Guest guest Posted February 9, 2007 Report Share Posted February 9, 2007 Hello, I have gone4 through the lesson on samadharmi as well as samadharmi discussion in FAQ. A few things are not clear to me. Here are the quaestions: 1. When one has 4:10 relationship. Now here are we taking about natal positions or lordships? 2. Say for planets placed 4:10 from each other. The planet in 4th place becomes samadharmi to planet in 10th place, if palnet in the 4th place ( called planet A) has more points..That is clear 3. It goes on to say that If planet in the 10th place, call it planet B, gets more points than A, however if planet B aspects significating houses A,B,C thenplanet in 4th place( planet A) can give results for planet B even if it has less points than B...Is this correct ? 4.Point 4 in that lesson is not clear to me at all. Here we have palnet B aspecting significating house and so does planet A. It goes on to say that sun's transit is important. Its not clear why? If planet A ( i.e planet in 4th place from planet B) also aspects the significating house, wo'nt it disqualify him from giving result? 5. Can natural smadharmis be still be samdharmi if they are 1:7 position from each other? It is said no planet in1:7 relationship can be samadharmi. It is not clear whether this extends to natural smadharmi. Thanks Satish ______________________________\ ____ Need Mail bonding? Go to the Mail Q & A for great tips from Answers users. http://answers./dir/?link=list & sid=396546091 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 9, 2007 Report Share Posted February 9, 2007 Dear Satish, My answers in CAPS below , SPK <aquaris_rising wrote: > > Hello, > > I have gone4 through the lesson on samadharmi as well > as samadharmi discussion in FAQ. A few things are not > clear to me. Here are the quaestions: > > 1. When one has 4:10 relationship. Now here are we > taking about natal positions or lordships? ASH : SA AND VE ARE NSD, MA AND MO ARE NSD AND SUN AND MA ARE NSD. THESE ARE YOGAKARAK FOR EACH OTHER. SA AND VE SIGNS ARE IN 5:9 AND 4:10. SAME FOR SU AND MA, LEO IS IN 10TH FROM SCO AND ARIES AND LEO ARE IN 5:9 SIMILARLY FOR MA AND MO. SO WE CALL THEM OR CONSIDER THEM AS NSD. > > 2. Say for planets placed 4:10 from each other. The > planet in 4th place becomes samadharmi to planet in > 10th place, if palnet in the 4th place ( called planet > A) has more points..That is clear > ASH : B IS IN 10TH PLACE FROM A. B IS WITH < 4 BINDUS AND A IS WITH MORE THAN 4 THEN A GIVES IT POWER TO B PLANET. THAT U CAN SEE IN WS I.E H1 TO H12 WHERE AFTER A+B+C WE ARE CHECKING 4:10. B = 4 BINDUS AND A > B I.E. 5,6,7,8 BINDU AND IF B IS LOD OR LOE IN THAT CASE IT CAN STILL CONTROL PLANET A. B > 4 AND A < 4, IN THAT CASE, PLANET A WILL OPPOSE PLANET B. SO HERE SUBORDINATE MALEFIC AND BOSS IS NOBLE SO SUBORDINATE WILL CREATE MISCHIEF FOR BOSS. THERE ARE LOTS OF DISCUSSION IN THE ARCHIVES WHERE KRUSHNAJI , SANJAY JAGGIA AND MYSELF HAVE EXPLAINED THIS CONCEPT. KRUSHNAJI HAD GIVEN A WONDERFUL MAIL IF U CAN FIND THAT ON THIS PORTION IT WILL BE SUPER. > 3. It goes on to say that If planet in the 10th place, > call it planet B, gets more points than A, however if > planet B aspects significating houses A,B,C thenplanet > in 4th place( planet A) can give results for planet B > even if it has less points than B...Is this correct ? > ASH : 4:10 IS A VERY POWERFUL SAMDHARMI. SUCH PLANETS BECOME POWERFUL FOR ALL 12 HOUSES, AND WS WILL REFLECT THAT. IF PLANET B IS ASPECTINGG HOUSE A, B, C THEN IT CAN DEPUTE ITS POWERFUL SD SO PLANET A WILL BE DEPUTED BY PLANET B. > 4.Point 4 in that lesson is not clear to me at all. > Here we have palnet B aspecting significating house > and so does planet A. It goes on to say that sun's > transit is important. Its not clear why? If planet A ( > i.e planet in 4th place from planet B) also aspects > the significating house, wo'nt it disqualify him from > giving result? ASH : IT IS ALSO GIVEN SOMEWHERE, THAT IF A PLANET ASPECTS A B C HOUSE THEN ITS SD WILL STEP IN. IF PLANET B IS LOD OR LOE THEN DESPITE IT ASPECTS, IT CAN STILL GIVE ITS RESULT OR ITS SD CAN. IF A PLANET ASPECTS ABC THEN ITSELF CANT GIVE, HOWEVER IF AFTER DELAY IS OVER AND SAY A POWERFUL'S PLANETS ANTRA IS OVER AND ITS SD'S ANTRA COMES THEN IT MIGHT GIVE THE RESULT. HANG IN THERE, AS WE SOLVE CHARTS THESE THINGS WILL GET CLEAR, AS IT WILL BE MORE EASIER TO EXPLAIN WITH PROPER CHARTS. > > 5. Can natural smadharmis be still be samdharmi if > they are 1:7 position from each other? It is said no > planet in1:7 relationship can be samadharmi. It is not > clear whether this extends to natural smadharmi. > ASH : NO WAY. WHEN PLANETS ARE IN 1:7 THEY ARE HAVING ENIMITY WITH EACH OTHER. SO VE AND SA IF THEY ARE IN 1:7 THEN THEY CEASE TO ACT AS SD. SIMILARLY MA AND MO ARE IN 1:7 OR SUN AND MARS IF THEY ARE IN 1:7 THEN THEY HAVE ENIMITY AND THEY CANT ACT AS NSD FOR EACH OTHER. HOPE THAT CLARIFIES, CHEERS !!! ASH -> http://www.ashtro.ca > Thanks > > Satish > > > > > ______________________________\ ____ > Need Mail bonding? > Go to the Mail Q & A for great tips from Answers users. > http://answers./dir/?link=list & sid=396546091 > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.