjay - <krushanain Friday, June 08, 2001 12:53 AM Re: Picking up the relevant items in a chart for a sub period Dear Sanjay, My comments in block letters. krushna > Respected Krushnaji, > > I have studied your answer. While everything is not crystal clear, it seems > that there can be some rules that we can follow from your explanations. > These are: > > 1. A planet is functional karak (FK) for the house for it is the lord of the 8th from it. CORRECT It is also the FK for which it is in 8th from B with more than > 4 points. IT ACTS AS SAMDHARMI TO FK. FOR MERCURY IT IS MORE TRUE. mERCURY ACTS AS PER THE SIGN LORD, AND FOR THE PLANET IT IS SITUATED WITH. > > 2. If planet A is in the rashi or navamsha of B then A is samdharmi to B. That is, it can give the result for B.CORRECT. But B is not samdharmi to it. B would not give the result for A unless it was samdharmi sue to some other reason. CORRECT > > - A and B are samdharmi to each other Please advise which of the above is correct. ABOVE IS CORRECT > > 3. At a particular time, there may be results related to any house B. However, these results will not be related to houses for which the main lord is FK if the main lord has sight on B. OR SIGHT ON A OR C ALSO. THIS ABOUT MAIN DASHA LORD. RESULT WILL RELATED TO THE HOUSES FOR WHOM SAMDHARMI PLANET IS LORD. > I will not ask any more questions as this takes too much of your time. But I would request you to answer these. U ARE WELCOME > > As I have many many more questions, I would highly appreciate if you could > illustrate these concepts by showing more examples. At your own convenience, > of course. YES I WILL TRY TO GIVE. .......KRUSHNA > > Thanks and kind regards > Sanjay > - > <krushanain@h...> > > Friday, June 01, 2001 6:30 PM > Re: Picking up the relevant items in a > chart for a sub period > > > Dear Sanjay, > You are welcome with more questions. Please ask one or two > questions in a mail. More questions in one mail, results in keeping > it pending. I came to this fact, after thinking over the matter. Big > mail or more questions remains pending, only because answering small > mail or one question is easy. So after answering all small mail, it > is too late, so big mails are kept pending, with a thought I will > answer it tomarrow. and tommarrow never comes. > krushna > > , " Sanjay Jaggia " <sanjaygg@l...> > wrote: > > Respected Krushnaji, > > > > Thank you for the answers. I am sorry that I caused the tension. > > > > I am now studying your answers as well as the several exchanges > that you had > > with Peter which seem to be very illuminating. I am sure that I > will come > > back with more questions. > > > > I will take your advice and try to ask separate questions. The > problem is > > that everything seems to be linked with everything else initially > until you > > start clarifying the issues. > > > > Thanks again. > > > > Kind regards > > Sanjay > > - > > " krushna jugalkalani " <krushanain> > > > > Friday, June 01, 2001 4:16 AM > > Re: Re: Picking up the relevant > items in > > a chart for a sub period > > > > > > Dear Sanjay, > > My answers are in serial no. > > 1. No you are not, as you called your self. You have > > done a very nice thing for the list. The work sheet > > you have made, is very help ful. It is realy a > > wonderful job you have done. > > 2. Mercury is in house A with more points for house 5 > > as B. We consider lord of the house and planets > > situated in any house with more then 4 points. > > 3. Yes there can be more then one samdharmi, We have > > to select the powerful out of those. Here Moon is > > malefic for this chart, as it is having very less > > points for all houses. Only for 8th house it is with > > 12 points. So Rahu sub will give malefic result. > > 4. > > 5. as per ans 2nd. Some time the planets situated in > > the house becomes more powerful FK. > > 6. Saturn would have been samdharmi to Mercury. > > 7. Yes. even Rahu being samdharmi to moon also do the > > same thing. > > 8 The main Dasha lord lord is Mercury, and it is > > F.K. for 5,9.and 12 houses. ( for 5th house it is > > being with more points in 8th house) Here I mean the > > result must have some connection with these house. The > > Moon being sub lord, so in it's sub period it will > > give malefic result for all the houses. Those results > > should have some connection with 5th 9th and 12th > > houses. for example 9th and 12th house denotes some > > travel. So person may loose some money, or theft in > > traveling. for 5th house loss in lottery, gambling. > > Some loss or bad fortune due to children etc. > > 9. Result for 11th house in moon sub, it is having > > only 9 points, In moon sub there will not be any > > achivement for 11th house, and the reasoning may be > > Children, father of the jatak, or 12th house matter. > > 4th house: Some problem for 4th house, loss of > > happiness in family, reason may be as above. > > 2nd similar result for 2nd house. > > 10. Yes we do not consider the sight of main period > > lord for our calculation purpose. but the result for > > 6th house, will not be related to 5, 9 and 12th house. > > because mercury the main period lord is aspecting 6th > > house. Any malefic result in Moon sub for 6th house, > > will not have any connection with the houses, for > > those mercury is FK. > > Sorry Sanjay, The delay was not deliberate. For > > this or that reason delay was causing. Yes you can > > blame me, that I answered others qu, and not yours. > > One thing the I can say in excuse that this message > > became more complecated, due to your and mine write > > up. > > I think, it is much easy to ask separate qu. > > instead of using the same. > > Any how I was having tension, for not answering > > your queries. Any how it is now 2:35 Am., and I have > > done it. Now tension free. > > thanks > > krushna > > > > --- Sanjay Jaggia <sanjaygg@l...> wrote: > > <HR> > > <html><body> > > <tt> > > Respected Krushnaji,<BR> > > <BR> > > Thank you for your prompt reply. The relevant chart > > details are as follows:<BR> > > <BR> > > Ascendant - Pisces. Sun in 11th house (5 points) , > > Moon in 5th (4 points),<BR> > > Mars in 9th (2 points), Mercury in 12th (5 points), > > Jupiter in 2nd (4<BR> > > points), Venus in 12th (4 points), Saturn in 10th (4 > > points), Rahu in lagna<BR> > > and Ketu in 7th.<BR> > > <BR> > > Navamsha lagna - Aquarius. Sun in Gemini, Moon in > > Libra, Mars in Aquarius,<BR> > > Mercury in Scorpio, Jupiter in Aries, Venus in Gemini, > > Saturn in Taurus,<BR> > > Rahu in Cancer, and Ketu in Capricorn.<BR> > > <BR> > > I am attaching the worksheet summary for you to see if > > you need to.<BR> > > <BR> > > There is no specific event that I am trying to prove. > > I am just trying to<BR> > > understand your system of picking up the relevant > > areas of life.<BR> > > <BR> > > Having given this background, I have some queries on > > your reply which I hope<BR> > > you will see below and answer. My original questions > > are preceded by ' & gt;',<BR> > > your reply is in capitals, and my new questions are > > marked by ' & gt; & gt; & gt;'.<BR> > > <BR> > > krushanain@h...<BR> > > To: > > <BR> > > Tuesday, May 15, 2001 11:03 PM<BR> > > <BR> > > Dear Sanjay,<BR> > > & nbsp; & nbsp; & nbsp; After a long time you are in the > > group. Realy I missed you. No<BR> > > body ask me questions like you.<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; & gt; & gt; Thank you. It is nice to be back. About > > the questions, I suppose I am<BR> > > just dumber than the other members :-)<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; Finally, I have gone through the previous lessons > > and I have time<BR> > > for a few questions. I hope you can find the time to > > answer these.<BR> > > I am trying to check some events in a chart that I > > have. The chart<BR> > > is of a Pisces ascendant and Mercury and Venus are in > > the 12th house.<BR> > > The main period is that of Mercury. Mercury is the > > lord of 4th and<BR> > > 7th and is in 12th with 5 points.<BR> > > <BR> > > SO IT IS F.K. OF 9TH AND 12TH HOUSE. SO OVER ALL > > RESULTS GIVEN BY THE SUB<BR> > > PERIOD SHOULD HAVE SOME CONNECTION<BR> > > WITH 9TH 12TH AND 5TH HOUSE ( MERCURY BEING IN 12TH > > WITH MORE POINTS) AND IT<BR> > > IS NOT ASPECTING ANY OF THE UPCHAY HOUSES RELATED TO > > THESE HOUSES<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; & gt; & gt; I thought planets with 5 points or more > > were relevant when they are in D<BR> > > or E. 12th house is D or E for the 3rd and 7th houses > > and Mercury should<BR> > > become eager to give results for these. Why should it > > give results related<BR> > > to 5th for which is only the lord of A?<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; Venus is the lord of 3 and 8 and is in 12th with > > 4 points. O.K.<BR> > > & gt; The sub period is that of Moon. Moon has 4 points > > and is placed in<BR> > > the 5th house. Moon is natural samdharmi to Mars so > > this sub can represent<BR> > > that also. Moon is not samdharmi to any other planet > > in the chart.<BR> > > THIS SHOULD BE CHECKED WITH NAVAMANSHA CHART, YOU MUST > > HAVE CHECKED IT, IT<BR> > > MEANS NO PLANET IS IN THE NAVAMANSHA OF MOON)<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; & gt; & gt; Actually only Rahu is in the navamsha of > > Moon. Do planets become<BR> > > samdharmi to their dispositor in Rashi and Navamsha > > both or only in<BR> > > Navamsha? Would this not lead to too many samdharmis > > so that any event might<BR> > > be explained?<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; Since Moon has only 4 points, it can signify > > matters related to<BR> > > only the 8th and 12th houses where it is lord of D and > > E. CORRECT.<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt;Mars also has only one point so it can signify > > matters related to 4,<BR> > > 5, 9 and 12 where it is the lord of D or E. CORRECT. ( > > WHERE MARS IS<BR> > > SITUATED?)<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; & gt; & gt; It is in the 9th house.<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; The functional karaka for the 4th and 5th house > > is Saturn. For 8th<BR> > > it is Venus, for 9th and 12th it is Mercury. (ALSO FOR > > 5TH)<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; & gt; & gt; I thought we were only to look for the > > functional karakas for the houses<BR> > > signified by the sub period lord or its samdharmi. I > > also thought the karak<BR> > > is the lord of the 8th house. Is a planet in the 8th > > house with 5 poitns or<BR> > > more also a karak for that house?<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; Since Saturn is neither the main lord or its > > samdharmi (IT MEANS<BR> > > MERCURY IS NOT IN THE NAVAMANSHA OF SATURN, AND SATURN > > IS NOT SITUATED IN<BR> > > 9TH OR 3RD HOUSE) ,<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; & gt; & gt; All these conditions are true as you > > would see from the chart. However,<BR> > > if Saturn was in one of the conditions nnnmentioned by > > you, what would be<BR> > > the significance?<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt;...the emphasis in this period must be restricted > > to & nbsp; 8th, 9th, and<BR> > > 12th houses.<BR> > > AS PER WORK SHEET HOW MANY POINTS MOON IS GETING > > FOR<BR> > > OTHER HOUSES. IT WILL GIVE GOOD RESULTS FOR HOUSES > > HAVING MORE POINTS AND<BR> > > MALEFIC RESULTS FOR HOUSES HAVING LESS POINTS. ALL THE > > RESULTS WILL BE<BR> > > CONNECTED TO 5,9,12TH HOUSES. RESULTS OF DIFFERENT > > HOUSES WILL BE<BR> > > EXPERIENCED AS PER THE 17 MONTHS PERIOD OF MOON IN > > MERCURY. THE EVENT DATES<BR> > > WILL BE RELATED TO OTHER PLANETS HAVING RELATIVE > > POINTS AND TRANSIT OF SUN<BR> > > IN THOSE SIGN OR CONSTELLATIONS.<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; & gt; & gt; Moon has less than 12 points for all > > house except 8th where it has 12<BR> > > points. Does this mean that bad results will be felt > > for all these houses?<BR> > > Or will these be restricted to the 9th or 12th > > houses.<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; & gt; & gt; I am still having soem problem in > > understanding how the events will be<BR> > > related to the 5th house instead of the 8th house.<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; The events related to 8th, 9th and 12th houses > > will occur during<BR> > > this period and these will be with the support of the > > 3rd, 4th, 7th, and 8th<BR> > > houses (PERTICULARLY FOR THE RESULT OF 11TH HOUSE , > > 4TH HOUSE,AND 2ND HOUSE)<BR> > > ( DUE TO MOON'S SIGHT ON 11TH HOUSE) & gt; (lordship of > > the main period lord and<BR> > > its samdharmi).<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; & gt; & gt; & nbsp; Could you please advise how would > > the results be related to the 11th<BR> > > 4th and 2nd houses?<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; Please advise if this reasoning is correct. YOUR > > REASONING IS<BR> > > CORRECT,<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; Venus is natural samdharmi to Saturn. However, we > > are using Venus<BR> > > as a samdharmi to the main period lord, Mercury. Can > > we use this period<BR> > > for events related to 4th and 5th houses also since > > Saturn is the karak<BR> > > for these and is samdharmi to Venus? VENUS CAN BE USED > > IF YOU ARE<BR> > > FINDING THE RESULT OF 2ND HOUSE , SIXTH HOUSE, 11TH > > HOUSE. WHERE VENUS BEING<BR> > > SAMDHARMI TO MERCURY WILL COME FORWARD. (DUE TO SIGHT > > OF MERCURY ON 6TH<BR> > > HOUSE)<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; & gt; & gt; I am only looking here for the main > > period lord indications and looked<BR> > > to Venus as Mercury is samdharmi to it. As far as I > > understand, the sight of<BR> > > a main period lord is not relevant and only that of a > > subperiod lord is<BR> > > relevant.<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; Your reply would be highly appreciated.<BR> > > & gt; IF YOU GIVE COMPLETE CHART IT WILL BE EASY TO > > ANSWER, IF ANY POINT LEFT<BR> > > OUT. ........KRUSHNA<BR> > > <BR> > > & gt; & gt; & gt; The chart details as well as worksheet is > > enclosed.<BR> > > <BR> > > Once again, I have no specific queries relating to > > this chart. I am only<BR> > > trying to understand the principles you mentioned.<BR> > > <BR> > > Kind regards<BR> > > Sanjay<BR> > > </tt> > > > > <br> > > > > <!-- |**|begin egp html banner|**| --> > > > > <table border=0 cellspacing=0 cellpadding=2> > > <tr bgcolor=#FFFFCC> > > <td align=center><font size= " -1 " > > color=#003399><b> Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 8, 2001 Report Share Posted June 8, 2001 Dear Sanjay, You are welcome krushna , " Sanjay Jaggia " <sanjaygg@l...> wrote: > Respected Krushnaji, > > Thank you for your answers. I will come with more questions after I come > back from a 3 week trip starting tomorrow. > > Kind regards > Sanjay > ://docs./info/terms/ Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.