Guest guest Posted December 14, 2006 Report Share Posted December 14, 2006 Respected Ashji namaskaar I was going through your lessons regarding samdharmi planets.Would you please be kind enough to clear this On'tenth house theory'If two planets are situated in 4-10 positions One planet'A' has more than 4 points and the second planet'B' has less than 4 points, Planet A is samdharmi to planet'B' If planet 'B' is aspecting the signicating house and has got more points even then planet'A'would be samdharmi planet There are two separate points which i have understood.Have I understood rightly or is there any mistake in my understanding? pl.clarify Thanks Regards chand Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 14, 2006 Report Share Posted December 14, 2006 Dear Chand, These are not MY lessons. These are lessons given by Krushnaji. Chand, please address your questions to the list members. There are many students on this list learning so they can also answer and get confidence. I shall wait for some time, for the KAS students to reply to your question. It is a very important question and one must have very clear understanding of this principle. If you also notice the Worksheet, after we consider A+B+C points we then check to see 4:10 and if there is a 4:10 relation (subject to condition) then the points of those planets are added. This is very important phenemon. Since the list is quite, please take it up in discussion as everyone should be clear. Cheers !!! Ash -> http://www.ashtro.ca , " caprimoon_lady " <caprimoon_lady wrote: > > Respected Ashji > namaskaar > I was going through your lessons regarding samdharmi planets.Would you > please be kind enough to clear this > On'tenth house theory'If two planets are situated in 4-10 positions One > planet'A' has more than 4 points and the second planet'B' has less than > 4 points, Planet A is samdharmi to planet'B' > If planet 'B' is aspecting the signicating house and has got more > points even then planet'A'would be samdharmi planet > There are two separate points which i have understood.Have I understood > rightly or is there any mistake in my understanding? pl.clarify > Thanks > Regards > chand > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 15, 2006 Report Share Posted December 15, 2006 Dear Ashji/Chandji, As far as i understand from the query is that. A is samdhari to B on 4:10 point basis. if B aspects the significating houses then it wont deliver the result but its samdhari A would come forward and give the result during its antra... other then that i cant make out what the query is... Functional samdhari on 4:10 basis are the most powerful samdhari besides the natural samdharis.. other are of lower order... depending on the criteria already given in the lesson.. 2 planets in same nakshatra but different sign would also be samdharis.... thanks/regards harjeet , " caprimoon_lady " <caprimoon_lady wrote: > > Respected Ashji > namaskaar > I was going through your lessons regarding samdharmi planets.Would you > please be kind enough to clear this > On'tenth house theory'If two planets are situated in 4-10 positions One > planet'A' has more than 4 points and the second planet'B' has less than > 4 points, Planet A is samdharmi to planet'B' > If planet 'B' is aspecting the signicating house and has got more > points even then planet'A'would be samdharmi planet > There are two separate points which i have understood.Have I understood > rightly or is there any mistake in my understanding? pl.clarify > Thanks > Regards > chand > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 15, 2006 Report Share Posted December 15, 2006 Dear Harjeet ji and all other learned members Thank you very much for your reply My query is that in Lesson No.8 at point No.2 on samdharmi planets, two points are given on Tenth house theory:-- 1) if two planets say A and B are in 4-10 relationship. B is the signficator and planet A can give the results of B in its antardasha provided A has more bindus than B in Ashkatkvarga 2)Second condition is If planet B being the significator is aspecting the significating house even then A can givethe results of B in its antardasha even if planet B has more points than A. Now I wanted to ask if i have understood these two principles correctly or is there some mistake in my understanding? Regards chand -- In , " harjeet bakshi " <harjeet_bakshi wrote: > > Dear Ashji/Chandji, > As far as i understand from the query is that. > A is samdhari to B on 4:10 point basis. > if B aspects the significating houses then it wont deliver the result > but its samdhari A would come forward and give the result during its > antra... > other then that i cant make out what the query is... > > Functional samdhari on 4:10 basis are the most powerful samdhari > besides the natural samdharis.. > other are of lower order... depending on the criteria already given in > the lesson.. > 2 planets in same nakshatra but different sign would also be samdharis.... > > thanks/regards > harjeet > > , " caprimoon_lady " > <caprimoon_lady@> wrote: > > > > Respected Ashji > > namaskaar > > I was going through your lessons regarding samdharmi planets.Would you > > please be kind enough to clear this > > On'tenth house theory'If two planets are situated in 4-10 positions One > > planet'A' has more than 4 points and the second planet'B' has less than > > 4 points, Planet A is samdharmi to planet'B' > > If planet 'B' is aspecting the signicating house and has got more > > points even then planet'A'would be samdharmi planet > > There are two separate points which i have understood.Have I understood > > rightly or is there any mistake in my understanding? pl.clarify > > Thanks > > Regards > > chand > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 15, 2006 Report Share Posted December 15, 2006 Respected Ashji namskaar I am really sorry and shall take care in future.I shall put my queries to the list members.Being a new to your forum I did not know the procedure Thanks Regards chand , " ashsam73 " <ashsam73 wrote: > > Dear Chand, > These are not MY lessons. These are lessons given by Krushnaji. > Chand, please address your questions to the list members. There are > many students on this list learning so they can also answer and get > confidence. > > I shall wait for some time, for the KAS students to reply to your > question. > > It is a very important question and one must have very clear > understanding of this principle. > > If you also notice the Worksheet, after we consider A+B+C points we > then check to see 4:10 and if there is a 4:10 relation (subject to > condition) then the points of those planets are added. > > This is very important phenemon. > > Since the list is quite, please take it up in discussion as everyone > should be clear. > > Cheers !!! > Ash -> http://www.ashtro.ca > > > , " caprimoon_lady " > <caprimoon_lady@> wrote: > > > > Respected Ashji > > namaskaar > > I was going through your lessons regarding samdharmi planets.Would you > > please be kind enough to clear this > > On'tenth house theory'If two planets are situated in 4-10 positions One > > planet'A' has more than 4 points and the second planet'B' has less than > > 4 points, Planet A is samdharmi to planet'B' > > If planet 'B' is aspecting the signicating house and has got more > > points even then planet'A'would be samdharmi planet > > There are two separate points which i have understood.Have I understood > > rightly or is there any mistake in my understanding? pl.clarify > > Thanks > > Regards > > chand > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 15, 2006 Report Share Posted December 15, 2006 Dear Chand, Let me try to explain. I am refering to figure 1 in lesson 8. Here planet A has got more than 4 points and planet B has less than 4 points. So, A becomes SD to B. If you check the way WS is also calculated, you will notice that the basic strength of A gets added to strength of B. So, B becomes powerful to give the result. That is one part. Now, let us say that planet B has more strength than A in the WS but planet B aspects one of the significator houses then B itself cannot give the result, so A will come forward here to give the result for B since it is a strong Samdharmi to B. Samdharmis normally come forward only when the other planet is not capable to give result due to sight or delay or even if other planet's sub-period is much later than SD's sub period. In your point 2, read it as " ...even if planet B has more points than A [in worksheet] " . Ash, kindly correct if I am wrong. Thanks & Regards, Manu , " caprimoon_lady " <caprimoon_lady wrote: > > Dear Harjeet ji and all other learned members > Thank you very much for your reply My query is that in Lesson No.8 at > point No.2 on samdharmi planets, two points are given on Tenth house > theory:-- > > 1) if two planets say A and B are in 4-10 relationship. B is the > signficator and planet A can give the results of B in its antardasha > provided A has more bindus than B in Ashkatkvarga > > 2)Second condition is If planet B being the significator is aspecting > the significating house even then A can givethe results of B in its > antardasha even if planet B has more points than A. > Now I wanted to ask if i have understood these two principles > correctly or is there some mistake in my understanding? > Regards > chand > -- In , " harjeet bakshi " > <harjeet_bakshi@> wrote: > > > > Dear Ashji/Chandji, > > As far as i understand from the query is that. > > A is samdhari to B on 4:10 point basis. > > if B aspects the significating houses then it wont deliver the > result > > but its samdhari A would come forward and give the result during its > > antra... > > other then that i cant make out what the query is... > > > > Functional samdhari on 4:10 basis are the most powerful samdhari > > besides the natural samdharis.. > > other are of lower order... depending on the criteria already given > in > > the lesson.. > > 2 planets in same nakshatra but different sign would also be > samdharis.... > > > > thanks/regards > > harjeet > > > > , " caprimoon_lady " > > <caprimoon_lady@> wrote: > > > > > > Respected Ashji > > > namaskaar > > > I was going through your lessons regarding samdharmi > planets.Would you > > > please be kind enough to clear this > > > On'tenth house theory'If two planets are situated in 4-10 > positions One > > > planet'A' has more than 4 points and the second planet'B' has > less than > > > 4 points, Planet A is samdharmi to planet'B' > > > If planet 'B' is aspecting the signicating house and has got more > > > points even then planet'A'would be samdharmi planet > > > There are two separate points which i have understood.Have I > understood > > > rightly or is there any mistake in my understanding? pl.clarify > > > Thanks > > > Regards > > > chand > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 15, 2006 Report Share Posted December 15, 2006 yes mam... i guess u r right... first the conditon given for A to be samdhari to B.. it should be more points and in 4th position... second if B is the strong significator for the event but it aspects house A, house B or house C it cannot give the result. in this case antra of its samdhari i.e. antra of planet A would give the result. also i guess when samdhari gives the resutl it doesnt matters if it aspects house A, B or C... thanks/regards harjeet , " caprimoon_lady " <caprimoon_lady wrote: > > Dear Harjeet ji and all other learned members > Thank you very much for your reply My query is that in Lesson No.8 at > point No.2 on samdharmi planets, two points are given on Tenth house > theory:-- > > 1) if two planets say A and B are in 4-10 relationship. B is the > signficator and planet A can give the results of B in its antardasha > provided A has more bindus than B in Ashkatkvarga > > 2)Second condition is If planet B being the significator is aspecting > the significating house even then A can givethe results of B in its > antardasha even if planet B has more points than A. > Now I wanted to ask if i have understood these two principles > correctly or is there some mistake in my understanding? > Regards > chand > -- In , " harjeet bakshi " > <harjeet_bakshi@> wrote: > > > > Dear Ashji/Chandji, > > As far as i understand from the query is that. > > A is samdhari to B on 4:10 point basis. > > if B aspects the significating houses then it wont deliver the > result > > but its samdhari A would come forward and give the result during its > > antra... > > other then that i cant make out what the query is... > > > > Functional samdhari on 4:10 basis are the most powerful samdhari > > besides the natural samdharis.. > > other are of lower order... depending on the criteria already given > in > > the lesson.. > > 2 planets in same nakshatra but different sign would also be > samdharis.... > > > > thanks/regards > > harjeet > > > > , " caprimoon_lady " > > <caprimoon_lady@> wrote: > > > > > > Respected Ashji > > > namaskaar > > > I was going through your lessons regarding samdharmi > planets.Would you > > > please be kind enough to clear this > > > On'tenth house theory'If two planets are situated in 4-10 > positions One > > > planet'A' has more than 4 points and the second planet'B' has > less than > > > 4 points, Planet A is samdharmi to planet'B' > > > If planet 'B' is aspecting the signicating house and has got more > > > points even then planet'A'would be samdharmi planet > > > There are two separate points which i have understood.Have I > understood > > > rightly or is there any mistake in my understanding? pl.clarify > > > Thanks > > > Regards > > > chand > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 15, 2006 Report Share Posted December 15, 2006 Dear Manuji and Harjeet ji Thanks a lot for your reply and the time given to explain in a very nice manner.The point is clear to me.I have started reading the lessons to understand KAS system properly. Thanks once again Regards chand , " Manu Batura " <manubatura wrote: > > Dear Chand, > > Let me try to explain. I am refering to figure 1 in lesson 8. > > Here planet A has got more than 4 points and planet B has less than 4 > points. So, A becomes SD to B. If you check the way WS is also > calculated, you will notice that the basic strength of A gets added to > strength of B. So, B becomes powerful to give the result. That is one > part. > > Now, let us say that planet B has more strength than A in the WS but > planet B aspects one of the significator houses then B itself cannot > give the result, so A will come forward here to give the result for B > since it is a strong Samdharmi to B. Samdharmis normally come forward > only when the other planet is not capable to give result due to sight > or delay or even if other planet's sub-period is much later than SD's > sub period. > > In your point 2, read it as " ...even if planet B has more points than > A [in worksheet] " . > > Ash, kindly correct if I am wrong. > > Thanks & Regards, > Manu > > > > , " caprimoon_lady " > <caprimoon_lady@> wrote: > > > > Dear Harjeet ji and all other learned members > > Thank you very much for your reply My query is that in Lesson No.8 at > > point No.2 on samdharmi planets, two points are given on Tenth house > > theory:-- > > > > 1) if two planets say A and B are in 4-10 relationship. B is the > > signficator and planet A can give the results of B in its antardasha > > provided A has more bindus than B in Ashkatkvarga > > > > 2)Second condition is If planet B being the significator is aspecting > > the significating house even then A can givethe results of B in its > > antardasha even if planet B has more points than A. > > Now I wanted to ask if i have understood these two principles > > correctly or is there some mistake in my understanding? > > Regards > > chand > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > -- In , " harjeet bakshi " > > <harjeet_bakshi@> wrote: > > > > > > Dear Ashji/Chandji, > > > As far as i understand from the query is that. > > > A is samdhari to B on 4:10 point basis. > > > if B aspects the significating houses then it wont deliver the > > result > > > but its samdhari A would come forward and give the result during its > > > antra... > > > other then that i cant make out what the query is... > > > > > > Functional samdhari on 4:10 basis are the most powerful samdhari > > > besides the natural samdharis.. > > > other are of lower order... depending on the criteria already given > > in > > > the lesson.. > > > 2 planets in same nakshatra but different sign would also be > > samdharis.... > > > > > > thanks/regards > > > harjeet > > > > > > --- In , " caprimoon_lady " > > > <caprimoon_lady@> wrote: > > > > > > > > Respected Ashji > > > > namaskaar > > > > I was going through your lessons regarding samdharmi > > planets.Would you > > > > please be kind enough to clear this > > > > On'tenth house theory'If two planets are situated in 4-10 > > positions One > > > > planet'A' has more than 4 points and the second planet'B' has > > less than > > > > 4 points, Planet A is samdharmi to planet'B' > > > > If planet 'B' is aspecting the signicating house and has got more > > > > points even then planet'A'would be samdharmi planet > > > > There are two separate points which i have understood.Have I > > understood > > > > rightly or is there any mistake in my understanding? pl.clarify > > > > Thanks > > > > Regards > > > > chand > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 16, 2006 Report Share Posted December 16, 2006 Dear Manu, I dont know if I understood u properly. Assume Planet B is in 10th house of the chart and Planet A is in 1st house of the chart. Planet B is < 4 bindus and Planet A is > 4 bindus. So here Planet B controls Planet A and Planet A, gives its Basic Points to planet B and makes Planet B very powerful and becomes very powerful SD to Planet B. So if Planet B is unable to give result due to aspect then if Planet A gets a chance then it will be deputed by Planet B or in other word step in for planet B. Now, here Planet A is SD to Planet B. Planet B is not SD to planet A. Subordinate cant tell boss to step in, boss can tell subordinate to step in. I am just noting this down, maybe what u said is right, but I was not clear if the above is what u meant. Cheers !!! Ash -> http://www.ashtro.ca , " caprimoon_lady " <caprimoon_lady wrote: > > Dear Manuji and Harjeet ji > Thanks a lot for your reply and the time given to explain in a very > nice manner.The point is clear to me.I have started reading the > lessons to understand KAS system properly. > Thanks once again > Regards > chand , " Manu Batura " > <manubatura@> wrote: > > > > Dear Chand, > > > > Let me try to explain. I am refering to figure 1 in lesson 8. > > > > Here planet A has got more than 4 points and planet B has less than > 4 > > points. So, A becomes SD to B. If you check the way WS is also > > calculated, you will notice that the basic strength of A gets added > to > > strength of B. So, B becomes powerful to give the result. That is > one > > part. > > > > Now, let us say that planet B has more strength than A in the WS but > > planet B aspects one of the significator houses then B itself cannot > > give the result, so A will come forward here to give the result for > B > > since it is a strong Samdharmi to B. Samdharmis normally come > forward > > only when the other planet is not capable to give result due to > sight > > or delay or even if other planet's sub-period is much later than > SD's > > sub period. > > > > In your point 2, read it as " ...even if planet B has more points > than > > A [in worksheet] " . > > > > Ash, kindly correct if I am wrong. > > > > Thanks & Regards, > > Manu > > > > > > > > , " caprimoon_lady " > > <caprimoon_lady@> wrote: > > > > > > Dear Harjeet ji and all other learned members > > > Thank you very much for your reply My query is that in Lesson > No.8 at > > > point No.2 on samdharmi planets, two points are given on Tenth > house > > > theory:-- > > > > > > 1) if two planets say A and B are in 4-10 relationship. B is the > > > signficator and planet A can give the results of B in its > antardasha > > > provided A has more bindus than B in Ashkatkvarga > > > > > > 2)Second condition is If planet B being the significator is > aspecting > > > the significating house even then A can givethe results of B in > its > > > antardasha even if planet B has more points than A. > > > Now I wanted to ask if i have understood these two principles > > > correctly or is there some mistake in my understanding? > > > Regards > > > chand > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > -- In , " harjeet bakshi " > > > <harjeet_bakshi@> wrote: > > > > > > > > Dear Ashji/Chandji, > > > > As far as i understand from the query is that. > > > > A is samdhari to B on 4:10 point basis. > > > > if B aspects the significating houses then it wont deliver the > > > result > > > > but its samdhari A would come forward and give the result > during its > > > > antra... > > > > other then that i cant make out what the query is... > > > > > > > > Functional samdhari on 4:10 basis are the most powerful samdhari > > > > besides the natural samdharis.. > > > > other are of lower order... depending on the criteria already > given > > > in > > > > the lesson.. > > > > 2 planets in same nakshatra but different sign would also be > > > samdharis.... > > > > > > > > thanks/regards > > > > harjeet > > > > > > > > --- In > , " caprimoon_lady " > > > > <caprimoon_lady@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > Respected Ashji > > > > > namaskaar > > > > > I was going through your lessons regarding samdharmi > > > planets.Would you > > > > > please be kind enough to clear this > > > > > On'tenth house theory'If two planets are situated in 4-10 > > > positions One > > > > > planet'A' has more than 4 points and the second planet'B' has > > > less than > > > > > 4 points, Planet A is samdharmi to planet'B' > > > > > If planet 'B' is aspecting the signicating house and has got > more > > > > > points even then planet'A'would be samdharmi planet > > > > > There are two separate points which i have understood.Have I > > > understood > > > > > rightly or is there any mistake in my understanding? > pl.clarify > > > > > Thanks > > > > > Regards > > > > > chand > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 16, 2006 Report Share Posted December 16, 2006 Dear Manu, yes, for NSD both can step in for each other. Say if Sa was in 10th house of the chart and Ve in 1st house and Sa < 3 and Ve > 4 then Sa can depute Ve and in this case if Ve cant give result then Sa can step in due to being NSD. Cheers !!! Ash -> http://www.ashtro.ca , " caprimoon_lady " <caprimoon_lady wrote: > > Dear Manuji and Harjeet ji > Thanks a lot for your reply and the time given to explain in a very > nice manner.The point is clear to me.I have started reading the > lessons to understand KAS system properly. > Thanks once again > Regards > chand , " Manu Batura " > <manubatura@> wrote: > > > > Dear Chand, > > > > Let me try to explain. I am refering to figure 1 in lesson 8. > > > > Here planet A has got more than 4 points and planet B has less than > 4 > > points. So, A becomes SD to B. If you check the way WS is also > > calculated, you will notice that the basic strength of A gets added > to > > strength of B. So, B becomes powerful to give the result. That is > one > > part. > > > > Now, let us say that planet B has more strength than A in the WS but > > planet B aspects one of the significator houses then B itself cannot > > give the result, so A will come forward here to give the result for > B > > since it is a strong Samdharmi to B. Samdharmis normally come > forward > > only when the other planet is not capable to give result due to > sight > > or delay or even if other planet's sub-period is much later than > SD's > > sub period. > > > > In your point 2, read it as " ...even if planet B has more points > than > > A [in worksheet] " . > > > > Ash, kindly correct if I am wrong. > > > > Thanks & Regards, > > Manu > > > > > > > > , " caprimoon_lady " > > <caprimoon_lady@> wrote: > > > > > > Dear Harjeet ji and all other learned members > > > Thank you very much for your reply My query is that in Lesson > No.8 at > > > point No.2 on samdharmi planets, two points are given on Tenth > house > > > theory:-- > > > > > > 1) if two planets say A and B are in 4-10 relationship. B is the > > > signficator and planet A can give the results of B in its > antardasha > > > provided A has more bindus than B in Ashkatkvarga > > > > > > 2)Second condition is If planet B being the significator is > aspecting > > > the significating house even then A can givethe results of B in > its > > > antardasha even if planet B has more points than A. > > > Now I wanted to ask if i have understood these two principles > > > correctly or is there some mistake in my understanding? > > > Regards > > > chand > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > -- In , " harjeet bakshi " > > > <harjeet_bakshi@> wrote: > > > > > > > > Dear Ashji/Chandji, > > > > As far as i understand from the query is that. > > > > A is samdhari to B on 4:10 point basis. > > > > if B aspects the significating houses then it wont deliver the > > > result > > > > but its samdhari A would come forward and give the result > during its > > > > antra... > > > > other then that i cant make out what the query is... > > > > > > > > Functional samdhari on 4:10 basis are the most powerful samdhari > > > > besides the natural samdharis.. > > > > other are of lower order... depending on the criteria already > given > > > in > > > > the lesson.. > > > > 2 planets in same nakshatra but different sign would also be > > > samdharis.... > > > > > > > > thanks/regards > > > > harjeet > > > > > > > > --- In > , " caprimoon_lady " > > > > <caprimoon_lady@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > Respected Ashji > > > > > namaskaar > > > > > I was going through your lessons regarding samdharmi > > > planets.Would you > > > > > please be kind enough to clear this > > > > > On'tenth house theory'If two planets are situated in 4-10 > > > positions One > > > > > planet'A' has more than 4 points and the second planet'B' has > > > less than > > > > > 4 points, Planet A is samdharmi to planet'B' > > > > > If planet 'B' is aspecting the signicating house and has got > more > > > > > points even then planet'A'would be samdharmi planet > > > > > There are two separate points which i have understood.Have I > > > understood > > > > > rightly or is there any mistake in my understanding? > pl.clarify > > > > > Thanks > > > > > Regards > > > > > chand > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 17, 2006 Report Share Posted December 17, 2006 Dear Ash, Thanks for further explaining this in more detail. Cheers, Manu , " ashsam73 " <ashsam73 wrote: > > Dear Manu, > yes, for NSD both can step in for each other. > > Say if Sa was in 10th house of the chart and Ve in 1st house and Sa < > 3 and Ve > 4 then Sa can depute Ve and in this case if Ve cant give > result then Sa can step in due to being NSD. > > Cheers !!! > Ash -> http://www.ashtro.ca > > , " caprimoon_lady " > <caprimoon_lady@> wrote: > > > > Dear Manuji and Harjeet ji > > Thanks a lot for your reply and the time given to explain in a very > > nice manner.The point is clear to me.I have started reading the > > lessons to understand KAS system properly. > > Thanks once again > > Regards > > chand > > > > > > > > > > > > > > , " Manu Batura " > > <manubatura@> wrote: > > > > > > Dear Chand, > > > > > > Let me try to explain. I am refering to figure 1 in lesson 8. > > > > > > Here planet A has got more than 4 points and planet B has less than > > 4 > > > points. So, A becomes SD to B. If you check the way WS is also > > > calculated, you will notice that the basic strength of A gets added > > to > > > strength of B. So, B becomes powerful to give the result. That is > > one > > > part. > > > > > > Now, let us say that planet B has more strength than A in the WS but > > > planet B aspects one of the significator houses then B itself cannot > > > give the result, so A will come forward here to give the result for > > B > > > since it is a strong Samdharmi to B. Samdharmis normally come > > forward > > > only when the other planet is not capable to give result due to > > sight > > > or delay or even if other planet's sub-period is much later than > > SD's > > > sub period. > > > > > > In your point 2, read it as " ...even if planet B has more points > > than > > > A [in worksheet] " . > > > > > > Ash, kindly correct if I am wrong. > > > > > > Thanks & Regards, > > > Manu > > > > > > > > > > > > , " caprimoon_lady " > > > <caprimoon_lady@> wrote: > > > > > > > > Dear Harjeet ji and all other learned members > > > > Thank you very much for your reply My query is that in Lesson > > No.8 at > > > > point No.2 on samdharmi planets, two points are given on Tenth > > house > > > > theory:-- > > > > > > > > 1) if two planets say A and B are in 4-10 relationship. B is the > > > > signficator and planet A can give the results of B in its > > antardasha > > > > provided A has more bindus than B in Ashkatkvarga > > > > > > > > 2)Second condition is If planet B being the significator is > > aspecting > > > > the significating house even then A can givethe results of B in > > its > > > > antardasha even if planet B has more points than A. > > > > Now I wanted to ask if i have understood these two principles > > > > correctly or is there some mistake in my understanding? > > > > Regards > > > > chand > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > -- In , " harjeet bakshi " > > > > <harjeet_bakshi@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > Dear Ashji/Chandji, > > > > > As far as i understand from the query is that. > > > > > A is samdhari to B on 4:10 point basis. > > > > > if B aspects the significating houses then it wont deliver the > > > > result > > > > > but its samdhari A would come forward and give the result > > during its > > > > > antra... > > > > > other then that i cant make out what the query is... > > > > > > > > > > Functional samdhari on 4:10 basis are the most powerful samdhari > > > > > besides the natural samdharis.. > > > > > other are of lower order... depending on the criteria already > > given > > > > in > > > > > the lesson.. > > > > > 2 planets in same nakshatra but different sign would also be > > > > samdharis.... > > > > > > > > > > thanks/regards > > > > > harjeet > > > > > > > > > > --- In > > , " caprimoon_lady " > > > > > <caprimoon_lady@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > > > Respected Ashji > > > > > > namaskaar > > > > > > I was going through your lessons regarding samdharmi > > > > planets.Would you > > > > > > please be kind enough to clear this > > > > > > On'tenth house theory'If two planets are situated in 4-10 > > > > positions One > > > > > > planet'A' has more than 4 points and the second planet'B' has > > > > less than > > > > > > 4 points, Planet A is samdharmi to planet'B' > > > > > > If planet 'B' is aspecting the signicating house and has got > > more > > > > > > points even then planet'A'would be samdharmi planet > > > > > > There are two separate points which i have understood.Have I > > > > understood > > > > > > rightly or is there any mistake in my understanding? > > pl.clarify > > > > > > Thanks > > > > > > Regards > > > > > > chand > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 17, 2006 Report Share Posted December 17, 2006 Respected Ashji Thank you very much for telling more in detail.Now the concept is very much clear to me regards chand , " ashsam73 " <ashsam73 wrote: > > Dear Manu, > yes, for NSD both can step in for each other. > > Say if Sa was in 10th house of the chart and Ve in 1st house and Sa < > 3 and Ve > 4 then Sa can depute Ve and in this case if Ve cant give > result then Sa can step in due to being NSD. > > Cheers !!! > Ash -> http://www.ashtro.ca > > , " caprimoon_lady " > <caprimoon_lady@> wrote: > > > > Dear Manuji and Harjeet ji > > Thanks a lot for your reply and the time given to explain in a very > > nice manner.The point is clear to me.I have started reading the > > lessons to understand KAS system properly. > > Thanks once again > > Regards > > chand > > > > > > > > > > > > > > , " Manu Batura " > > <manubatura@> wrote: > > > > > > Dear Chand, > > > > > > Let me try to explain. I am refering to figure 1 in lesson 8. > > > > > > Here planet A has got more than 4 points and planet B has less than > > 4 > > > points. So, A becomes SD to B. If you check the way WS is also > > > calculated, you will notice that the basic strength of A gets added > > to > > > strength of B. So, B becomes powerful to give the result. That is > > one > > > part. > > > > > > Now, let us say that planet B has more strength than A in the WS but > > > planet B aspects one of the significator houses then B itself cannot > > > give the result, so A will come forward here to give the result for > > B > > > since it is a strong Samdharmi to B. Samdharmis normally come > > forward > > > only when the other planet is not capable to give result due to > > sight > > > or delay or even if other planet's sub-period is much later than > > SD's > > > sub period. > > > > > > In your point 2, read it as " ...even if planet B has more points > > than > > > A [in worksheet] " . > > > > > > Ash, kindly correct if I am wrong. > > > > > > Thanks & Regards, > > > Manu > > > > > > > > > > > > --- In , " caprimoon_lady " > > > <caprimoon_lady@> wrote: > > > > > > > > Dear Harjeet ji and all other learned members > > > > Thank you very much for your reply My query is that in Lesson > > No.8 at > > > > point No.2 on samdharmi planets, two points are given on Tenth > > house > > > > theory:-- > > > > > > > > 1) if two planets say A and B are in 4-10 relationship. B is the > > > > signficator and planet A can give the results of B in its > > antardasha > > > > provided A has more bindus than B in Ashkatkvarga > > > > > > > > 2)Second condition is If planet B being the significator is > > aspecting > > > > the significating house even then A can givethe results of B in > > its > > > > antardasha even if planet B has more points than A. > > > > Now I wanted to ask if i have understood these two principles > > > > correctly or is there some mistake in my understanding? > > > > Regards > > > > chand > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > -- In , " harjeet bakshi " > > > > <harjeet_bakshi@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > Dear Ashji/Chandji, > > > > > As far as i understand from the query is that. > > > > > A is samdhari to B on 4:10 point basis. > > > > > if B aspects the significating houses then it wont deliver the > > > > result > > > > > but its samdhari A would come forward and give the result > > during its > > > > > antra... > > > > > other then that i cant make out what the query is... > > > > > > > > > > Functional samdhari on 4:10 basis are the most powerful samdhari > > > > > besides the natural samdharis.. > > > > > other are of lower order... depending on the criteria already > > given > > > > in > > > > > the lesson.. > > > > > 2 planets in same nakshatra but different sign would also be > > > > samdharis.... > > > > > > > > > > thanks/regards > > > > > harjeet > > > > > > > > > > --- In > > , " caprimoon_lady " > > > > > <caprimoon_lady@> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > > > Respected Ashji > > > > > > namaskaar > > > > > > I was going through your lessons regarding samdharmi > > > > planets.Would you > > > > > > please be kind enough to clear this > > > > > > On'tenth house theory'If two planets are situated in 4-10 > > > > positions One > > > > > > planet'A' has more than 4 points and the second planet'B' has > > > > less than > > > > > > 4 points, Planet A is samdharmi to planet'B' > > > > > > If planet 'B' is aspecting the signicating house and has got > > more > > > > > > points even then planet'A'would be samdharmi planet > > > > > > There are two separate points which i have understood.Have I > > > > understood > > > > > > rightly or is there any mistake in my understanding? > > pl.clarify > > > > > > Thanks > > > > > > Regards > > > > > > chand > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.