Guest guest Posted November 20, 2007 Report Share Posted November 20, 2007 Dear Manu, While clarifying for the message n:6056,you wrote as follows... "If Mo is in Pisces navamsa then it is samdharmi to Jupiter. A samdharmi planet steps in for the planet it is samdharmi to. So, mo will step in for Jupiter not the other way around" On the otherhand,in some archives Ash has written like this... "JUST AS AN EXAMPLE, SAY JUPITER IS FROM 6DEG40 TO 10 DEG IN ARIES THENIT WOULD BECOME SAMDHARMI TO MERCURY AS IT WOULD BE IN GEMINI INNAVAMSA. SO FOR SOME CASES, DEPENDING ON STRENGTH OF JUPITER IN RASIIF ITS UNABLE TO GIVE THE TIMING DUE TO SAY ITS ANTRA BEING FAR AWAY,THEN IF MERCURY ANTA COMES BEFORE JUPITER AND IF MERCURY HAS ENOUGHPOWER THEN IT CAN STEP IN FOR JUPITER AND FURNISH THE TIMING OF EVENT" I have no hesitation asking you such simple key questions. Am i getting confused smwhere? In first case Moon is SD to Jup and will stepin for Jup(Lord of Pisces in navamsa). In second case,Mer (lord of gemini sign in navamsa) can stepin for Jup. Thanxs and reagrds Anup Be a better pen pal. Text or chat with friends inside Mail. See how. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 20, 2007 Report Share Posted November 20, 2007 Dear Anup, This is interesting. Thanks for pointing this out. As per my understanding the following will hold: First Case: Mo can step in for Ju, Ju cannot step in for Mo unless Ju is SD to mo in some other way. Second Case: Ju can step in for Me, Me cannot step in for Ju unless Me is SD to Ju in some other way. I know this is contradictory to what Ash has mentioned. Maybe my understanding is incorrect. I will request Ash to correct me and elaborate this point. Thanks Again. Regards, Manu , " Anup. M " <dalh_1 wrote: > > Dear Manu, > > While clarifying for the message n:6056,you wrote as follows... > > " If Mo is in Pisces navamsa then it is samdharmi to Jupiter. A samdharmi planet steps in for the planet it is samdharmi to. So, mo will step in for Jupiter not the other way around " > > On the otherhand,in some archives Ash has written like this... > > " JUST AS AN EXAMPLE, SAY JUPITER IS FROM 6DEG40 TO 10 DEG IN ARIES THEN > IT WOULD BECOME SAMDHARMI TO MERCURY AS IT WOULD BE IN GEMINI IN > NAVAMSA. SO FOR SOME CASES, DEPENDING ON STRENGTH OF JUPITER IN RASI > IF ITS UNABLE TO GIVE THE TIMING DUE TO SAY ITS ANTRA BEING FAR AWAY, > THEN IF MERCURY ANTA COMES BEFORE JUPITER AND IF MERCURY HAS ENOUGH > POWER THEN IT CAN STEP IN FOR JUPITER AND FURNISH THE TIMING OF EVENT " > > I have no hesitation asking you such simple key questions. > Am i getting confused smwhere? > In first case Moon is SD to Jup and will stepin for Jup(Lord of Pisces in navamsa). > In second case,Mer (lord of gemini sign in navamsa) can stepin for Jup. > > Thanxs and reagrds > Anup > > > > Be a better pen pal. Text or chat with friends inside Mail. See how. > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 20, 2007 Report Share Posted November 20, 2007 Dear Manu, REALLY INTERESTING BUT AS I WROTE I NEVER HESITATE TO ASK ANYTHING WHICH IS CONFUSING.SURE, I REQUEST ASH TO PLEASE CLEAR THIS CONFUSION IF POSSIBLE.SOME IMPORTANT POINT MAY LEAD TO A GOOD LEARNING AS WELL. THANXS MANU, AGAIN. REGARDS ANUPManu Batura <astro.manu wrote: Dear Anup,This is interesting. Thanks for pointing this out. As per my understanding the following will hold:First Case: Mo can step in for Ju, Ju cannot step in for Mo unless Ju is SD to mo in some other way.Second Case: Ju can step in for Me, Me cannot step in for Ju unless Me is SD to Ju in some other way.I know this is contradictory to what Ash has mentioned. Maybe my understanding is incorrect. I will request Ash to correct me and elaborate this point.Thanks Again.Regards,Manu , "Anup. M" <dalh_1 wrote:>> Dear Manu,> > While clarifying for the message n:6056,you wrote as follows...> > "If Mo is in Pisces navamsa then it is samdharmi to Jupiter. A samdharmi planet steps in for the planet it is samdharmi to. So, mo will step in for Jupiter not the other way around"> > On the otherhand,in some archives Ash has written like this...> > "JUST AS AN EXAMPLE, SAY JUPITER IS FROM 6DEG40 TO 10 DEG IN ARIES THEN> IT WOULD BECOME SAMDHARMI TO MERCURY AS IT WOULD BE IN GEMINI IN> NAVAMSA. SO FOR SOME CASES, DEPENDING ON STRENGTH OF JUPITER IN RASI> IF ITS UNABLE TO GIVE THE TIMING DUE TO SAY ITS ANTRA BEING FAR AWAY,> THEN IF MERCURY ANTA COMES BEFORE JUPITER AND IF MERCURY HAS ENOUGH> POWER THEN IT CAN STEP IN FOR JUPITER AND FURNISH THE TIMING OF EVENT"> > I have no hesitation asking you such simple key questions.> Am i getting confused smwhere?> In first case Moon is SD to Jup and will stepin for Jup(Lord of Pisces in navamsa).> In second case,Mer (lord of gemini sign in navamsa) can stepin for Jup. > > Thanxs and reagrds> Anup> > > > Be a better pen pal. Text or chat with friends inside Mail. See how.> Be a better sports nut! Let your teams follow you with Mobile. Try it now. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 20, 2007 Report Share Posted November 20, 2007 Dear Manu and Anup, What Manu has written is correct. If Ju is in navamsa of Me then Ju can step in for Me. I might have written that in haste. Thanks for pointing that out. Cheers !!! Ash -> http://www.ashtro.ca On Behalf Of Manu Batura Tuesday November 20, 2007 10:47 PM Re: navamsa depositer and samdharmi Dear Anup, This is interesting. Thanks for pointing this out. As per my understanding the following will hold: First Case: Mo can step in for Ju, Ju cannot step in for Mo unless Ju is SD to mo in some other way. Second Case: Ju can step in for Me, Me cannot step in for Ju unless Me is SD to Ju in some other way. I know this is contradictory to what Ash has mentioned. Maybe my understanding is incorrect. I will request Ash to correct me and elaborate this point. Thanks Again. Regards, Manu , " Anup. M " <dalh_1 wrote: > > Dear Manu, > > While clarifying for the message n:6056,you wrote as follows... > > " If Mo is in Pisces navamsa then it is samdharmi to Jupiter. A samdharmi planet steps in for the planet it is samdharmi to. So, mo will step in for Jupiter not the other way around " > > On the otherhand,in some archives Ash has written like this... > > " JUST AS AN EXAMPLE, SAY JUPITER IS FROM 6DEG40 TO 10 DEG IN ARIES THEN > IT WOULD BECOME SAMDHARMI TO MERCURY AS IT WOULD BE IN GEMINI IN > NAVAMSA. SO FOR SOME CASES, DEPENDING ON STRENGTH OF JUPITER IN RASI > IF ITS UNABLE TO GIVE THE TIMING DUE TO SAY ITS ANTRA BEING FAR AWAY, > THEN IF MERCURY ANTA COMES BEFORE JUPITER AND IF MERCURY HAS ENOUGH > POWER THEN IT CAN STEP IN FOR JUPITER AND FURNISH THE TIMING OF EVENT " > > I have no hesitation asking you such simple key questions. > Am i getting confused smwhere? > In first case Moon is SD to Jup and will stepin for Jup(Lord of Pisces in navamsa). > In second case,Mer (lord of gemini sign in navamsa) can stepin for Jup. > > Thanxs and reagrds > Anup > > > > Be a better pen pal. Text or chat with friends inside Mail. See how. > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 20, 2007 Report Share Posted November 20, 2007 Dear Ash, Thanks for this. And thanxs, Manu. Rerards Anup Ash <kas wrote: Dear Manu and Anup, What Manu has written is correct. If Ju is in navamsa of Me then Ju can step in for Me. I might have written that in haste. Thanks for pointing that out. Cheers !!! Ash -> http://www.ashtro.ca On Behalf Of Manu BaturaTuesday November 20, 2007 10:47 PM Subject: Re: navamsa depositer and samdharmi Dear Anup,This is interesting. Thanks for pointing this out. As per my understanding the following will hold:First Case: Mo can step in for Ju, Ju cannot step in for Mo unless Ju is SD to mo in some other way.Second Case: Ju can step in for Me, Me cannot step in for Ju unless Me is SD to Ju in some other way.I know this is contradictory to what Ash has mentioned. Maybe my understanding is incorrect. I will request Ash to correct me and elaborate this point.Thanks Again.Regards,Manu , "Anup. M" <dalh_1 wrote:>> Dear Manu,> > While clarifying for the message n:6056,you wrote as follows...> > "If Mo is in Pisces navamsa then it is samdharmi to Jupiter. A samdharmi planet steps in for the planet it is samdharmi to. So, mo will step in for Jupiter not the other way around"> > On the otherhand,in some archives Ash has written like this...> > "JUST AS AN EXAMPLE, SAY JUPITER IS FROM 6DEG40 TO 10 DEG IN ARIES THEN> IT WOULD BECOME SAMDHARMI TO MERCURY AS IT WOULD BE IN GEMINI IN> NAVAMSA. SO FOR SOME CASES, DEPENDING ON STRENGTH OF JUPITER IN RASI> IF ITS UNABLE TO GIVE THE TIMING DUE TO SAY ITS ANTRA BEING FAR AWAY,> THEN IF MERCURY ANTA COMES BEFORE JUPITER AND IF MERCURY HAS ENOUGH> POWER THEN IT CAN STEP IN FOR JUPITER AND FURNISH THE TIMING OF EVENT"> > I have no hesitation asking you such simple key questions.> Am i getting confused smwhere?> In first case Moon is SD to Jup and will stepin for Jup(Lord of Pisces in navamsa).> In second case,Mer (lord of gemini sign in navamsa) can stepin for Jup. > > Thanxs and reagrds> Anup> > > > Be a better pen pal. Text or chat with friends inside Mail. See how.> Be a better sports nut! Let your teams follow you with Mobile. Try it now. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 21, 2007 Report Share Posted November 21, 2007 Thanks Ash. Regards, Manu On Behalf Of Ash Wednesday, November 21, 2007 9:32 AM To: RE: Re: navamsa depositer and samdharmi Dear Manu and Anup, What Manu has written is correct. If Ju is in navamsa of Me then Ju can step in for Me. I might have written that in haste. Thanks for pointing that out. Cheers !!! Ash -> http://www.ashtro.ca On Behalf Of Manu Batura Tuesday November 20, 2007 10:47 PM Subject: Re: navamsa depositer and samdharmi Dear Anup, This is interesting. Thanks for pointing this out. As per my understanding the following will hold: First Case: Mo can step in for Ju, Ju cannot step in for Mo unless Ju is SD to mo in some other way. Second Case: Ju can step in for Me, Me cannot step in for Ju unless Me is SD to Ju in some other way. I know this is contradictory to what Ash has mentioned. Maybe my understanding is incorrect. I will request Ash to correct me and elaborate this point. Thanks Again. Regards, Manu , " Anup. M " <dalh_1 wrote: > > Dear Manu, > > While clarifying for the message n:6056,you wrote as follows... > > " If Mo is in Pisces navamsa then it is samdharmi to Jupiter. A samdharmi planet steps in for the planet it is samdharmi to. So, mo will step in for Jupiter not the other way around " > > On the otherhand,in some archives Ash has written like this... > > " JUST AS AN EXAMPLE, SAY JUPITER IS FROM 6DEG40 TO 10 DEG IN ARIES THEN > IT WOULD BECOME SAMDHARMI TO MERCURY AS IT WOULD BE IN GEMINI IN > NAVAMSA. SO FOR SOME CASES, DEPENDING ON STRENGTH OF JUPITER IN RASI > IF ITS UNABLE TO GIVE THE TIMING DUE TO SAY ITS ANTRA BEING FAR AWAY, > THEN IF MERCURY ANTA COMES BEFORE JUPITER AND IF MERCURY HAS ENOUGH > POWER THEN IT CAN STEP IN FOR JUPITER AND FURNISH THE TIMING OF EVENT " > > I have no hesitation asking you such simple key questions. > Am i getting confused smwhere? > In first case Moon is SD to Jup and will stepin for Jup(Lord of Pisces in navamsa). > In second case,Mer (lord of gemini sign in navamsa) can stepin for Jup. > > Thanxs and reagrds > Anup > > > > Be a better pen pal. Text or chat with friends inside Mail. See how. > Version: 7.5.503 / Virus Database: 269.16.1/1140 - Release 11/19/2007 7:05 PM Version: 7.5.503 / Virus Database: 269.16.1/1140 - Release 11/19/2007 7:05 PM Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 21, 2007 Report Share Posted November 21, 2007 Dear Anup, Completely in agreement with you. Thanks & Regards, Manu On Behalf Of Anup. M Wednesday, November 21, 2007 9:22 AM To: Re: Re: navamsa depositer and samdharmi Dear Manu, REALLY INTERESTING BUT AS I WROTE I NEVER HESITATE TO ASK ANYTHING WHICH IS CONFUSING.SURE, I REQUEST ASH TO PLEASE CLEAR THIS CONFUSION IF POSSIBLE.SOME IMPORTANT POINT MAY LEAD TO A GOOD LEARNING AS WELL. THANXS MANU, AGAIN. REGARDS ANUP Manu Batura <astro.manu wrote: Dear Anup, This is interesting. Thanks for pointing this out. As per my understanding the following will hold: First Case: Mo can step in for Ju, Ju cannot step in for Mo unless Ju is SD to mo in some other way. Second Case: Ju can step in for Me, Me cannot step in for Ju unless Me is SD to Ju in some other way. I know this is contradictory to what Ash has mentioned. Maybe my understanding is incorrect. I will request Ash to correct me and elaborate this point. Thanks Again. Regards, Manu , " Anup. M " <dalh_1 wrote: > > Dear Manu, > > While clarifying for the message n:6056,you wrote as follows... > > " If Mo is in Pisces navamsa then it is samdharmi to Jupiter. A samdharmi planet steps in for the planet it is samdharmi to. So, mo will step in for Jupiter not the other way around " > > On the otherhand,in some archives Ash has written like this... > > " JUST AS AN EXAMPLE, SAY JUPITER IS FROM 6DEG40 TO 10 DEG IN ARIES THEN > IT WOULD BECOME SAMDHARMI TO MERCURY AS IT WOULD BE IN GEMINI IN > NAVAMSA. SO FOR SOME CASES, DEPENDING ON STRENGTH OF JUPITER IN RASI > IF ITS UNABLE TO GIVE THE TIMING DUE TO SAY ITS ANTRA BEING FAR AWAY, > THEN IF MERCURY ANTA COMES BEFORE JUPITER AND IF MERCURY HAS ENOUGH > POWER THEN IT CAN STEP IN FOR JUPITER AND FURNISH THE TIMING OF EVENT " > > I have no hesitation asking you such simple key questions. > Am i getting confused smwhere? > In first case Moon is SD to Jup and will stepin for Jup(Lord of Pisces in navamsa). > In second case,Mer (lord of gemini sign in navamsa) can stepin for Jup. > > Thanxs and reagrds > Anup > > > > Be a better pen pal. Text or chat with friends inside Mail. See how. > Be a better sports nut! Let your teams follow you with Mobile. Try it now. Version: 7.5.503 / Virus Database: 269.16.1/1140 - Release 11/19/2007 7:05 PM Version: 7.5.503 / Virus Database: 269.16.1/1140 - Release 11/19/2007 7:05 PM Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.