a basic question - Manoshi - Further thought

[Guest guest]

Dear Manoshi,

My answer here is based functional SD.

 

Now another scenario is this.

 

Lets take X = Ve, Y = Me, Z = Sa.

 

Assume X and Z are not in 1:7.

 

Now X is SD to Y (Ve is SD to Me)

 

and Y is SD to Z (Me is SD to Sa).

 

Now Ve is not Functional SD to Sa however in this exception Ve is

NSD to Sa i.e natural Samdharmi.

 

So please keep this in mind also when u study.

 

Cheers !!!

Ash

 

 

 

, " ashsam73 "

<ashsam73> wrote:

> Dear Manoshi,

> No.

> Cheers !!!

> Ash

>

> , " Manoshi

> Chatterjee " <khallopapa> wrote:

> > Dear Ash,

> >

> > Thanx for all the information on samadharmi planets, but my

> question

> > was...

> >

> > let there be three planets X, Y, and Z.

> >

> > if X=Y ( = be SD)

> > and Y=Z

> >

> > Is X=Z too?

> >

> > means, if Y can give results for X

> > and if Z can give results for Y

> > will Z will give results for X too? I thnik NO but still was

> > clarifying.

> >

> > --Manoshi

> >

> > , " ashsam73 "

> > <ashsam73> wrote:

> > > Dear Manoshi,

> > >

> > > Here is an old mail I had written on 4:10.

> > >

> > >

> /message/5886

> > >

> > > Cheers !!!

> > > Ash

> > >

> > > , " Manoshi

> > Chatterjee "

> > > <khallopapa> wrote:

> > > > Dear Ash and others,

> > > >

> > > > say Mercury is samdharmee to Venus and moon is also

> samadharmee

> > to

> > > > venus. will venus act as a samadharmi to Mercury, I mean if

> > mercury

> > > > is giving " move " , then Venus might give move ( I am

> > considerining

> > > only

> > > > SD factor to give results here), will Moon also will have

the

> > > > capability to give move ( based on SD factor)?

> > > >

> > > > --Manoshi