Guest guest Posted March 11, 2003 Report Share Posted March 11, 2003 Dear Krushnaji and Visti, While brain storming with Visti studying BAV, we came across this for distribution of points for Mercury for Sun and wanted some clarity. - If Sun is in 5th, 6th, 9th, 11th or 12th house then Mercury will contribute a bindu. Now astronomical facts we know that Mercury cannot be more than a sign ahead or behind sun. So what was Varharamira trying to say ? After thrashing this concept out we thought that this could only be possible in Vargas. If this is true then its another proof that AV SHOULD and CAN be used in Varga Chakra. - We also found that Guru if in 3rd place from any planet (except Guru itself) did not contribute any bindus ? Is this the Marna karak sthan concept that is being considered automatically ? - We also found that Mercury does not contribute any bindus in 7th from itself toward any planet. - 7th house In Venus's BAV does not get any bindu from Venus We also found that ALL PLANETS are NOT giving bindus to 12th from themselves EXCEPT GURU FOR SHANI. ? Is that why Good muhurat is not taken when Guru is in 12th house ? Can you please confirm this ? Thanking you, Cheers !!! Ash Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 13, 2003 Report Share Posted March 13, 2003 Does this not happen for each planet, because in each BAV, there are more than one places indicated for the BAV planet itself, hence in Sun's BAV, sun is (beneficial) in 1, 11, 4, 8, 2, 10,9, 7 (8 places). How can the sun be in 8 places from itself in any varga, including rashi. Does this mean that the varga placements must be calculated for the vargas from the rashi position. Therefore if sun is in libra in rashi but sagittarius in navamsha, we would still put the points in navamsha, oriented from rashi position (hence in the libra, scorpio, capricorn and not in sag, capricorn, pisces etc.)? Or, we can just take the BAV placements as indicative of benefic places from the natal position and not " X is benefic in houses 1,3,4 ... etc. from (a certain position) " . The latter opens up a can of worms as described above. MKu , " ashsam73 " <ashsam73@h...> wrote: > Dear Krushnaji and Visti, > > While brain storming with Visti studying BAV, we came across this for > distribution of points for Mercury for Sun and wanted some clarity. > > - If Sun is in 5th, 6th, 9th, 11th or 12th house then Mercury will > contribute a bindu. > > Now astronomical facts we know that Mercury cannot be more than a > sign ahead or behind sun. > > So what was Varharamira trying to say ? > > After thrashing this concept out we thought that this could only be > possible in Vargas. > > If this is true then its another proof that AV SHOULD and CAN be used > in Varga Chakra. > > - We also found that Guru if in 3rd place from any planet (except > Guru itself) did not contribute any bindus ? Is this the Marna karak > sthan concept that is being considered automatically ? > > - We also found that Mercury does not contribute any bindus in 7th > from itself toward any planet. > > - 7th house In Venus's BAV does not get any bindu from Venus > > We also found that ALL PLANETS are NOT giving bindus to 12th from > themselves EXCEPT GURU FOR SHANI. ? > Is that why Good muhurat is not taken when Guru is in 12th house ? > > Can you please confirm this ? > > > Thanking you, > Cheers !!! > Ash Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 13, 2003 Report Share Posted March 13, 2003 Dear Manas, Ash and list members, BAV gives the benefic places for a planet. For Example Mercury benefic strength from Sun for the places 5,6,9,11,and 12 house. Or Mercury is benefic for 1,3,5,6,9,10,11,and 12 houses from it self. This way we can know the benefic strength of the planets for all the houses. The benefic points are relative to the planets from each other. Where planets do not get benefic point, it means it is malefic for that house. It is nothing to do with astronomical facts. krushna , " Manas Kumar " <manaskumar@h...> wrote: > Does this not happen for each planet, because in each BAV, there are > more than one places indicated for the BAV planet itself, hence in > Sun's BAV, sun is (beneficial) in 1, 11, 4, 8, 2, 10,9, 7 (8 > places). How can the sun be in 8 places from itself in any varga, > including rashi. Does this mean that the varga placements must be > calculated for the vargas from the rashi position. Therefore if sun > is in libra in rashi but sagittarius in navamsha, we would still put > the points in navamsha, oriented from rashi position (hence in the > libra, scorpio, capricorn and not in sag, capricorn, pisces etc.)? > > Or, we can just take the BAV placements as indicative of benefic > places from the natal position and not " X is benefic in houses > 1,3,4 ... etc. from (a certain position) " . The latter opens up a can > of worms as described above. > > MKu > > , " ashsam73 " > <ashsam73@h...> wrote: > > Dear Krushnaji and Visti, > > > > While brain storming with Visti studying BAV, we came across this > for > > distribution of points for Mercury for Sun and wanted some clarity. > > > > - If Sun is in 5th, 6th, 9th, 11th or 12th house then Mercury will > > contribute a bindu. > > > > Now astronomical facts we know that Mercury cannot be more than a > > sign ahead or behind sun. > > > > So what was Varharamira trying to say ? > > > > After thrashing this concept out we thought that this could only > be > > possible in Vargas. > > > > If this is true then its another proof that AV SHOULD and CAN be > used > > in Varga Chakra. > > > > - We also found that Guru if in 3rd place from any planet (except > > Guru itself) did not contribute any bindus ? Is this the Marna > karak > > sthan concept that is being considered automatically ? > > > > - We also found that Mercury does not contribute any bindus in 7th > > from itself toward any planet. > > > > - 7th house In Venus's BAV does not get any bindu from Venus > > > > We also found that ALL PLANETS are NOT giving bindus to 12th from > > themselves EXCEPT GURU FOR SHANI. ? > > Is that why Good muhurat is not taken when Guru is in 12th house ? > > > > Can you please confirm this ? > > > > > > Thanking you, > > Cheers !!! > > Ash Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 13, 2003 Report Share Posted March 13, 2003 Dear Krushnaji, Thank you for your explanation. Cheers !!! Ash , " krushanain " <krushanain> wrote: > Dear Manas, Ash and list members, > BAV gives the benefic places for a planet. For Example > Mercury benefic strength from Sun for the places 5,6,9,11,and 12 > house. Or Mercury is benefic for 1,3,5,6,9,10,11,and 12 houses from > it self. > This way we can know the benefic strength of the planets for > all the houses. > The benefic points are relative to the planets from each > other. Where planets do not get benefic point, it means it is malefic > for that house. > It is nothing to do with astronomical facts. > krushna > > > , " Manas Kumar " > <manaskumar@h...> wrote: > > Does this not happen for each planet, because in each BAV, there > are > > more than one places indicated for the BAV planet itself, hence in > > Sun's BAV, sun is (beneficial) in 1, 11, 4, 8, 2, 10,9, 7 (8 > > places). How can the sun be in 8 places from itself in any varga, > > including rashi. Does this mean that the varga placements must be > > calculated for the vargas from the rashi position. Therefore if sun > > is in libra in rashi but sagittarius in navamsha, we would still > put > > the points in navamsha, oriented from rashi position (hence in the > > libra, scorpio, capricorn and not in sag, capricorn, pisces etc.)? > > > > Or, we can just take the BAV placements as indicative of benefic > > places from the natal position and not " X is benefic in houses > > 1,3,4 ... etc. from (a certain position) " . The latter opens up a > can > > of worms as described above. > > > > MKu > > > > , " ashsam73 " > > <ashsam73@h...> wrote: > > > Dear Krushnaji and Visti, > > > > > > While brain storming with Visti studying BAV, we came across this > > for > > > distribution of points for Mercury for Sun and wanted some > clarity. > > > > > > - If Sun is in 5th, 6th, 9th, 11th or 12th house then Mercury > will > > > contribute a bindu. > > > > > > Now astronomical facts we know that Mercury cannot be more than a > > > sign ahead or behind sun. > > > > > > So what was Varharamira trying to say ? > > > > > > After thrashing this concept out we thought that this could only > > be > > > possible in Vargas. > > > > > > If this is true then its another proof that AV SHOULD and CAN be > > used > > > in Varga Chakra. > > > > > > - We also found that Guru if in 3rd place from any planet (except > > > Guru itself) did not contribute any bindus ? Is this the Marna > > karak > > > sthan concept that is being considered automatically ? > > > > > > - We also found that Mercury does not contribute any bindus in > 7th > > > from itself toward any planet. > > > > > > - 7th house In Venus's BAV does not get any bindu from Venus > > > > > > We also found that ALL PLANETS are NOT giving bindus to 12th from > > > themselves EXCEPT GURU FOR SHANI. ? > > > Is that why Good muhurat is not taken when Guru is in 12th house ? > > > > > > Can you please confirm this ? > > > > > > > > > Thanking you, > > > Cheers !!! > > > Ash Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.